Bitcoin Forum

Economy => Economics => Topic started by: Hydrogen on June 18, 2017, 01:02:31 AM



Title: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: Hydrogen on June 18, 2017, 01:02:31 AM
Quote
A new bill seeks to track your money and assets incessantly, will enjoin any business with government ties to act as a de facto arm of DHS, and would steal all of your assets — including Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies — should you fail to report funds when traveling with over $10,000.

Under the guise of combating money laundering, Senate Bill 1241, “Combating Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing, and Counterfeiting Act of 2017,” ramps up regulation of digital currency and other autocratic financial controls in an attempt to ensure none of your assets can escape one of the State’s most nefarious, despised powers: civil asset forfeiture.

All of this under the farcically broad umbrella of fighting terrorism.

Civil forfeiture grants the government robbery writ large: your cash, property, and assets can be stolen completely sans due process, your guilt — frequently pertaining to drug ‘crimes’ — matters not.

A court verdict of not guilty doesn’t even guarantee the return of State-thefted property.

In fact, the government can seize virtually whatever it wants if it so much as suspects some of your assets might have been acquired through or used in the commission of even lesser crimes.

For some time, a war on cash has been brewing behind the closed doors of government, and — although officials prefer to claim counterfeiting, terrorism, and money laundering as the impetus for asset tracking — in actuality, physical currency facilitates black market and untaxed transactions, and, most imperatively to the U.S., cannot be thefted under civil asset forfeiture laws as easily as money exchanged digitally.

Characterized as an effort to “to improve the prohibitions on money laundering, and for other purposes,” the bill severely curtails the right to travel freely, without undue hindrance, as travelers with more than $10,000 in assets — including those held digitally, like Bitcoin — must file a report with the U.S. government.

Noncompliance with the tyrannical law — including failing to fill out the aforementioned form — would incur penalties befitting a fascist dictatorship: an individual could find the entirety of their assets seized, not just those unreported, and could be locked in a prison cage for up to ten years.

To be clear, the State wants to write a permission slip to seize all of your assets — bank accounts, including, specifically, “safety deposit boxes,” prepaid cards, gift cards, prepaid phones, prepaid coupons, cryptocurrencies, all of it — even for being remiss in reporting what you’re traveling with.

Considering one’s digital assets veritably follow wherever that travel takes them, a cryptocurrency portfolio would theoretically have to be reported each time that person travels outside the confines of the U.S.

Of course, the legislation in actuality just amends laws pertaining to assets and travel already considered dictatorial — right now, failure to fill out the form carries not just the penalty of seizure, but a sentence of up to five years behind bars.

“And if that weren’t enough, this bill also gives them with new authority to engage in surveillance and wiretapping (including phone, email, etc.) if they have even a hint of suspicion that you might be transporting excess ‘monetary instruments,’” Simon Black of SovereignMan.com reports.

“Usually wiretapping authority is reserved for major crimes like kidnapping, human trafficking, felony fraud, etc.

“Now we can add cash to that list.”

But it wouldn’t just be the government hawkishly surveilling your every transaction, as, essentially, all retailers would be roped into becoming State spies — any business selling gift or prepaid cards would be required to report those, too.

Worse — and in defiance of current structures pertaining to digital currency — the government wishes to somehow require issuers of cryptocurrencies into its abhorrent, ostensive money-laundering police spy ring.

According to the legislation, reports Smaulgold.com, the Secretary of Homeland Security and the Commissioner of U.S. Customs and Border Protection must, within 18 months of the legislation’s passage, devise a “border protection strategy to interdict and detect prepaid access devices, digital currencies, or other similar instruments, at border crossings and other ports of entry for the United States, including an assessment of infrastructure needed [emphasis added] to carry out the strategy […]

“The obligation to declare amounts in any form over $10,000 exists, irrespective of whether custom officials have a way of detecting such holdings. Since digital currencies technically travel with the holder [wherever] the holder goes, one would have to declare one’s entire crypto portfolio each time the holder entered the U.S.”

