Bitcoin Forum

Other => New forum software => Topic started by: twister on September 27, 2015, 01:56:27 PM



Title: Would it be possible to track PMs in the new forum?
Post by: twister on September 27, 2015, 01:56:27 PM
I sent some PMs to someone and they haven't responded and I don't know if they even read them or not which makes me wonder, can this feature be added in the new forum, a sort of notification or a tick in the sender's sent PM box when the other person reads the PM?

I think it might also help people who open up threads in Meta saying they sent the account recovery signed message but haven't receive any response and this way they'll know that the reason for that is their PM hasn't been handled yet?


Title: Re: Would it be possible to track PMs in the new forum?
Post by: Athertle on September 27, 2015, 06:57:01 PM
Kind of like how Facebook Messenger tracks if the recipient has read the PM? I suppose this would be a good idea, although I'm on the fence because many people would start complaining about how their PMs were read and not answered for a couple days. I've been reading a few "account hacked" posts and they seem to disregard the fact that theymos/BB are busy.


Title: Re: Would it be possible to track PMs in the new forum?
Post by: twister on September 28, 2015, 10:08:19 AM
Kind of like how Facebook Messenger tracks if the recipient has read the PM? I suppose this would be a good idea, although I'm on the fence because many people would start complaining about how their PMs were read and not answered for a couple days. I've been reading a few "account hacked" posts and they seem to disregard the fact that theymos/BB are busy.

Don't use FB, so don't know how that works there but I imagine it might be the same, some of the email providers have that, when the recipient reads the email, they inform the sender about it.


Title: Re: Would it be possible to track PMs in the new forum?
Post by: Vod on September 28, 2015, 10:11:19 AM
I sent some PMs to someone and they haven't responded and I don't know if they even read them or not which makes me wonder, can this feature be added in the new forum, a sort of notification or a tick in the sender's sent PM box when the other person reads the PM?

I don't like this idea.

To me, it's an invasion of privacy.  I like choosing when people think I'm online/available.  I don't want alarms/triggers going off when I read a PM.

Besides, I think the forum admin already addressed this when they disabled being able to send a 1x1 image in a PM.


Title: Re: Would it be possible to track PMs in the new forum?
Post by: twister on September 28, 2015, 02:58:38 PM
Yeah, it probably isn't a great idea but maybe there can be an option to turn it off in settings, like you appear online by default unless you specifically choose to appear offline. Don't know anything about the image in PM thing.


Title: Re: Would it be possible to track PMs in the new forum?
Post by: Restored on September 29, 2015, 07:06:28 PM
Yeah, it probably isn't a great idea but maybe there can be an option to turn it off in settings, like you appear online by default unless you specifically choose to appear offline. Don't know anything about the image in PM thing.

In that case, I think it'll be a good idea. Most people will turn it off though.


Title: Re: Would it be possible to track PMs in the new forum?
Post by: newtons1 on October 04, 2015, 11:57:59 PM
This is impossible to implement. Users receive e-mail notifications when PM's are received and it would be too easy to get around any kind of tracking to see when an e-mail is received from the forum (this is also ignoring the invasion of privacy that such e-mail tracking would impose).

I might support some kind of opt-in system when users choose to have a notification automatically sent to the sender notifying them their message was read. This might be good if a message does not elicit a response.