Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Bitcoin Discussion => Topic started by: rosegarden on July 20, 2017, 11:25:16 AM



Title: Can someone tell me is the graph right?
Post by: rosegarden on July 20, 2017, 11:25:16 AM
saw it on twitter, looks like a nice graph but not quite sure is the graph getting the things right.
anyone wanna comment on it?

https://i.imgur.com/g32xKY7.jpg?3
https://twitter.com/PrescottRegency/status/887925121490366464 (https://twitter.com/PrescottRegency/status/887925121490366464)


Title: Re: Can someone tell me is the graph right?
Post by: StevenRA on July 20, 2017, 11:50:00 AM
saw it on twitter, looks like a nice graph but not quite sure is the graph getting the things right.
anyone wanna comment on it?

https://i.imgur.com/g32xKY7.jpg?3
https://twitter.com/PrescottRegency/status/887925121490366464 (https://twitter.com/PrescottRegency/status/887925121490366464)


Do you mean this article  ("Bitcoin swings as civil war looms")  ?

http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-40654194


Title: Re: Can someone tell me is the graph right?
Post by: Red-Apple on July 20, 2017, 11:54:39 AM
saw it on twitter, looks like a nice graph but not quite sure is the graph getting the things right.
anyone wanna comment on it?

https://i.imgur.com/g32xKY7.jpg?3
https://twitter.com/PrescottRegency/status/887925121490366464 (https://twitter.com/PrescottRegency/status/887925121490366464)


from the top to bottom:
>80% is supporting Soft fork during the 21-29 with signalling for BIP91
if it locks in until tomorrow then there is no NO part (if it didn't i will add more information here tomorrow) because so far we are above 80%

when Yes part happens, SegWit is activated with majority. if by the deadline (Aug 1) there is anyone left who has not upgraded to SegWit, their blocks will be rejected by the majority (orphaned)

after SegWit BTC (that circle in the end) is MOON :D

we have some more stuff coming on Aug 1 like Bitmain wanting to individually split from the rest of the network, but since nobody wants or supports it, i call it a dumb move and may not even happen since their purpose was to go against UASF and with the current trend there is not going to be any UASF.

the next step is the 2 MB hard fork somewhere down the line, which we can't say what will happen at this point. lets get SegWit activated for now and get it working for a couple of months first then worry about that.

the bottom part of the chart is not going to happen as i explained above and if things change i will post a new comment tomorrow...


Title: Re: Can someone tell me is the graph right?
Post by: Mandoy on July 20, 2017, 12:32:06 PM
saw it on twitter, looks like a nice graph but not quite sure is the graph getting the things right.
anyone wanna comment on it?

https://i.imgur.com/g32xKY7.jpg?3
https://twitter.com/PrescottRegency/status/887925121490366464 (https://twitter.com/PrescottRegency/status/887925121490366464)


I have also met a the same graph but it has some few differences with that graph that you have posted. Almost everything is the same except that thing on BIP148. As I remember there are also yes or no section on the BIP148 but I cannot clearly remember what is that section. I also forgot the link but I have seen that graph here in bitcoin forum. But anyway I agree with the graph that everything should be settled with BIP 91 so that no split will happen and that both parties will also agree. Bitmain have give their support to BIP 91 as well as other miners hope the core developers and other groups will also support BIP 91 for the future of bitcoin.