Bitcoin Forum

Other => Politics & Society => Topic started by: Spendulus on April 09, 2015, 04:03:49 PM



Title: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Spendulus on April 09, 2015, 04:03:49 PM
The Quran (Koran, the book of Islam) does not contains scientific knowledge that could not have been known 1400 years ago.

It does not contain miracles.

The Moon was not split and rejoined.

Also, belief in miracles is not necessary for belief in Koran.


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Muhammed Zakir on April 09, 2015, 04:36:01 PM
=snip=
Also, belief in miracles is not necessary for belief in Koran.

True. I am not saying anything false because it will make more discussions here. I request you to lock this thread. I am not posting in religious post and didn't post in religious post like Bible's to not to make further hates. People who make a quick-look will think a religion hate them and hence, all followers hate them. This makes more hate between people.

 Anyway, I think I know how your response will be to this. I thought it's good to take a risk to solve this. However, if you think you want to get optionions, you are free to do so! Good luck! :)


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: pedrog on April 09, 2015, 04:40:00 PM
=snip=
Also, belief in miracles is not necessary for belief in Koran.

True. I am not saying anything false because it will make more discussions here. I request you to lock this thread. I am not posting in religious post and didn't post in religious post like Bible's to not to make further hates. People who make a quick-look will think a religion hate them and hence, all followers hate them. This makes more hate between people.

 Anyway, I think I know how your response will be to this. I thought it's good to take a risk to solve this. However, if you think you want to get optionions, you are free to do so! Good luck! :)

It's mot hate, it's reality, although reality usually 'offends' religious people...


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: abyrnes81 on April 09, 2015, 04:52:32 PM
The Quran (Koran, the book of Islam) does not contains scientific knowledge that could not have been known 1400 years ago.

It does not contain miracles.

The Moon was not split and rejoined.

Also, belief in miracles is not necessary for belief in Koran.


This,

I don't think the book of islam contains any miracles, but his poetry is very awesome! But as you told, with a little bit of "brain" we can explain everything.


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Wilikon on April 09, 2015, 05:00:23 PM
=snip=
Also, belief in miracles is not necessary for belief in Koran.

True. I am not saying anything false because it will make more discussions here. I request you to lock this thread. I am not posting in religious post and didn't post in religious post like Bible's to not to make further hates. People who make a quick-look will think a religion hate them and hence, all followers hate them. This makes more hate between people.

 Anyway, I think I know how your response will be to this. I thought it's good to take a risk to solve this. However, if you think you want to get optionions, you are free to do so! Good luck! :)






Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: BADecker on April 09, 2015, 05:01:53 PM
Islam, the religion of science fiction. Oh wait. Science, itself, is the religion of science fiction. Which one is the copycat?

:)


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: redsn0w on April 09, 2015, 05:03:04 PM
In these days a lot of Islam's related thread, and I want only to say a couple of things (related with the Quran):

- How many version of that "book" are around the world? Not "style or graphic" version.
- How many version of Bible is present at the moment? And if we pick a bible of 60-70 years ago, is it the same ( same words) of the actual?

I don't think this time I am a straw man (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man) just want to share with you my personal opinion. Thanks for the attention.

Yes, the Quran does not contain any miracles.


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: BADecker on April 09, 2015, 05:05:05 PM
=snip=
Also, belief in miracles is not necessary for belief in Koran.

True. I am not saying anything false because it will make more discussions here. I request you to lock this thread. I am not posting in religious post and didn't post in religious post like Bible's to not to make further hates. People who make a quick-look will think a religion hate them and hence, all followers hate them. This makes more hate between people.

 Anyway, I think I know how your response will be to this. I thought it's good to take a risk to solve this. However, if you think you want to get optionions, you are free to do so! Good luck! :)

I think that you and your buddies hacked everybody's locations through their ISPs, and you are sending out terrorists to destroy all your opponents.

 ;D


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Muhammed Zakir on April 09, 2015, 05:12:29 PM
[ center][ img]https://i.imgur.com/wtnyLpk.gif[/img][/center]
[ center][ img]https://i.imgur.com/7SoqC3g.png[/img][/center]

Thanks for pictorial representation, friend!

I think that you and your buddies hacked everybody's locations through their ISPs, and you are sending out terrorists to destroy all your opponents.

 ;D

Yeah. theymos put a backdoor so that terrorists like me can access IP addresses. I have sent a vehicle with a bomb to Wilikon. It was hard to find an exact car he sent me. I have paid the debt with a small tip. Confirm here if you receive it.


