Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Bitcoin Discussion => Topic started by: JompinDox on September 05, 2012, 01:24:27 PM



Title: Is blockchain.info illegal?
Post by: JompinDox on September 05, 2012, 01:24:27 PM
Blockchain.info, aside from being a great tool and web wallet, offers and advertises a coin mixer service - or to put it in plain English, a money laundering service. Under what jurisdiction is money laundering legal??


Title: Re: Is blockchain.info illegal?
Post by: flower1024 on September 05, 2012, 01:26:29 PM
Blockchain.info, aside from being a great tool and web wallet, offers and advertises a coin mixer service - or to put it in plain English, a money laundering service. Under what jurisdiction is money laundering legal??

bitcoins are no money so they cannot be laundered.


Title: Re: Is blockchain.info illegal?
Post by: stevegee58 on September 05, 2012, 01:41:23 PM
Blockchain.info, aside from being a great tool and web wallet, offers and advertises a coin mixer service - or to put it in plain English, a money laundering service. Under what jurisdiction is money laundering legal??

bitcoins are no money so they cannot be laundered.

BTC is money:

"Money is any object or record that is generally accepted as payment for goods and services and repayment of debts"


Title: Re: Is blockchain.info illegal?
Post by: gweedo on September 05, 2012, 01:44:55 PM
Blockchain.info, aside from being a great tool and web wallet, offers and advertises a coin mixer service - or to put it in plain English, a money laundering service. Under what jurisdiction is money laundering legal??

And under which laws are bitcoins covered? None


Title: Re: Is blockchain.info illegal?
Post by: flower1024 on September 05, 2012, 01:46:58 PM
Blockchain.info, aside from being a great tool and web wallet, offers and advertises a coin mixer service - or to put it in plain English, a money laundering service. Under what jurisdiction is money laundering legal??

bitcoins are no money so they cannot be laundered.

BTC is money:

"Money is any object or record that is generally accepted as payment for goods and services and repayment of debts"

lets see if glbse gets registered as a company easily... for me this would the first proof (i live in eu too)


Title: Re: Is blockchain.info illegal?
Post by: hazek on September 05, 2012, 01:49:17 PM
Blockchain.info, aside from being a great tool and web wallet, offers and advertises a coin mixer service - or to put it in plain English, a money laundering service. Under what jurisdiction is money laundering legal??

Money laundering is a recently invented crime designed to control us to which I say fuck you.


Title: Re: Is blockchain.info illegal?
Post by: bg002h on September 05, 2012, 01:51:45 PM
Blockchain.info, aside from being a great tool and web wallet, offers and advertises a coin mixer service - or to put it in plain English, a money laundering service. Under what jurisdiction is money laundering legal??

bitcoins are no money so they cannot be laundered.

 I think anything can be laundered, not just fiat money and Bitcoin money. All laundering is is an attempt to conceal the identities/amounts of a transfer...of anything.

Doubt there has been any case yet to clearly decide if laundering services are illegal.


Title: Re: Is blockchain.info illegal?
Post by: piuk on September 05, 2012, 01:58:39 PM
The mixer is for privacy, not money laundering. Bitcoin being traceable is an artefact of the technology. There is no law which states BTC sent back to a users must originate from the same set out outputs as the BTC paid in.

Besides that blockchain.info is well under the volume threshold required to register as an MSB within the UK.


Title: Re: Is blockchain.info illegal?
Post by: knight22 on September 05, 2012, 02:10:39 PM
If I would like to wash my money, I would simply go to the laundromat machine which I call "casino", buy a plenty of token and then change them back to money as the grand winner!
Are casinos illegal in Vegas??


Title: Re: Is blockchain.info illegal?
Post by: stevegee58 on September 05, 2012, 02:20:26 PM
In casinos, transactions over $10,000 are automatically are automatically reported to the feds.


