Bitcoin Forum

Economy => Speculation => Topic started by: Elwar on March 19, 2013, 06:56:49 PM



Title: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: Elwar on March 19, 2013, 06:56:49 PM
I have confidence in MtGox and I tend to trust a portion of my BTC in my account, but with their transition to the US and with prices going up so much bad things could happen.

Transfer most of your coins to an offline wallet for a while, keep your private key secure.


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: Matthew N. Wright on March 19, 2013, 07:00:28 PM
Normally I'd be against alarmist posts, but since there isn't much reason to have MtGox holding your private wallet contents in the first place, this post just rings of common sense and nothing else. Bitcoins should always be under your own control until you're ready to spend them.


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: Elwar on March 19, 2013, 07:14:39 PM
Normally I'd be against alarmist posts, but since there isn't much reason to have MtGox holding your private wallet contents in the first place, this post just rings of common sense and nothing else. Bitcoins should always be under your own control until you're ready to spend them.

It is common sense for most of us but when I first started trading I kept almost all of my BTC on my exchange accounts. Fortunately someone posted something similar about not trusting your BTC on exchanges. I pulled almost all of my BTC out of Bitcoinica soon after that. A week later they got hacked.


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: blackreplica on March 19, 2013, 07:44:16 PM
Personally I pulled all of mine off Mt Gox to a blockchain wallet, encrypted it with 2 passwords and set my mobile number for 2FA, just last week. Prior to that everything just sat in my trading account (though i did have a yubikey 2FA on my Gox account)

The main reason was simply because with the recent price runup, the value of my holdings was just too substantial now to just leave on an exchange rather than any doubts on Mt Gox in particular. The incentive to hack is really high now though, who knows Gox may get hacked again in future.

Never hurts to be careful, especially with something so easily movable as bitcoin


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: RodeoX on March 19, 2013, 07:47:12 PM
I try to keep only a few hundred dollars worth of coins at the exchange. But it keeps going up so I am constantly pulling more out.
Not a bad problem to have.


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: ehoffman on March 19, 2013, 07:48:22 PM
Well, I was thinking of that, but you know, the incentive is as great to write a virus that could get your wallet.dat and keystokes of your password...  Maybe diversifying, in 3 exchanges plus your wallet, so if one get hacked, you only lose 25%...


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: jgarzik on March 19, 2013, 07:48:49 PM
Who would keep their money at a centralized website, rather than a decentralized wallet?  :)



Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: Jrock on March 19, 2013, 07:54:35 PM
You guys are making me nervous.

I keep a lot of cash in mtgox cause I keep hoping for a major crash lol.



Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: RodeoX on March 19, 2013, 07:57:01 PM
Well, I was thinking of that, but you know, the incentive is as great to write a virus that could get your wallet.dat and keystokes of your password...  Maybe diversifying, in 3 exchanges plus your wallet, so if one get hacked, you only lose 25%...
That would help. Better yet, come get mine. They are on a USB stick right behind me and my arsenal of assault weapons.


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: Tirapon on March 19, 2013, 08:58:32 PM
Well, I was thinking of that, but you know, the incentive is as great to write a virus that could get your wallet.dat and keystokes of your password...  Maybe diversifying, in 3 exchanges plus your wallet, so if one get hacked, you only lose 25%...

Learn to use secure offline storage. Armory is great.


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: Mae on March 19, 2013, 10:10:03 PM
You guys are making me nervous.

I keep a lot of cash in mtgox cause I keep hoping for a major crash lol.



Yeah me too! hehe But I prefer the dollars to sit and wait in my ordinary bank account. If that happens then I will send the money again to MtGox.

Now the BTC is so expensieve... it looks like really interesting for hackers to thief. Also since BTC is anonymous you can't sue or track the thief... to thief bit coins is a no-brainer, it's almost sure you won't go to jail! A friend of mine works as security auditor and I've learnt that no system is really safe, the only safe place for a server is under water and unplugged.


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: yokosan on March 19, 2013, 10:14:35 PM
You guys are making me nervous.

I keep a lot of cash in mtgox cause I keep hoping for a major crash lol.



Yeah me too! hehe But I prefer the dollars to sit and wait in my ordinary bank account. If that happens then I will send the money again to MtGox.

Now the BTC is so expensieve... it looks like really interesting for hackers to thief. Also since BTC is anonymous you can't sue or track the thief... to thief bit coins is a no-brainer, it's almost sure you won't go to jail! A friend of mine works as security auditor and I've learnt that no system is really safe, the only safe place for a server is under water and unplugged.

