Bitcoin Forum

Other => Beginners & Help => Topic started by: crypto serina on March 14, 2017, 05:20:52 AM



Title: About transaction fees.
Post by: crypto serina on March 14, 2017, 05:20:52 AM
How much will transaction fees eventually be?


Title: Re: About transaction fees.
Post by: pooya87 on March 14, 2017, 08:04:32 AM
transaction fees will be calculated based on the following factors:
1) size of your transaction in bytes.
if you have lots of inputs (meaning you have received a lot of payments in one address) you will end up having a big transaction size when spending it and pay more fees.

2) block reward and mining cost and price [his is an argument for a very far future.]
one of the reason for transaction fees is to compensate for mining cost. which means when block reward goes down after a couple of more halvings miners can only earn money by receiving the transaction fees.
also amount of fees is set based on price. for example when price was $1 fees were 0.001-0.01BTC and when it is $100,000 it obviously goes down to math the price.

3) how full is the memory pool! [this one is new and hopefully temporary]
since blocks are full and only a limited number of transactions can be included in one block, obviously some transactions won't "fit in" so miners pick whoever pays a higher fee and that is why fees are rising now.

i hope this answers your question.


Title: Re: About transaction fees.
Post by: exabb on March 14, 2017, 08:33:26 PM

3) how full is the memory pool! [this one is new and hopefully temporary]
since blocks are full and only a limited number of transactions can be included in one block, obviously some transactions won't "fit in" so miners pick whoever pays a higher fee and that is why fees are rising now.


How do miners pick the transactions. Is it by actually looking at it on a computer and clicking yes or no, or is it done automatically by an algorithm

Regards
John


Title: Re: About transaction fees.
Post by: DannyHamilton on March 14, 2017, 10:02:59 PM
How do miners pick the transactions. Is it by actually looking at it on a computer and clicking yes or no, or is it done automatically by an algorithm

It is typically done automatically by an algorithm, but some of the mining pools do allow certain users to pick specific transactions to add if they want to.

It really is up to the mining pool (or solo miner) how they want to choose the transactions for their block.. They can use a standard algorithm, they can write their own algorithm, they can pick one at a time themselves. There are no rules in the protocol about how miners (and pools) choose transactions to confirm.  As long as the transaction is valid, they can pick it if they want to.


Title: Re: About transaction fees.
Post by: dawnasor on March 14, 2017, 11:24:46 PM
How much will transaction fees eventually be?
For me the higher the better to avoid stuck transactions in the Blockchain.
You can use this website to know what is the proper fee for every transaction :  https://bitcoinfees.21.co/#fees


Title: Re: About transaction fees.
Post by: xIIImaL on March 15, 2017, 03:09:06 AM
How much will transaction fees eventually be?

Each and every wallet site contributors have the minimum level of transaction amount for bitcoins. Simply to say you cannot send the little satoshis. By default wallet has minimum amount of fee and its enough to get transferred the bitcoin to one to another wallet. Normally it takes 2 or 4 confirmations to complete one transaction.


Title: Re: About transaction fees.
Post by: U2 on March 15, 2017, 03:15:33 AM
How do miners pick the transactions. Is it by actually looking at it on a computer and clicking yes or no, or is it done automatically by an algorithm

It is typically done automatically by an algorithm, but some of the mining pools do allow certain users to pick specific transactions to add if they want to.

It really is up to the mining pool (or solo miner) how they want to choose the transactions for their block.. They can use a standard algorithm, they can write their own algorithm, they can pick one at a time themselves. There are no rules in the protocol about how miners (and pools) choose transactions to confirm.  As long as the transaction is valid, they can pick it if they want to.

Most will set a priority to higher fees though of course. If you're sending 10 Satoshis/byte they'll have to have a written letter from you explaining why you need the money for your dying aunt or something lol. All I've heard and seen from pools is higher fees are accepted over lower, but yes in the protocol level they could technically accept whatever tx's based on nothing.


Title: Re: About transaction fees.
Post by: crypto serina on March 15, 2017, 08:29:48 AM
Okay, i appreciate your answer.


