Bitcoin Forum

Other => Beginners & Help => Topic started by: bitcoindude80 on May 07, 2013, 04:52:42 AM



Title: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: bitcoindude80 on May 07, 2013, 04:52:42 AM
Hi all,

I'm building my first rig with 4 x Sapphire AMD Radeon HD 7970 3GB GDDR5 OC.

Do I  need to use the riser cable with or without power?

Thanks for your feedback!


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: AzureEngineer on May 07, 2013, 04:55:24 AM
Depends how many GPUs your motherboard is designed to handle. Most boards aren't designed with more than two GPUs in mind. Powered risers are your safest bet regardless.


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: bitcoindude80 on May 07, 2013, 05:12:13 AM
I have this motherboard = GIGABYTE GA-990FXA-UD5


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: AzureEngineer on May 07, 2013, 05:16:33 AM
I have this motherboard = GIGABYTE GA-990FXA-UD5

Quote
3way AMD CrossFireX and SLI multi-graphics support

You will need a powered riser for at least the fourth card, I would suggest at least two just to be safe, though. 7970's are power hungry.


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: bitcoindude80 on May 07, 2013, 05:22:13 AM
Thanks for the feedback AzureEngineer!!


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: AzureEngineer on May 07, 2013, 05:26:04 AM
Thanks for the feedback AzureEngineer!!

 ;D


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: kirchhoff on May 07, 2013, 05:30:45 AM
Anyone have a link for a good powered riser?


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: AzureEngineer on May 07, 2013, 05:36:00 AM
Anyone have a link for a good powered riser?

www.cablesaurus.com

www.buyahash.com


I have an order with Cablesaurus (they still have not been delivered) I ordered about a week and a half ago.

The Owner of BuyAHash responded to me on Reddit:

http://www.reddit.com/r/litecoin/comments/1dlpfs/cheap_and_easy_risers/c9syqb8?context=3



Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: marvel212 on May 07, 2013, 06:13:16 AM
why not use a riser and use power adapter instead?  Much cheaper route I think


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: CynosureEPR on May 07, 2013, 06:15:22 AM
Anyone have a link for a good powered riser?

I got an order of 5 off of E-Bay (from Hong Kong, though, so be prepared to wait) in a single listing for ~$25.

They shipped out the day I ordered along with tracking.


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: Cryptocables on May 08, 2013, 09:03:23 AM
I'd like to tack onto this thread!

I also offer both types powered risers at Cryptocables.com (http://Cryptocables.com) if anyone is looking for any! I am based in the US, and have flat rate shipping domestically and internationally. Additionally, I also include free Pop Rocks candy with every order :o)

If you have any questions please don't hesitate to contact me!



Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: bitcoindude80 on May 09, 2013, 03:28:29 AM
Can i use all x16 by x16 riser cable for all slots? because the there is one x4 and one x8 and two x16.



Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: astralvoid on May 09, 2013, 03:35:54 AM
I think you can use 1x to 16x cables for all cards.  At least I've seen many rigs with this setup. someone please tell me if I'm wrong because I ordered a 10x lot of 1x to 16x cables.



Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: Sophokles on May 09, 2013, 06:48:45 AM
I think you can use 1x to 16x cables for all cards.  At least I've seen many rigs with this setup. someone please tell me if I'm wrong because I ordered a 10x lot of 1x to 16x cables.



1x to x16 cables are fine for all cards



Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: Sophokles on May 09, 2013, 06:56:02 AM
I have this motherboard = GIGABYTE GA-990FXA-UD5

Quote
3way AMD CrossFireX and SLI multi-graphics support

You will need a powered riser for at least the fourth card, I would suggest at least two just to be safe, though. 7970's are power hungry.

Actually, I have the exactly the same setup (mobo and cards) running with 4 cards, without powered risers. Has been running stable for weeks (mining litecoin), no problem so far. I have just mailed Gigabyte customer support if its ok to plug in a fifth card... We keep you posted about the results, hehe.


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: bitcoindude80 on May 09, 2013, 09:07:50 AM
I have this motherboard = GIGABYTE GA-990FXA-UD5

Quote
3way AMD CrossFireX and SLI multi-graphics support

You will need a powered riser for at least the fourth card, I would suggest at least two just to be safe, though. 7970's are power hungry.

Actually, I have the exactly the same setup (mobo and cards) running with 4 cards, without powered risers. Has been running stable for weeks (mining litecoin), no problem so far. I have just mailed Gigabyte customer support if its ok to plug in a fifth card... We keep you posted about the results, hehe.

