Bitcoin Forum

Other => Meta => Topic started by: vodaljepa on June 30, 2016, 06:30:25 PM



Title: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: vodaljepa on June 30, 2016, 06:30:25 PM
Mine is

You have reported 199 posts with 100% accuracy


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: SeriousInvestor on June 30, 2016, 06:30:43 PM
I never report any posts. Im not a rat.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Lauda on June 30, 2016, 06:38:38 PM
While your accuracy does seem very good, considering the quantity of posts (199) it is not something special. I sometimes notice your reports, but they're far less frequent than some of the top reporters (having a few thousand reports and reporting accuracy of over 95% is excellent). Anyhow, threads like these are usually not a good idea as they get abused by signatuer spammers with their seemingly on-topic posts.

I never report any posts. Im not a rat.
That has nothing to do with "being a rat".


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Lutpin on June 30, 2016, 06:41:34 PM
but they're far less frequent than some of the top reporters (having a few thousand reports and reporting accuracy of over 95% is excellent).

"You have reported 5097 posts with 99% accuracy"

I'd imagine there are people with even higher numbers (shorena for example, would be curious about where he currently stands), but I think 5k is a good start :)



I never report any posts. Im not a rat.
Come at me, please.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Vod on June 30, 2016, 07:21:13 PM
I never report any posts. Im not a rat.

LOL.  That was funny!  :)

I have reported 879 posts with 99% accuracy


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Gimpeline on June 30, 2016, 07:38:53 PM
I have reported 0 posts, but then, I'm for free speech


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: InvoKing on June 30, 2016, 08:06:20 PM
I have reported 0 posts, but then, I'm for free speech

It has nothing to do with free speech

Mine is : "You have reported 265 posts with 100% accuracy"  mainly reporting the bots and the brand new with referral url or spamming useless words like bitcoin is a ponzi...


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: theymos on June 30, 2016, 11:52:50 PM
"You have reported 5097 posts with 99% accuracy"

I'd imagine there are people with even higher numbers (shorena for example, would be curious about where he currently stands), but I think 5k is a good start :)

You're in second place for total number of correct reports. Thank you!


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: janggernaut on June 30, 2016, 11:56:28 PM
mine still "You have reported 23 posts with 92% accuracy" never know if someone already reported more than 5k posts  :o


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: minifrij on July 01, 2016, 12:41:59 AM
"You have reported 249 posts with 96% accuracy".
I thought I was doing alright until I saw others' stats.

(shorena for example, would be curious about where he currently stands)
I'd be interested in what mexxer was at, since I saw himself and staff commenting about his reports.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Lutpin on July 01, 2016, 12:45:22 AM
I'd be interested in what mexxer was at, since I saw himself and staff commenting about his reports.
Last time he and I discussed about reports, he was somewhere in the low 3ks IIRC (and pretty d*mn happy about reaching 99%), that's however some time back...

You're in second place for total number of correct reports. Thank you!
I'm just trying to help, glad it's being appreciated.
shorena wouldn't be the one on the first place, would he?


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: BlindMayorBitcorn on July 01, 2016, 12:47:53 AM
Ok admit it. How many of you have reported my posts? I want funny usernames! >:(

I've reported 261 posts with 99% accuracy, and I can never unsee any of those.  :-[


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Foxpup on July 01, 2016, 05:03:57 AM
"You have reported 1760 posts with 100% accuracy"

http://www.vizzed.com/vizzedboard/retro/user_screenshots/saves34/342187/SNES--Street%20Fighter%20Alpha%202_Mar31%2017_27_03.png


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Decoded on July 01, 2016, 05:25:23 AM
*When you search high and low for reports worth restoring and think you've reported a million*

You have reporter 56 posts with 100% accuracy. Shit.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Quickseller on July 01, 2016, 05:42:23 AM
"You have reported 5097 posts with 99% accuracy"

I'd imagine there are people with even higher numbers (shorena for example, would be curious about where he currently stands), but I think 5k is a good start :)

You're in second place for total number of correct reports. Thank you!
Out of curiosity, what place am I in?


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: theymos on July 01, 2016, 06:13:36 AM
Here are the top 50 reporters by total good reports.

Thanks to everyone who reports! Even one good report is helpful. But massive thanks to those in this list: without you, moderation would be basically impossible.

Although most people in this list have very high accuracies, in general there's no need to worry about accuracy too much.

Code:
+--------------------+------+-----+-----------+----------+
| user               | good | bad | unhandled | accuracy |
+--------------------+------+-----+-----------+----------+
| shorena            | 9140 | 331 |       466 |  96.5051 |
| Lutpin             | 4881 |  69 |       180 |  98.6061 |
| Cyrus              | 4641 | 170 |        90 |  96.4664 |
| botany             | 4202 | 149 |       182 |  96.5755 |
| mexxer-2           | 3778 |  79 |        69 |  97.9518 |
| EAL                | 2882 |  72 |       141 |  97.5626 |
| hilariousandco     | 2721 |  82 |        30 |  97.0746 |
| Quickseller        | 2553 | 120 |       119 |  95.5107 |
| TheButterZone      | 2393 | 229 |        92 |  91.2662 |
| Welsh              | 2213 |  42 |        20 |  98.1375 |
| mprep              | 1995 | 118 |        85 |  94.4155 |
| Foxpup             | 1705 |  13 |        43 |  99.2433 |
| redsn0w            | 1646 | 268 |       103 |  85.9979 |
| -ck                | 1501 |  26 |         5 |  98.2973 |
| mitzie             | 1499 |  65 |        31 |  95.8440 |
| deadley            | 1384 |  79 |        13 |  94.6001 |
| subSTRATA          | 1360 |  55 |       103 |  96.1131 |
| EcuaMobi           | 1331 |  11 |        14 |  99.1803 |
| DannyHamilton      | 1261 |  15 |        46 |  98.8245 |
| malevolent         | 1253 |  36 |        14 |  97.2071 |
| --Encrypted--      | 1222 |  23 |        27 |  98.1526 |
| xandry             | 1029 |  18 |       102 |  98.2808 |
| okae               | 1014 |   0 |         0 | 100.0000 |
| dbshck             |  988 |  13 |         7 |  98.7013 |
| railzand           |  965 |  61 |         3 |  94.0546 |
| tmfp               |  936 |  35 |        17 |  96.3955 |
| austin             |  896 |  46 |         0 |  95.1168 |
| knightdk           |  895 |  19 |        20 |  97.9212 |
| Lauda              |  885 |  21 |        54 |  97.6821 |
| Vod                |  846 |  17 |        16 |  98.0301 |
| Muhammed Zakir     |  840 |  68 |        83 |  92.5110 |
| xhomerx10          |  712 |   6 |        20 |  99.1643 |
| xetsr              |  709 |  43 |        43 |  94.2819 |
| dogie              |  691 | 186 |        72 |  78.7913 |
| Mitchełł |  666 |  29 |        87 |  95.8273 |
| KWH                |  654 |  70 |        44 |  90.3315 |
| unamis76           |  556 |   0 |         1 | 100.0000 |
| grue               |  540 |  36 |         7 |  93.7500 |
| NLNico             |  530 |  12 |         3 |  97.7860 |
| Grand_Voyageur     |  521 |  32 |        60 |  94.2134 |
| OnkelPaul          |  520 |   2 |         0 |  99.6169 |
| pedrog             |  514 |   4 |         4 |  99.2278 |
| suchmoon           |  509 |  70 |       135 |  87.9102 |
| LMGTFY             |  507 |   3 |         2 |  99.4118 |
| whywefight         |  496 |  40 |        38 |  92.5373 |
| jl2012             |  477 |  30 |        35 |  94.0828 |
| ocminer            |  476 |  30 |         4 |  94.0711 |
| soullyG            |  467 |  13 |       181 |  97.2917 |
| justusranvier      |  462 |  25 |         1 |  94.8665 |
| Holliday           |  445 |  10 |         5 |  97.8022 |
+--------------------+------+-----+-----------+----------+

"Unhandled" means that every moderator with jurisdiction over the post was unsure about the correct thing to do with the post and so left it for other mods to deal with, but no mod ever decided to act on it. I suppose it can be thought of as a "weak bad", though it's ignored for your accuracy percentage.