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: BADecker on April 09, 2015, 05:24:12 PM
[ center][ img]https://i.imgur.com/wtnyLpk.gif[/img][/center]
[ center][ img]https://i.imgur.com/7SoqC3g.png[/img][/center]

Thanks for pictorial representation, friend!

I think that you and your buddies hacked everybody's locations through their ISPs, and you are sending out terrorists to destroy all your opponents.

 ;D

Yeah. theymos put a backdoor so that terrorists like me can access IP addresses. I have sent a vehicle with a bomb to Wilikon. It was hard to find an exact car he sent me. I have paid the debt with a small tip. Confirm here if you receive it.

Wow! Didn't think you'd ever admit it.    ???


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Spendulus on April 09, 2015, 11:37:58 PM
=snip=
Also, belief in miracles is not necessary for belief in Koran.

True. I am not saying anything false because it will make more discussions here. I request you to lock this thread. I am not posting in religious post and didn't post in religious post like Bible's to not to make further hates. People who make a quick-look will think a religion hate them and hence, all followers hate them. This makes more hate between people.

 Anyway, I think I know how your response will be to this. I thought it's good to take a risk to solve this. However, if you think you want to get optionions, you are free to do so! Good luck! :)
I think what I am saying is an important point, so correct me if I am wrong.

To be a devout Muslim one does NOT have to believe in miracles.

To be a devout Christian one DOES have to believe in miracles.

True or false?  Badecker?


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Muhammed Zakir on April 09, 2015, 11:48:26 PM
I think what I am saying is an important point, so correct me if I am wrong.

To be a devout Muslim one does NOT have to believe in miracles.

To be a devout Christian one DOES have to believe in miracles.

True or false?  Badecker?

My mistake, false. Devout muslim needs to believe in Miracles.


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: BADecker on April 09, 2015, 11:55:23 PM
=snip=
Also, belief in miracles is not necessary for belief in Koran.

True. I am not saying anything false because it will make more discussions here. I request you to lock this thread. I am not posting in religious post and didn't post in religious post like Bible's to not to make further hates. People who make a quick-look will think a religion hate them and hence, all followers hate them. This makes more hate between people.

 Anyway, I think I know how your response will be to this. I thought it's good to take a risk to solve this. However, if you think you want to get optionions, you are free to do so! Good luck! :)
I think what I am saying is an important point, so correct me if I am wrong.

To be a devout Muslim one does NOT have to believe in miracles.

To be a devout Christian one DOES have to believe in miracles.

True or false?  Badecker?

It is only logical to conclude that devout people of any religion need to believe what their religious books say. This means that they must believe in miracles if their religious books speak about miracles.

The interesting thing is that among the miracles of the Bible are a lot of foretelling of the future. Things predicted in the Bible happened or didn't happen depending on the strength of the prophet. There are Bible predictions that haven't happened yet; they are for the future. The predictions that Jesus made happened as far as they go. The ones that haven't happened yet will happen.

The Quran makes no direct predictions like the Bible. There is far less strength in the Quran than the Bible.

:)


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Muhammed Zakir on April 10, 2015, 12:16:38 AM
Qur'an make predictions about the end of the world. The war and many more. :)


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Spendulus on April 10, 2015, 02:00:13 AM
I think what I am saying is an important point, so correct me if I am wrong.

To be a devout Muslim one does NOT have to believe in miracles.

To be a devout Christian one DOES have to believe in miracles.

True or false?  Badecker?

My mistake, false. Devout muslim needs to believe in Miracles.
What miracles does one have to believe?

Just the end of world stuff?



Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: r3wt on April 10, 2015, 02:15:02 AM
Quote
Proverbs 3:5-6
"Confide in God with all thy heart, and lean not unto thine own intelligence;
in all thy ways acknowledge him, and he will make plain thy paths."


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Spendulus on April 10, 2015, 12:01:58 PM
Quote
Proverbs 3:5-6
"Confide in God with all thy heart, and lean not unto thine own intelligence;
in all thy ways acknowledge him, and he will make plain thy paths."

Generally speaking, in Christianity and perhaps in Judeo-christian culture, a religious "prophecy" is not considered a "miracle."

Help me out a bit with this because as an Athiest I view these concepts as total bullshit, and that makes it difficult to separate the various flavors.

In Islam, are alleged "prophecies" considered "miracles?"


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Muhammed Zakir on April 10, 2015, 03:05:52 PM
What miracles does one have to believe?