The private keys aren't even held on the gox servers. The worst a hacker could do is get hold of all the password hashes, which doesn't matter if you use 2 factor authentication.

The biggest weakness is a full blown raid of their office.


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: Odalv on March 19, 2013, 10:14:58 PM
You guys are making me nervous.

I keep a lot of cash in mtgox cause I keep hoping for a major crash lol.



Yeah me too! hehe But I prefer the dollars to sit and wait in my ordinary bank account. If that happens then I will send the money again to MtGox.

Now the BTC is so expensieve... it looks like really interesting for hackers to thief. Also since BTC is anonymous you can't sue or track the thief... to thief bit coins is a no-brainer, it's almost sure you won't go to jail! A friend of mine works as security auditor and I've learnt that no system is really safe, the only safe place for a server is under water and unplugged.

You will have hard time not to buy at $1000,


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: Elwar on March 19, 2013, 10:24:33 PM
I've learnt that no system is really safe, the only safe place for a server is under water and unplugged.

That is where I keep my wallet file.


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: ehoffman on March 20, 2013, 12:15:55 AM
I guess one thing that can be done is create a second wallet, by starting bitcoin-qt specifying an alternate directory (for ex: bitcoin-qt.exe -datadir=%APPDATA%\BitcoinAlternateDir).  Then, a new wallet.dat is created.  Encrypt that wallet, copy  the 'receive coin' address to clipboard.

Now, from the client where you have your coins, transfer to the new wallet address.  If you go to your new client, you should be able to confirm you have received the transaction.  From there, there's no point to wait for the 6 confirmations.  In fact, you don't even have to check the new client that you 'received transaction'.  It's in the global blockchain, and your new wallet.dat is just the private key.

Close the new client and copy the new client wallet.dat to a safe place.  Do multiple offline copies (USB stick, DVD, floppy disk, audio cassette using Comodore-64 dataset, punch card, whatever! :P), as long as those stays offline.  You have the password in your head, and the key file offline.  Now, if you delete the new client wallet.dat from computer, it's safe from hacking.

The fun thing is you can even split for example 20BTC to one wallet.dat file.  40BTC to another, etc.

The day you do need this money, you just do as above, creating a new work directory, but then, copy the wallet.dat from storage to the new work directory.  Start bitcoin-qt, and use your funds as needed.

So, is this correct?  Does it make sense?  Am I missing something?  I think you can even run multiple instances of bitcoin-qt simultaneously each in their own workdir.


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: Elwar on March 20, 2013, 12:24:38 AM
Use an offline computer.

Run VanityGen (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=25804.0)

Get a public key/private key.

Write them down/engrave it on a ring/tattoo it to your penis.

Go to MtGox and withdraw to Bitcoin, give your public key.

No hacker can get to your private key unless they had some screen recording virus going on, even then you can encrypt your vanitygen key with a password that is not displayed.

Just do not lose that private key.


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: Herodes on March 20, 2013, 12:29:52 AM
Normally I'd be against alarmist posts, but since there isn't much reason to have MtGox holding your private wallet contents in the first place, this post just rings of common sense and nothing else. Bitcoins should always be under your own control until you're ready to spend them.

It is common sense for most of us but when I first started trading I kept almost all of my BTC on my exchange accounts. Fortunately someone posted something similar about not trusting your BTC on exchanges. I pulled almost all of my BTC out of Bitcoinica soon after that. A week later they got hacked.

Dang ! Yes, it's good advice you're giving out here!


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: Herodes on March 20, 2013, 12:31:45 AM
You guys are making me nervous.

I keep a lot of cash in mtgox cause I keep hoping for a major crash lol.



Yeah me too! hehe But I prefer the dollars to sit and wait in my ordinary bank account. If that happens then I will send the money again to MtGox.

Now the BTC is so expensieve... it looks like really interesting for hackers to thief. Also since BTC is anonymous you can't sue or track the thief... to thief bit coins is a no-brainer, it's almost sure you won't go to jail! A friend of mine works as security auditor and I've learnt that no system is really safe, the only safe place for a server is under water and unplugged.

The private keys aren't even held on the gox servers. The worst a hacker could do is get hold of all the password hashes, which doesn't matter if you use 2 factor authentication.

The biggest weakness is a full blown raid of their office.