Since so many people have so many reports, I changed the percentage on the reports page so that it uses proper rounding instead of ceil() and shows 1 decimal. Actually, I changed my mind. This would probably make people feel subconsciously paranoid about reporting.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: EFS on July 01, 2016, 01:58:39 PM
Thanks for stats theymos.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Vod on July 01, 2016, 02:11:45 PM
Since so many people have so many reports, I changed the percentage on the reports page so that it uses proper rounding instead of ceil() and shows 1 decimal. Actually, I changed my mind. This would probably make people feel subconsciously paranoid about reporting.

I actually requested that some time ago.

https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1182554.0


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: aakashsangwan on July 01, 2016, 02:55:08 PM
Mine is 103 posts reported with 98% accuracy.

Well, I am posting here for some reason. What should be done to those images posted in the alt-coin section of Lamborghini and ships and whatever. Should they be reported as off-topic? As they aren't contributing in the healthy discussion.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Holdaaja on July 01, 2016, 06:09:19 PM
I have reported 18 posts with 94% accuracy.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: shorena on July 01, 2016, 08:09:27 PM
Here are the top 50 reporters by total good reports.

Thanks to everyone who reports! Even one good report is helpful. But massive thanks to those in this list: without you, moderation would be basically impossible.

Although most people in this list have very high accuracies, in general there's no need to worry about accuracy too much.

Code:
+--------------------+------+-----+-----------+----------+
| user               | good | bad | unhandled | accuracy |
+--------------------+------+-----+-----------+----------+
| shorena            | 9140 | 331 |       466 |  96.5051 |
| Lutpin             | 4881 |  69 |       180 |  98.6061 |
| Cyrus              | 4641 | 170 |        90 |  96.4664 |
| botany             | 4202 | 149 |       182 |  96.5755 |
| mexxer-2           | 3778 |  79 |        69 |  97.9518 |
| EAL                | 2882 |  72 |       141 |  97.5626 |
| hilariousandco     | 2721 |  82 |        30 |  97.0746 |
| Quickseller        | 2553 | 120 |       119 |  95.5107 |
| TheButterZone      | 2393 | 229 |        92 |  91.2662 |
| Welsh              | 2213 |  42 |        20 |  98.1375 |
| mprep              | 1995 | 118 |        85 |  94.4155 |
| Foxpup             | 1705 |  13 |        43 |  99.2433 |
| redsn0w            | 1646 | 268 |       103 |  85.9979 |
| -ck                | 1501 |  26 |         5 |  98.2973 |
| mitzie             | 1499 |  65 |        31 |  95.8440 |
| deadley            | 1384 |  79 |        13 |  94.6001 |
| subSTRATA          | 1360 |  55 |       103 |  96.1131 |
| EcuaMobi           | 1331 |  11 |        14 |  99.1803 |
| DannyHamilton      | 1261 |  15 |        46 |  98.8245 |
| malevolent         | 1253 |  36 |        14 |  97.2071 |
| --Encrypted--      | 1222 |  23 |        27 |  98.1526 |
| xandry             | 1029 |  18 |       102 |  98.2808 |
| okae               | 1014 |   0 |         0 | 100.0000 |
| dbshck             |  988 |  13 |         7 |  98.7013 |
| railzand           |  965 |  61 |         3 |  94.0546 |
| tmfp               |  936 |  35 |        17 |  96.3955 |
| austin             |  896 |  46 |         0 |  95.1168 |
| knightdk           |  895 |  19 |        20 |  97.9212 |
| Lauda              |  885 |  21 |        54 |  97.6821 |
| Vod                |  846 |  17 |        16 |  98.0301 |
| Muhammed Zakir     |  840 |  68 |        83 |  92.5110 |
| xhomerx10          |  712 |   6 |        20 |  99.1643 |
| xetsr              |  709 |  43 |        43 |  94.2819 |
| dogie              |  691 | 186 |        72 |  78.7913 |
| Mitchełł |  666 |  29 |        87 |  95.8273 |
| KWH                |  654 |  70 |        44 |  90.3315 |
| unamis76           |  556 |   0 |         1 | 100.0000 |
| grue               |  540 |  36 |         7 |  93.7500 |
| NLNico             |  530 |  12 |         3 |  97.7860 |
| Grand_Voyageur     |  521 |  32 |        60 |  94.2134 |
| OnkelPaul          |  520 |   2 |         0 |  99.6169 |
| pedrog             |  514 |   4 |         4 |  99.2278 |
| suchmoon           |  509 |  70 |       135 |  87.9102 |
| LMGTFY             |  507 |   3 |         2 |  99.4118 |
| whywefight         |  496 |  40 |        38 |  92.5373 |
| jl2012             |  477 |  30 |        35 |  94.0828 |
| ocminer            |  476 |  30 |         4 |  94.0711 |
| soullyG            |  467 |  13 |       181 |  97.2917 |
| justusranvier      |  462 |  25 |         1 |  94.8665 |
| Holliday           |  445 |  10 |         5 |  97.8022 |
+--------------------+------+-----+-----------+----------+

"Unhandled" means that every moderator with jurisdiction over the post was unsure about the correct thing to do with the post and so left it for other mods to deal with, but no mod ever decided to act on it. I suppose it can be thought of as a "weak bad", though it's ignored for your accuracy percentage.

Since so many people have so many reports, I changed the percentage on the reports page so that it uses proper rounding instead of ceil() and shows 1 decimal. Actually, I changed my mind. This would probably make people feel subconsciously paranoid about reporting.

Thanks for the update, mexxer-2 and me wondered a while back whether Cyrus was still number one. I guess lutpin will be the one to overtake me then.

Btw, was it actually ceil()? I thought it was floor().


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: EcuaMobi on July 01, 2016, 09:35:23 PM
Btw, was it actually ceil()? I thought it was floor().

Yes, was and still is. I still see my own stats as "100%" when it's really 99.1803%

By the way it will be a long way for Lutpin or anyone else to overtake you! :D


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Cyrus on July 01, 2016, 11:52:37 PM
Thanks for the update, mexxer-2 and me wondered a while back whether Cyrus was still number one. I guess lutpin will be the one to overtake me then.
Looks like my reporting days are behind me and I didn't get to 5k. Congrats shorena!

Thank you to everyone on the list, you make this forum a better place!
Also, thanks theymos for updating this list.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: BitcoinEXpress on July 02, 2016, 12:47:23 AM
Anyhow, threads like these are usually not a good idea as they get abused by signatuer spammers with their seemingly on-topic posts.


Thanks for the prime example Sig Spammer!  ;)


288 post with 88% accuracy.

I report under the influence sometimes LOL


~BCX~


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: SeriousInvestor on July 02, 2016, 05:45:15 AM
I never report any posts. Im not a rat.

LOL.  That was funny!  :)

I have reported 879 posts with 99% accuracy

You're welcome.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: botany on July 02, 2016, 02:18:47 PM
Here are the top 50 reporters by total good reports.

Thanks to everyone who reports! Even one good report is helpful. But massive thanks to those in this list: without you, moderation would be basically impossible.

Aah... Feels good to be in the top 5.  :)
The number of reports that Shorena has is truly amazing.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: SmartIphone on July 02, 2016, 04:57:58 PM
The top 50 reporters reported 75,307 good reports which are really a huge number. Btw my contribution is not too much but when I report I make sure it will be a good report ."You have reported 41 posts with 100% accuracy"


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: botany on July 03, 2016, 03:35:42 AM
Btw, was it actually ceil()? I thought it was floor().

Yes, was and still is. I still see my own stats as "100%" when it's really 99.1803%

By the way it will be a long way for Lutpin or anyone else to overtake you! :D


It was definitely rounded down at one point of time.