Just the end of world stuff?

Everything. AFAIK If they can't see it logical, they don't want to believe it but they shouldn't spread misunderstanding/misinterpretation to backup their claims.

"End of the world" is one of the many predictions.

Help me out a bit with this because as an Athiest I view these concepts as total bullshit, and that makes it difficult to separate the various flavors.

It is not only you, all humans are like that. Once we carve something on heart/mind, it is hard to change it. I too see somethings in that way.

In Islam, are alleged "prophecies" considered "miracles?"

It's debatable because for some it is miracles and for some it is just prophecies. I will have to look a little more on this. I will try to reply ASAP.

Meanwhile, here are some of the fulfilled prophecies:

Quote from: wiki
One of the more general prophecies is that the Qur'an predicts its own preservation and endurance. The Qur'an states that the book itself will survive as a valid source and that the religion of Islam will last, even dominate, because of this. Muslim scholars argue that today's Qur'an is the same Qur'an originally compiled by Muhammad. The following passages from the Qur'an state these prophecies:

“We have, without doubt, Sent down the Message; And We will assuredly Guard it (from corruption)” (15:9).

“It is He Who has sent His Apostle with Guidance And the Religion of Truth, That he may proclaim it Over all religion, Even though the Pagans May detest (it)” (61:9).

Another interpretation of the Qur'an is that it predicted the defeat of the Persians by the Romans. Before the prophecy, at the Battle of Antioch, in 613 C.E., the Persians defeated the Romans. Muslims were upset by this defeat because they felt more connected to Rome, a Christian empire, than to Persia, a Zoroastrian one. A few years afterwards, the following verse was revealed in the Qur'an: "The Roman Empire Has been defeated – In a land close by; But they, (even) after (This) defeat of theirs, Will soon be victorious – Within a few years. With God is the Decision, In the Past And in the Future: On that Day shall The Believers rejoice” (30:2-4). By 627 C.E., the Romans had successfully defeated the Persians, resulting in much celebration by Muslims and fulfilling the prophecy of the Qur'an.

## Another prophecy of the Qur'an that Muslims might argue has been fulfilled is the ease with which the book can be memorized. Because this is not a factual prophecy but based, rather, on opinion, it cannot truly be proven. However, Muslims do consider reciting or reading the Qur'an to be holy and a way to receive blessings, so it is extremely common for Muslims to memorize a large number of Qur'anic verses. The fact that this is possible and has been done by scholars and children alike, does suggest a certain quality of the Qur'an that makes it easily memorable. The Qur'an’s “rhythmic style and eloquent expression” have been cited as aids in verbatim memorization. The following verse from the Qur'an is one example of the prophecy that the Qur'an will be easily memorized by future readers: “And We have indeed Made the Qur-an easy to understand and remember: Then is there any that Will receive admonition?” (54:17) ##

Another prophecy, according to the Qur'an, may have predicted the preservation of the Pharaoh of the Exodus's body. In the Qur'an, God says to the Pharaoh: "This day shall We save thee In thy body, that thou Mayest be a Sign to those Who come after thee! But verily, many among mankind Are heedless of Our Signs!" The body of the Pharaoh, who was argued to be either Ramesses II or his son Merneptah, was thought to be lost at sea until the mummies of both were discovered in the 19th century. They are on display today in Cairo's Egyptian Museum; thus, it is argued that the prophecy was fulfilled.

What I put in "##" is debatable too. Unlike most other religious books, Qur'an is easy to remember. So it can also be considered as a prophecy.


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Spendulus on April 10, 2015, 05:04:01 PM
What miracles does one have to believe?

Just the end of world stuff?

Everything. AFAIK If they can't see it logical, they don't want to believe it but they shouldn't spread misunderstanding/misinterpretation to backup their claims.

"End of the world" is one of the many predictions.

Help me out a bit with this because as an Athiest I view these concepts as total bullshit, and that makes it difficult to separate the various flavors.

It is not only you, all humans are like that. Once we carve something on heart/mind, it is hard to change it. I too see somethings in that way.

In Islam, are alleged "prophecies" considered "miracles?"

It's debatable because for some it is miracles and for some it is just prophecies. I will have to look a little more on this. I will try to reply ASAP.
....
Now that's total bullshit.  If you don't even know what's a miracle and what's not, probably better to not act knowledgeable about them.  Wouldn't you agree?


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: alani123 on April 10, 2015, 05:13:08 PM
What's remarkable here, is that Wilikon's meme-making skills have vastly improved. Keep going Wilikon, maybe one day you'll become a memelord.


