Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Mining => Topic started by: enmaku on September 30, 2012, 07:05:10 AM



Title: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: enmaku on September 30, 2012, 07:05:10 AM
http://codinginmysleep.com/butterfly-labs-releases-more-data/


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: juhakall on September 30, 2012, 07:15:35 AM
Can't really blame them if they deliver more than was promised. It just seems weird that the Jalapeno only gets a ~29% increase, while the Single and Minirig both get 50%.


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: DeaDTerra on September 30, 2012, 07:26:27 AM
Can't really blame them if they deliver more than was promised. It just seems weird that the Jalapeno only gets a ~29% increase, while the Single and Minirig both get 50%.
This is in fact what happens in almost all chip production.
Take for example 6950 and 6970 they are the same chip yet they perform differently this is due to that the better performing chips becomes the 6970 while the worse performing becomes the 6950.
Probably the same is true for the BFLS, maybe the good chips becomes Singles and minirigs while the worse performing becomes singles.
Just a guess.
//DeaDTerra


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: Jack1Rip1BurnIt on September 30, 2012, 07:29:37 AM
Can't really blame them if they deliver more than was promised. It just seems weird that the Jalapeno only gets a ~29% increase, while the Single and Minirig both get 50%.

Well, from what I can gather from the article it all has to do with the power. If you notice the trend is 1 gh/s per watt. Therefore the total max watts on the jalepeno is 4.5 because that is the maximum output for dual usb 2.0 outputs. Crazy hashrates/watts either way...very interesting futureahead of us.


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: BCMan on September 30, 2012, 07:30:59 AM
 1Gh per watt? Yeah, right.


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: enmaku on September 30, 2012, 07:31:23 AM
Can't really blame them if they deliver more than was promised. It just seems weird that the Jalapeno only gets a ~29% increase, while the Single and Minirig both get 50%.

Power consumption, friend, power consumption.

Say before they were thinking their numbers would let them pull off < 2.5 watts, that would let them run off a single USB port without having to worry about whether your port is a 500ma or 1000ma port, without going to the double-plug USB cables or without having to think about USB 3.0 compatibility. With the upgrade they threw the old 2.5 watt max out the window and went to the most you can possibly pull from a USB 2.0 port if it's new or if you have a double cable, 5 watts. I'm guessing they could probably clock it way higher if the power and heating were available, but they're limited by USB power since they don't want to go to wall adapters.


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: enmaku on September 30, 2012, 07:32:09 AM
1Gh per watt? Yeah, right.

http://cdn.head-fi.org/2/24/249fa280_artworks-000000560200-m3phen-crop.jpg


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: Jack1Rip1BurnIt on September 30, 2012, 07:39:30 AM
If these performance claims are true then the bitcoin network will be unbelievably secure and we would more than likely see thousands of terahashes before the 12.5 reward half.


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: dust on September 30, 2012, 07:52:57 AM
The SC single board rendering that BFL released had 8 sha256 chips.  I assume the jalapeno will have 1.  It it even more strange now that the single gets more hash rate out of each chip.  The single is now doing 7.5Gh/s/chip compared to the jalapeno's 4.5Gh/s/chip, but they are equally energy efficient.

This announcement is probably in response to bASIC's announcement.  It doesn't increase my confidence in BFL as if they were scamming it would also make sense to make this kind of announcement.  Pictures of the actual products and working demos would be nice...


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: enmaku on September 30, 2012, 07:55:06 AM
The SC single board rendering that BFL released had 8 sha256 chips.  I assume the jalapeno will have 1.  It it even more strange now that the single gets more hash rate out of each chip.  The single is now doing 7.5Gh/s/chip compared to the jalapeno's 4.5Gh/s/chip, but they are equally energy efficient.

This announcement is probably in response to bASIC's announcement.  It doesn't increase my confidence in BFL as if they were scamming it would also make sense to make this kind of announcement.  Pictures of the actual products and working demos would be nice...

I don't have pics or working demos for you, but I can tell you why the jally is only doing 4.5gh/s while the single is getting 7.5gh/s per chip - they didn't want to add a power brick. This limits them to the 5 watts they can reasonably expect to pull from a USB port (either a 1000ma port or using a dual USB adapter with 500ma ports) Assuming they had 7.5 watts to work with I'd bet the jally could pull 7.5 GH/s but it would then require a power adapter.


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: Monkey1 on September 30, 2012, 08:56:05 AM
Still no idea of when they are likely to ship and in one of the posts, Josh states that they dont know how many of each type they will be able to ship initially.  Surely with 4 weeks to go to their (revised) stated shipping date, they should know a little more that that?


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: Jutarul on September 30, 2012, 09:34:01 AM
1Gh per watt? Yeah, right.
Why does 1J/GH trigger my bullshit detector?


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: Luno on September 30, 2012, 09:41:50 AM
I don't think the specs are based on actual measurements. A 1500W Power supply would have higher efficiency than the 4.5W one. The figures are estimates based on board design not from the wall measurements on production / prototype -boards. Their headline also don't claim the specs to be measured.


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: Monkey1 on September 30, 2012, 03:56:47 PM
With 4 weeks to go you would expect them to have some actual measurements surely? 


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: Shadow383 on September 30, 2012, 04:00:59 PM
With 4 weeks to go you would expect them to have some actual measurements surely? 
This announcement is probably in response to bASIC's announcement.  It doesn't increase my confidence in BFL as if they were scamming it would also make sense to make this kind of announcement.  Pictures of the actual products and working demos would be nice...

Noooo! Don't forget what Inaba said! You guys are being entitled and unreasonable.

Look! They've used your millions of dollars and made an extruded cube with rounded edges and applied their logo to it in Solidworks.


