Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Project Development => Topic started by: Lion87346 on August 18, 2016, 07:11:59 PM



Title: New Merchant Features!
Post by: Lion87346 on August 18, 2016, 07:11:59 PM
Ihtth



Title: Re: New Merchant Features!
Post by: eternalgloom on August 19, 2016, 01:57:23 PM
The way Bitcoin works is already good, we do not need things such as smart contracts, there are other altcoins that offer that kind of functionality.
And you can already incorporate messages in your transactions through Blockchain.info and IMO we don't really need that.

No-one will pay you for your ideas btw


Title: Re: New Merchant Features!
Post by: Patatas on August 19, 2016, 06:53:23 PM
The way Bitcoin works is already good, we do not need things such as smart contracts, there are other altcoins that offer that kind of functionality.
You really want to depend on a shitcoin to connect the dots left vacant by bitcoins ?The problem is,merchants probably haven't heard about them.I don't really mind seeing smart contracts implemented as a party of bitcoin project,including a third party dev.Although that does not seem feasible but certainly a topic to think about.

And you can already incorporate messages in your transactions through Blockchain.info and IMO we don't really need that.
That does have a length restriction right ? Don't think it can fit an entire contract.


Title: Re: New Merchant Features!
Post by: eternalgloom on August 19, 2016, 08:13:42 PM
The way Bitcoin works is already good, we do not need things such as smart contracts, there are other altcoins that offer that kind of functionality.
You really want to depend on a shitcoin to connect the dots left vacant by bitcoins ?The problem is,merchants probably haven't heard about them.I don't really mind seeing smart contracts implemented as a party of bitcoin project,including a third party dev.Although that does not seem feasible but certainly a topic to think about.

And you can already incorporate messages in your transactions through Blockchain.info and IMO we don't really need that.
That does have a length restriction right ? Don't think it can fit an entire contract.

He wasn't saying to use that for the contract, but for including information like an address.
Asking for donations for an idea that anyone could have thought about, ideas aren't worth anything if you're not willing to make them happen yourself.

If this can be implemented as some external service, fine, no problem. But not as a part of core, and good luck getting that implemented.

Anyway, would still like to see what other people think of the idea.


Title: Re: New Merchant Features!
Post by: Dinki on August 20, 2016, 07:11:15 AM
The idea would be better off as an external service, not part of the bitcoin core.

It's not a bad idea in its entirety.


Title: Re: New Merchant Features!
Post by: avatar_kiyoshi on August 20, 2016, 02:56:36 PM
This system actually is basic of merchant must have.
Use bitcoin as payment can tracking in blockchain which is traceable.
For shipping tracking, use a shipping service API to add to merchant system.
Done. Your idea is basically merchant must do.


Title: Re: New Merchant Features!
Post by: SparkedDev on August 29, 2016, 07:28:16 AM
People will just take the idea make it better but as i see it no need for this.