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Wilikon on April 10, 2015, 05:20:24 PM
[ center][ img]https://i.imgur.com/wtnyLpk.gif[/img][/center]
[ center][ img]https://i.imgur.com/7SoqC3g.png[/img][/center]

Thanks for pictorial representation, friend!

I think that you and your buddies hacked everybody's locations through their ISPs, and you are sending out terrorists to destroy all your opponents.

 ;D

Yeah. theymos put a backdoor so that terrorists like me can access IP addresses. I have sent a vehicle with a bomb to Wilikon. It was hard to find an exact car he sent me. I have paid the debt with a small tip. Confirm here if you receive it.


A direct personal threat. Not coming from an Atheist. Not coming from a Christian. Not coming from a Buddhist. Not coming from an Amish...









Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Muhammed Zakir on April 10, 2015, 07:26:33 PM
Now that's total bullshit.  If you don't even know what's a miracle and what's not, probably better to not act knowledgeable about them.  Wouldn't you agree?

Sometimes prophecies can be miracles too.

A direct personal threat. Not coming from an Atheist. Not coming from a Christian. Not coming from a Buddhist. Not coming from an Amish...

Do you think I reall meant it? BADecker was joking which was more personal and direct. It was meant ro tease and probably more. I simply made another one. :-\


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Wilikon on April 10, 2015, 07:41:13 PM
Now that's total bullshit.  If you don't even know what's a miracle and what's not, probably better to not act knowledgeable about them.  Wouldn't you agree?

Sometimes prophecies can be miracles too.

A direct personal threat. Not coming from an Atheist. Not coming from a Christian. Not coming from a Buddhist. Not coming from an Amish...

Do you think I reall meant it? BADecker was joking which was more personal and direct. It was meant ro tease and probably more. I simply made another one. :-\


I am not the only one reading your posts, on a support meant to be read by the whole world, long after we are all gone, years from now. Still not sure why I was "part" of your joke, when I was not part of that back and forth between you and someone else...

There is no need to let me live in your mind rent free...





Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Wilikon on April 10, 2015, 08:16:54 PM
What's remarkable here, is that Wilikon's meme-making skills have vastly improved. Keep going Wilikon, maybe one day you'll become a memelord.






 :)






Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: MegaFall on April 10, 2015, 08:23:36 PM
The Moon was not split and rejoined.

Actually it kind of was... that's why half of known chemical make-up of the earth is in the moon and vice-versa. Granted it wasn't the moon until after this happened but a planetesimal did get split in half (along with the earth) to form the moon.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giant_impact_hypothesis


That is likely where that came from. With a little bit lost in translation of the years; being changed from a proto-planet to instead directly say it was pre-existing moon. We all know that nearly all stories in religious texts are modified and expanded on.


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Hamuki on April 10, 2015, 08:25:23 PM
The Moon was not split and rejoined.

Actually it was... that's why half of known chemical make-up of the earth is in the moon and vis-versa.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giant_impact_hypothesis

You do realize that earth colided with a twin planet.. The space debree then started to form and got more gravity pull and then went in orbit with earth and formed the moon.
It was never split.. It was created.. We are lucky to be here.


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Hamuki on April 10, 2015, 08:25:46 PM
http://img-9gag-ftw.9cache.com/photo/aAr2e5L_700b.jpg


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: MegaFall on April 10, 2015, 08:33:03 PM
We are lucky to be here.

This impact is likely one of the reasons why we are here. If I'm not mistaken it is thought that the proto-planet that hit earth contained some of the essential ingredients for life to begin. (Along with a bombardment of comets and asteroids after this impact.)


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: r3wt on April 10, 2015, 08:45:23 PM
Wow, its pretty sad that people have taken it upon themselves to come and pick on the Muslim here. I do not agree with his point of view on somethings, but its no reason to break peace among us.


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Wilikon on April 10, 2015, 08:57:37 PM



How can we source an objective view of a faith?




Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Spendulus on April 10, 2015, 09:06:07 PM
Okay but consider this.

If you've seen the movie, Big Lebowski, which is hilarious, you get the joke.

But if you haven't seen it, this is just a picture of some mad guy cocking a gun.


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Hamuki on April 10, 2015, 09:43:44 PM

They say there is proof.
When we ask for it they go to islamic sources instead of showing the physical proof from either Nasa or any other trusted source of intel..


