Bitcoin Forum

Economy => Speculation => Topic started by: wormbog on May 17, 2013, 04:01:20 PM



Title: MtGOX exchange rate artificially high
Post by: wormbog on May 17, 2013, 04:01:20 PM
Check out the exchange rates, gox is substantially higher that the other exchanges:

http://bitcoinity.org/markets/list?currency=USD&span=24h

With the Dwolla account freeze, people with money at gox who rely on dwolla can buy btc and move it out, but they can't sell for USD and get their money out of the exchange. Thus, more people buying bitcoin, resulting in a higher price.

Good arbitrage opportunity for gox account holders who don't rely on dwolla.


Title: Re: MtGOX exchange rate artificially high
Post by: Zaih on May 17, 2013, 04:13:24 PM
Yeh noticed that too. I'm sure it'll quickly make itself less apparent as people catch on


Title: Re: MtGOX exchange rate artificially high
Post by: Le Happy Merchant on May 17, 2013, 04:33:46 PM
It was like this for most of the big rally, Mt.Gox tends to lead price.

Arbitrage is feasible, and it closes the gaps.


Title: Re: MtGOX exchange rate artificially high
Post by: adamstgBit on May 17, 2013, 04:35:39 PM
can't they wire the money???


Title: Re: MtGOX exchange rate artificially high
Post by: BitcoinAshley on May 17, 2013, 04:36:10 PM
It's funny, because all the noobs assumed that the dwolla freeze would drive price DOWN, WAY DOWN.

However, it is well known by most of us that some of the price difference in exchanges is due to ease/difficulty in getting USD in or out. For instance. BTC-e was always typically lower, and I'm sure the difficulty in getting USD in partly contributed to the imbalance on the buy side. And Bitfloor was INCREDIBLY easy, one simply had to walk into mordor bank of america and cash deposit, you had your USD ready to trade in 30 minutes. Bitfloor price tended to be a few dollars higher than Gox price at all times. Other exchanges also presented unique arbitrage opportunities depending on their funding methods.

Right now, we might be seeing a very slight buy/sell imbalance at Gox due to the Dwolla freeze.

But since the Gox price is used the most as reference, due to the liquidity, Department of Homeland Security's actions potentially (depending on if you believe there is an imbalance) caused the price of BTC in the most-referenced market to rise. And even if people are selling on other exchanges - it won't offset the increase because people on other exchanges have an interesting tendency to look to the Gox price for reference and confirmation of trend analysis. Gox price pulls other exchanges, rather than vice versa. Very interesting situation we have.

Noobs were wrong. I was right. What else is new?

Oh, don't forget that Gox is usually higher than the other exchanges anyways. So maybe we're just reading into this a bit too much, folks ;)


Title: Re: MtGOX exchange rate artificially high
Post by: davout on May 17, 2013, 04:39:55 PM
Noobs were wrong. I was right. What else is new?
Your Bitcointalk account.


Title: Re: MtGOX exchange rate artificially high
Post by: relm9 on May 17, 2013, 04:53:27 PM
With how slow Bitcoin deposits / withdrawls are on Gox right now I don't know if arbitrage would be effective.

I withdrew some BTC over 12 hours ago and it hasn't even showed up on Blockchain yet. Not sure if it's a  glitch in their system or what, still waiting on support...


Title: Re: MtGOX exchange rate artificially high
Post by: MAbtc on May 17, 2013, 05:00:14 PM
Not easy getting USD out of BTC-E. And Bitstamp sell pressure is scary as hell right now. This looks pretty iffy.


Title: Re: MtGOX exchange rate artificially high
Post by: adamstgBit on May 17, 2013, 05:07:08 PM
is their no way to withdraw USD out of gox,

can't they just wire money?


Title: Re: MtGOX exchange rate artificially high
Post by: N12 on May 17, 2013, 05:08:56 PM
is their no way to withdraw USD out of gox,

can't they just wire money?
They can. International Bank Transfers are working fine.

