|
Title: [video] Nothing At Stake Explained in 4 Minutes Post by: jones_ on August 13, 2015, 06:15:17 AM I made a short video explaining what nothing at stake means with proof of stake cryptocurrencies as well as what can be done about it and how much it effects the currency as a whole.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pzIl3vmEytY In this video I discuss what is generally called a short range nothing at stake double spend attempt. Nothing at stake could mean a few other potential issues, but this is the most interesting to study and the one that is potentially feasible in most Proof of stake systems. thank you to kushti and the consensus research team (http://consensusresearch.org/) for their work on this subject. Title: Re: [video] Nothing At Stake Explained in 4 Minutes Post by: monsterer on August 13, 2015, 08:55:34 AM Here's nothing at stake explained in one sentence:
If it costs nothing to produce a block, then attacking the network also costs nothing. Title: Re: [video] Nothing At Stake Explained in 4 Minutes Post by: Este Nuno on August 13, 2015, 10:00:19 AM Nice vid. Thanks for posting it.
Title: Re: [video] Nothing At Stake Explained in 4 Minutes Post by: HCLivess on August 13, 2015, 10:42:28 AM Why do you keep beating around this debunked myth? It does not cost nothing to produce a block. Wha t the fuck...
Title: Re: [video] Nothing At Stake Explained in 4 Minutes Post by: r0ach on August 13, 2015, 11:45:23 AM I just made a thread talking about proof of capacity with a few references to nothing at stake attacks in that system here:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1151924.0 Title: Re: [video] Nothing At Stake Explained in 4 Minutes Post by: Este Nuno on August 13, 2015, 12:10:01 PM Why do you keep beating around this debunked myth? It does not cost nothing to produce a block. Wha t the fuck... Who are you replying to here? Title: Re: [video] Nothing At Stake Explained in 4 Minutes Post by: HCLivess on August 13, 2015, 01:04:27 PM Why do you keep beating around this debunked myth? It does not cost nothing to produce a block. Wha t the fuck... Who are you replying to here? Proof of stake in the PP/NVC fork is essentially different from NXT algo. It is not true that no resources are used. Everything is mixed up and confusing. Title: Re: [video] Nothing At Stake Explained in 4 Minutes Post by: Este Nuno on August 13, 2015, 01:49:37 PM Why do you keep beating around this debunked myth? It does not cost nothing to produce a block. Wha t the fuck... Who are you replying to here? Proof of stake in the PP/NVC fork is essentially different from NXT algo. It is not true that no resources are used. Everything is mixed up and confusing. Yes, I assume you're responding monsterer rather than OP then. Title: Re: [video] Nothing At Stake Explained in 4 Minutes Post by: jones_ on August 13, 2015, 03:20:46 PM Why do you keep beating around this debunked myth? It does not cost nothing to produce a block. Wha t the fuck... Who are you replying to here? Proof of stake in the PP/NVC fork is essentially different from NXT algo. It is not true that no resources are used. Everything is mixed up and confusing. Yes, in the video I focus on nxt like 100% pos systems, but parallels can be drawn from this to other more complicated systems. Title: Re: [video] Nothing At Stake Explained in 4 Minutes Post by: jabo38 on August 13, 2015, 03:25:32 PM that was a pretty good video. Thanks Jones
Title: Re: [video] Nothing At Stake Explained in 4 Minutes Post by: monsterer on August 13, 2015, 04:25:36 PM Why do you keep beating around this debunked myth? It does not cost nothing to produce a block. Wha t the fuck... Where is the cost? Title: Re: [video] Nothing At Stake Explained in 4 Minutes Post by: kushti on August 13, 2015, 06:40:58 PM The explanation is just superb!
Title: Re: [video] Nothing At Stake Explained in 4 Minutes Post by: jones_ on August 14, 2015, 04:27:39 AM Why do you keep beating around this debunked myth? It does not cost nothing to produce a block. Wha t the fuck... Where is the cost? I think you misunderstand the concept. Sure it is possible to fork a POS cryptocurrency by forging a block on an alternate chain and broadcasting your new chain, but if the chain that you do this on doesn't have over 50% of the stake forging on it, it will lose out to the main branch. You are welcome to attempt to forge on as many branches as you want at the same time in Proof of Stake, but unless everyone else is mindlessly running their nodes with a multibranch stategy, the attack that you try may cost nothing, but it will not work. The explanation is just superb! Thanks Kushti, happy to know I got it correct :) Title: Re: [video] Nothing At Stake Explained in 4 Minutes Post by: BayAreaCoins on August 14, 2015, 04:33:15 AM Attack CLAM then ::)
Title: Re: [video] Nothing At Stake Explained in 4 Minutes Post by: monsterer on August 14, 2015, 07:00:01 AM I think you misunderstand the concept. Sure it is possible to fork a POS cryptocurrency by forging a block on an alternate chain and broadcasting your new chain, but if the chain that you do this on doesn't have over 50% of the stake forging on it, it will lose out to the main branch. You are talking about the specifics of a subclass of attacks which only exist because of the zero cost of block production. |