Lets assume 97.0000% of these are correct, thats 1843 correct and 57 not. In order to reach 97.5% (I assume thats when 98% will be shown) he would have to make 2223 total correct reports vs 57 bad. Thats 380 good reports without fail.

Accuracy is always rounded down IIRC, so it'll take even longer.

People shouldn't worry about accuracy much, and certainly not single percentage points.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: vodaljepa on July 03, 2016, 02:24:42 PM
Very cool to see those stats theymos!


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: cpfreeplz on July 03, 2016, 02:32:24 PM
Thanks for the update, mexxer-2 and me wondered a while back whether Cyrus was still number one. I guess lutpin will be the one to overtake me then.
Looks like my reporting days are behind me and I didn't get to 5k. Congrats shorena!

Thank you to everyone on the list, you make this forum a better place!
Also, thanks theymos for updating this list.

Technically you could always raise your reporting stats the shady way. Report, delete, checkmark, report, delete, checkmark.

But wait... then you would get reported for reporting to moderating... hmmmm... a paradox!


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: rizzlarolla on July 03, 2016, 03:27:44 PM
The report to moderator button, when activated, says,
"Use this function to inform the moderators and administrators of an abusive or wrongly posted message."

Is "abuse" reportable?
Is this report button also for off topic and zero or low value posts? (if so, why does it not say)

What sort of posts are people reporting?
I have never reported, but have just started a thread.
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1532295.0

I would like to know, does my thread highlight reportable posts or not, in the opinion of proven accurate reporters?


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: DeathAngel on July 03, 2016, 04:01:49 PM
Mine is

You have reported 199 posts with 100% accuracy

Just checked I've only ever done it once :D


You have reported 1 posts with 100% accuracy


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: xhomerx10 on July 03, 2016, 04:13:19 PM
Whoo hoo! I made the list!  Thanks for the kind words Theymos; it's nice to know our efforts are appreciated.
I'm pretty sure I'd be over 1000 by now if Cyrus was a little slower on the delete button ;)



Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: unamis76 on July 03, 2016, 05:17:51 PM
Here are the top 50 reporters by total good reports.

Thanks to everyone who reports! Even one good report is helpful. But massive thanks to those in this list: without you, moderation would be basically impossible.

Although most people in this list have very high accuracies, in general there's no need to worry about accuracy too much.

Code:
+--------------------+------+-----+-----------+----------+
| user               | good | bad | unhandled | accuracy |
+--------------------+------+-----+-----------+----------+
| shorena            | 9140 | 331 |       466 |  96.5051 |
| Lutpin             | 4881 |  69 |       180 |  98.6061 |
| Cyrus              | 4641 | 170 |        90 |  96.4664 |
| botany             | 4202 | 149 |       182 |  96.5755 |
| mexxer-2           | 3778 |  79 |        69 |  97.9518 |
| EAL                | 2882 |  72 |       141 |  97.5626 |
| hilariousandco     | 2721 |  82 |        30 |  97.0746 |
| Quickseller        | 2553 | 120 |       119 |  95.5107 |
| TheButterZone      | 2393 | 229 |        92 |  91.2662 |
| Welsh              | 2213 |  42 |        20 |  98.1375 |
| mprep              | 1995 | 118 |        85 |  94.4155 |
| Foxpup             | 1705 |  13 |        43 |  99.2433 |
| redsn0w            | 1646 | 268 |       103 |  85.9979 |
| -ck                | 1501 |  26 |         5 |  98.2973 |
| mitzie             | 1499 |  65 |        31 |  95.8440 |
| deadley            | 1384 |  79 |        13 |  94.6001 |
| subSTRATA          | 1360 |  55 |       103 |  96.1131 |
| EcuaMobi           | 1331 |  11 |        14 |  99.1803 |
| DannyHamilton      | 1261 |  15 |        46 |  98.8245 |
| malevolent         | 1253 |  36 |        14 |  97.2071 |
| --Encrypted--      | 1222 |  23 |        27 |  98.1526 |
| xandry             | 1029 |  18 |       102 |  98.2808 |
| okae               | 1014 |   0 |         0 | 100.0000 |
| dbshck             |  988 |  13 |         7 |  98.7013 |
| railzand           |  965 |  61 |         3 |  94.0546 |
| tmfp               |  936 |  35 |        17 |  96.3955 |
| austin             |  896 |  46 |         0 |  95.1168 |
| knightdk           |  895 |  19 |        20 |  97.9212 |
| Lauda              |  885 |  21 |        54 |  97.6821 |
| Vod                |  846 |  17 |        16 |  98.0301 |
| Muhammed Zakir     |  840 |  68 |        83 |  92.5110 |
| xhomerx10          |  712 |   6 |        20 |  99.1643 |
| xetsr              |  709 |  43 |        43 |  94.2819 |
| dogie              |  691 | 186 |        72 |  78.7913 |
| Mitchełł |  666 |  29 |        87 |  95.8273 |
| KWH                |  654 |  70 |        44 |  90.3315 |
| unamis76           |  556 |   0 |         1 | 100.0000 |
| grue               |  540 |  36 |         7 |  93.7500 |
| NLNico             |  530 |  12 |         3 |  97.7860 |
| Grand_Voyageur     |  521 |  32 |        60 |  94.2134 |
| OnkelPaul          |  520 |   2 |         0 |  99.6169 |
| pedrog             |  514 |   4 |         4 |  99.2278 |
| suchmoon           |  509 |  70 |       135 |  87.9102 |
| LMGTFY             |  507 |   3 |         2 |  99.4118 |
| whywefight         |  496 |  40 |        38 |  92.5373 |
| jl2012             |  477 |  30 |        35 |  94.0828 |
| ocminer            |  476 |  30 |         4 |  94.0711 |
| soullyG            |  467 |  13 |       181 |  97.2917 |
| justusranvier      |  462 |  25 |         1 |  94.8665 |
| Holliday           |  445 |  10 |         5 |  97.8022 |
+--------------------+------+-----+-----------+----------+

"Unhandled" means that every moderator with jurisdiction over the post was unsure about the correct thing to do with the post and so left it for other mods to deal with, but no mod ever decided to act on it. I suppose it can be thought of as a "weak bad", though it's ignored for your accuracy percentage.

Since so many people have so many reports, I changed the percentage on the reports page so that it uses proper rounding instead of ceil() and shows 1 decimal. Actually, I changed my mind. This would probably make people feel subconsciously paranoid about reporting.

Very interesting stats, thank you. Never thought I'd make it to the top 100, much less to top 50 and I'm also surprised to see I'm just one of two at 100% accuracy haha :) We have amazing staff and good members always contributing. This is why we still have a nice forum, I think. I'll keep reporting whenever I see issues arising :)


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: shorena on July 03, 2016, 09:45:31 PM
-snip-
Lets assume 97.0000% of these are correct, thats 1843 correct and 57 not. In order to reach 97.5% (I assume thats when 98% will be shown) he would have to make 2223 total correct reports vs 57 bad. Thats 380 good reports without fail.

Accuracy is always rounded down IIRC, so it'll take even longer.

People shouldn't worry about accuracy much, and certainly not single percentage points.

Had that in mind as well.

The report to moderator button, when activated, says,
"Use this function to inform the moderators and administrators of an abusive or wrongly posted message."

Is "abuse" reportable?

Depends on your definiton of abuse. Anything that is against forum rules.

Is this report button also for off topic and zero or low value posts? (if so, why does it not say)

Yes, but sometimes the bigger picture needs to be painted. In this case a PM to a global mod or admin might be better.

What sort of posts are people reporting?

The majority of my reports are threads in wrong sections. Which makes the "Im no snitch" comment hilarious.

I have never reported, but have just started a thread.
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1532295.0

I would like to know, does my thread highlight reportable posts or not, in the opinion of proven accurate reporters?

Looks like you have answers to that in your thread already. What is constructive and what is spam are tricky questions that may not always have an easy answer.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: springgers on July 04, 2016, 06:12:04 AM
how can we see this report to moderator rate? or where?