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: MegaFall on April 10, 2015, 09:51:09 PM

They say there is proof.
When we ask for it they go to islamic sources instead of showing the physical proof from either Nasa or any other trusted source of intel..

NASA is hardly trustworthy. Anybody that believes any government source is truly gullible.


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: maku on April 10, 2015, 10:14:36 PM

They say there is proof.
When we ask for it they go to islamic sources instead of showing the physical proof from either Nasa or any other trusted source of intel..

NASA is hardly trustworthy. Anybody that believes any government source is truly gullible.
NASA is still better source of the information than old prophecy books imo. But that is not the point here. This religious dispute is not going to end well. Worldview opinions and the matters religion never are resolved in  peace because people are just too blind to acknowledge each other point of  view. It is hard to wn a dispute when you have no proof that things you are telling are true.


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Hamuki on April 10, 2015, 10:17:36 PM

They say there is proof.
When we ask for it they go to islamic sources instead of showing the physical proof from either Nasa or any other trusted source of intel..

NASA is hardly trustworthy. Anybody that believes any government source is truly gullible.

Okay, then maybe not a government official.. But atleast somekind of scientist.


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Spendulus on April 10, 2015, 10:32:05 PM

Here is the clip of the section of Big Lebowski where Goodman pulls the gun.

It's a comedy.   Great movie.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YedqV4Gl_us


How can we source an objective view of a faith?


Go forth to Ayn Rand, grasshopper.


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: BADecker on April 11, 2015, 02:07:57 AM
Now that's total bullshit.  If you don't even know what's a miracle and what's not, probably better to not act knowledgeable about them.  Wouldn't you agree?

Sometimes prophecies can be miracles too.

A direct personal threat. Not coming from an Atheist. Not coming from a Christian. Not coming from a Buddhist. Not coming from an Amish...

Do you think I reall meant it? BADecker was joking which was more personal and direct. It was meant ro tease and probably more. I simply made another one. :-\

BADecker's joke didn't have a gigantic personal threat attached to it.

:)


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Hazir on April 11, 2015, 02:37:06 AM
-snip-


How can we source an objective view of a faith?




Religion is something left over from the infancy of our intelligence, it will fade away as we adopt reason and science as our guidelines. - I like to tell people that, but as time flows and I see that most people would sooner die than think; in fact, they do so...



Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: r3wt on April 11, 2015, 02:41:34 AM
Now that's total bullshit.  If you don't even know what's a miracle and what's not, probably better to not act knowledgeable about them.  Wouldn't you agree?

Sometimes prophecies can be miracles too.

A direct personal threat. Not coming from an Atheist. Not coming from a Christian. Not coming from a Buddhist. Not coming from an Amish...

Do you think I reall meant it? BADecker was joking which was more personal and direct. It was meant ro tease and probably more. I simply made another one. :-\

BADecker's joke didn't have a gigantic personal threat attached to it.

:)

Haha, thought you were posting under your sockpuppet huh bud? Either that or you reference yourself in the 3rd person. you fail either way.


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Derek492 on April 11, 2015, 04:37:16 AM
Muhammed was illiterate. He did not write the Koran. The Koran was written by Augustinian monks...it is a product of the Vatican, to create Islam to be the sword of the Vatican (Antichrist Roman Catholic Church).

Jesus is the Rock.... It is on Christ that the true Church be built, not Peter (little pebble). Also, Peter was a married man, not celebate, and he was nothing compared to the Pope of Romanism. Popes started after Constantine, a wicked pagan Baal worshiper.

Even to this day, Islam is controlled by the Vatican (city on seven hills). The Jesuits, and the Pope control the Sunni Islam 100%. This is why they hate the Shia Muslims and are killing them out right now in Yemen and Iran etc...

The Jesuits and Knights of Malta work for the Pope! They control all the Banks! Turn to Jesus of the Bible for truth! Wake up!!! Time is running out!


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Spendulus on April 11, 2015, 04:46:31 AM

They say there is proof.
When we ask for it they go to islamic sources instead of showing the physical proof from either Nasa or any other trusted source of intel..

NASA is hardly trustworthy. Anybody that believes any government source is truly gullible.
Well....

NASA has done an excellent job with it's planetary robotic exploration work.  The STS program, the space shuttle, that's arguable.  In general, NASA is flanked on the left by research departments at universities and private, and it is flanked on the right by an array of industries.  Those produce spacecraft, instrumentation, computer and control systems, rocket motors and so forth.

