Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Bitcoin Discussion => Topic started by: cloud9 on June 07, 2011, 11:04:54 AM



Title: P2P Crypto-Utility or P2P Virtual Currency?
Post by: cloud9 on June 07, 2011, 11:04:54 AM
Is Bitcoins an accounting utility or a currency when legally defined?

The  formal  description  of  Bitcoin  on  bitcoin.org  states  it  is  a  currency.

Is the  right  to  mobile phone network airtime a  digital  radio  wave  utility  commodity  that  enables  the  holder  of  the  right  to  communicate  voice  or  data  on  a  Network  over  vast  distances?

Is  the  cryptographic  key  pair  right  to  a  network  working  at  a  high  hash  rate  to  secure  values  attributed  to  a  key  pair  right  a  digital  utility  commodity?

In  short  -  is  Bitcoin.org  a  crypto-commodity  like  MtGox  sells  /  buys  for  fiat  currency?

Does  bitcoin.org  view  bitcoins  bought  from  someone  to  be  bartered  when  exchanged  for  goods  /  services?

Can  bitcoins  be  used  as  medium  of  exchange  in  barter  transactions  for  the  digital  age,  like  pebbles,  eggs,  salt,  gold,  mobile  airtime,  etc.,  have  been  used  in  other  ages  /  different  communities  as  medium  of  exchange  in  barter  transactions?

Or  is  bitcoin.org  proposing  a  rival  currency  to  national  currencies?

Which  of  the  above  would  be  legal  under  the  current  social  contract?


Title: Re: Is Bitcoin a digital utility or a currency?
Post by: billyjoeallen on June 07, 2011, 11:30:59 AM
The  formal  description  of  Bitcoin  on  bitcoin.org  states  it  is  a  currency.

Is the  right  to  mobile phone network airtime a  digital  radio  wave  utility  commodity  that  enables  the  holder  of  the  right  to  communicate  voice  or  data  on  a  Network  over  vast  distances?

Is  the  cryptographic  key  pair  right  to  a  network  working  at  a  high  hash  rate  to  secure  values  attributed  to  a  key  pair  right  a  digital  utility  commodity?

In  short  -  is  Bitcoin.org  a  crypto-commodity  like  MtGox  sells  /  buys  for  fiat  currency?

Does  bitcoin.org  view  bitcoins  bought  from  someone  to  be  bartered  when  exchanged  for  goods  /  services?

Can  bitcoins  be  used  as  medium  of  exchange  in  barter  transactions  for  the  digital  age,  like  pebbles,  eggs,  salt,  gold,  mobile  airtime,  etc.,  have  been  used  in  other  ages  /  different  communities  as  medium  of  exchange  in  barter  transactions?

Or  is  bitcoin.org  proposing  a  rival  currency  to  national  currencies?

Which  of  the  above  would  be  legal  under  the  current  social  contract?

I didn't agree to any social contract.


Title: Re: Is Bitcoin a digital utility or a currency?
Post by: cloud9 on June 07, 2011, 12:30:32 PM
Are  you  not  -  if  you  live  in  a  democracy  that  determines  the  social  contract?


Title: Re: Is Bitcoin a digital utility or a currency?
Post by: cloud9 on June 07, 2011, 12:36:04 PM
In  which  democracies  is  barter  trade  currently  allowed?


Title: Re: Is Bitcoin a digital utility or a currency?
Post by: kokjo on June 07, 2011, 12:37:58 PM
pleas don't do  double  spacing  it  annoyes  me.


Title: Re: Is Bitcoin a digital utility or a currency?
Post by: srb123 on June 07, 2011, 12:46:23 PM
The  formal  description  of  Bitcoin  on  bitcoin.org  states  it  is  a  currency.

Is the  right  to  mobile phone network airtime a  digital  radio  wave  utility  commodity  that  enables  the  holder  of  the  right  to  communicate  voice  or  data  on  a  Network  over  vast  distances?

Is  the  cryptographic  key  pair  right  to  a  network  working  at  a  high  hash  rate  to  secure  values  attributed  to  a  key  pair  right  a  digital  utility  commodity?

In  short  -  is  Bitcoin.org  a  crypto-commodity  like  MtGox  sells  /  buys  for  fiat  currency?

Does  bitcoin.org  view  bitcoins  bought  from  someone  to  be  bartered  when  exchanged  for  goods  /  services?

Can  bitcoins  be  used  as  medium  of  exchange  in  barter  transactions  for  the  digital  age,  like  pebbles,  eggs,  salt,  gold,  mobile  airtime,  etc.,  have  been  used  in  other  ages  /  different  communities  as  medium  of  exchange  in  barter  transactions?

Or  is  bitcoin.org  proposing  a  rival  currency  to  national  currencies?

Which  of  the  above  would  be  legal  under  the  current  social  contract?


Are  you  a  poorly  coded  bot   that  generates  random  questions   and  has  a glitch  that  makes  double  spaces   ??


Title: Re: Is Bitcoin a digital utility or a currency?
Post by: justusranvier on June 07, 2011, 12:49:17 PM
The Social Contract: Defined and Destroyed in under 5 mins (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jNj0VhK19QU)