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: aakashsangwan on July 04, 2016, 10:16:00 AM
how can we see this report to moderator rate? or where?
At the end of each post, there is the "report to moderator" button on right hand bottom corner, click on it and on new page you will see your accuracy and number of reported posts.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Cyrus on July 04, 2016, 07:13:04 PM
Whoo hoo! I made the list!  Thanks for the kind words Theymos; it's nice to know our efforts are appreciated.
I'm pretty sure I'd be over 1000 by now if Cyrus was a little slower on the delete button ;)
Thanks for the reports, they're spot on!

@shorena:
https://media.giphy.com/media/Mra7xZQpHxNC/giphy.gif


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: MadZ on July 05, 2016, 05:57:04 PM
And I thought my 97% was good, don't have anywhere near as many as those listed though.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: rizzlarolla on July 05, 2016, 06:56:41 PM
Thanks for your reply shorena.

Is this report button also for off topic and zero or low value posts? (if so, why does it not say)
Yes, but sometimes the bigger picture needs to be painted. In this case a PM to a global mod or admin might be better.

That is why I didn't use the report button in this instance. I thought there was a bigger picture to paint.
I've never reported before. I'm new to all this.
Seems like very hard work to get a moderator to respond to this issue.

I would like to know, does my thread highlight reportable posts or not, in the opinion of proven accurate reporters?
Looks like you have answers to that in your thread already. What is constructive and what is spam are tricky questions that may not always have an easy answer.

I am struggling to see how any of the posts I questioned are constructive, in any way.
(but then that is why I have reported it)

The only answer I seem to have had is to pm a global mod, which I shall do shortly.
Seems a bit strange now though. Obviously my thread is being ignored by these moderators.  
(clearly, global mods have seen my thread, but chosen not to responded in any way)



Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Lutpin on July 05, 2016, 10:51:42 PM
By the way it will be a long way for Lutpin or anyone else to overtake you!
Is that a challenge? ;D



@thermos:
It would be nice getting a regular (e.g. monthly) dump of the top 50 (or even 100) reporters.
Might also be an incentive for some of the less-active reporters to step up their game.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: EcuaMobi on July 05, 2016, 11:09:36 PM
By the way it will be a long way for Lutpin or anyone else to overtake you!
Is that a challenge? ;D

Definitely not for me! Haha. But I'd be glad if you surpass him on the next updated list :)
That challenge would only help the forum.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: rizzlarolla on July 09, 2016, 07:56:06 PM
Mine is

You have reported 199 posts with 100% accuracy

Looking at your 20+ posts today, which include several pointless new threads,
do you report yourself to achieve such accuracy?

Not as bad as hermahns09 though, over 200 shit posts today.
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=378917
Has anyone reported this?

There is currently no option to report several posts at once either.

Good luck pushing the report button 200 times, but it will get someones stats up!


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: redsn0w on July 09, 2016, 09:55:11 PM
Thanks for the update theymos.


Currently :
Code:
You have reported 2020 posts with 87% accuracy


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: okae on July 12, 2016, 01:41:45 PM
Thanks to everyone who reports!

Is always a pleasure to keep "clean" this forum, our forum. I really encourage people to understand that ALL of us are moderators, help this forum by using the Report to moderator button, is like help ourselves.

Keep up the good job guys!


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Soros Shorts on July 13, 2016, 09:50:45 AM
I swear that those crap bot-generated posts that appear every 5 minutes in Bitcoin Discussion are generated by someone who wants to improve their Report to Moderator %.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: redsn0w on July 13, 2016, 09:55:11 AM
I swear that those crap bot-generated posts that appear every 5 minutes in Bitcoin Discussion are generated by someone who wants to improve their Report to Moderator %.


No, I don't think. I suppose that there are a lot of users opening those 'crap' threads for the only purpose to reply with their main/alt forum accounts and be paid by the various signature campaigns. Improve your report to moderator % doesn't give you any benefit.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Soros Shorts on July 13, 2016, 10:11:26 AM
I swear that those crap bot-generated posts that appear every 5 minutes in Bitcoin Discussion are generated by someone who wants to improve their Report to Moderator %.


No, I don't think. I suppose that there are a lot of users opening those 'crap' threads for the only purpose to reply with their main/alt forum accounts and be paid by the various signature campaigns. Improve your report to moderator % doesn't give you any benefit.

I'm mostly kidding. However, I am referring to those newbie posts that are so bad that they get 0 replies and are deleted by a moderator within a few minutes (unless they are all asleep). I don't even know why people bother making such posts. Some of them are just random words put together and have zero meaning. If you just report these posts you are literally guaranteed a 100% accuracy rate.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Lutpin on July 13, 2016, 10:13:36 AM
I'm mostly kidding. However, I am referring to those newbie posts that are so bad that they get 0 replies and are deleted by a moderator within a few minutes (unless they are all asleep). I don't even know why people bother making such posts. Some of them are just random words put together and have zero meaning. If you just report these posts you are literally guaranteed a 100% accuracy rate.
They even get deleted when all mods are asleep.
As long as Mitchell is running the bot checking all newbie posts, those are usually being deleted faster than you can report them.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: SeriousInvestor on July 18, 2016, 04:54:41 PM
I want to SERIOUSLY report this thread for having the most SERIOUS amount of tattletales in one place on this very SERIOUS forum.
SERIOUSLY.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: notlist3d on July 18, 2016, 08:54:03 PM
I want to SERIOUSLY report this thread for having the most SERIOUS amount of tattletales in one place on this very SERIOUS forum.
SERIOUSLY.

Not sure if your trolling but reporting really does help.  There are accounts out there that just troll... getting rid of those comments helps forum.  Also there is a lot of spam sometimes a website makes multiple account's and post's crap posts to promote.   And there are some post that are so bad they add what I call one liners like "I agree good info!".   This is just some of the utter crud that pop's up.

I think reporting is a good thing for the forum's.   We don't know what they reported in this... but for them to agree chances are it was utter crap posts.  So I would say it helps forum  greatly having a lot report post's (assuming they are correctly reporting).


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: cooldgamer on July 19, 2016, 03:17:57 AM
I'm at 135 with 93% accuracy right now.  On some occasions me and the mods disagree with what's spam, or something seems scammy but doesn't have enough evidence to remove.  Unless you're just spamming the button the % seems pointless, it's really just a percentage of the time you and the mods agree that something sucks.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: SeriousInvestor on July 19, 2016, 02:28:04 PM
I want to SERIOUSLY report this thread for having the most SERIOUS amount of tattletales in one place on this very SERIOUS forum.
SERIOUSLY.

Not sure if your trolling but reporting really does help.  There are accounts out there that just troll... getting rid of those comments helps forum.  Also there is a lot of spam sometimes a website makes multiple account's and post's crap posts to promote.   And there are some post that are so bad they add what I call one liners like "I agree good info!".   This is just some of the utter crud that pop's up.

I think reporting is a good thing for the forum's.   We don't know what they reported in this... but for them to agree chances are it was utter crap posts.  So I would say it helps forum  greatly having a lot report post's (assuming they are correctly reporting).

SERIOUSLY reporting does help keep the forum SERIOUSLY clean, for an aids infected forum that is.  ;D
No. SERIOUSLY. There is nothing wrong with SERIOUSLY Ratting but making a SERIOUS thread to gloat about it is a bit obnoxious. SERIOUSLY!


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Dahhi on July 19, 2016, 02:51:41 PM
I've never reported a post before, don't see any reason why I should. I mean why get someone's account banned?


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: EcuaMobi on July 19, 2016, 03:25:27 PM
I'm at 135 with 93% accuracy right now.  On some occasions me and the mods disagree with what's spam, or something seems scammy but doesn't have enough evidence to remove.  Unless you're just spamming the button the % seems pointless, it's really just a percentage of the time you and the mods agree that something sucks.
Not exactly. There are rules and if you know them then on most cases you can know what is allowed and what is not.
Posts are not removed just because they 'suck' but because they're against the rules. For example scamming is not against the rules. If you report a post because you think OP is a scammer then you'll get it wrong. But posts do get removed when they're clearly illegal, among other reasons.

