Bitcoin Forum

After reading a thread named ("Would you eat a human?"), i got shocked from the answers saying "Yes we will eat a human to stay alive", So i'm asking this question :

Would you eat your Mother to stay alive?


Example this guy "Sithara007" Profile : https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=305398

Replied to a member saying:

"Who is going to eat the internal organs, when you have the choice of eating the muscle tissue? An average human body is around 40% muscle and 15% fat. Taking an average of 80 kg per person, that will give you a total of 32 kg of muscle and 6 kg of fat, enough for someone to survive for a few months until alternate supplies can be found."


So Would you eat your Mother to survive until alternate supplies can be found ?


I'm very intersted to read the answers.

Note: A guy below said he can eat his mother if she is dead, What about alive ?

Please No bullshit "Yes i can or No and why?"

Assuming my mother's already dead, then yeah I'd eat her to stay alive. If your mother died first I'd eat her, If I died first I'd have no problem letting both our mothers eat me.

Basic survival shit, no shame if you survive to tell the tale. Survival being the key concept here.

So you can eat your mother if she is dead, very intersting, And can you eat her alive??.

As I said before and I say it again, NO. Either it's my mother or any other person, I would rather drink from the sea or chew some tree leaves than dishonouring someone's dead body by eating it, even if it was a "survival" situation. This would vary from person to another, but personally, for me, it's about one's will.

OK, serious answer:

No, I don't think I could bring myself to eat another live human, to me that is simply immoral because there is a chance they might survive. I don't condone murder.

However if the person is dead, I see absolutely no problem in using their meat to keep as many of the survivors alive as possible. They're dead, they don't care what happens to them. And if I found out that my mother had died in a plane crash, and after her death she was eaten by the survivors which led to their rescue, I would be proud and happy that my mother's meat had saved the lives of others!

I see the issue in a similar way to organ donation - when you die you may as well donate your shit to other people who need it. You're not gonna need those organs any more, so why not save some lives by donating them to someone who can use them?

So you would rather die, than "dishonour" someone's dead body by eating it. Resulting in two dead people rather than just one.

If I was the person who had just died, that you were refusing to eat, I would find the refusal of you to eat me very disrespectful. If I was the mother of the person who had just died, I would find your refusal to eat the person very disrespectful.

Why sacrifice your own life for a dead piece of meat?

"Why sacrifice your own life for a dead piece of meat?"  

Short answer: GOD but im sure you dont believe in him so this answer cannot be accepted by you, I understand anyways if i wasn't a muslim or lets say a GOD believer i would be very VERY happy to eat you alive or dead to stay alive infact i will be right now doing some things to be rich and powerfull.

I believe in god and its the ONLY reason that stops me and LOTS of believers from doing bad things like eating a human.

Mr human eater, i see your mind is fucked up and the problem is your soul needs a god and i really feel sorry for your mother.

The son who ate his mother to stay alive under the name of honor.

OR

The son who died beside his mother under the name of love and honor.

Good luck.

Because I know there are some options in front of me and eating a dead body would be their last. If it was a plane crash on an island, most islands have trees, weed and plants, I would go there (eating those). Not making my first option; chewing someone's arm or thigh.

If I was on a ship/boat with a dead body, I would look around me for fish or seafood before eating that person. At least, I could tell myself afterwards that I tried my best to survive and could live with what I did for the rest of my life.

Yeah, I'm pretty sure the discussion is based on the fact that there are no other forms of sustenance easily available (according to the line in the OP: "until alternate supplies can be found")

Of course you would look to gather plants/hunt animals first - the dilemma here (if you hadn't gathered it yet) is that your mother's body is the only nutrition available.

That's the whole point of this thought experiment.

An other thing : If you're a good son you wont lets your mother die of hunger, since its okay for you to eat a human , you should cut some parts of your body and feed her.

You are an evil dirty human eater.

Again i feel sorry for your mom, What a son, and i'm done!

Wow. So the only reason you're not a cannibal is because you believe you will be judged by god if you commit such a sin? You believe that god's wrath is the ONLY thing that stops you from commiting murder and cannibalism? That's insane.

Hypothetical question then: If you DIDN'T believe in god and knew for a fact that god didn't exist, you would murder and eat people with no remorse whatsoever? If that's true then you're a fucking sociopath my friend. I don't believe in any god, but I don't do things like this because I have my own moral standard, the main moral being "don't do unto others what you wouldn't want done to yourself". I haven't killed or eaten anyone alive by the way, and not because some book written by some ancient scholars told me it was bad - I worked that out on my own  :D

You dont understand son, without religion you will be dead by now , and also you are very stupid or a kid lets me explaine a litle to you:

I will give you a simple example:

Why robbery is bad Prove it?

Please answer this than watch :

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dsLsatOhnvk

You have so much to learn, But i garantee you that without religion lots of people would be looking for you, and your meat will be sold on alphabuy and maybe on amazon.com.

