Bitcoin Forum

Alternate cryptocurrencies => Altcoin Discussion => Topic started by: SebastianJu on October 10, 2015, 07:11:08 PM



Title: Vanity Gen Address Cost?
Post by: SebastianJu on October 10, 2015, 07:11:08 PM
So i'm escrow for an altcoin ico and the issuer claimed to have sent unsold coins to a burn address. That address seems to be not a burn address after earlz rules though it contains the word BurnAddress. https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1195417.msg12651182#msg12651182

My question now is how much would it cost to create such an address as a vanity address? I know there are services for bitcoin vanity addresses, though i did not find a price for them yet. Though it might be possible to judge from these prices.

Besides that, i guess that creating such a vanity address has the same difficulty in a new altcoin like with bitcoin, right?

Thanks!


Title: Re: Vanity Gen Address Cost?
Post by: Quickseller on October 10, 2015, 08:09:25 PM
To create a vanity address, you will need to tell a program certain criteria that you wish the vanity address to contain and then that program will check various private keys until the public address associated with that private key matches that criteria. In theory a vanity address generator can generate a very complex vanity address on it's first "guess". It would also be possible to create a program that checks for multiple vanity addresses at a time, for example it could check for "BurnAddress" as well as "Burned" at the same time and would save the private keys of any address that contains either of the above words.

It is my understanding that, if you were to assume 100% luck, it takes an exponentially greater amount of computing power for each additional letter in a vanity address, so it would take more then 2x the computing power to generate a vanity address containing 6 letters verses one containing 3 specific letters.

As mentioned in the other thread, it would be very expensive to generate a bitcoin address of that complexity, prohibitively so regarding the amounts of money in question, but this assumes 100% luck.

Quote
Besides that, i guess that creating such a vanity address has the same difficulty in a new altcoin like with bitcoin, right?
This depends on the relationship between the private key and the address. If the address is calculated in a different way from the private key then the difficulty to generate an altcoin vanity address could be different from bitcoin.



It would be my opinion that the best way to handle a burn address when an escrow is being used would be to have the dev of the altcoin to send the funds that are to be burned to an address that the escrow controls, and then the escrow would delete the private key, and since the investors are already trusting the escrow with their money, they should be able to trust hat the escrow actually deletes the private key. Alternatively, the escrow could specify a specific burn address for the dev of an altcoin to send the coins to be burned that the escrow knows is unspendable in order to avoid this kind of dispute, as it is really impossible to know at this point one way or another if the dev did something that does not conform with what is normally done, but is still acting in good faith (and does not control the private key to that address), or if the dev is acting maliciously.


Title: Re: Vanity Gen Address Cost?
Post by: OgNasty on October 10, 2015, 08:37:04 PM
That is a long vanity address.  Without doing more than making an educated guess, I would say it would cost several thousand dollars in electricity to generate such an address.


Title: Re: Vanity Gen Address Cost?
Post by: ocminer on October 10, 2015, 09:13:14 PM
It's a fake address, it is 1 char too long, its just photoshop.


Title: Re: Vanity Gen Address Cost?
Post by: unamis76 on October 10, 2015, 09:58:07 PM
It would take quite a bit of "horse power" to create such an address... Meaning, it wouldn't be feasible to create it.

It's a fake address, it is 1 char too long, its just photoshop.

And yes, just look at the address part, the lettering, the font, and how it's positioned...


Title: Re: Vanity Gen Address Cost?
Post by: Erkallys on October 10, 2015, 10:07:37 PM
I was not aware that vanity address generator were existing for Bitcoin too. But tell, if it's possible to search address this way, would it be possible to hack an address by entering the complete address as the desired output ? This is something that afraid me, like if someone could generate the same Electrum passphrase as me and stole my coins  :-\...


Title: Re: Vanity Gen Address Cost?
Post by: unamis76 on October 10, 2015, 10:22:01 PM
I was not aware that vanity address generator were existing for Bitcoin too. But tell, if it's possible to search address this way, would it be possible to hack an address by entering the complete address as the desired output ? This is something that afraid me, like if someone could generate the same Electrum passphrase as me and stole my coins  :-\...

What you're saying is impossible. The sun would have higher chances of extinguishing soon than finding the key to a certain address.


Title: Re: Vanity Gen Address Cost?
Post by: Erkallys on October 11, 2015, 06:50:40 AM
I was not aware that vanity address generator were existing for Bitcoin too. But tell, if it's possible to search address this way, would it be possible to hack an address by entering the complete address as the desired output ? This is something that afraid me, like if someone could generate the same Electrum passphrase as me and stole my coins  :-\...

What you're saying is impossible. The sun would have higher chances of extinguishing soon than finding the key to a certain address.

So that's nice  :) ! But are you talking about ? Finding a Bitcoin address' private key or an Electrum passphrase ? Maybe both of them are impossible and I prefer that !


Title: Re: Vanity Gen Address Cost?
Post by: TastyChillySauce00 on October 11, 2015, 07:00:06 AM
the cost depend on how much letter you will generate , for example 6 custom letter took long time to get , so the cost will be higher


Title: Re: Vanity Gen Address Cost?
Post by: unamis76 on October 11, 2015, 02:21:39 PM
I was not aware that vanity address generator were existing for Bitcoin too. But tell, if it's possible to search address this way, would it be possible to hack an address by entering the complete address as the desired output ? This is something that afraid me, like if someone could generate the same Electrum passphrase as me and stole my coins  :-\...

What you're saying is impossible. The sun would have higher chances of extinguishing soon than finding the key to a certain address.

So that's nice  :) ! But are you talking about ? Finding a Bitcoin address' private key or an Electrum passphrase ? Maybe both of them are impossible and I prefer that !

I was talking about a private key, as that was the objective of the thread. As for Electrum, if you're referring to the seed, you need a dictionary attack, I think, but don't quote me on that. It's also a very expensive attack.


Title: Re: Vanity Gen Address Cost?
Post by: SebastianJu on October 11, 2015, 08:25:53 PM
It's a fake address, it is 1 char too long, its just photoshop.

Oh wow, i already had the guess that this might be the case since he only posted an image, knowing that it would take quite some work to copy the address or the tid, and it's even more complicated since no block explorer exists.

It would have been the next thing i would have checked though it would have meant installing the wallet, which would sound like a risk in itself if something would be fishy with that.

Thanks a lot for all the help. I only now started to be accepted as an ICO escrow when i escrowed stepscoin and i had three small ico's after that. 2 of them turned out to be scam. Which translates in a lot of work refunding and even defending against investors that did not care about sending from an address they can prove their ownership for.

Though, i already wrote that, i'm somewhat happy that iam was the escrow and i would accept ICO's, where i think they might be fishy again, since at the end it's safer a trusted escrow holds the funds than funds being hold differently.

Thanks a lot guys. :)