Moderating is not too subjective, and it shouldn't be. It's the result of applying a list of rules.



I've never reported a post before, don't see any reason why I should. I mean why get someone's account banned?
It's up to you. You can decide to help the spammers by not reporting and keeping their account safe or help the forum by reporting the spam and help keep everything clean. You can't help both.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: shorena on July 25, 2016, 10:46:47 AM

:)

By the way it will be a long way for Lutpin or anyone else to overtake you!
Is that a challenge? ;D

Catch me if you can, hit 10k yesterday (or this morning, not sure)

@thermos:
It would be nice getting a regular (e.g. monthly) dump of the top 50 (or even 100) reporters.
Might also be an incentive for some of the less-active reporters to step up their game.

I and others asked for updates every now and then, Im not sure they will happen regularly. I think it could be automated, so maybe there is another reason why theymos does not want it.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Lutpin on July 25, 2016, 10:48:38 AM
By the way it will be a long way for Lutpin or anyone else to overtake you!
Is that a challenge?
Catch me if you can, hit 10k yesterday (or this morning, not sure)
Can't you go inactive again? That would make things alot easier for me :D
I've just passed 6600, comming for you ;)



To be very true . the forum is far far away to become/be a better place. but yeah. over all these all/include you of course did superb work so far. if you guys continue your contribution to the forum one day the forum surely become a better or even a perfect place.
Better is always a term of comparison.
Imagine this place without a report function/without active moderation.
We'd be drowning in ref-spam, the common KnC/Speculation FUD, hourly bumps and all that other sh*t.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Ardenyham on July 25, 2016, 12:33:45 PM
Thanks for the update, mexxer-2 and me wondered a while back whether Cyrus was still number one. I guess lutpin will be the one to overtake me then.
Looks like my reporting days are behind me and I didn't get to 5k. Congrats shorena!

Thank you to everyone on the list, you make this forum a better place!
Also, thanks theymos for updating this list.

To be very true . the forum is far far away to become/be a better place. but yeah. over all these all/include you of course did superb work so far. if you guys continue your contribution to the forum one day the forum surely become a better or even a perfect place.

Sadly I have no such status. Only reported one posts which was declared un-accurated. so my % is Zero(0)


---Snip---
Better is always a term of comparison.
Imagine this place without a report function/without active moderation.
We'd be drowning in ref-spam, the common KnC/Speculation FUD, hourly bumps and all that other sh*t.

Agreed and of course I appreciate the work you done so far and still doing


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: shorena on July 25, 2016, 06:25:56 PM
Thanks for the update, mexxer-2 and me wondered a while back whether Cyrus was still number one. I guess lutpin will be the one to overtake me then.
Looks like my reporting days are behind me and I didn't get to 5k. Congrats shorena!

Thank you to everyone on the list, you make this forum a better place!
Also, thanks theymos for updating this list.

To be very true . the forum is far far away to become/be a better place. but yeah. over all these all/include you of course did superb work so far. if you guys continue your contribution to the forum one day the forum surely become a better or even a perfect place.

Sadly I have no such status. Only reported one posts which was declared un-accurated. so my % is Zero(0)
-snip-

Keep reporting, you will get the hang of it. I think the forum is in a better state than it appears to be. Often (I assume this hasnt changed recently) spammers are just banned, but their posts not removed. Thus the spam stays and makes it look like it wasnt handled, but it was. Just not removed.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: CoinBreader on July 25, 2016, 06:49:25 PM
mine is 5 with 100%
but its keep growing the last weeks since iv found time & a sig camp  ;D so taking a look here and there to see if i can have a insightful input or share my exp


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Lutpin on October 25, 2016, 09:14:44 PM
Here are the top 50 reporters by total good reports.
Would it be in any way possible to get an updated version of this list?


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: ahmedjadoon on October 27, 2016, 03:42:48 AM
Great job top 50. Here is mine, I'm ashamed:
You have reported 3 posts with 100% accuracy


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: A! on October 27, 2016, 03:54:28 AM
Mine, You have reported 2 posts with 100% accuracy


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: dogie on October 27, 2016, 04:09:52 AM
You have reported 1043 posts with 78% accuracy

Lost 2% when reporting dox information that never got actioned.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Mr. Big on October 27, 2016, 04:36:32 AM
Mine is "You have reported 316 posts with 100% accuracy" , not to mention the copy pastes that I usually report directly to a moderator without using the report to moderator button...  :)


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Foxpup on October 27, 2016, 04:59:17 AM
"You have reported 2514 posts with 100% accuracy"

I've still got it. 8)


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: JITENDERPAR3 on October 27, 2016, 05:16:45 AM
Mine is

You have reported 199 posts with 100% accuracy
i have yet not reported for any post or new topic , because in my opinion we should explain the person directly about the mistake did by the user at his post or by making quote of his reply at the post .
while it is also best to report moderator because moderator's duty is to make this form free of spam .
so thank you all the moderators of this forum .


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: shorena on November 17, 2016, 07:25:55 PM
Here are the top 50 reporters by total good reports.
Would it be in any way possible to get an updated version of this list?

Stats out for reporters?!

We probably have to keep updating manually:

Code:
You have reported 10332 posts with 97% accuracy


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: redsn0w on November 17, 2016, 07:28:21 PM
Here are the top 50 reporters by total good reports.
Would it be in any way possible to get an updated version of this list?

Stats out for reporters?!

We probably have to keep updating manually:

Code:
You have reported 10332 posts with 97% accuracy


Mine:

Code:
You have reported 2157 posts with 87% accuracy


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Lutpin on November 17, 2016, 09:34:05 PM
Code:
You have reported 10332 posts with 97% accuracy
Code:
You have reported 2157 posts with 87% accuracy
Code:
You have reported 9124 posts with 99% accuracy

http://www.mememaker.net/static/images/memes/4122910.jpg


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: achow101 on November 17, 2016, 10:05:01 PM
Code:
You have reported 10332 posts with 97% accuracy
Code:
You have reported 2157 posts with 87% accuracy
Code:
You have reported 9124 posts with 99% accuracy
Code:
You have reported 1500 posts with 99% accuracy

But who needs reporting when you can just go and delete/move the post yourself anyways.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Gleb Gamow on November 18, 2016, 01:40:25 AM
I just reported this thread to the mods because it's in the wrong section. Hopefully, this action will result in me finally having an integer in front of my % rate (assuming 0 is not an integer).  ::) ::) ::)


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Vod on November 18, 2016, 01:41:52 AM
I just reported this thread to the mods because it's in the wrong section. Hopefully, this action will result in me finally having an integer in front of my % rate (assuming 0 is not an integer).  ::) ::) ::)

0 is an integer.  Anything without a decimal place is an integer.  :)


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: eaLiTy on November 18, 2016, 02:08:37 AM
i am just a baby compared to all the big timers who reports post,just now noticed this thread, thanks to VOD  ;)
I have reported 140 posts with 98% accuracy

You will be rewarded in the afterlife!
i guess so buddy ,but i dont expect that and die soon  ;D


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Vod on November 18, 2016, 02:18:11 AM
thanks to VOD  ;)

You will be rewarded in the afterlife!

I am almost at 1,000 reports at 99% accuracy.   I am impressed by Foxpup!


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: minifrij on November 18, 2016, 09:13:54 AM
You have reported 405 posts with 97% accuracy.
Not enough.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: digaran on November 18, 2016, 09:38:58 AM
The only things I hate most are the male enhancement and skin care ads in bitcoin discussion section.
I rarely report any other posts maybe 2 or 3 but total I think I'm at 50 with 96%.
And frankly I can't afford to spend time on things other than stupid and completely unrelated to crypto with brand new accounts :).