Travelers possessing assets, precious metals, and accounts in excess of $10,000 held outside the United States, however, would not be required to declare those to the government — perhaps leaving an albeit sketchy option for those wary of unscrupulous authorities.

While the government insists ‘If you’ve got nothing to hide, you’ve got nothing to fear,’ the Combating Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing, and Counterfeiting Act of 2017 proves you might not be able to hide anything from its greedy clutches — and if you try, you could wind up thrown in a cage for a decade, penniless upon release.

Welcome to America, where your assets are literally the government’s business, and freedom is anything but free.

http://www.anonews.co/senate-bill-cash/

Your tax dollars @ work.

Wouldn't it be nice if tax dollars went towards bettering society rather than propping up the corrupt, dysfunctional, standards of elites.

Paypal, police, DEA and others already confiscate money without just cause. This bill would give the state the power to confiscate any crypto for no reason whatsoever and imprison those who didn't report their crypto holdings so that the state could steal it.



Title: Re: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: btcney on June 18, 2017, 03:13:28 AM
Of course, it's not unexpected at all.

Government always want more power. They want to have full control over people's wealth, and to do that they can't just say give me all your money, salary, wages and i'll redistribute it. Then they'll be accused of being communists. The subtle way is to obviously do this by tracking people's wealth, make sure that nothing is out of their sight, and make sure that everyone stays within limits, or they get a knock on their door.

Unfortunately, this is how it is. But storing your wealth in crypto will ensure that you don't get tracked, or at least as easily as cash. AGCs are a huge problem though, a lot of them are indeed being used for money laundering. But there is really no need for the gvmt to chip in on this issue, it's amazon's problem.


Title: Re: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: davis196 on June 18, 2017, 06:20:28 AM
Of course, it's not unexpected at all.

Government always want more power. They want to have full control over people's wealth, and to do that they can't just say give me all your money, salary, wages and i'll redistribute it. Then they'll be accused of being communists. The subtle way is to obviously do this by tracking people's wealth, make sure that nothing is out of their sight, and make sure that everyone stays within limits, or they get a knock on their door.

Unfortunately, this is how it is. But storing your wealth in crypto will ensure that you don't get tracked, or at least as easily as cash. AGCs are a huge problem though, a lot of them are indeed being used for money laundering. But there is really no need for the gvmt to chip in on this issue, it's amazon's problem.

By AGCs  you mean Amazon gift cards,right?
Amazon and all the big retailers should remove those gift cards(unfortunately this will destroy the btc/gift cards market  ;D ).They are more popular than cryptos,when it comes to scams and money laundering.
Anyway,the government has good intentions,but this is not the right way to fight money laundering and criminals.
I thought that the republicans and Trump`s administration are bitcoin friendly  :( .


Title: Re: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: bitcoinvestor on June 18, 2017, 06:48:14 AM
Congratulation to the regulation. What do you think? Many government will not loose their control over citizens properties. In fact, there are many government officers involved in corruption scandal. ( I don't say US govt) but some govt. That's too bad in the digital world. Will this regulation withstand against the growth of acceptance of cryptocurrency worldwide? I am not sure.


Title: Re: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: iamTom123 on June 18, 2017, 07:40:27 AM
Right now, there seems to be a jerk reactions from the government on matters of crime and terrorism. While it is true that Bitcoin or nay cryptocurrency for that matter can be utilized for terrorism activities we should also realize that any form of money or fiat money can be used for the same purpose.

While I personally agree that we have to address the terrorism head on we should do it without getting a heavy collateral damage on the freedom and liberty of the ordinary citizens. Without getting into a certain balance, the solutions can result into more problems.

There are no easy answers for problems affecting our society for now but we should always think many times if the supposed answers we are offering will not kill a blossoming industry.


Title: Re: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: eaLiTy on June 18, 2017, 08:13:18 AM
Quote
While the government insists ‘If you’ve got nothing to hide, you’ve got nothing to fear,’ the Combating Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing, and Counterfeiting Act of 2017 proves you might not be able to hide anything from its greedy clutches — and if you try, you could wind up thrown in a cage for a decade, penniless upon release.
Yet another way to counter people holding their assets in crypto currency ,i would like to know one thing are the politicians financial details in the public domain,to be frank they need to be some transparency on that before the government elected by the people impose these kind of silly rules in the name of countering terrorism.Privacy is just a dream in this day and age.


