Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Legal => Topic started by: hzmbeyond80 on July 31, 2017, 06:33:04 PM



Title: exchange lowering withdrawal limit without notice
Post by: hzmbeyond80 on July 31, 2017, 06:33:04 PM
I am using a major us based exchange and managed to pass the higher verification level (by providing all kinds of private information, such as credit history, income source, id, employment, etc ... )  and was granted to deposit and withdraw up to $1 million a day.  After putting in a large amount of USD, i was told "due to compliance change", they now only allow $100,000 dollar withdrawal a year!  though i could still convert USD into crypto currency and withdraw to another exchange and sell, it causes a loss. they also refused to give any details on the 'compliance change" and didn't explain why there was no notice. I was wondering whether such act,  lowering the withdraw limit significantly on fully verified clients without notice, is legal and is there any action i can take. thank you!



Title: Re: exchange lowering withdrawal limit without notice
Post by: beerlover on August 02, 2017, 05:55:14 PM
Afterall exchanges are business which has to keep a fiat account with some bank and hence have to register as a business in some country or other and forced to follow the law of the land. The limits set by exchanges are actually permissible limits of the country where the exchanges file their tax returns.


Title: Re: exchange lowering withdrawal limit without notice
Post by: GreenBits on August 05, 2017, 09:50:30 PM
I am using a major us based exchange and managed to pass the higher verification level (by providing all kinds of private information, such as credit history, income source, id, employment, etc ... )  and was granted to deposit and withdraw up to $1 million a day.  After putting in a large amount of USD, i was told "due to compliance change", they now only allow $100,000 dollar withdrawal a year!  though i could still convert USD into crypto currency and withdraw to another exchange and sell, it causes a loss. they also refused to give any details on the 'compliance change" and didn't explain why there was no notice. I was wondering whether such act,  lowering the withdraw limit significantly on fully verified clients without notice, is legal and is there any action i can take. thank you!



They lied to you when they told you 1 mil ;)

Regardless of the amount of verification, every withdrawal/deposit from a legit platform over 10k MUST be reported by the platform, with a written explanation of the details of said transaction. No exchange in their right mind would allow you such a limit; you could possibly generate an expensive amount of paper work to accurately record your transactions in and out of the platform. Fees from trading are cool and all, but a compliance officer would need to file the report, and trust me, they are expensive.

By using an exchange, you are usually subject to the TOS. I dont know what exchange you are on, but usually the TOS states they can change stuff like this at their discretion. It's suck, but this is the nature of our unregulated space at the moment.

If they dont spell this out in the TOS, they are fair game. ;)



Title: Re: exchange lowering withdrawal limit without notice
Post by: botany on August 06, 2017, 11:42:40 AM
By using an exchange, you are usually subject to the TOS. I dont know what exchange you are on, but usually the TOS states they can change stuff like this at their discretion. It's suck, but this is the nature of our unregulated space at the moment.

Most services have a blanket right to change any terms of service inserted in their standard disclaimer. I will be very surprised if a crypto exchange didn't have this protection.