And if you are talking about me than no i will not eat or hurt anyone even if there is no god BUT if i see that everyone is evil than i will make sure to fuck them right and fight for my self.

That video is terrible. The speaker uses fallacies to propagate false truths. Just in the first 3 minutes he tells a member of the audience that he is religious when the guy specifically said he doesn't believe in religion, just a "power". This could be any power, a pantheist idea of perhaps the laws of physics being a "power". That does not equate to a religion. Then he just says "we need to believe in god because he created us". Circular bullshit logic.

You CANNOT prove god through scientific means, that goes against the whole idea of faith and the nature of god. If you could prove god in these means, it would not be a god.

Anyway, the point about robbing is really stupid. Agreed, some people (sociopaths/psychopaths) wouldn't care who they robbed. But most morally sound people (myself included) would say that robbing someone actually would affect me negatively, as I experience something called "empathy". This is the key point that the speaker in your video doesn't incorporate, and it's very important to humans success on this planet.

If I was to do something bad to someone else, I would feel guilt and remorse, as I would empathise with them and their family. I don't need belief in a sky fairy to have empathy to my fellow human. That's why us humans are so succesful on this earth. In fact, atheists tend to be much more tolerant than radical religious people (eg Westboro Baptist Church, Scientologists, radical Islamic terrorists etc.) When was the last time you heard of an "Atheist terrorist attack"?

As for his last point about Hitler and his punishment, that is fucking nonsense. He's basically saying that "Hitler burned [sic] 6m Jews, but just burning him is an unfair punishment, because that's burning 1 person vs 6m. That is why we have Hell, where we burn him once, then give him new skin and burn him again and again for eternity"

That logic is ridiculous. There's no evidence for Hell, and we frequently see good people die and bad people become succesful. If anything, that's a better argument for the non-existence of god, rather than a weak argument for the "usefulness" of hell (which has yet to be proven to exist).

I could just make up a horrible place (let's call it SuperHell) where bad people go when they die and get punished for eternity by the SuperDevil. That explains why bad people get away with bad things, because then they go to the SuperHell for eternal damnation! Lesson, don't do bad things. I made that up, but it's no different from the guy's argument in the video.


Anyway, the moral of the story is, when people are dead, they're dead and it doesn't really matter whether they get eaten or not.
The second observation, my friend bararily, is if the ONLY thing stopping you from robbing, raping and killing your fellow humans for personal gain is the fear of hell and the wrath of god, then that makes you a pretty psychopathic person.

To be clear, I'll ask you again to answer my hypothetical question:

If you DIDN'T believe in god and knew for a fact that god and hell didn't exist, would you murder, rape, rob and even eat people with no remorse whatsoever?

I await your answer, a yes or no would be fine.

#protokol

First thing : You are full of shit.

Now lets me answer you even if i know that talking to an atheist is a real waste of time.

Even if I've already replied to your question (read my recent reply).

Anyways you said "if the ONLY thing stopping you from robbing, raping and killing your fellow humans for personal gain is the fear of hell and the wrath of god, then that makes you a pretty psychopathic person. "

You dont know shit about this world (Funny you will be shocked soon...) Anyways  for me Yes if there is no god i will NEVER lets anyone to be rich and im poor, I will NEVER sleep hungry while you have food, and i will NEVER lets you have anything better than me, Cause use your little mind stupid, IF there is NO god than why the fuck would i lets you be better than me ? Give me one reason ??


it's because i believe in the other life, its okay for you to enjoy this life cause god promised what better inchalluh but for you only hell after you die so enjoy your life being an atheist.

And as i said god is stopping lots of people from hurting/ killing each other.


And funny you dirty human eater:

OK you little bitch, in what way am I full of shit?


Would talking to a satanist or a christian or even a buddhist be a real waste of time too? Learn to respect other peoples points of view you pitiful, indoctrinated fool.


You first said: "I believe in god and its the ONLY reason that stops me and LOTS of believers from doing bad things like eating a human."
Then you said: "no i will not eat or hurt anyone even if there is no god BUT if i see that everyone is evil than i will make sure to fuck them right and fight for my self."

You didn't answer my question of whether you would feel guilt or remorse for your actions. So, how would you feel?


So now you're backtracking to your earlier answer - you WOULD commit immoral crimes if there was no god - You just said you would steal everyone's things that let them be better than you.
I would say that the better person wouldn't steal from his fellow citizens - instead he would work together to make the community a better place.

And I already gave you that ONE REASON why most people don't do this - It's because they feel something called EMPATHY for their fellow humans. After all, I (and the majority of my country) don't believe in any god, and most of us don't go round stealing, raping, murdering or suicide bombing each other - we may not believe in punishment in the afterlife, but we are empathetic towards our fellow humans so we don't try to kill them. It's not fucking rocket surgery mate...