I'm not sure how words and phrases like "trustworthy" apply to such complex groupings.  Within NASA, there are  divisions by subject matter and by geographical location.

Do I trust the sort-of librarians in Houston whose job is to take care of the lunar rocks and material returned by the Apollo missions? 

Sure.

Etc.


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: MegaFall on April 11, 2015, 04:48:57 AM

They say there is proof.
When we ask for it they go to islamic sources instead of showing the physical proof from either Nasa or any other trusted source of intel..

NASA is hardly trustworthy. Anybody that believes any government source is truly gullible.
Well....

NASA has done an excellent job with it's planetary robotic exploration work.  The STS program, the space shuttle, that's arguable.  In general, NASA is flanked on the left by research departments at universities and private, and it is flanked on the right by an array of industries.  Those produce spacecraft, instrumentation, computer and control systems, rocket motors and so forth.

I'm not sure how words and phrases like "trustworthy" apply to such complex groupings.  Within NASA, there are  divisions by subject matter and by geographical location.

Do I trust the sort-of librarians in Houston whose job is to take care of the lunar rocks and material returned by the Apollo missions? 

Sure.

Etc.

Fine... Got nothing more to say. I think I'll stay out of the "Other" section of BCT from now on...


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: redsn0w on April 11, 2015, 05:07:23 AM

They say there is proof.
When we ask for it they go to islamic sources instead of showing the physical proof from either Nasa or any other trusted source of intel..

NASA is hardly trustworthy. Anybody that believes any government source is truly gullible.
Well....

NASA has done an excellent job with it's planetary robotic exploration work.  The STS program, the space shuttle, that's arguable.  In general, NASA is flanked on the left by research departments at universities and private, and it is flanked on the right by an array of industries.  Those produce spacecraft, instrumentation, computer and control systems, rocket motors and so forth.

I'm not sure how words and phrases like "trustworthy" apply to such complex groupings.  Within NASA, there are  divisions by subject matter and by geographical location.

Do I trust the sort-of librarians in Houston whose job is to take care of the lunar rocks and material returned by the Apollo missions?  

Sure.

Etc.

+1.

We return to an important question, the problem of trust "something" (yes I'm straw man) everyone can believe in whatever he want, but he should not oblige the other to do the same. It is normal all the Muslim believe in the Quran, and it will be most difficult to comvince the other . I remember that one tune my Muslim friend asked me to join the Islam and I've replied to him "I will join only if your religion is better than mine".


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: r3wt on April 11, 2015, 07:53:35 AM
So much agenda here. It reaks


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Spendulus on April 11, 2015, 02:46:38 PM

We return to an important question, the problem of trust "something" (yes I'm straw man) everyone can believe in whatever he want, but he should not oblige the other to do the same. It is normal all the Muslim believe in the Quran, and it will be most difficult to comvince the other . I remember that one tune my Muslim friend asked me to join the Islam and I've replied to him "I will join only if your religion is better than mine".
I agree with you on freedom of each person to choose even if he or she was born into Islam they should have freedom to leave, whatever.

But the thread here is on the Debate Position that there are No Miracles in the Koran.  By contrast the New Testament is full of "Miracles."


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Hamuki on April 11, 2015, 06:55:15 PM

We return to an important question, the problem of trust "something" (yes I'm straw man) everyone can believe in whatever he want, but he should not oblige the other to do the same. It is normal all the Muslim believe in the Quran, and it will be most difficult to comvince the other . I remember that one tune my Muslim friend asked me to join the Islam and I've replied to him "I will join only if your religion is better than mine".
I agree with you on freedom of each person to choose even if he or she was born into Islam they should have freedom to leave, whatever.

But the thread here is on the Debate Position that there are No Miracles in the Koran.  By contrast the New Testament is full of "Miracles."

So.. Islam is great and peacefull..

Lets make some muhammed drawings, lets drink some alcohol and let woman do what they want and dress as they like.
Oh shit.. People in Dubai got in prison for drinking and having sex without being married.
And women get slaughtered if they wear Normal clothing..

Such Peace.. Much Open.. No conflics.



Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Muhammed Zakir on April 12, 2015, 05:29:03 AM
So.. Islam is great and peacefull..

Yes but some people aren't.

Lets make some muhammed drawings,

Isn't what you are saying UAE laws rather than Islamic laws?

lets drink some alcohol and let woman do what they want and dress as they like.

You shouldn't dress as you like unless you are wearing normal dress of the place you live.