Do you have a picture to share with all of us :)

With 4 cards do you have to do any kind of special configuration? or just plug it into the motherboard with the riser cable?

What OS are you running?


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: Sophokles on May 09, 2013, 10:58:28 AM
You don't need special configuration, just plug in the risers. But not all combinations of PCIe slots work. Was a bit of trial and error until all cards got recognized.

OS is Win 7.

Will post some pictures later!


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: bitcoindude80 on May 09, 2013, 02:56:01 PM
You don't need special configuration, just plug in the risers. But not all combinations of PCIe slots work. Was a bit of trial and error until all cards got recognized.

OS is Win 7.

Will post some pictures later!

Thanks Sophokles!


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: bitcoindude80 on May 11, 2013, 05:01:44 AM
There you go. This is the stable configuration with 4 cards. There is a bit of space between the cards and the PSU, so I'm currently fitting a fifth one in there  :D

http://s7.directupload.net/images/130510/vkxi66i4.jpg

It's awesome!!

Where did you get the hardware for that open air rig?


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: BitshireHashaway on May 11, 2013, 05:05:01 AM
Very nice design, well built and looks to be very good at cooling. If your using windows I wouldn't recommend a fifth graphics card because they have problems after four but other than that, good job and best of luck!


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: Sophokles on May 12, 2013, 11:25:56 AM
There you go. This is the stable configuration with 4 cards. There is a bit of space between the cards and the PSU, so I'm currently fitting a fifth one in there  :D


It's awesome!!

Where did you get the hardware for that open air rig?

Thanks! I actually designed it myself  ;). The aluminum profiles were ordered cut to the required lengths (4,50€/m). Including nuts, bolts, angular connectors and the black stopper caps, it was about 70€.


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: Sophokles on May 12, 2013, 11:29:44 AM
Very nice design, well built and looks to be very good at cooling. If your using windows I wouldn't recommend a fifth graphics card because they have problems after four but other than that, good job and best of luck!

Thanks! I also got the fifth card running now. Didn't work with 13.1 drivers (code 43 for one card), but with 12.6 all working. Seems like the older drivers are more likely to be ok with more than four cards.

I think I'm going to post some images in the 'Show us your rig'-Thread now  :)


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: jonsi on May 12, 2013, 01:06:36 PM
Anyone know a seller in Europe?


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: bitcoindude80 on May 16, 2013, 03:24:35 AM
Finally got my 4 * 7970 up and running!!

https://i.imgur.com/elsSe16.jpg


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: scab on May 16, 2013, 04:58:44 AM
Well, I suppose power would be better! :)


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: Sophokles on May 16, 2013, 08:06:36 AM
Anyone know a seller in Europe?

Just google 'aluminum profiles' in your local language. This stuff is readily available. Even on ebay.


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: optimusprime on May 16, 2013, 08:14:59 AM
nice rig


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: Sophokles on May 16, 2013, 08:31:01 AM
Finally got my 4 * 7970 up and running!!

https://i.imgur.com/elsSe16.jpg

Nice job! Are the big fans blowing downwards? Maybe you want them to suck air upwards, in the normal direction the heat would go. That could optimize airflow and temperatures.


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: netCoins on May 16, 2013, 10:54:34 AM
nice rigs


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: bitcoindude80 on May 16, 2013, 03:21:38 PM
Finally got my 4 * 7970 up and running!!

https://i.imgur.com/elsSe16.jpg

Nice job! Are the big fans blowing downwards? Maybe you want them to suck air upwards, in the normal direction the heat would go. That could optimize airflow and temperatures.

Thanks for the feedback Sophokles!! I've put it on the side now so it'll blow hot air out the window.



Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: enzz0 on May 16, 2013, 03:34:54 PM
 ::) ??? 8)


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: reich on May 16, 2013, 03:45:29 PM
Power is better


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: hashhash01 on May 21, 2013, 02:33:44 PM
Very nice design, well built and looks to be very good at cooling. If your using windows I wouldn't recommend a fifth graphics card because they have problems after four but other than that, good job and best of luck!

Thanks! I also got the fifth card running now. Didn't work with 13.1 drivers (code 43 for one card), but with 12.6 all working. Seems like the older drivers are more likely to be ok with more than four cards.

I think I'm going to post some images in the 'Show us your rig'-Thread now  :)

Sophokles,
Excellent Setup, neat and tidy very well designed. Did you try the 13.5 Beta drivers, they are very stable for me even better than 13.4

Back to the issue of the PCI-e riser cables, as i can understand you are currently using 1x risers (non powered) for all five GPUs, it that correct?
i have been reading tons about the subject and there is lots of conflicting views out there, so i would prefer the experience of a working setup.