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: Fcx35x10 on October 01, 2012, 03:56:38 AM
BFL had to adapt to competitions  :-X


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: crazyates on October 01, 2012, 05:28:52 AM
A 1500W Power supply would have higher efficiency than the 4.5W one.
Umm where was it ever said that the "4.5W one" (I'm assuming you're talking about the Jalapeno) would even HAVE a power supply? The Jalapeno receives it's power from a DC feed through the USB. Its efficiency would be whatever your computer's PSU's efficiency is.


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: VeeMiner on October 01, 2012, 12:56:38 PM
these numbers sound great, I hope BFL can deliver...


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: Fcx35x10 on October 01, 2012, 01:58:40 PM
these numbers sound great, I hope BFL can deliver...

+1

I agree


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: Monkey1 on October 01, 2012, 08:43:55 PM
But When?


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: GenTarkin on October 01, 2012, 09:42:25 PM
5.16.2014


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: mentalove on October 02, 2012, 05:46:10 AM
5.16.2014

lol


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: nameface on October 04, 2012, 10:59:56 PM
with performance at 35% of claimed specs :P


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: Fiyasko on October 05, 2012, 03:50:37 PM
UNNGGHHHHHHH IM FUCKING HITTING MYSELF!
I had a chance of "invest in a BFL ASIC" or "buy a new keyboard and mouse"
FUUUUUU I Need one of these!


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: Shadow383 on October 05, 2012, 03:58:59 PM
UNNGGHHHHHHH IM FUCKING HITTING MYSELF!
I had a chance of "invest in a BFL ASIC" or "buy a new keyboard and mouse"
FUUUUUU I Need one of these!
bASIC FTW  ;)


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: crazyates on October 05, 2012, 04:45:37 PM
UNNGGHHHHHHH IM FUCKING HITTING MYSELF!
I had a chance of "invest in a BFL ASIC" or "buy a new keyboard and mouse"
FUUUUUU I Need one of these!
Geez! How expensive are keyboards and mice where you live?!  ;D ;D


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: Fiyasko on October 05, 2012, 09:20:00 PM
UNNGGHHHHHHH IM FUCKING HITTING MYSELF!
I had a chance of "invest in a BFL ASIC" or "buy a new keyboard and mouse"
FUUUUUU I Need one of these!
Geez! How expensive are keyboards and mice where you live?!  ;D ;D
Well, I can buy crap gear at $20 total wich wouldnt be better than replacing the damaged gear.
Or buy some proper gaming imput devices, Mouse and Keyboard, For around $170


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: crazyates on October 05, 2012, 09:28:32 PM
UNNGGHHHHHHH IM FUCKING HITTING MYSELF!
I had a chance of "invest in a BFL ASIC" or "buy a new keyboard and mouse"
FUUUUUU I Need one of these!
Geez! How expensive are keyboards and mice where you live?!  ;D ;D
Well, I can buy crap gear at $20 total wich wouldnt be better than replacing the damaged gear.
Or buy some proper gaming imput devices, Mouse and Keyboard, For around $170
$170? I've never understood why people need to spend that much on a keyboard/mouse. Don't get me wrong, I love nice computer equipment, and considering it's the hardware you are physically interacting with to control your computer, it better be nice. But a $30 apple keyboard and a $15 Razor mouse (both on sale) is absolutely perfect for me.


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: Fiyasko on October 06, 2012, 03:27:06 AM
UNNGGHHHHHHH IM FUCKING HITTING MYSELF!
I had a chance of "invest in a BFL ASIC" or "buy a new keyboard and mouse"
FUUUUUU I Need one of these!
Geez! How expensive are keyboards and mice where you live?!  ;D ;D
Well, I can buy crap gear at $20 total wich wouldnt be better than replacing the damaged gear.
Or buy some proper gaming imput devices, Mouse and Keyboard, For around $170
$170? I've never understood why people need to spend that much on a keyboard/mouse. Don't get me wrong, I love nice computer equipment, and considering it's the hardware you are physically interacting with to control your computer, it better be nice. But a $30 apple keyboard and a $15 Razor mouse (both on sale) is absolutely perfect for me.
Not gonna comment on the apple keyboard...
Razor products break fast

I bought a CoolerMaster QuickFirePro Cherry MX Reds and a R.A.T.5 Mouse
Both are gonna last me Atleast five years, The keyboard i expect to last 10, Things built So tough, Its almost like your supposed to hit it with your fists and toss it


Title: Re: BFL releases actual specs. ACTUAL SPECS!
Post by: crazyates on October 06, 2012, 04:12:11 AM
$170? I've never understood why people need to spend that much on a keyboard/mouse. Don't get me wrong, I love nice computer equipment, and considering it's the hardware you are physically interacting with to control your computer, it better be nice. But a $30 apple keyboard and a $15 Razor mouse (both on sale) is absolutely perfect for me.
Not gonna comment on the apple keyboard...
Razor products break fast

I bought a CoolerMaster QuickFirePro Cherry MX Reds and a R.A.T.5 Mouse
Both are gonna last me Atleast five years, The keyboard i expect to last 10, Things built So tough, Its almost like your supposed to hit it with your fists and toss it
Why? That Apple keyboard (the wired one with the numpad, I can stand the wireless ones) is pretty decent. I like the low profile not found in too many other keyboards. It's taken a lot of abuse, and is even slightly bent (damn little brothers), but works great after 4 years now. The Razor is very comfortable, has been going for about 3 years now, and is solid as well.

Granted I'v never used a R.A.T.5, but they've always seemed overengineered, and overpriced. What makes it worth 5x the cost of my Razor? Will my games be any less fun if I don't?