Not the right ones apparently - that's why we have suicide bombers blowing up innocent children, politicians dealing arms to create wars in foreign lands to make money until their 90 years old, and then we have an innocent, kind afghani muslim who followed the teachings of Allah his whole life, whose was killed together with his whole family in a freak IED accident. Some nice guy this god must be, think he needs to try harder with the whole "stopping people killing each other", right?

Here's an interesting quote for you to ponder:


Makes you think, right?


 :D :D So you pulled my reply from the other thread, well done! If you look it up, then you'll find that the "long pig" name is true. I have never actually tried it (yet), so if you could refrain from branding me a "dirty human eater" then that would be great.

And I probably won't bother to answer any more posts of yours, you're boring me now with your shitty logic and badly thought out arguments. Plus I'm starting to lose the buzz from the vodka and energy drink I had earlier and this shit is beginning to bore me.

For your sake I hope we're not together on a plane crash in a deserted area any time soon. And if we are, I hope your survival skills are up to scratch and you ate all of your airline food..............

I'm not going to get into your little argument but rather answer the question.
I wouldn't eat my mother to stay alive just as I wouldn't eat my wife or child. I'd want to live, that's for sure, but I'd rather wait it out and see if maybe tables turn and we get rescued or find something to eat at the last moment, miracles happen. Have you ever seen the movie "The Mist"? If you don't want a spoiler don't read, but the main protagonist decides to commit suicide along with his family in the face of inevitable death by attacking monsters. He kills them first and as he is about to kill himself he gets rescued. I'd rather die than eat my loved ones and then get rescued.

#protokol

EMPATHY like you feel when eating your dead mom ?

It takes a make believe God for you to be a good person? Think about that.....

Well this is one crazy topic but i like it very much :D your assuming that zombie apocalypse just requesting :D but still i would not eat my mother because it really bad if you ate your mother for all i know is i am going to eat my dog or scavenge some food you don't eat human because its againt's the low of the God even if your dying in hunger you don't eat human being you find food or steal food for you to stay alive i would die for scavenging food for my mother so that she can be alive and i would be the one who protects her when she has protected me for i am a baby in the past i would kill for food but not eat human being its really cannibalism man.. i wont eat human if i did i am a animal >.<

Never, because my mom born me here in the world and I will never hurt my mom because since birth she care for me even I'm so importunate she is always there to give me advices, she gets my report card in my school and she always care.

I'd rather prefer myself to die than to do the same thing said on the topic ;D I've never wished for it to happen but it is really awful to eat human especially your mother who gave birth to you . I wonder why you are making a topic like this, is there a catastrophe that going to happen in the near future ? ;D lol

Nope, but there is a thread here on bitcointalk asking people if they can eat a human to stay alive and alots of the answers accepted to eat a human, so i made this topic asking if that human was your mother and as you see not much replies, only one member who said yes i can eat her if she is dead to honor her , he is a very nice son.

This topic is veeerry tricky. Of course if you think about it, the fact that it's someone close to you, your mother in this case, this topic would be pretty much a taboo for most people. But for me it would situational. Of course i wouldn't eat my mother alive. But for example, like in the movie alive, a plane crash. People died. You're in the middle of nowhere and you have very limited supplies. You wouldn't be left with much of choice but to suck it all up and eat the people who died there whoever they are to stay alive. It's not like you're doing it for leisure i mean who would even arrive at such a thought right? But again it's situational at the extreme level.

I don't understand reasons to create such topics. Are you preparing for apocalypse?
We know that in extreme situations people acting by their insticts. I can't imagine what would need to happen that I would eat my mother. As one person already said, I'll better die myself than eat my mother. And I can't understand people who are saying that they would women, who gave him birth.

Maybe if they cooked it really good. Lol. Just kidding.
Who would do such thing. Eating your own mother? That is sick. You should go to mental hospital.
Only mentally sick would do that thing. Also theres a possibility you could get virus and deseases if you eat human's flesh. What the hell? I'd rathered starved to death than eating your own mother. Thats really uncommon and really disgusting.

yeah I know mate and I've already Participated with that topic sorry If I didn't mentioned my mother on my posts but there's nothing to change with what I've said . because it's hell no, if I am not going to earn other human in order to survive how about my mother ? lol ;D even she's already dead I will never ever do it . lol

Assuming there was no food and it was important that I survive to save many people and my mother was dead, I would eat it, No matter how traumatized I was later, if it would save a lot of people I would.

Let's put it this way:

The earth was dominated by aliens and to save the few survivors and the land someone would need to go to the mother ship of the aliens and step on a button that would blow up all the aliens, but this one (in this case I) would be very hungry because there are days that I had not eaten anything, my mother is on my side, she is dead. In that case I would eat her to have strength and complete the mission to save the earth and the people.