Title: Re: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: freebutcaged on June 18, 2017, 10:29:35 AM
They were either asleep this whole time and or are just completely retarded, so many years crypto exist and only now that price went up

They remembered to control the movement of digital currencies? how could they possibly do that while services such as Bitmixer are active?

When people say there is no way to keep track of the coins after they have gone through a mixing process it's because there is no way.

Just ignore the governments when it comes to tax and crypto and rest assured that you are %100 safe and undetected if you are using a mixer.


Title: Re: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: arpon11 on June 18, 2017, 05:40:55 PM
Bitcoin has alot of enemies from the beginning but it has conquered them. Hope this bill will be thrown into dust bin. Most of the American elites who has they assets in billions of dollars has be fighting bitcoin from inception because they know bitcoin was invented to help the poor in the society especially The third world countries.


Title: Re: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: Yakamoto on June 18, 2017, 05:49:26 PM
You seem to make a lot of these threads, don't you Hydrogen? Or is it someone else with the same signature. Doesn't really matter to me either way.

I'm still confused as to why they go after prepaid sources of money, though. I guess you could re-sell them for cash since they provide value for owners of the cards, but it doesn't really make sense as to why they care about them so much. It's not like a terrorist is going to be able to buy a kalashnikov with a wal-mart gift card (although they might be able to if the demand is there).

The US government does enough already. I don't know why they bother with petty shit like this.


Title: Re: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: freeyourmind on June 18, 2017, 07:05:44 PM

Your tax dollars @ work.

Wouldn't it be nice if tax dollars went towards bettering society rather than propping up the corrupt, dysfunctional, standards of elites.

Paypal, police, DEA and others already confiscate money without just cause. This bill would give the state the power to confiscate any crypto for no reason whatsoever and imprison those who didn't report their crypto holdings so that the state could steal it.


It will only change once either the elites give up their power, or when a manipulated population rises up, unites and stops contributing to this system.  But it will not happen with a divided population as it is now.  We likely have a ways to go before that point, if ever.  But yes, it would be great if taxes one day went to improving society.



Title: Re: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: Rader on June 18, 2017, 07:31:42 PM
That is good for bitcoin, now the people will select between dollar or btc. Time to make your bets ;)


Title: Re: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: buwaytress on June 18, 2017, 07:53:10 PM
I'd really like to know how the US government plans to follow up their intention to "seize" cryptocurrency. Crack the private keys from their citizen's wallets? And how would they propose to utilise these seized assets? Exchange it for their USD?


Title: Re: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: Hydrogen on June 19, 2017, 02:57:43 AM
I'm still confused as to why they go after prepaid sources of money, though. I guess you could re-sell them for cash since they provide value for owners of the cards, but it doesn't really make sense as to why they care about them so much. It's not like a terrorist is going to be able to buy a kalashnikov with a wal-mart gift card (although they might be able to if the demand is there).

I view this as banks flexing their politicial influence to attack business competitors as a means of achieving a bank monopoly over currency exchange.

If ford, chrysler and GM influenced the UN into confiscating cars made by toyota, nissan, acura, honda, suzuki & other foreign automakers to give themselves a monopoly over the domestic vehicle market, that could represent a similar precedent.

State authorities should require probable cause to confiscate money which represent peoples livelihood. There should be a form of paper trail, a system of checks and balances to ensure the power to confiscate currency isn't abused.


Title: Re: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: olubams on June 19, 2017, 04:33:55 AM
I am not seeing this as anything anti- bitcoin in any way because what they are doing is just exploiting the loophole which some people have given them the opportunity to exploit despite the fact that they have not even foxed their own issues politically. At the same time, I see this as a way for slowing down the growth of bitcoin but they cannot stop it unless they have the key to destroy everything all together which is something very difficult to achieve. When a group of people make a resolution to pursue a course if action, nothing is stopping them.