What PSU you are using that provides 10 x 8 PCIe power connectors?


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: Sophokles on May 21, 2013, 03:45:28 PM
Very nice design, well built and looks to be very good at cooling. If your using windows I wouldn't recommend a fifth graphics card because they have problems after four but other than that, good job and best of luck!

Thanks! I also got the fifth card running now. Didn't work with 13.1 drivers (code 43 for one card), but with 12.6 all working. Seems like the older drivers are more likely to be ok with more than four cards.

I think I'm going to post some images in the 'Show us your rig'-Thread now  :)

Sophokles,
Excellent Setup, neat and tidy very well designed. Did you try the 13.5 Beta drivers, they are very stable for me even better than 13.4

Back to the issue of the PCI-e riser cables, as i can understand you are currently using 1x risers (non powered) for all five GPUs, it that correct?
i have been reading tons about the subject and there is lots of conflicting views out there, so i would prefer the experience of a working setup.

What PSU you are using that provides 10 x 8 PCIe power connectors?

I have 4 non-powered risers. And one powered for the fifth. Working fine until now, even with litecoins, which brings extra load on the hardware. (Was too chicken to add a fifth without powered riser. Just read massnerder's thread before about his rig catching fire).

The PSU is an Enermax Platimaxx 1500. Real beauty. Comes with even 6x double 8 PCIe connectors. And a lot more stuff. Even certified to run 24/7 at 100% load, at 40 °C ambient temperature. Plus 93% efficiency. Comes at a price, but definitely worth it!


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: hashhash01 on May 21, 2013, 04:16:11 PM
Very nice design, well built and looks to be very good at cooling. If your using windows I wouldn't recommend a fifth graphics card because they have problems after four but other than that, good job and best of luck!

Thanks! I also got the fifth card running now. Didn't work with 13.1 drivers (code 43 for one card), but with 12.6 all working. Seems like the older drivers are more likely to be ok with more than four cards.

I think I'm going to post some images in the 'Show us your rig'-Thread now  :)

Sophokles,
Excellent Setup, neat and tidy very well designed. Did you try the 13.5 Beta drivers, they are very stable for me even better than 13.4

Back to the issue of the PCI-e riser cables, as i can understand you are currently using 1x risers (non powered) for all five GPUs, it that correct?
i have been reading tons about the subject and there is lots of conflicting views out there, so i would prefer the experience of a working setup.

What PSU you are using that provides 10 x 8 PCIe power connectors?

I have 4 non-powered risers. And one powered for the fifth. Working fine until now, even with litecoins, which brings extra load on the hardware. (Was too chicken to add a fifth without powered riser. Just read massnerder's thread before about his rig catching fire).

The PSU is an Enermax Platimaxx 1500. Real beauty. Comes with even 6x double 8 PCIe connectors. And a lot more stuff. Even certified to run 24/7 at 100% load, at 40 °C ambient temperature. Plus 93% efficiency. Comes at a price, but definitely worth it!

Thanks for the quick reply.
I am still not buying the need for powered riser with the 7970s, moderately OCed at stock voltage (1.17x v) each card burns approx 270W-280W (at wall socket measurement), since each card is feed with dual 8-pin PCIe power, that's 300W total which makes power draw from the mobo a minimal amount unless the card by design prefers to draw from the mobo than the PCIe power input.


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: Sophokles on May 21, 2013, 04:43:56 PM
Very nice design, well built and looks to be very good at cooling. If your using windows I wouldn't recommend a fifth graphics card because they have problems after four but other than that, good job and best of luck!

Thanks! I also got the fifth card running now. Didn't work with 13.1 drivers (code 43 for one card), but with 12.6 all working. Seems like the older drivers are more likely to be ok with more than four cards.

I think I'm going to post some images in the 'Show us your rig'-Thread now  :)

Sophokles,
Excellent Setup, neat and tidy very well designed. Did you try the 13.5 Beta drivers, they are very stable for me even better than 13.4

Back to the issue of the PCI-e riser cables, as i can understand you are currently using 1x risers (non powered) for all five GPUs, it that correct?
i have been reading tons about the subject and there is lots of conflicting views out there, so i would prefer the experience of a working setup.

What PSU you are using that provides 10 x 8 PCIe power connectors?

I have 4 non-powered risers. And one powered for the fifth. Working fine until now, even with litecoins, which brings extra load on the hardware. (Was too chicken to add a fifth without powered riser. Just read massnerder's thread before about his rig catching fire).

