|
Title: Why Solidity isn’t solid Post by: BitcoinLady on July 02, 2016, 02:09:56 PM Enjoy! https://medium.com/@Hibryda/why-solidity-isnt-solid-3341af77fc1c#.1dtwe7gc9 (https://medium.com/@Hibryda/why-solidity-isnt-solid-3341af77fc1c#.1dtwe7gc9)
Title: Re: Why Solidity isn’t solid Post by: Nxtblg on July 02, 2016, 07:22:24 PM Enjoy! https://medium.com/@Hibryda/why-solidity-isnt-solid-3341af77fc1c#.1dtwe7gc9 (https://medium.com/@Hibryda/why-solidity-isnt-solid-3341af77fc1c#.1dtwe7gc9) An incisive article, that was. A pity that a project intended for The DAO that's shepherded by Pamela D. Morgan was shot into limbo by The DAO's collapse. Her DAMN Project (https://github.com/thirdkey-solutions/damn/blob/master/proposal.asciidoc) was working on the same lines as Hibryda's critique of Solidity, albeit from a lawyer's perspective. Maybe she and Hibryda should get a room. :P Title: Re: Why Solidity isn’t solid Post by: Hibryda on July 02, 2016, 11:13:11 PM Hi, Hibryda here (I registered after my colleague posted my articles here),
Actually I did what I could to show the community of theDAO all the deficiencies in code, logic and legal side (I wrote loads about legal side of this enterprise, see this thread on daohub - filter for Hibryda posts (http://"https://forum.daohub.org/t/the-legal-status-of-the-dao/81/")). This DAMN project, while being interesting, disregarded obvious deficiencies of smart contract, for example now so prominent intent/code discrepancy. But as I stated there are also more fundamental issues, with Solidity in particular. It's even good that Pamela's project was shot down, as setting a house on dunes usually results in collapse. Nevertheless I think that DAMN is a prospective idea and if asked I can consider helping it. Title: Re: Why Solidity isn’t solid Post by: Nxtblg on July 05, 2016, 05:40:03 PM Hi, Hibryda here (I registered after my colleague posted my articles here), Actually I did what I could to show the community of theDAO all the deficiencies in code, logic and legal side (I wrote loads about legal side of this enterprise, see this thread on daohub - filter for Hibryda posts (http://"https://forum.daohub.org/t/the-legal-status-of-the-dao/81/")). This DAMN project, while being interesting, disregarded obvious deficiencies of smart contract, for example now so prominent intent/code discrepancy. But as I stated there are also more fundamental issues, with Solidity in particular. It's even good that Pamela's project was shot down, as setting a house on dunes usually results in collapse. Nevertheless I think that DAMN is a prospective idea and if asked I can consider helping it. Thanks for your fill-in. It certainly explains why I wrote her via Email & didn't get a response. I thought I was being ignored as usual. :) |