But this is no different from the things that rich countries do by invading poor countries to steal their natural resources.

Or what we all do when we kill animals and eat them.

We do a lot of bad things to survive.




This is very beautiful and easy to say, but the reality of the world is completely different:

https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/15/9f/38/159f38150f4f81936eddf4d328b2c559.jpg

https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/236x/99/52/3e/99523e8c02e85dd311e2d7370072afa0.jpg

The fish, the chicken, the ox, the shrimp, the squid, the buffalo, do not have the right to live?

Absolutely not. I would rather buried her than to eat her. Come to think of it that your mother almost died just to gave birth you in order for you to see and experience this world. Then you will eat her for survival even though she is dead? I'd rather died if that happens or find another way to survive. 

Definitely no. Eating a stranger is one thing, and eating someone you know is another. I am not averse to eating a human corpse, in order to stay alive. But eating someone who is known to me is a strict no-no, even if that person is already dead.

Hell no. My mother has been a source of inspiration to me and others. She has been the reason why I am still alive, she has nurtured and cultured me to an enviable position. Thanks to the Almighty also for grace. I can't eat her to stay alive

So its not about staying alive anymore ? it's about who you know, You will eat a human only if you dont know him HAHHAHAHHAHAHAH WHAAAAT!!!

This forum should be a palce for social fucktards experiments. And yeah you are a SICK fuck.

Why the hell would i eat my own mother? Am i that desperate to survive? Even in survival i will not do that thing. I rather eat a mouse than eating human's flesh. Whats the matter with you people? Are you struggling financialy? Thats a stupid things people should not do. But i wonder what is the taste of human's flesh like? Anyway, i know a person who really do that. He is mentally sick. He smash his mother in the head with a hammer and it burst her brains out. He ate the brain of her mother. Its sounds like movie doesn't it? Yes, its really true.

I don't know if you're trying to act stupid or a re you really are. "You will eat a human only if you dont know him", well yes, someone elses body doesn't mean anything to me, just another stranger among the 7bil people on this planet, why should I care about them? So ofcourse the body of someone I know and is close to me and the body of someone who is a complete stranger isnt the same.

I have a feeling that all these threads are full of fake morale people, hippies and the ones that human is just another animal.

No, because mother is the one who has brought me into this world .I would rather die of poverty than eating my mother. Its so sick that people will think about eating their mother alive just to stay alive.

I'll never Eat my mother in order to survive even she is already dead, I would rather eat any food that I hate than to eat my mother or any human ;D lol if there are no other to eat maybe I'll Go kill myself just to end the suffering of starvation .

I'm surprised by the number of people saying they would rather die of starvation than eat their dead mother/another dead person.

I totally understand that it wouldn't be a very pleasant thing to do, but sometimes in survival situations you have to make difficult decisions in order to stay alive.

I reckon a lot of people here would change their mind if they found themselves in a life or death situation with no other options.

It's similar to when mountain climbers hack off their own arm or leg to escape - most people could never bring themselves to do such a thing, but when your life is on the line people prioritise things differently.

The survival instinct of humans is very strong, but we don't see that side of people very often because we've made the modern world so safe and friendly.

What kind of question is this ??? after the forum "Would you eat a human?" Now there is "Would you eat your mother alive?". Absolutely unbelievable contemporary man actually had a strange thought. To eat the flesh of men I would never, How could I eat the flesh of my own mother ?? Live or die, I will never eat the flesh of my mother, now a lot of questions that made me queasy. The world is already funny. What kind of a crazy question that will appear ??

I see it as a thought experiment, a hypothetical scenario which will probably never happen, but it is interesting to debate nonetheless.

Have a read of this article, an interview with a guy who was in a plane crash and managed to survive on the side of a mountain, in part by eating the flesh of some of the victims.

http://news.nationalgeographic.com/2016/04/160403-andes-uruguay-rugby-cannibal-plane-crash-canessa-ngbooktalk/ (http://news.nationalgeographic.com/2016/04/160403-andes-uruguay-rugby-cannibal-plane-crash-canessa-ngbooktalk/)


I think that last part is beautiful - what seems initially like a grotesque act, becomes a statement of peace and love to humanity, giving life to friends who would otherwise have died.

I also do not understand what the purpose of this topic ?? This topic is very disgusting, disturbing thoughts. Perhaps indeed if in a state of urgency, in a state in order to survive, humanity will use instinct, and I'm sure the human animal will not get to eat their own mothers. Mother is the one who most love us, the most valuable. Would not be able to eat it. I prefer to die rather than eat my mother, and this is not bullshit.

no no no.Why people making such kind of post/topic?

The OP is a religious loony, who created this BS thread to counter the following topic:

https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1315922.0

Religious loonies are incapable of rational thinking. They don't understand the difference between eating a dead body as a last resort to survive, and eating someone just because of mental illness.