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: unamis76 on November 18, 2016, 01:33:02 PM
Curiously I was questioning myself during this week what's the status on report count and % on the top 50, and this thread appeared on my Watchlist now. Would be interesting if this info got released periodically, say, every half a year :)


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: mexxer-2 on November 18, 2016, 01:36:01 PM
Code:
You have reported 10332 posts with 97% accuracy
Code:
You have reported 2157 posts with 87% accuracy
Code:
You have reported 9124 posts with 99% accuracy
Well shit, don't go becoming a staff member already
Code:
You have reported 3954 posts with 98% accuracy


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: veleten on November 20, 2016, 05:50:32 PM
well in the "reporter of the year" competition
I will finish last
You have reported 3 posts with 100% accuracy


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: chixka000 on November 20, 2016, 11:25:37 PM
I reported only one account and it is a 100% accurate  ;) Never plan to do some research for faggots but when i do came across to it. This would just add up to my list.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: jacee on November 22, 2016, 10:57:45 AM
Code:
You have reported 151 posts with 100% accuracy
I used to have 99% and I thought it will stay at that once I made a mitake on reporting (I saw a post about this)  but suddenly it got up to 100%.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: LFC_Bitcoin on November 22, 2016, 06:50:02 PM
I don't do it very often but my stats are 92% from 87 posts.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Lutpin on January 03, 2017, 08:58:08 AM
Here are the top 50 reporters by total good reports.
Would it be in any way possible to get an updated version of this list?
Stats out for reporters?!
Time for another round, I guess.
I think this marks me as #2 (after sho) with over 10k reports.
Code:
You have reported 10003 posts with 99% accuracy


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: botany on January 03, 2017, 11:40:37 AM
Here are the top 50 reporters by total good reports.
Would it be in any way possible to get an updated version of this list?
Stats out for reporters?!
Time for another round, I guess.
I think this marks me as #2 (after sho) with over 10k reports.
Code:
You have reported 10003 posts with 99% accuracy

That is a commendable number.
You have achieved it in a shorter time frame as well.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: shorena on January 04, 2017, 08:37:12 PM
Here are the top 50 reporters by total good reports.
Would it be in any way possible to get an updated version of this list?
Stats out for reporters?!
Time for another round, I guess.
I think this marks me as #2 (after sho) with over 10k reports.
Code:
You have reported 10003 posts with 99% accuracy

Nice, lets see who gets 20k first. :)

Code:
You have reported 10783 posts with 97% accuracy


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: botany on January 05, 2017, 12:42:45 AM
Nice, lets see who gets 20k first. :)

Code:
You have reported 10783 posts with 97% accuracy

By that time, I am sure a staff position will open up and your profile would stand out amongst the candidates.  :P


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: jackg on January 05, 2017, 01:46:30 AM
I've only reported 34 posts with 70% accuracy. Maybe I'll take another look at the rules in order to work out what's best to look out for.

It would be interesting to know my breakdown stats like the ones theymos posted on the first page.



Time for another round, I guess.
I think this marks me as #2 (after sho) with over 10k reports.
Code:
You have reported 10003 posts with 99% accuracy

Nice, lets see who gets 20k first. :)

Code:
You have reported 10783 posts with 97% accuracy

Both of your stats are very close! Competition maybe?


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: xhomerx10 on January 05, 2017, 03:06:08 AM
I've only reported 34 posts with 70% accuracy. Maybe I'll take another look at the rules in order to work out what's best to look out for.

It would be interesting to know my breakdown stats like the ones theymos posted on the first page.



Time for another round, I guess.
I think this marks me as #2 (after sho) with over 10k reports.
Code:
You have reported 10003 posts with 99% accuracy


Nice, lets see who gets 20k first. :)

Code:
You have reported 10783 posts with 97% accuracy

Both of your stats are very close! Competition maybe?

 Sounds like it's already on!
Where can we place our bets?  8)



Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: shorena on January 05, 2017, 07:13:25 AM
Nice, lets see who gets 20k first. :)

Code:
You have reported 10783 posts with 97% accuracy

By that time, I am sure a staff position will open up and your profile would stand out amongst the candidates.  :P

Several people became staff before me regardless of my report numbers or accuracy. My goal was never to become staff, but to help improve the board. I guess if it was my goal, I would have stopped reporting by now.



-snip-
 Sounds like it's already on!
Where can we place our bets?  8)

Feel free to open a thread in games and rounds and PM me a link.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Lauda on January 05, 2017, 09:15:46 AM
I've only reported 34 posts with 70% accuracy. Maybe I'll take another look at the rules in order to work out what's best to look out for.
You may be reporting some complex issues wrongly (e.g. trolling). If you want the easiest to increase that number, then reporting backlink spam, referral spam or old bumps it the way to go.

-snip-
 Sounds like it's already on!
Where can we place our bets?  8)
Feel free to open a thread in games and rounds and PM me a link.
That would be an interesting sight to see. There's a long way till 20k though.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: botany on January 05, 2017, 04:14:02 PM
I've only reported 34 posts with 70% accuracy. Maybe I'll take another look at the rules in order to work out what's best to look out for.
You may be reporting some complex issues wrongly (e.g. trolling). If you want the easiest to increase that number, then reporting backlink spam, referral spam or old bumps it the way to go.

-snip-
 Sounds like it's already on!
Where can we place our bets?  8)
Feel free to open a thread in games and rounds and PM me a link.
That would be an interesting sight to see. There's a long way till 20k though.

With bitcoin's price increasing, we may get more spammers and bots. Then 20K might not seem a long way off.
There should be another statistic - number of reports which resulted in the mods imposing a ban.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: shorena on January 05, 2017, 04:37:23 PM
I've only reported 34 posts with 70% accuracy. Maybe I'll take another look at the rules in order to work out what's best to look out for.
You may be reporting some complex issues wrongly (e.g. trolling). If you want the easiest to increase that number, then reporting backlink spam, referral spam or old bumps it the way to go.

-snip-
 Sounds like it's already on!
Where can we place our bets?  8)
Feel free to open a thread in games and rounds and PM me a link.
That would be an interesting sight to see. There's a long way till 20k though.

With bitcoin's price increasing, we may get more spammers and bots. Then 20K might not seem a long way off.
There should be another statistic - number of reports which resulted in the mods imposing a ban.

I think you have the wrong impression. The majority of my reports are "should be in <insert correct subboard here>", distantly followed by "spam/spambot" which are usually obvious anyway and "spam/double post: <link to other thread>". Id say this is similar for Lutpin, I know it was for mexxer-2. Me and mexxer-2 had some sort of contest for some time, but it seems they are less active now.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Lutpin on January 05, 2017, 06:45:36 PM
Both of your stats are very close! Competition maybe?
Wouldn't call contributing to the forum competition.
I mean sure, you take a peek left and right what the other (active) reporters are doing, but in the end, everybody is doing what they are abled to,
and any reporting activity (given it's good reports, not spamming or whatever) is a good thing, no matter how high the numbers.
That being said, I'd eat shorena for breakfast any given day :P

Feel free to open a thread in games and rounds and PM me a link.
I wouldn't be abled to bet on that one, huh?

I think you have the wrong impression. The majority of my reports are "should be in <insert correct subboard here>", distantly followed by "spam/spambot" which are usually obvious anyway and "spam/double post: <link to other thread>". Id say this is similar for Lutpin, I know it was for mexxer-2.
Yes and no. Indeed, posts in wrong sections are quite a big junk of my reports, not to mention the annoying backlink spam for whatever products.
Another thing I can't stand is when marketplace seller either don't delete old bumps or violate the 24h bump rule, so I report those very often aswell.
However, there is one group of threads/spam/reports, which is somehow related to btc price movements.
In case of big jumps, aswell as crashes (like the little one we had earlier today), the Speculation FUD spam gets significantly more active.
Those threads ("bitcoin ponzi scheme", "2014 all over again",...think we all know the hits) make up for a big part of my reports aswell.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: shorena on January 06, 2017, 12:05:02 PM
Both of your stats are very close! Competition maybe?
Wouldn't call contributing to the forum competition.
I mean sure, you take a peek left and right what the other (active) reporters are doing, but in the end, everybody is doing what they are abled to,
and any reporting activity (given it's good reports, not spamming or whatever) is a good thing, no matter how high the numbers.
That being said, I'd eat shorena for breakfast any given day :P

It seems I eat my breakfast when you are still sleeping, goes whos reporting while you catching Zs?