Title: Re: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: sana54210 on June 20, 2017, 10:31:51 AM
This is something which was not so unexpected. The government will try to ensure that it gathers the taxes and the tax dollars contribute to the development of the country. However, there has to be adequate measures to ensure that it does not go in the pockets of the corrupts eventually.


Title: Re: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: dillpicklechips on June 30, 2017, 09:26:18 AM
Right now, there seems to be a jerk reactions from the government on matters of crime and terrorism. While it is true that Bitcoin or nay cryptocurrency for that matter can be utilized for terrorism activities we should also realize that any form of money or fiat money can be used for the same purpose.

While I personally agree that we have to address the terrorism head on we should do it without getting a heavy collateral damage on the freedom and liberty of the ordinary citizens. Without getting into a certain balance, the solutions can result into more problems.

There are no easy answers for problems affecting our society for now but we should always think many times if the supposed answers we are offering will not kill a blossoming industry.

You have a massive point there. Let's say the government has a good intention behind this but we should think of a way that will not kill this blossoming industry. I believe that there are ways that the government can do which will not require resorting to this. Hoping for them to be more open minded regarding this matter so they will see other viable options awaiting to be pulled out.

Meanwhile in Japan, it's spreading and making a really good use to it.


I have known this topic through this: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1992072.0

There is already a thread on this.

https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1972056.msg19623419

I don't understand why good threads on forums are ignored while the generic and pointless threads reach 50+ pages.

It seems like an industry standard.

Also has a point.


Title: Re: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: Hydrogen on July 01, 2017, 07:07:59 PM
I haven't seen any updates on this. Senate Bill 1241, upon which this is based, must be anti-constitutional to some degree. I have to look up what the constitution says on lawful search and seizure.

Hopefully someone is organizing a petition / raising awareness on this.


Title: Re: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: olushakes on July 01, 2017, 07:37:05 PM
I'd really like to know how the US government plans to follow up their intention to "seize" cryptocurrency. Crack the private keys from their citizen's wallets? And how would they propose to utilise these seized assets? Exchange it for their USD?

I guess what they will want to encourage is voluntary disclosure and those threats are what will follow eventually when they found out.  Seizing assets does not necessarily means they would convert it the moment they can use it to get conviction, they can also conitue using it for more caldenstine operations and off the books missions. So, the possibilities are endless in using it.


Title: Re: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: Qartersa on July 01, 2017, 07:47:32 PM
It's still a bill and is still up for review. If it is logical then it may be approved but looking at it, it could be damaging to the public and might be revised. A law needs to be fair to every party and should not be confiscatory in nature. I guess regulation is expected and inevitable. Being decentralized, a feature of most crypto, doesn't mean it will be immune to regulation of the state where the user belongs to.


Title: Re: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: pixie85 on July 01, 2017, 08:24:19 PM
It's still a bill and is still up for review. If it is logical then it may be approved but looking at it, it could be damaging to the public and might be revised. A law needs to be fair to every party and should not be confiscatory in nature. I guess regulation is expected and inevitable. Being decentralized, a feature of most crypto, doesn't mean it will be immune to regulation of the state where the user belongs to.
This is a very important point.
Also even if it passes, they will still have to find a way to track your coins which is almost impossible and no software will help them do it. The only way for them to get your coins is if you give them away yourself. Good they still can't torture you to make you spill the passphrase ;D


Title: Re: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: Xavofat on July 02, 2017, 08:12:21 AM
That is good for bitcoin, now the people will select between dollar or btc. Time to make your bets ;)
No, it's extremely bad for Bitcoin, because it implies that they're trying to prevent people from travelling with too much of it.

Solution:

1.  Buy a TREZOR.
2.  Create a load of hidden wallets behind additional passphrases.
3.  When they look at it, they won't see that you're travelling with >$10,000.


Title: Re: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: Yuuto on July 02, 2017, 09:42:44 AM
Solution:

1.  Buy a TREZOR.
2.  Create a load of hidden wallets behind additional passphrases.
3.  When they look at it, they won't see that you're travelling with >$10,000.