Oh shit.. People in Dubai got in prison for drinking

There isn't a rule in Islam to imprison someone for drinking alcohol. It is UAE law. And alcoholic drinks and drugs aren't allowed in Islam because it is the door of bad habits.

UAE law:

Drugs

There is zero tolerance for drugs-related offences. The penalties for drug trafficking, smuggling and possession, of even residual amounts, of drugs are severe. Sentences for drug trafficking can include the death penalty and possession of even the smallest amount of illegal drugs can lead to a minimum 4-year jail sentence. The Emirati authorities count the presence of drugs in the blood stream as possession. You should take care over the import of prescription drugs, some over-the-counter drugs and certain substances known as herbal highs, such as Spice or Space, which can include synthetic cannabinoids.

Many people stop off in UAE airports on their way to other destinations. UAE airports have excellent technology and security, so transiting passengers carrying even residual amounts of drugs are arrested.


Alcohol

Non-Muslim residents can get a liquor licence to drink alcohol at home. These licences are valid only in the Emirate that issued the licence. Residents must also get a permit to be able to drink in licensed venues.

Alcoholic drinks are served in licensed hotels and clubs, but it is a punishable offence to drink, or to be under the influence of alcohol, in public. The legal age for drinking alcohol is 18 in Abu Dhabi (although a Ministry of Tourism by-law allows hotels to serve alcohol only to those over 21), and 21 in Dubai and the Northern Emirates (except Sharjah, where drinking alcohol is illegal).

Passengers in transit through the UAE under the influence of alcohol may also be arrested.


and having sex without being married.

It is UAE law.

Relationships outside marriage

Sex outside marriage is illegal and if any offenders are brought to the attention of the UAE authorities they run the risk of prosecution, imprisonment and/or a fine and deportation. Same sex marriages are not recognised.

Problems will be encountered if an unmarried woman gives birth in the UAE. These problems can range from a refusal to issue a birth certificate to arrest and imprisonment. To get a birth certificate from the UAE authorities, you must provide a marriage certificate. The registration authorities may compare the date of the marriage against the date of birth.

It is against the law to live together or to share the same hotel room with someone of the opposite sex to whom you are not married or closely related.
Homosexual relationships are illegal.


And women get slaughtered if they wear Normal clothing..

Slaughtered? You must be kidding...

UAE law:

Dress code

Women should dress modestly when in public areas like shopping malls. Clothes should cover the tops of the arms and legs, and underwear should not be visible. Swimming attire should be worn only on beaches or at swimming pools.



Such Peace.. Much Open.. No conflics.

Don't spread FUD.


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Hamuki on April 12, 2015, 02:52:21 PM
So.. Islam is great and peacefull..

Yes but some people aren't.

Lets make some muhammed drawings,

Isn't what you are saying UAE laws rather than Islamic laws?

lets drink some alcohol and let woman do what they want and dress as they like.

You shouldn't dress as you like unless you are wearing normal dress of the place you live.

Oh shit.. People in Dubai got in prison for drinking

There isn't a rule in Islam to imprison someone for drinking alcohol. It is UAE law. And alcoholic drinks and drugs aren't allowed in Islam because it is the door of bad habits.

UAE law:

Drugs

There is zero tolerance for drugs-related offences. The penalties for drug trafficking, smuggling and possession, of even residual amounts, of drugs are severe. Sentences for drug trafficking can include the death penalty and possession of even the smallest amount of illegal drugs can lead to a minimum 4-year jail sentence. The Emirati authorities count the presence of drugs in the blood stream as possession. You should take care over the import of prescription drugs, some over-the-counter drugs and certain substances known as herbal highs, such as Spice or Space, which can include synthetic cannabinoids.

Many people stop off in UAE airports on their way to other destinations. UAE airports have excellent technology and security, so transiting passengers carrying even residual amounts of drugs are arrested.


Alcohol

Non-Muslim residents can get a liquor licence to drink alcohol at home. These licences are valid only in the Emirate that issued the licence. Residents must also get a permit to be able to drink in licensed venues.

Alcoholic drinks are served in licensed hotels and clubs, but it is a punishable offence to drink, or to be under the influence of alcohol, in public. The legal age for drinking alcohol is 18 in Abu Dhabi (although a Ministry of Tourism by-law allows hotels to serve alcohol only to those over 21), and 21 in Dubai and the Northern Emirates (except Sharjah, where drinking alcohol is illegal).

Passengers in transit through the UAE under the influence of alcohol may also be arrested.


and having sex without being married.

It is UAE law.

