|
Title: CAN MY TX GET ANY CONFIRMATION? Post by: Jack4009 on November 21, 2016, 05:23:50 PM TX: https://blockchain.info/tx/58f23fe453c84b067f6cbe46b0859d41e10006b5a9706235f9fd54391bd3f871
Don't blame me for putting this much fee because i did not. I withdraw this from online wallet and this stupid wallet put this small fee. Please tell me if it can be confirmed or not? Title: Re: CAN MY TX GET ANY CONFIRMATION? Post by: longbob72 on November 21, 2016, 05:33:19 PM It can be confirmed but it might take days. There's a decent chance that it will be dropped by the network before that happens. In that case the bitcoins will return to the sender's wallet.
According to https://bitcoinfees.21.co/ a transaction with 10 satoshi per byte will take 50-Inf minutes (Inf is infinite). Title: Re: CAN MY TX GET ANY CONFIRMATION? Post by: DannyHamilton on November 21, 2016, 06:18:24 PM - snip - I withdraw this from online wallet and this stupid wallet put this small fee. - snip - You should contact support for that wallet and tell them that they need to fix this. If the wallet does not provide a way for you to control the fees, then you should also stop using that wallet until this problem is fixed AND they fix the wallet so it doesn't do this anymore. You should also tell us which wallet this is so that we can ALL stop using the wallet until they fix the wallet so it doesn't do this anymore. Title: Re: CAN MY TX GET ANY CONFIRMATION? Post by: Jack4009 on November 21, 2016, 06:31:27 PM - snip - I withdraw this from online wallet and this stupid wallet put this small fee. - snip - You should contact support for that wallet and tell them that they need to fix this. If the wallet does not provide a way for you to control the fees, then you should also stop using that wallet until this problem is fixed AND they fix the wallet so it doesn't do this anymore. You should also tell us which wallet this is so that we can ALL stop using the wallet until they fix the wallet so it doesn't do this anymore. Title: Re: CAN MY TX GET ANY CONFIRMATION? Post by: DannyHamilton on November 21, 2016, 07:01:01 PM It is perfectmoney bitcoin wallet. I withrawn my bitcoins today and they send it with this small fee. Contact perfectmoney and ask them to fix this for you. Please is there any chance it can get confirm,if i continue rebroadcast the raw hex of this tx on the network every 2 hours so that network do not forget about this? Yes, there is a chance it can get confirmed. You just have to wait for ALL of the higher paying transactions to get confirmed OR until a solo-miner or pool decides to confirm it for you aout of the charity in their heart. If you keep re-broadcasting the transaction, then this might happen in the next few hours, or days, or weeks, or months, or years. Also, you could contact someone that has the ability to add transactions to blocks for one of the larger pools and offer to pay them to get the transaction confirmed in that pool's next block. Title: Re: CAN MY TX GET ANY CONFIRMATION? Post by: Jack4009 on November 21, 2016, 07:25:36 PM It is perfectmoney bitcoin wallet. I withrawn my bitcoins today and they send it with this small fee. Contact perfectmoney and ask them to fix this for you. Please is there any chance it can get confirm,if i continue rebroadcast the raw hex of this tx on the network every 2 hours so that network do not forget about this? Yes, there is a chance it can get confirmed. You just have to wait for ALL of the higher paying transactions to get confirmed OR until a solo-miner or pool decides to confirm it for you aout of the charity in their heart. If you keep re-broadcasting the transaction, then this might happen in the next few hours, or days, or weeks, or months, or years. Also, you could contact someone that has the ability to add transactions to blocks for one of the larger pools and offer to pay them to get the transaction confirmed in that pool's next block. Is there any auto online sevice that rebroadcast my tx automatically every 6 hours? any script? Title: Re: CAN MY TX GET ANY CONFIRMATION? Post by: DannyHamilton on November 21, 2016, 11:07:30 PM Is there any auto online sevice that rebroadcast my tx automatically every 6 hours? Not that I'm aware of. any script? I'm certain that people have written such scripts. I don't know if any of them are publicly available. Title: Re: CAN MY TX GET ANY CONFIRMATION? Post by: shorena on November 21, 2016, 11:17:02 PM Is there any auto online sevice that rebroadcast my tx automatically every 6 hours? Not that I'm aware of. any script? I'm certain that people have written such scripts. I don't know if any of them are publicly available. Windows batch: Code: @echo off Ruby (can handle multiple if needed): Code: require bitcoin_rpc.rb #https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/API_reference_(JSON-RPC) Title: Re: CAN MY TX GET ANY CONFIRMATION? Post