That's not wise, because technically you'd still be travelling with $10000 and no matter how many addresses you create, there might still be a way for the government to detect that you have this much and potentially fine you for not declaring or even confiscate your coins.

The easy solution is to get a 2-2 multisig wallet. Have one redemption/private key as one of your addreses', and the other as one of your family member's or trusted friend's addreses. Don't tell him/her your private key because they can take your coin with ease if thats the case. And when you go to the US, if you need access to coins, you just give them a call and they give you the private key, and you can access your coins. You never really owned the coins this way. Or you could use Chipmixer's new service, but it's based on the same concept.

The new laws are definitely going to negatively impact bitcoin. Though i don't see how it can be enforced. Warpwallets(basically a more secure version of brainwallets) is virtually indetectable.


Title: Re: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: Hydrogen on July 02, 2017, 05:53:52 PM
http://i63.tinypic.com/16bkdx4.jpg

If nothing else, the search and seizure part of this bill which claims the government has the authority to confiscate crypto without due process has to be anti-constitutional.

I would have to think it won't pass on that basis alone.

The problem is the patriot act and other legislature have eroded the 4th amendment and set a bad legal precedent for laws ignoring it.


Title: Re: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: Kyraishi on July 03, 2017, 03:12:39 AM
http://i63.tinypic.com/16bkdx4.jpg

If nothing else, the search and seizure part of this bill which claims the government has the authority to confiscate crypto without due process has to be anti-constitutional.

I would have to think it won't pass on that basis alone.

The problem is the patriot act and other legislature have eroded the 4th amendment and set a bad legal precedent for laws ignoring it.

The amendments are going to be twisted, because they're not searching in houses for bitcoins but rather for anyone travelling with bitcoins in their laptops. So they'll probably say it's just to strengthen the border control etc.

In the past, laws that outlaw gold holdings has been implemented. So don't expect everything to be done the way it should be, the president can sign an executive order much like the last one(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Order_6102) that said you can't hold private gold.

Though the law also targets gift cards, which is a very important revenue source for big corporations, making me think that the bill probably won't get passed.


Title: Re: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: Hydrogen on July 13, 2017, 07:02:38 PM
As far as I can tell, this senate bill 1241 news release was the cause of the last big price drop.

News release was on june 14th, right around the timeline of the last big decline.

http://i63.tinypic.com/16bkdx4.jpg

If nothing else, the search and seizure part of this bill which claims the government has the authority to confiscate crypto without due process has to be anti-constitutional.

I would have to think it won't pass on that basis alone.

The problem is the patriot act and other legislature have eroded the 4th amendment and set a bad legal precedent for laws ignoring it.

The amendments are going to be twisted, because they're not searching in houses for bitcoins but rather for anyone travelling with bitcoins in their laptops. So they'll probably say it's just to strengthen the border control etc.

In the past, laws that outlaw gold holdings has been implemented. So don't expect everything to be done the way it should be, the president can sign an executive order much like the last one(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Order_6102) that said you can't hold private gold.

Though the law also targets gift cards, which is a very important revenue source for big corporations, making me think that the bill probably won't get passed.

The amendment doesn't exclusively specify "in-house" searches.

That's a good point on gold holdings/gold standard, btw.


Title: Re: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: Kaller on July 13, 2017, 07:54:22 PM
This is quite funny considering just yesterday some guy held up a "Buy BTCitcoin" sign behind Janet Yellen (current Chair of the Federal Reserve) on live television. He was later escorted out of the courtroom (where she was giving her testimony) and his friend shared a pic of him and his Bitcoin address on social media.

So far he has received almost five Bitcoins in donations. xD


Title: Re: Anti bitcoin/crypto/gift card/redeemable legislature bill proposed in senate
Post by: CarrieBGage on September 22, 2017, 03:26:23 PM
We should also recognize that any form of money or small money can be used for the same purpose. Just ignore the government when talking about taxes and codes and rest assured that you are 100% safe and undetected if you are using a mixer. But it will not happen to the population divided as The current. We may have a way to go before that time, if ever. But yes, it would be great if one day tax was to improve society