The PSU is an Enermax Platimaxx 1500. Real beauty. Comes with even 6x double 8 PCIe connectors. And a lot more stuff. Even certified to run 24/7 at 100% load, at 40 °C ambient temperature. Plus 93% efficiency. Comes at a price, but definitely worth it!

Thanks for the quick reply.
I am still not buying the need for powered riser with the 7970s, moderately OCed at stock voltage (1.17x v) each card burns approx 270W-280W (at wall socket measurement), since each card is feed with dual 8-pin PCIe power, that's 300W total which makes power draw from the mobo a minimal amount unless the card by design prefers to draw from the mobo than the PCIe power input.

Yes, exactly. Unless someone takes the time to measure it, we will not know how much power the 7970 draw from the PCIe slot. And so we cannot say if the mobo can safely provide 5 times that. I inquired with the mobo manufacturer, and they advised against running more than 3 high-end cards on that one.

So, try it if you feel lucky  ;). But the risk is burning up your board, or even setting your place on fire when it happens in your absence. I'd rather not risk it...


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: hashhash01 on May 21, 2013, 05:23:41 PM
Very nice design, well built and looks to be very good at cooling. If your using windows I wouldn't recommend a fifth graphics card because they have problems after four but other than that, good job and best of luck!

Thanks! I also got the fifth card running now. Didn't work with 13.1 drivers (code 43 for one card), but with 12.6 all working. Seems like the older drivers are more likely to be ok with more than four cards.

I think I'm going to post some images in the 'Show us your rig'-Thread now  :)

Sophokles,
Excellent Setup, neat and tidy very well designed. Did you try the 13.5 Beta drivers, they are very stable for me even better than 13.4

Back to the issue of the PCI-e riser cables, as i can understand you are currently using 1x risers (non powered) for all five GPUs, it that correct?
i have been reading tons about the subject and there is lots of conflicting views out there, so i would prefer the experience of a working setup.

What PSU you are using that provides 10 x 8 PCIe power connectors?

I have 4 non-powered risers. And one powered for the fifth. Working fine until now, even with litecoins, which brings extra load on the hardware. (Was too chicken to add a fifth without powered riser. Just read massnerder's thread before about his rig catching fire).

The PSU is an Enermax Platimaxx 1500. Real beauty. Comes with even 6x double 8 PCIe connectors. And a lot more stuff. Even certified to run 24/7 at 100% load, at 40 °C ambient temperature. Plus 93% efficiency. Comes at a price, but definitely worth it!

Thanks for the quick reply.
I am still not buying the need for powered riser with the 7970s, moderately OCed at stock voltage (1.17x v) each card burns approx 270W-280W (at wall socket measurement), since each card is feed with dual 8-pin PCIe power, that's 300W total which makes power draw from the mobo a minimal amount unless the card by design prefers to draw from the mobo than the PCIe power input.

Yes, exactly. Unless someone takes the time to measure it, we will not know how much power the 7970 draw from the PCIe slot. And so we cannot say if the mobo can safely provide 5 times that. I inquired with the mobo manufacturer, and they advised against running more than 3 high-end cards on that one.

So, try it if you feel lucky  ;). But the risk is burning up your board, or even setting your place on fire when it happens in your absence. I'd rather not risk it...
No One can claim to be that lucky  :)
check this post, have some figures on the PCIe slot current but for bitcoin mining
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=199706.msg2082941#msg2082941


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: Sophokles on May 21, 2013, 05:29:30 PM
Very nice design, well built and looks to be very good at cooling. If your using windows I wouldn't recommend a fifth graphics card because they have problems after four but other than that, good job and best of luck!

Thanks! I also got the fifth card running now. Didn't work with 13.1 drivers (code 43 for one card), but with 12.6 all working. Seems like the older drivers are more likely to be ok with more than four cards.

I think I'm going to post some images in the 'Show us your rig'-Thread now  :)

Sophokles,
Excellent Setup, neat and tidy very well designed. Did you try the 13.5 Beta drivers, they are very stable for me even better than 13.4

Back to the issue of the PCI-e riser cables, as i can understand you are currently using 1x risers (non powered) for all five GPUs, it that correct?
i have been reading tons about the subject and there is lots of conflicting views out there, so i would prefer the experience of a working setup.

What PSU you are using that provides 10 x 8 PCIe power connectors?

I have 4 non-powered risers. And one powered for the fifth. Working fine until now, even with litecoins, which brings extra load on the hardware. (Was too chicken to add a fifth without powered riser. Just read massnerder's thread before about his rig catching fire).