Title: Re: Is blockchain.info illegal?
Post by: Graet on September 05, 2012, 02:29:27 PM
In casinos, transactions over $10,000 are automatically are automatically reported to the feds.
i'm not American
but
how many casinos are in vegas?
x $9,000

walk in buy chips, play a couple of games -doesnt matter if you win or lose- cashout $8,900 worth of chips go to next casino?

tho the casions dont call themselves "mixer services" :)

This whole AML stuff is a sham, doesn't catch the big players, they already successfully use banks, just another imposition on the little guy who probably wouldn't have a reason to launder money...


Title: Re: Is blockchain.info illegal?
Post by: optimator on September 05, 2012, 02:34:55 PM
In casinos, transactions over $10,000 are automatically are automatically reported to the feds.

CASH. Cash is reportable. I can make $10,000 credit card purchase, wire transfers, check transactions. These aren't reportable because a paper tail exists. Form 8300 for reference - http://apps2.irs.gov/businesses/small/article/0,,id=148821,00.html (http://apps2.irs.gov/businesses/small/article/0,,id=148821,00.html)



Title: Re: Is blockchain.info illegal?
Post by: Jan on September 05, 2012, 02:35:26 PM
Blockchain.info, aside from being a great tool and web wallet, offers and advertises a coin mixer service - or to put it in plain English, a money laundering service. Under what jurisdiction is money laundering legal??
Hmm... Interesting discussion. I guess we will not have an answer until it has been tried in a court :o


Title: Re: Is blockchain.info illegal?
Post by: bg002h on September 05, 2012, 03:26:42 PM
In casinos, transactions over $10,000 are automatically are automatically reported to the feds.
i'm not American
but
how many casinos are in vegas?
x $9,000

walk in buy chips, play a couple of games -doesnt matter if you win or lose- cashout $8,900 worth of chips go to next casino?

tho the casions dont call themselves "mixer services" :)

This whole AML stuff is a sham, doesn't catch the big players, they already successfully use banks, just another imposition on the little guy who probably wouldn't have a reason to launder money...

I'm not quite sure how chips work in a casino, but, can one really walk up to the....uhh...check out counter and plop down $9k worth of plastic chips and get handed $9k cash, no questions asked?


Title: Re: Is blockchain.info illegal?
Post by: ErnestoJuarell on September 05, 2012, 03:42:52 PM
Blockchain.info, aside from being a great tool and web wallet, offers and advertises a coin mixer service - or to put it in plain English, a money laundering service. Under what jurisdiction is money laundering legal??
It's about privacy. Addresses can be tied to users (like how you put a vanity address (http://blockchain.info/address/1ELECeJompinDox61L73eAUyaWpe3Q5HZB) in your sig).

Now if you go and purchase some boner pills, the whole world will know about it.


Title: Re: Is blockchain.info illegal?
Post by: gbl08ma on September 05, 2012, 04:17:37 PM
Interesting how the OP asked the question and then didn't say anything else on this thread...


Title: Re: Is blockchain.info illegal?
Post by: sadpandatech on September 05, 2012, 04:19:51 PM
@OP   VERY illegal, you should report them immediatly!!!


Title: Re: Is blockchain.info illegal?
Post by: thallium205 on September 05, 2012, 04:24:26 PM
Blockchain.info, aside from being a great tool and web wallet, offers and advertises a coin mixer service - or to put it in plain English, a money laundering service. Under what jurisdiction is money laundering legal??
It's about privacy. Addresses can be tied to users (like how you put a vanity address (http://blockchain.info/address/1ELECeJompinDox61L73eAUyaWpe3Q5HZB) in your sig).

Now if you go and purchase some boner pills, the whole world will know about it.

It's not just addresses - groups of addresses can be be identified to the same user.  Go here and click on the owner icon: http://blockviewer.com/#/owns/1ELECeJompinDox61L73eAUyaWpe3Q5HZB (http://blockviewer.com/#/owns/1ELECeJompinDox61L73eAUyaWpe3Q5HZB) - you can see 190+ addresses has been linked to him as well!  In fact, the tool even identified his screen name (look at the line label pointing from his address to the owner icon) so he's explicitly identified.