by: arransiv on November 22, 2016, 02:42:58 AM It is perfectmoney bitcoin wallet. I withrawn my bitcoins today and they send it with this small fee. Contact perfectmoney and ask them to fix this for you. Please is there any chance it can get confirm,if i continue rebroadcast the raw hex of this tx on the network every 2 hours so that network do not forget about this? Yes, there is a chance it can get confirmed. You just have to wait for ALL of the higher paying transactions to get confirmed OR until a solo-miner or pool decides to confirm it for you aout of the charity in their heart. If you keep re-broadcasting the transaction, then this might happen in the next few hours, or days, or weeks, or months, or years. Also, you could contact someone that has the ability to add transactions to blocks for one of the larger pools and offer to pay them to get the transaction confirmed in that pool's next block. Years? I read in somewhere that this transactions with low fees return to the original wallet after some time(few days), it's an wrong info? What about double spending? Can solve this problem? Sending a higher fee with the same amount from transaction? Title: Re: CAN MY TX GET ANY CONFIRMATION? Post by: DannyHamilton on November 22, 2016, 03:15:43 AM Years? Possibly. Or possibly even never. I read in somewhere that this transactions with low fees return to the original wallet after some time(few days), it's an wrong info? That is "wrong info". There are a LOT of people who give advice on here even if they don't know anything. They just make stuff up, and everyone else repeats their nonsense. If nobody re-broadcasts the transaction, then eventually nearly all the nodes on the network will forget about the transaction. Some wallets might choose to forget the transaction after a set amount of time, and to show those bitcoins in your balance. Other wallets might just keep broadcasting the transaction forever. Even if the sending wallet doesn't rebroadcast the transaction, the receiving wallet can, and so can any other user on the network if they want to. Each wallet behaves differently. What about double spending? Can solve this problem? Sending a higher fee with the same amount from transaction? No. The OP specifically said that he doesn't have control over this transaction. It is not possible for him to double spend or send a higher fee. Title: Re: CAN MY TX GET ANY CONFIRMATION? Post by: shorena on November 22, 2016, 06:14:48 AM Just to keep everyone here updated, the transaction is confirmed now. I often rebroadcast transactions for others with my node using the ruby script above. If anyone else has need, just send me a PM and Ill add yours to the loop as soon as I can.
Title: Re: CAN MY TX GET ANY CONFIRMATION? Post by: bL4nkcode on November 23, 2016, 01:47:13 AM Just to keep everyone here updated, the transaction is confirmed now. I often rebroadcast transactions for others with my node using the ruby script above. If anyone else has need, just send me a PM and Ill add yours to the loop as soon as I can. Whoah :o I don't expect that transactions can be rebrodcast for some script ( did you own/made that script shorena? )Well that is very helpful maybe there are so many people here also experiencing what OP feels, and I guess shorena will be the one who can help them. Title: Re: CAN MY TX GET ANY CONFIRMATION? Post by: BingoDog on November 25, 2016, 10:22:15 PM Using very small fees below recommended is very risky. Once it could happen that your transaction never got confirmation. These days there are to many unconfirmed transactions anyway so next time try to avoid very low fees because at the end you will not profit but possibly loose.
Title: Re: CAN MY TX GET ANY CONFIRMATION? Post by: xeqoRameshAxueamExaqana on December 01, 2016, 04:28:28 AM Using very small fees below recommended is very risky. Once it could happen that your transaction never got confirmation. These days there are to many unconfirmed transactions anyway so next time try to avoid very low fees because at the end you will not profit but possibly loose. I think Op can't setting about sending fee because op say withdraw from perfectmoney wallet to Op if fee sending vey low only wait to confirmation, and very long time i think case is problem solved, because i see tx id is ready confirmation Title: Re: CAN MY TX GET ANY CONFIRMATION? Post by: neochiny on December 02, 2016, 01:16:17 PM Just to keep everyone here updated, the transaction is confirmed now. I often rebroadcast transactions for others with my node using the ruby script above. If anyone else has need, just send me a PM and Ill add yours to the loop as soon as I can. Thanks shorena! I sure am glad I checked out this thread. ;D ;D Gonna keep what you said in mind in case I encounter the same issue in future. Thank you in advance and it's great to see people who're willing to help out. :D |