Relationships outside marriage

Sex outside marriage is illegal and if any offenders are brought to the attention of the UAE authorities they run the risk of prosecution, imprisonment and/or a fine and deportation. Same sex marriages are not recognised.

Problems will be encountered if an unmarried woman gives birth in the UAE. These problems can range from a refusal to issue a birth certificate to arrest and imprisonment. To get a birth certificate from the UAE authorities, you must provide a marriage certificate. The registration authorities may compare the date of the marriage against the date of birth.

It is against the law to live together or to share the same hotel room with someone of the opposite sex to whom you are not married or closely related.
Homosexual relationships are illegal.


And women get slaughtered if they wear Normal clothing..

Slaughtered? You must be kidding...

UAE law:

Dress code

Women should dress modestly when in public areas like shopping malls. Clothes should cover the tops of the arms and legs, and underwear should not be visible. Swimming attire should be worn only on beaches or at swimming pools.



Such Peace.. Much Open.. No conflics.

Don't spread FUD.

Still because of Islam.

Not FUD, its facts.


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Muhammed Zakir on April 12, 2015, 05:03:49 PM
Still because of Islam.

Not FUD, its facts.

Give me the rule where Islam tells to imprison people for drinking alcohol and where Islam tells to slaughter if women wear normal clothing. BTW, what is "normal cloth"? IMHO a normal cloth is a cloth which is used widely by people in that place. All types related to that cloth can be considered normal. For example, in UK(or countries which have similar culture), a woman wearing bikini dress in street may be a normal cloth but in Arabian countries or even in India, it may not be considered as a normal cloth.

To me the dress code UAE states in law is normal but, assuming you are in UK(or countries which have similar culture), this dress code may not be normal,

“Dress code

Women should dress modestly when in *public areas like shopping malls*. Clothes should cover the tops of the arms and legs, and underwear should not be visible. Swimming attire should be worn *only on beaches or at swimming pools*.”


Also some of the clothing are long lasted tradition. For example, "Hijab" which is often misinterpreted:

Quote
Head cover for the Jewish woman is encouraged by the Rabbis and religious leaders. Religious Jewish women still cover their heads most of the time and especially in the synagogues, at weddings and religious festivities. This Jewish tradition is a cultural not a religious one. Hijab was observed by the women of the civilizations that preceded the Jews and was passed down to the Jewish culture.

Some Christian women cover their heads in many religious occasions while the nuns cover their heads all the time. The tradition of covering the head was practiced thousands of years before Islam came.

The traditional Arabs, of all religions, Jews, Christians and Muslims used to wear 'hijab' not because of Islam, but because of tradition. In Saudi Arabia for example, all men cover their heads, not because of Islam but because of tradition.

North Africa is known for its Tribe (Tuareg) that have the Muslim men wearing 'hijab' instead of women. Here the tradition has the 'hijab' in reverse. If wearing 'hijab' is the sign of Muslim woman, Mother Teresa would have been the first woman to be counted.

Here is some of the verses from Qur'an:

7:26 - “O children of Adam, We have brought down to you garments to cover your private parts, as well as for adornment, yet the garment of reverence is the best. These are some of God's signs, perhaps they will remember.”

24:31 - “And tell the believing women to lower their gaze and to guard their private parts and not to show their adornments except that of it which normally shows. They shall cover their cleavage with their ‘khimar’. They shall not show their adornments except in the presence of their husbands, their fathers, the fathers of their husbands, their sons, the sons of their husbands, their brothers, the sons of their brothers, the sons of their sisters, other women, their slaves, the male attendants who have no sexual desire and the children who are yet to attain awareness of women’s nakedness. They shall not strike their feet so as to reveal details of their hidden ornaments. You shall repent to God all you believers, so that you may succeed.”

33:59 - “O prophet, tell your wives, your daughters and the wives of the believers that they shall lengthen their garments. This is better so that they will be recognized and not for being molested. God is Forgiver, Merciful.”

24:60 - “The elderly women who no longer anticipate marriage commit no error by relaxing their dress code, provided they do not flaunt their adornments, but to abstain from doing so would be better for them. God is Hearer, Knowledgeable.”


FYI: IIRC there are 4 dress codes for a Muslim man and woman.


Title: Re: NO Miracles in Koran
Post by: Spendulus on April 12, 2015, 07:55:26 PM
....

Still because of Islam.

Not FUD, its facts.
Aw come on.  Wouldn't you want to dress properly to go to the neighborhood stoning?

I know I would.