Title: Re: About transaction fees.
Post by: fuckitall on March 18, 2017, 03:30:36 PM
it depends on several factors like :

1. SIZE OF YOUR TRANSACTION
2. BLOCK REWARD
3. TRANSACTION FEES


Title: Re: About transaction fees.
Post by: barota on March 19, 2017, 07:01:28 PM
transaction fees btc 0.0003btc
this is large amount


Title: Re: About transaction fees.
Post by: bohr on March 20, 2017, 05:23:47 PM
How much will transaction fees eventually be?
That is difficult to know, the concept of supply and demand applies here, demand is high but supply is limited, so the fees go higher and that is exactly what happened, there are some proposed solutions to try to remedy that, but we are in the middle of a political debate about which one is better.


Title: Re: About transaction fees.
Post by: kolloh on March 20, 2017, 05:54:01 PM
How much will transaction fees eventually be?
That is difficult to know, the concept of supply and demand applies here, demand is high but supply is limited, so the fees go higher and that is exactly what happened, there are some proposed solutions to try to remedy that, but we are in the middle of a political debate about which one is better.

Yeah, I really hope we can find a good solution to lower bitcoin fees without causing any negative consequences to Bitcoin.


Title: Re: About transaction fees.
Post by: Janation on March 21, 2017, 12:12:03 PM
As far as I know, every sites has their own transaction fees and these days it is getting larger and larger making it a pain for users. The higher the fee, the faster the transaction will be.


Title: Re: About transaction fees.
Post by: NewRanger on March 21, 2017, 04:46:29 PM
hi sir i have some question
how many fee require to fast confirm my transaction ?
because i get 1 confirm in next hours

thanks sir if you answer my question  :)


Title: Re: About transaction fees.
Post by: BTCmax24 on March 22, 2017, 12:31:05 PM
How much will transaction fees eventually be?

Each and every wallet site contributors have the minimum level of transaction amount for bitcoins. Simply to say you cannot send the little satoshis. By default wallet has minimum amount of fee and its enough to get transferred the bitcoin to one to another wallet. Normally it takes 2 or 4 confirmations to complete one transaction.

Yes sir and you may adjust your wallet settings for its fee according to its priority level for quick confirmation the quickest you want the more higher fee


Title: Re: About transaction fees.
Post by: faisalrambo on March 22, 2017, 12:46:14 PM
0.0001BTC ~ NORMAL FEES.
NOW THE FEE IS SO HIGH DUE TO HARD FORKING  AND  BITCOIN PRICE


Title: Re: About transaction fees.
Post by: Jodee_r on March 22, 2017, 02:17:13 PM
What is a current transaction fee for Bitcoin network?


Title: Re: About transaction fees.
Post by: bobita on March 22, 2017, 03:14:10 PM
So high fee=fast transfer
Is it correct?


Title: Re: About transaction fees.
Post by: Frosxh on March 22, 2017, 04:03:11 PM
So high fee=fast transfer
Is it correct?

transfer is instant, confirmation isn't. if you mean confirmation then the answer is yes, if you paid the miners high enough fee they will include your transaction in the next block tho the next block could be in a minute up to 1 hour so you still have to wait a little bit


Title: Re: About transaction fees.
Post by: TravelMug on March 22, 2017, 09:38:13 PM
So high fee=fast transfer
Is it correct?

transfer is instant, confirmation isn't. if you mean confirmation then the answer is yes, if you paid the miners high enough fee they will include your transaction in the next block tho the next block could be in a minute up to 1 hour so you still have to wait a little bit

Exactly. This is want I experience from my bitcoin core to my local exchange was an instant when I increased the miners fee. I was quite surprised though, in minutes I got my bitcoin and I was looking at the blockchain and saw in confirm already. Check my local wallet then and exchange it to my local currency smooth and flawless.


Title: Re: About transaction fees.
Post by: hoian0809 on March 23, 2017, 12:10:11 AM
There are no mandatory fees. You should be able to set the fee to any value you want. The main effect of the fee is in how fast the transaction makes it into the block chain. If the network is really busy, you may need a higher fee to get your transaction in. I don't recommend a 0 fee, but pay something at a minimum if you're not in a rush to make the transaction.


Title: Re: About transaction fees.
Post by: bobita on March 23, 2017, 08:15:10 AM
So high fee=fast transfer
Is it correct?

transfer is instant, confirmation isn't. if you mean confirmation then the answer is yes, if you paid the miners high enough fee they will include your transaction in the next block tho the next block could be in a minute up to 1 hour so you still have to wait a little bit
I get it now...Thx for your answer


Title: Re: About transaction fees.
Post by: crypto serina on March 23, 2017, 11:22:54 AM
okey, thank you for suggestion.