The price is genuinely increasing, it's not because of a "bank run". This is evidenced in that there is no major decoupling of MtGox from other exchanges. That MtGox leads the price a bit is normal.


Title: Re: MtGOX exchange rate artificially high
Post by: MAbtc on May 17, 2013, 05:13:20 PM
is their no way to withdraw USD out of gox,

can't they just wire money?

If someone in the US wants fiat and is worried about Gox's immediate future, they may not want incoming wires coming from Gox. The intermediary bank accounts in the US could be ripe for seizure. Now, I'd like to think that Gox would make it right if some bank accounts got taken, but one can't be sure. Personally, I've been screwed twice by offshore payment processors (Usemywallet and ewalletxpress), who, when "my cashouts" were seized by the feds, basically said "fuck off, we don't have your money" and cut off communication. Not the same situation, but not so different.


Title: Re: MtGOX exchange rate artificially high
Post by: MAbtc on May 17, 2013, 05:18:17 PM
is their no way to withdraw USD out of gox,

can't they just wire money?
They can. International Bank Transfers are working fine.

The price is genuinely increasing, it's not because of a "bank run". This is evidenced in that there is no major decoupling of MtGox from other exchanges. That MtGox leads the price a bit is normal.

What do you think about the big decrease in sell pressure on Gox, and the big increase in sell pressure on Bitstamp? I'm not sure about the other exchanges.

https://i.imgur.com/luvKcBH.png

Have you turned bullish in the short and/or medium term?


Title: Re: MtGOX exchange rate artificially high
Post by: BitcoinAshley on May 17, 2013, 05:25:14 PM
Noobs were wrong. I was right. What else is new?
Your Bitcointalk account.


You missed the part about relativity  ;D

Naturally I am only insulting people who joined 2 weeks ago and are spreading fud about a bank run (when the Gox lead is natural, it's like people just noticed it and are attributing it to this recent DHS action)

P.S. I could be one of those people who ditches their account every few months and starts a new throwaway B)


Title: Re: MtGOX exchange rate artificially high
Post by: N12 on May 17, 2013, 05:39:29 PM
What do you think about the big decrease in sell pressure on Gox, and the big increase in sell pressure on Bitstamp? I'm not sure about the other exchanges.

https://i.imgur.com/luvKcBH.png

Have you turned bullish in the short and/or medium term?
I took notice of it, but the price on Bitstamp is following MtGox's. It may simply be a matter of competition with MtGox shrinking a little as people have more concern.

Bullish for the short term at least. We've overcome a major horizontal resistance.


Title: Re: MtGOX exchange rate artificially high
Post by: ineededausername on May 17, 2013, 06:03:11 PM
With how slow Bitcoin deposits / withdrawls are on Gox right now I don't know if arbitrage would be effective.

I withdrew some BTC over 12 hours ago and it hasn't even showed up on Blockchain yet. Not sure if it's a  glitch in their system or what, still waiting on support...

If they're that slow, it's probably  because they're having to move BTC out of cold storage.


Title: Re: MtGOX exchange rate artificially high
Post by: smoothie on May 17, 2013, 06:51:14 PM
Check out the exchange rates, gox is substantially higher that the other exchanges:

http://bitcoinity.org/markets/list?currency=USD&span=24h

With the Dwolla account freeze, people with money at gox who rely on dwolla can buy btc and move it out, but they can't sell for USD and get their money out of the exchange. Thus, more people buying bitcoin, resulting in a higher price.

Good arbitrage opportunity for gox account holders who don't rely on dwolla.

Two words for USD holders: Wire Transfer


Title: Re: MtGOX exchange rate artificially high
Post by: adamstgBit on May 17, 2013, 06:58:47 PM
Check out the exchange rates, gox is substantially higher that the other exchanges:

http://bitcoinity.org/markets/list?currency=USD&span=24h

With the Dwolla account freeze, people with money at gox who rely on dwolla can buy btc and move it out, but they can't sell for USD and get their money out of the exchange. Thus, more people buying bitcoin, resulting in a higher price.