EDIT:
What's even more damming is that another address was explicity identified to be from the user "flatfly".  So the OP also owns flatfly username too -> https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=52782 (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=52782)


Title: Re: Is blockchain.info illegal?
Post by: JompinDox on September 05, 2012, 04:40:27 PM
Blockchain.info, aside from being a great tool and web wallet, offers and advertises a coin mixer service - or to put it in plain English, a money laundering service. Under what jurisdiction is money laundering legal??
It's about privacy. Addresses can be tied to users (like how you put a vanity address (http://blockchain.info/address/1ELECeJompinDox61L73eAUyaWpe3Q5HZB) in your sig).

Now if you go and purchase some boner pills, the whole world will know about it.

It's not just addresses - groups of addresses can be be identified to the same user.  Go here and click on the owner icon: http://blockviewer.com/#/owns/1ELECeJompinDox61L73eAUyaWpe3Q5HZB (http://blockviewer.com/#/owns/1ELECeJompinDox61L73eAUyaWpe3Q5HZB) - you can see 190+ addresses has been linked to him as well!  In fact, the tool even identified his screen name (look at the line label pointing from his address to the owner icon) so he's explicitly identified.

EDIT:
What's even more damming is that another address was explicity identified to be from the user "flatfly".  So the OP also owns flatfly username too -> https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=52782 (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=52782)

Which is totally public information... But congrats on your couch detective skills :)

And nice tool by the way.


Title: Re: Is blockchain.info illegal?
Post by: matthewh3 on September 05, 2012, 04:50:50 PM
Blockchain.info, aside from being a great tool and web wallet, offers and advertises a coin mixer service - or to put it in plain English, a money laundering service. Under what jurisdiction is money laundering legal??

Laundering money is not illegal but laundering the proceeds of criminal activity's raised funds is.   


Title: Re: Is blockchain.info illegal?
Post by: sadpandatech on September 05, 2012, 04:55:52 PM
Blockchain.info, aside from being a great tool and web wallet, offers and advertises a coin mixer service - or to put it in plain English, a money laundering service. Under what jurisdiction is money laundering legal??
It's about privacy. Addresses can be tied to users (like how you put a vanity address (http://blockchain.info/address/1ELECeJompinDox61L73eAUyaWpe3Q5HZB) in your sig).

Now if you go and purchase some boner pills, the whole world will know about it.

It's not just addresses - groups of addresses can be be identified to the same user.  Go here and click on the owner icon: http://blockviewer.com/#/owns/1ELECeJompinDox61L73eAUyaWpe3Q5HZB (http://blockviewer.com/#/owns/1ELECeJompinDox61L73eAUyaWpe3Q5HZB) - you can see 190+ addresses has been linked to him as well!  In fact, the tool even identified his screen name (look at the line label pointing from his address to the owner icon) so he's explicitly identified.

EDIT:
What's even more damming is that another address was explicity identified to be from the user "flatfly".  So the OP also owns flatfly username too -> https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=52782 (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=52782)

Which is totally public information... But congrats on your couch detective skills :)

ohhh, now you can make replies. ;p


Title: Re: Is blockchain.info illegal?
Post by: JoelKatz on September 05, 2012, 05:08:40 PM
Blockchain.info, aside from being a great tool and web wallet, offers and advertises a coin mixer service - or to put it in plain English, a money laundering service. Under what jurisdiction is money laundering legal??
Under any jurisdiction that doesn't have a law that makes what blockchain.info illegal. If there's a US Federal law that you think makes it illegal, I'd love a citation. Honestly, I don't know if it's legal or not. My bet is that you could probably find some law you could cram it into, but that's true of almost anything.