Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Development & Technical Discussion => Topic started by: deepceleron on April 12, 2013, 10:35:12 PM



Title: Payment confirming too fast
Post by: deepceleron on April 12, 2013, 10:35:12 PM
I just sent .0004 BTC with a .0001 fee to myself, and it has two confirmations within three minutes of hitting send. WTF is going on here?

8e3117b84468efdb06a76d9cf0d42f39de0bdf4317c2b378510caadf6345ec7a (https://blockchain.info/tx/8e3117b84468efdb06a76d9cf0d42f39de0bdf4317c2b378510caadf6345ec7a)

Just a counterpoint to the "blah blah blockchain.info didn't pay fee why no confirm" threads. Use your own Bitcoin-qt and include a bare minimum fee and you'll probably not wait much.

(same transaction 2 weeks ago, 15 blocks before inclusion though...)


Title: Re: Payment confirming too fast
Post by: deepceleron on April 13, 2013, 03:11:24 AM
The block after your transaction was mined within the same minute. Sometimes miners get lucky and multiple blocks get mined in close proximity.

Thanks for the clarification. :P

Maybe you find interesting - the chances of that second block being found in 23 seconds or less is about 4%, higher than intuition may lead you to believe:

0:06.31  1.04620%
0:13.28  2.18970%
0:20.99  3.43810%
0:29.51  4.79926%
0:38.92  6.28127%
0:49.32  7.89232%
1:00.82  9.64061%
1:13.53 11.53420%
1:27.57 13.58080%
1:43.09 15.78761%
2:00.25 18.16103%
2:19.20 20.70631%
2:40.15 23.42731%
3:03.31 26.32598%
3:28.90 29.40204%
3:57.18 32.65242%
4:28.43 36.07085%
5:02.98 39.64731%
5:41.15 43.36763%
6:23.34 47.21302%
7:09.97 51.15983%


What is less likely is a transaction with only 0.0001 fee being included in the next block - based on blockspace competition with other fee-paying transactions, that could have taken a long time. Miners like me today.