Good arbitrage opportunity for gox account holders who don't rely on dwolla.

Two words for USD holders: Wire Transfer

f that
1 word

BITCOIN


Title: Re: MtGOX exchange rate artificially high
Post by: Brunic on May 17, 2013, 10:32:13 PM

What do you think about the big decrease in sell pressure on Gox, and the big increase in sell pressure on Bitstamp? I'm not sure about the other exchanges.

https://i.imgur.com/luvKcBH.png

Have you turned bullish in the short and/or medium term?

Hahaha, what an odd situation. It look like people are buying at Mt. Gox and selling at Bitstamp to get out of the market. But since there is a lack of buyers at Bitstamp, they have nobody to sell to.

I'm curious to see how it will end.


Title: Re: MtGOX exchange rate artificially high
Post by: Malawi on May 17, 2013, 11:29:14 PM

What do you think about the big decrease in sell pressure on Gox, and the big increase in sell pressure on Bitstamp? I'm not sure about the other exchanges.


Have you turned bullish in the short and/or medium term?

Hahaha, what an odd situation. It look like people are buying at Mt. Gox and selling at Bitstamp to get out of the market. But since there is a lack of buyers at Bitstamp, they have nobody to sell to.

I'm curious to see how it will end.

+283


Title: Re: MtGOX exchange rate artificially high
Post by: kokojie on May 18, 2013, 01:40:32 AM
arbitriage will correct it, and if not, it's high for a reason.


Title: Re: MtGOX exchange rate artificially high
Post by: Beta-coiner1 on May 18, 2013, 03:49:15 AM
One other strange thing is trends (https://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=bitcoin&date=today%201-m&cmpt=q) seem to be going higher as of late.


Title: Re: MtGOX exchange rate artificially high
Post by: mp420 on May 18, 2013, 05:53:58 AM
is their no way to withdraw USD out of gox,

can't they just wire money?
They can. International Bank Transfers are working fine.

The price is genuinely increasing, it's not because of a "bank run". This is evidenced in that there is no major decoupling of MtGox from other exchanges. That MtGox leads the price a bit is normal.

What do you think about the big decrease in sell pressure on Gox, and the big increase in sell pressure on Bitstamp? I'm not sure about the other exchanges.

https://i.imgur.com/luvKcBH.png

Have you turned bullish in the short and/or medium term?

I think the high selling pressure on BitStamp is because of Europeans trying to get their money out of Gox. Even with the spread, it can be the cheapest option. The Gox rally is genuine, though, and not influenced by this very much.

I'm bearish in the medium term, by the way. Eventually the dumb money will run out. Smart money is out already.


Title: Re: MtGOX exchange rate artificially high
Post by: BitPirate on May 18, 2013, 06:54:22 AM
There are a lot of cheap coins right there for the taking.

Imagine the panic buying if someone bought it all. Might inject a bit of volume into Gox too.


Title: Re: MtGOX exchange rate artificially high
Post by: Miz4r on May 18, 2013, 09:56:05 AM
Just to put things in perspective, those 5-6k coins up to $122-123 would get eaten in seconds on MtGox. If there was a cheap and easy way to arbitrage those coins would disappear and hardly put a dent in the price on Gox.


Title: Re: MtGOX exchange rate artificially high
Post by: Ichthyo on May 18, 2013, 03:43:18 PM
If there was a cheap and easy way to arbitrage those coins would disappear and hardly put a dent in the price on Gox.

Indeed. Bitfinex has placed a limit on the USD able to be sold on Mt.Gox to prevent all of their user's USD to gravitate into the Mt.Gox account. Thus, right now Bitfinex can't be used for arbitrage between Gox and Bitstamp.