The PSU is an Enermax Platimaxx 1500. Real beauty. Comes with even 6x double 8 PCIe connectors. And a lot more stuff. Even certified to run 24/7 at 100% load, at 40 °C ambient temperature. Plus 93% efficiency. Comes at a price, but definitely worth it!

Thanks for the quick reply.
I am still not buying the need for powered riser with the 7970s, moderately OCed at stock voltage (1.17x v) each card burns approx 270W-280W (at wall socket measurement), since each card is feed with dual 8-pin PCIe power, that's 300W total which makes power draw from the mobo a minimal amount unless the card by design prefers to draw from the mobo than the PCIe power input.

Yes, exactly. Unless someone takes the time to measure it, we will not know how much power the 7970 draw from the PCIe slot. And so we cannot say if the mobo can safely provide 5 times that. I inquired with the mobo manufacturer, and they advised against running more than 3 high-end cards on that one.

So, try it if you feel lucky  ;). But the risk is burning up your board, or even setting your place on fire when it happens in your absence. I'd rather not risk it...
No One can claim to be that lucky  :)
check this post, have some figures on the PCIe slot current but for bitcoin mining
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=199706.msg2082941#msg2082941


So, finally someone took the trouble of making and publishing measurements! If the 7970 actually only draws 0.9 A, then 5 of them would be no problem in terms if PCIe power draw. Or even several  more.


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: kodo on May 21, 2013, 05:58:27 PM
Wow nice setup!


Title: Re: riser cable with power or without power
Post by: hashhash01 on May 22, 2013, 10:05:09 AM
Very nice design, well built and looks to be very good at cooling. If your using windows I wouldn't recommend a fifth graphics card because they have problems after four but other than that, good job and best of luck!

Thanks! I also got the fifth card running now. Didn't work with 13.1 drivers (code 43 for one card), but with 12.6 all working. Seems like the older drivers are more likely to be ok with more than four cards.

I think I'm going to post some images in the 'Show us your rig'-Thread now  :)

Sophokles,
Excellent Setup, neat and tidy very well designed. Did you try the 13.5 Beta drivers, they are very stable for me even better than 13.4

Back to the issue of the PCI-e riser cables, as i can understand you are currently using 1x risers (non powered) for all five GPUs, it that correct?
i have been reading tons about the subject and there is lots of conflicting views out there, so i would prefer the experience of a working setup.

What PSU you are using that provides 10 x 8 PCIe power connectors?

I have 4 non-powered risers. And one powered for the fifth. Working fine until now, even with litecoins, which brings extra load on the hardware. (Was too chicken to add a fifth without powered riser. Just read massnerder's thread before about his rig catching fire).

The PSU is an Enermax Platimaxx 1500. Real beauty. Comes with even 6x double 8 PCIe connectors. And a lot more stuff. Even certified to run 24/7 at 100% load, at 40 °C ambient temperature. Plus 93% efficiency. Comes at a price, but definitely worth it!

Thanks for the quick reply.
I am still not buying the need for powered riser with the 7970s, moderately OCed at stock voltage (1.17x v) each card burns approx 270W-280W (at wall socket measurement), since each card is feed with dual 8-pin PCIe power, that's 300W total which makes power draw from the mobo a minimal amount unless the card by design prefers to draw from the mobo than the PCIe power input.

Yes, exactly. Unless someone takes the time to measure it, we will not know how much power the 7970 draw from the PCIe slot. And so we cannot say if the mobo can safely provide 5 times that. I inquired with the mobo manufacturer, and they advised against running more than 3 high-end cards on that one.

So, try it if you feel lucky  ;). But the risk is burning up your board, or even setting your place on fire when it happens in your absence. I'd rather not risk it...
No One can claim to be that lucky  :)
check this post, have some figures on the PCIe slot current but for bitcoin mining
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=199706.msg2082941#msg2082941


So, finally someone took the trouble of making and publishing measurements! If the 7970 actually only draws 0.9 A, then 5 of them would be no problem in terms if PCIe power draw. Or even several  more.
So i guess its time for me to bounce the question back to you, "Do you feel lucky?"  ;) just kidding.

The only troubling part is about the card's memory drawing its power from the PCIe solt, that what makes all the difference between the Bitcoin and Litecoin mining. So i guess it will come down to your Thread Concurrency setting, too high TC will result in more memory used hence more power draw.
You can always check the mobo and power connectors to see if it is running hot as they described, not sure how we can do that effectivly with all the head blowing from the cards