Feel free to open a thread in games and rounds and PM me a link.
I wouldn't be abled to bet on that one, huh?

I dont see why not, we need someone neutral to verify the count anyway.

I think you have the wrong impression. The majority of my reports are "should be in <insert correct subboard here>", distantly followed by "spam/spambot" which are usually obvious anyway and "spam/double post: <link to other thread>". Id say this is similar for Lutpin, I know it was for mexxer-2.
Yes and no. Indeed, posts in wrong sections are quite a big junk of my reports, not to mention the annoying backlink spam for whatever products.
Another thing I can't stand is when marketplace seller either don't delete old bumps or violate the 24h bump rule, so I report those very often aswell.
However, there is one group of threads/spam/reports, which is somehow related to btc price movements.
In case of big jumps, aswell as crashes (like the little one we had earlier today), the Speculation FUD spam gets significantly more active.
Those threads ("bitcoin ponzi scheme", "2014 all over again",...think we all know the hits) make up for a big part of my reports aswell.

Lets hope for steady price. :P


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: iwandhdumas2003 on January 07, 2017, 11:35:38 PM
Mine is

You have reported 199 posts with 100% accuracy

wow having 199 posts reported is a nice record man and that with a 100% !

I have never reported any posts because I am worried that if I by mistake judge it wrongly I might get banned or bad trust :(


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Lauda on January 07, 2017, 11:39:59 PM
I have never reported any posts because I am worried that if I by mistake judge it wrongly I might get banned or bad trust :(
You don't get banned or negatively rated for creating bad reports. I'd advise against reporting when you are uncertain. It should be fairly trivial to correctly report thing such as spam, overbumping and old-bumps.

However, judging from your post history I understand why you made this useless assertion.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: rizzlarolla on January 08, 2017, 12:12:56 AM
judging from your post history I understand why you made this useless assertion.

Another old hacked and sold account lives again.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: phantastisch on January 08, 2017, 08:26:56 AM
judging from your post history I understand why you made this useless assertion.

Another old hacked and sold account lives again.


How much was lauda sold for?


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: 0x0010 on January 08, 2017, 08:29:09 AM
"You have reported 31 posts with 100% accuracy"

But I only report those funny websites related to old men with no hair that are posted every now and then.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: shorena on January 08, 2017, 01:08:50 PM
judging from your post history I understand why you made this useless assertion.

Another old hacked and sold account lives again.


How much was lauda sold for?

About treefiddy.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Lutpin on January 09, 2017, 12:20:04 AM
judging from your post history I understand why you made this useless assertion.
Another old hacked and sold account lives again.
How much was lauda sold for?
About treefiddy.
BTC or (freedom-)dollarz?
Sounds like somebody overpaid either way.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: canah17 on January 12, 2017, 12:20:59 PM
Mine is

You have reported 199 posts with 100% accuracy

Wow! amazing that many? :O i am very shocked to see you have many reported post but for me i never reported post because i don't really know how to report and really its hard i mean you look at the post and you don't like it because it has a bad manner or language in it "this is just an example" but then i will just reply nothing the less i just leave him a message also i don't really know how to report and i am afraid because when i will report a post i will get ban too >.< because  the post i reported the owner of it will report me also >.< and i don't want to get ban from this forum because this is my profit can you  teach me sir how to report a post because i don't really know and what is the transaction of it? Thank you and have a Good day! :)


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: ranochigo on January 12, 2017, 02:42:00 PM
406 posts, 98%.


I'm slowly making my way up to 99%, hopefully. No worries, this won't be counted for sig.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: jackg on January 12, 2017, 03:04:51 PM
Mine is

You have reported 199 posts with 100% accuracy

Wow! amazing that many? :O i am very shocked to see you have many reported post but for me i never reported post because i don't really know how to report and really its hard i mean you look at the post and you don't like it because it has a bad manner or language in it "this is just an example" but then i will just reply nothing the less i just leave him a message also i don't really know how to report and i am afraid because when i will report a post i will get ban too >.< because  the post i reported the owner of it will report me also >.< and i don't want to get ban from this forum because this is my profit can you  teach me sir how to report a post because i don't really know and what is the transaction of it? Thank you and have a Good day! :)

You report a post by clicking on the button in the bottom right of EVERY post that says "report to moderator" it really isn't that difficult to notice.
The owner of the post does not know who deleted it. I had a few deleted a while ago and it was sent from a forum default account that is unrelyable to and it works in the same way as the messaging system (thus you get a message when your post is deleted). On some boards, if there are multiple moderators then you don't know which moderator deleted it. And if you're of "Newbie" status then it could be deleted by "staff" and any other post could be deleted by moderators or admin (although I don't think admin report posts often).

Bans don't come directly from reporting posts. Bans come from many posts of yours that are deleted or abuse of the system (abuse would mean if you reported loads of posts and none of them seemed even slightly relavent to the data you gave or none of them break any forum rules).


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: SFR10 on January 26, 2017, 05:54:50 AM
Finally got to the overall report of 1000 (Nothing special since I only report easy stuff on my free time) :)
Code:
You have reported 1000 posts with 100% accuracy

Is there a chance that we could get an update (it's been 6 months from the last one)? Was wondering what's the top two stats (between "Sho" and "lutpin") since they seem to be very tight and also wondered if I finally got to the top 50 ;D

Update:
It would be nice if this information could be made public, as part of your profile information.
Indeed, It would be a great addition.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Vod on January 26, 2017, 06:06:44 AM
Is there a chance that we could get an update (it's been 6 months from the last one)? Was wondering what's the top two stats (between "Sho" and "lutpin") since they seem to be very tight and also wondered if I finally got to the top 50 ;D

It would be nice if this information could be made public, as part of your profile information.



Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Foxpup on January 26, 2017, 03:01:02 PM
"You have reported 2940 posts with 100% accuracy"

http://www.vizzed.com/vizzedboard/retro/user_screenshots/saves19/197318/Street%20Fighter%20Alpha%202_Jun22%2015_52_18.png

I've now reported more posts than I've made. Am I in the top 10 yet?


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: rifiuti on January 26, 2017, 03:04:34 PM
Damn, OP should change the thread name as; How much of a snitch are you?

S.O. to people who report the scams tho.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: shorena on January 28, 2017, 11:36:34 AM
Damn, OP should change the thread name as; How much of a snitch are you?

Lol, snitch? Most reports are about threads started in the wrong section. If anything the question should be how high is your compulsive orderliness?

S.O. to people who report the scams tho.

S.O.? Significant other? Scams are not handled by staff so reporting them would do nothing.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Lutpin on January 28, 2017, 01:01:05 PM
S.O. to people who report the scams tho.
S.O.? Significant other? Scams are not handled by staff so reporting them would do nothing.
Shout out, I'd guess.

I've now reported more posts than I've made.
I can beat that, more than twice  :)
Still stuck at 99% though, kudos for the 100.

It would be nice if this information could be made public, as part of your profile information.
It seems there were recently some changes made on profiles (I'm talking about the added link to topics started).
Might be a nice little addition to the general stats page, maybe below the total time logged in.



Haven't reached shorenas latest number yet (10382 currently over here), so they're still in the lead.



Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: instacalm on January 28, 2017, 06:36:09 PM
My rate as of now is only about 75%. I guess one of the reasons that it is not as high as some of you that have posted before me is that I am relatively strict in the way I perceive posts, I believe. That means my own line of thinking does not reflect the stance of moderators to a degree of more than my 75%. And I am fine with that. We all have our own perception, and we should respect each other's decisions and come to a rational conclusion. Overall I am relatively satisfied with the way Bitcointalk is moderated, and it definitely doesn't appear to be an easy job to do this well.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: coolcoinz on January 28, 2017, 07:10:27 PM
Damn, OP should change the thread name as; How much of a snitch are you?

