Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Bitcoin Discussion => Topic started by: Denker on February 12, 2016, 08:31:55 PM



Title: Bitcoin Problems - Computerphile
Post by: Denker on February 12, 2016, 08:31:55 PM
"Bitcoin may be doomed to failure as the blockchain struggles to scale up; Professor Ross Anderson from the University of Cambridge explains."

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s2XHyzPA9Zc (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s2XHyzPA9Zc)


I think this Professor Anderson an "expert in the financial word and technology" ::) needs some more information as it seems he is not up to date.
Also read through the comment section when you have some time left.
Maybe write yourself a few lines as some clarrifications seem to be needed due to missunderstanding or lack of informations.
Thanks guys.


Title: Re: Bitcoin Problems - Computerphile
Post by: shorena on February 12, 2016, 10:08:29 PM
"Bitcoin may be doomed to failure as the blockchain struggles to scale up; Professor Ross Anderson from the University of Cambridge explains."

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s2XHyzPA9Zc (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s2XHyzPA9Zc)


I think this Professor Anderson an "expert in the financial word and technology" ::) needs some more information as it seems he is not up to date.
Also read through the comment section when you have some time left.
Maybe write yourself a few lines as some clarrifications seem to be needed due to missunderstanding or lack of informations.
Thanks guys.

Firstly its just an opinion. If bitcoin can not scale it will indeed not become the global currency. Well, maybe it does not need to be the global currency to be successful. Maybe it can scale. The "bitcoin will not be used to pay your coffee" is not an uncommon opinion.

I dont recommend anyone wasting their time in the youtube comment section. If someone is interested in bitcoin they will find other means to get good information anyway.


Title: Re: Bitcoin Problems - Computerphile
Post by: MedaR on February 12, 2016, 10:34:35 PM
Bitcoin don't needs to become mainstream money.
It is just enough to be widely used and to grow from year to year.
From my perspective this is best payment system on internet!
Do you need more? Internet is very large place with tendencies to grows even more.


Title: Re: Bitcoin Problems - Computerphile
Post by: calkob on February 12, 2016, 10:48:45 PM
As usual some whack job talking about something he hasn't a clue about, youtube and the internet are full of them.  Put the word professor in-front of a name and people start thinking they know everything, pompous ass


Title: Re: Bitcoin Problems - Computerphile
Post by: commandrix on February 13, 2016, 03:14:33 AM
It is unfortunate that people like this do not get egg smeared on their face in a very public fashion more often. I say ignore him and continue to use Bitcoin or your favorite altcoin as normal.


Title: Re: Bitcoin Problems - Computerphile
Post by: Jet Cash on February 13, 2016, 03:23:02 AM
Bitcoin don't needs to become mainstream money.
It is just enough to be widely used and to grow from year to year.
From my perspective this is best payment system on internet!
Do you need more? Internet is very large place with tendencies to grows even more.

Isn't that the truth. Bitcoin will never become the Phoenix currency. I expect that will come from the IMF or the AIIB. However imho, it can become the gold reserve for altcoins on sidechains when its value increases to much higher levels.


Title: Re: Bitcoin Problems - Computerphile
Post by: Kprawn on February 13, 2016, 07:29:40 AM
It is unfortunate that people like this do not get egg smeared on their face in a very public fashion more often. I say ignore him and continue to use Bitcoin or your favorite altcoin as normal.

Well you have a chance to do just that and contribute to expose the truth in the comment section. There are media channels out there that moderate

their comment section or they have no comment section, so you cannot expose these people. YouTube is not one of them, and you can easily go in there

and post the true reflection of the information or links to it. If you ignore these things, it just strengthen their false opinions.


Title: Re: Bitcoin Problems - Computerphile
Post by: Blind Legs Parker on February 13, 2016, 08:50:32 AM
"Bitcoin may be doomed to failure as the blockchain struggles to scale up; Professor Ross Anderson from the University of Cambridge explains."

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s2XHyzPA9Zc (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s2XHyzPA9Zc)


I think this Professor Anderson an "expert in the financial word and technology" ::) needs some more information as it seems he is not up to date.
Also read through the comment section when you have some time left.
Maybe write yourself a few lines as some clarrifications seem to be needed due to missunderstanding or lack of informations.
Thanks guys.

Firstly its just an opinion. If bitcoin can not scale it will indeed not become the global currency. Well, maybe it does not need to be the global currency to be successful. Maybe it can scale. The "bitcoin will not be used to pay your coffee" is not an uncommon opinion.

I dont recommend anyone wasting their time in the youtube comment section. If someone is interested in bitcoin they will find other means to get good information anyway.
In that case we are going to need another international currency to pay for our coffee when we're abroad. Well it's not exactly like we are going to "need" it, but it would solve many travelling problems related to currency exchange. Bitcoin doesn't have to do it, but an alt will have to, may it have to not be as decentralized as bitcoin is to accomplish it. It might even have to be fully transparent and used only for small transactions abroad but it will be needed if bitcoin wants to remain a decentralized computerized version of gold.


Title: Re: Bitcoin Problems - Computerphile
Post by: shorena on February 13, 2016, 10:38:49 AM
"Bitcoin may be doomed to failure as the blockchain struggles to scale up; Professor Ross Anderson from the University of Cambridge explains."

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s2XHyzPA9Zc (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s2XHyzPA9Zc)


I think this Professor Anderson an "expert in the financial word and technology" ::) needs some more information as it seems he is not up to date.
Also read through the comment section when you have some time left.
Maybe write yourself a few lines as some clarrifications seem to be needed due to missunderstanding or lack of informations.
Thanks guys.

Firstly its just an opinion. If bitcoin can not scale it will indeed not become the global currency. Well, maybe it does not need to be the global currency to be successful. Maybe it can scale. The "bitcoin will not be used to pay your coffee" is not an uncommon opinion.

I dont recommend anyone wasting their time in the youtube comment section. If someone is interested in bitcoin they will find other means to get good information anyway.
In that case we are going to need another international currency to pay for our coffee when we're abroad. Well it's not exactly like we are going to "need" it, but it would solve many travelling problems related to currency exchange. Bitcoin doesn't have to do it, but an alt will have to, may it have to not be as decentralized as bitcoin is to accomplish it. It might even have to be fully transparent and used only for small transactions abroad but it will be needed if bitcoin wants to remain a decentralized computerized version of gold.

...or you could do the majority of your coffee trades "off-chain" (e.g. via payment channels) and only do the final account reconcilement with a single "on-chain" transaction. This would require some trust in the coffee selling company, but so does drinking the coffee and you can limit the amount you want to trust them with to something you would reasonably spend on coffee anyway.

There are many possible solutions. I dont know if bitcoin will implement them or which, but IMHO SegWit is a step in the right direction no matter what the goal is. It allows implementing new types of addresses (and transactions) in newer versions without breaking old clients. This could also introduce new signature algorithms e.g. resistant to quantum computer attacks.

Bitcoin is still nowhere near where it can be in the future and it will need time to grow.


Title: Re: Bitcoin Problems - Computerphile
Post by: virtualdn on February 13, 2016, 10:56:34 AM
Anything can be solved if someone really wants to but it seems to me many hope BTC will just vanish.


Title: Re: Bitcoin Problems - Computerphile
Post by: yenxz on February 13, 2016, 04:36:27 PM
Anything can be solved if someone really wants to but it seems to me many hope BTC will just vanish.
we dont mention someone,i just think sme of people or group that must be solve this problem.