LOL - everybody should work remotely in unknown locations! :)


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: Le Happy Merchant on March 20, 2013, 07:04:17 AM
LOL - everybody should work remotely in unknown locations! :)

They should come up with some kind of currency that facilitates this.


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: yokosan on March 20, 2013, 09:34:59 AM
I guess one thing that can be done is create a second wallet, by starting bitcoin-qt specifying an alternate directory (for ex: bitcoin-qt.exe -datadir=%APPDATA%\BitcoinAlternateDir).  Then, a new wallet.dat is created.  Encrypt that wallet, copy  the 'receive coin' address to clipboard.

Or you just do an offline wallet with armory. You can see the balance but never spend the coins as the wallet is held on an offline computer.

When you send funds you take your USB stick to the offline computer for a signature and bring it back to send.


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: ehoffman on March 20, 2013, 09:51:50 AM
I guess it's good for BTC you want to keep away.  But not useful for doing every day transactions.  So, I guess one could keep a large amount offline, and keep a few BTC in a "hot" wallet (online).


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: justusranvier on March 20, 2013, 01:48:02 PM
I guess it's good for BTC you want to keep away.  But not useful for doing every day transactions.  So, I guess one could keep a large amount offline, and keep a few BTC in a "hot" wallet (online).
Armory is good for an offline savings wallet, and blockchain.info is good for a convenient spending wallet.


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: Matthew N. Wright on March 20, 2013, 01:52:46 PM
The biggest weakness is a full blown raid of their office.

Or legal complications involving their new US presence or other draconian threats that would lead to accounts being limited or frozen. I'm not much of a conspiracy theorist, but there is plenty of evidence on these forums of "special" cases where people have found their funds suddenly unavailable, especially at the Paypal of Bitcoin, MtGox. The excuse for which is irrelevant imo, but is usually under the blanket guise of "AML compliance". So you can't process a transfer to the bank? Fine, send the funds back to the owner then.

If you value your bitcoins, treat it like you would gold. Stop lending in USD, stop gambling it away, stop investing. Bitcoin *is* the investment vehicle so long as the price is so volatile (it will settle one day, and then investment again might make sense) and unless I'm mistaken, there are no insured exchanges nor exchanges that are willing to go to jail to keep their customers happy in any situation.


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: Zangelbert Bingledack on March 20, 2013, 02:33:10 PM
Get a public key/private key...tattoo it to your penis.

Walk into MtGox HQ, whip it out and thrust forward while announcing, "IM ALL IN!!!"


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: RodeoX on March 20, 2013, 02:36:42 PM
Get a public key/private key...tattoo it to your penis.

Walk into MtGox HQ, whip it out and thrust forward while announcing, "IM ALL IN!!!"
I wish I could fit a whole private key.  :-[


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: 2weiX on March 20, 2013, 02:51:43 PM
Get a public key/private key...tattoo it to your penis.

Walk into MtGox HQ, whip it out and thrust forward while announcing, "IM ALL IN!!!"
I wish I could fit a whole private key.  :-[


mini-key? (https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Mini_private_key_format)


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: mufa23 on March 20, 2013, 02:52:19 PM
Get a public key/private key...tattoo it to your penis.

Walk into MtGox HQ, whip it out and thrust forward while announcing, "IM ALL IN!!!"
I wish I could fit a whole private key.  :-[
Bummer dude...


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: ehoffman on March 20, 2013, 03:13:29 PM
Get a public key/private key...tattoo it to your penis.

Find a nice lady and ask her if she want you to store your key in a private place...  Or ask her if she accepts deposits :P


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: Herodes on March 20, 2013, 03:54:59 PM
Just want to remind everybody about this:

https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Paper_wallet


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: Zangelbert Bingledack on March 20, 2013, 03:56:27 PM
Get a public key/private key...tattoo it to your penis.

Find a nice lady and ask her if she want you to store your key in a private place...  Or ask her if she accepts deposits :P

Reminded me of http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N9L7UUp0FxY (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N9L7UUp0FxY)


Title: Re: May want to move your funds from MtGox this week
Post by: John (John K.) on March 20, 2013, 03:59:49 PM
Normally I'd be against alarmist posts, but since there isn't much reason to have MtGox holding your private wallet contents in the first place, this post just rings of common sense and nothing else. Bitcoins should always be under your own control until you're ready to spend them.

This. I personally use a 4-tier system:
Amount of bitcoins stored increases from left to right.

MT.Gox/Centralized exchange < Blockchain.info < Hot wallet using Bitcoin-QT < Paper Wallet from Offline Armory