S.O. to people who report the scams tho.
And how do you know if something is a scam or not? You can suspect it' but neither you, nor the moderator should prosecute people without a valid proof.

My report is at 100%, but I'm only reporting obvious and most annoying violations.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: eaLiTy on January 28, 2017, 08:41:53 PM
Finally got to the overall report of 1000 (Nothing special since I only report easy stuff on my free time) :)
Code:
You have reported 1000 posts with 100% accuracy
Congrats on reaching 1000 posts with 100% accuracy .I am not actively reporting but i am still at 177 posts with 98% accuracy,if i see some dumb post in my free time i will report and will reach double century in a couple of months. ;) congrats to the leaders.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: jackg on January 29, 2017, 12:45:53 AM
Damn, OP should change the thread name as; How much of a snitch are you?

S.O. to people who report the scams tho.
And how do you know if something is a scam or not? You can suspect it' but neither you, nor the moderator should prosecute people without a valid proof.

My report is at 100%, but I'm only reporting obvious and most annoying violations.

Actually moderators are more proactively reomving scams (such as onzischemes) whenever they arise now and have more power to act.
It is true that it's difficult to know, better to use your own judgement to decide whether you think it is scam or not.

S.O. to people who report the scams tho.
S.O.? Significant other? Scams are not handled by staff so reporting them would do nothing.
Shout out, I'd guess.

I've now reported more posts than I've made.
I can beat that, more than twice  :)
Still stuck at 99% though, kudos for the 100.

It would be nice if this information could be made public, as part of your profile information.
It seems there were recently some changes made on profiles (I'm talking about the added link to topics started).
Might be a nice little addition to the general stats page, maybe below the total time logged in.



Haven't reached shorenas latest number yet (10382 currently over here), so they're still in the lead.



Moderators are deleting obvious scams.
I think shorena's is probably higher than that by now.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Jet Cash on January 29, 2017, 12:08:44 PM
I've only reported one post. That was from a member who was abusive and said I should leave the forum because I support core, and because I block unlimited and XT nodes. I didn't receive a reply, so I don't know if that was considered a valid reason for reporting a post. Imho. it's attitudes like that that reduce the popularity of this forum, and allow the hard-skinned spammers to dominate, and that is why I reported the post.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: mexxer-2 on January 29, 2017, 12:18:29 PM
I've only reported one post. That was from a member who was abusive and said I should leave the forum because I support core, and because I block unlimited and XT nodes. I didn't receive a reply, so I don't know if that was considered a valid reason for reporting a post. Imho. it's attitudes like that that reduce the popularity of this forum, and allow the hard-skinned spammers to dominate, and that is why I reported the post.
Click report on any random post again and if the accuracy is at 0, that means your report was not considered valid and if its at 100 it was handled.

Although I have to say one instance of such post is not likely to be removed


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: 0xfff on January 29, 2017, 12:57:09 PM
I only report referral links because I hate people that post them. 8 reported posts at a 100% rate.  ;D ;D ;D ;D


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Jet Cash on January 29, 2017, 01:16:05 PM
I've only reported one post. That was from a member who was abusive and said I should leave the forum because I support core, and because I block unlimited and XT nodes. I didn't receive a reply, so I don't know if that was considered a valid reason for reporting a post. Imho. it's attitudes like that that reduce the popularity of this forum, and allow the hard-skinned spammers to dominate, and that is why I reported the post.
Click report on any random post again and if the accuracy is at 0, that means your report was not considered valid and if its at 100 it was handled.

Although I have to say one instance of such post is not likely to be removed

Thanks for posting that. I got this
Quote
You have reported 1 posts with 100% accuracy

I hope I haven't got you into trouble, as I clicked on your post. :)

It would have been nice if there had been a "thank you" button there, so that one can make positive comments as well as negative ones.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: jackg on January 29, 2017, 01:24:48 PM
I've only reported one post. That was from a member who was abusive and said I should leave the forum because I support core, and because I block unlimited and XT nodes. I didn't receive a reply, so I don't know if that was considered a valid reason for reporting a post. Imho. it's attitudes like that that reduce the popularity of this forum, and allow the hard-skinned spammers to dominate, and that is why I reported the post.
Click report on any random post again and if the accuracy is at 0, that means your report was not considered valid and if its at 100 it was handled.

Although I have to say one instance of such post is not likely to be removed

Thanks for posting that. I got this
Quote
You have reported 1 posts with 100% accuracy

I hope I haven't got you into trouble, as I clicked on your post. :)

It would have been nice if there had been a "thank you" button there, so that one can make positive comments as well as negative ones.

There is a positive button, posting here and replying...
That's good! That means they thought their post was worthy of deleting and that you had made a contribution to this forum yourself.

(also, the mods only see reported posts when you hit  the button next to the text field).


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: mexxer-2 on February 04, 2017, 12:26:18 PM
Back to 99% again finally. Ha! Suck on that
Quote
You have reported 4023 posts with 99% accuracy
Back in the game, guessing I'm still the 5th place.


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: LFC_Bitcoin on February 04, 2017, 02:16:29 PM
You have reported 91 posts with 93% accuracy

Some of you guys have reported so many  ;D :D


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: sulendra12 on February 04, 2017, 02:23:50 PM
Let's see mine :

You have reported 92 posts with 99% accuracy


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: bitkilo on March 04, 2017, 02:26:01 PM
I'm sitting pretty at 100% accuracy too, although that is for a total of only 11 reported posts  :P


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: DomainMagnate on March 04, 2017, 10:10:42 PM
Mine is

You have reported 199 posts with 100% accuracy
Wow this is very good indeed.I have reported 10 posts so far and my accuracy is 90%.I guess it is because i reported a duplicate of same spammy report or whatever reason


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Nekutasa on March 05, 2017, 06:49:03 AM
I have 0 but thumbs up to those who take the time and effort to report useless posts!


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: DomainMagnate on March 05, 2017, 08:13:10 PM
but they're far less frequent than some of the top reporters (having a few thousand reports and reporting accuracy of over 95% is excellent).

"You have reported 5097 posts with 99% accuracy"

I'd imagine there are people with even higher numbers (shorena for example, would be curious about where he currently stands), but I think 5k is a good start :)



I never report any posts. Im not a rat.
Come at me, please.
Can we get the glimpse of reported posts to get idea what kind of posts should be reported?I usually report a post when I see some external website link either not related to topic or completely not related to crypto usually make to spam.
Which forum's topic usually get mostly reported or which forum is mostly targetted by spammers and abusers?


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: jackg on March 05, 2017, 08:46:16 PM
but they're far less frequent than some of the top reporters (having a few thousand reports and reporting accuracy of over 95% is excellent).

"You have reported 5097 posts with 99% accuracy"

I'd imagine there are people with even higher numbers (shorena for example, would be curious about where he currently stands), but I think 5k is a good start :)



I never report any posts. Im not a rat.
Come at me, please.
Can we get the glimpse of reported posts to get idea what kind of posts should be reported?I usually report a post when I see some external website link either not related to topic or completely not related to crypto usually make to spam.
Which forum's topic usually get mostly reported or which forum is mostly targetted by spammers and abusers?


There used to be a lot of spam in the offtopic section (not sure if there still is).
Mainly the bitcoin marketplace and the beginners&help section normally have the greatest amount of spam.
Any posts that break "the rules" of the forum should be reported, good ideas are:
1. Posts off-topic from the original post.
2. Post with referral links.
3. Bumps more than once a day (either as a post written as a plain "bump" or as making more than one announcement in the same day on a certain product/service to bump it that way).
4. Some obvious scams are also being picked up as well (ponzis for example).


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: th3nolo on March 05, 2017, 10:30:05 PM
29 post with 100% of accuracy, most of my reports come from bitcoin discussion where some bots published products or pages unrelated with bitcoin. ;D


Title: Re: What's your "Report to Moderator" % rate at?
Post by: Wapinter on March 09, 2017, 11:25:03 PM
I have 100% accuracy but then I have reported only 1 post  ;D I think you need to be really very active on forum to catch posts that break rules and needed to be reported