Title: . Post by: icoinv on May 19, 2013, 06:46:57 PM .
Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 19, 2013, 06:53:46 PM Access exchange under this URL https://i-co.in User needs to have tax PAN in order to register with exchange. You can transfer funds between exchange account and your bank account from anywhere in india. For any clarifications contact email: support@i-co.in Follow us at https://twitter.com/icoinv Nice. But is a PAN needed if a person makes a Bitcoin deposit? May be required to withdraw INR, but not for a BTC deposit. That kept me from registering. Any chances of looking into this? Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 19, 2013, 06:59:46 PM Thank you for your interest. When you deposit BTC, i believe you obviously would trade for INR which eventually look to withdraw and need to submit PAN. Just to keep things together users required to have PAN while registering. Not necessary that I would withdraw in INR. People can use an exchange for arbitrage as well. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: laserwolf on May 19, 2013, 07:03:01 PM So you need my PAN card. great.
But who are you guys anyway? Why would I send my BTC or INR your way? Access exchange under this URL https://i-co.in User needs to have tax PAN in order to register with exchange. You can transfer funds between exchange account and your bank account from anywhere in india. For any clarifications contact email: support@i-co.in Follow us at https://twitter.com/icoinv Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 19, 2013, 07:14:30 PM So you need my PAN card. great. But who are you guys anyway? Why would I send my BTC or INR your way? Access exchange under this URL https://i-co.in User needs to have tax PAN in order to register with exchange. You can transfer funds between exchange account and your bank account from anywhere in india. For any clarifications contact email: support@i-co.in Follow us at https://twitter.com/icoinv http://domaindb.in/i-co.in Not much to dig into. Registrant name, organization, address, etc, seem to be too new to have trace. The T&C Page seems to have substance. There has been legal opinion/ advice/ investment involved. Keen to see some more opinions/ +reps. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Pinwheel on May 19, 2013, 09:06:01 PM banks require PAN only if you deposit 50K cash. If you getting 2 lakh incoming transaction or withdrawing 2-5 lakhs in cash PAN is not required. I think for exchange regulations related PAN will be similar. As you are not taking cash deposits you no need PAN at all.
Second legit question if you asking people to deposit bitcoins or INR that would be reasonable to ask what kind of organization behinde of this exchange. It is some one personal savings account, it proprietorship or partnership, it is private limited company. certain level of public scrutiny and transparency is requited before anyone will deposit anything. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Dashing on May 19, 2013, 09:09:01 PM Quote Outgoing(Withdrawing funds) 0.99% or 99₹ whichever is higher Might want to think about that, what If I want to withdraw say Rs, 200 ? I'll end up losing Rs. 99 (as you say "Whichever is higher") Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Pinwheel on May 19, 2013, 09:43:10 PM Quote Outgoing(Withdrawing funds) 0.99% or 99₹ whichever is higher Might want to think about that, what If I want to withdraw say Rs, 200 ? I'll end up losing Rs. 99 (as you say "Whichever is higher") common dont be sily if you have question you can write it here Email:����support@i-co.in wicked sick one week exchange next week a coin. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 20, 2013, 02:32:51 AM banks require PAN only if you deposit 50K cash. If you getting 2 lakh incoming transaction or withdrawing 2-5 lakhs in cash PAN is not required. I think for exchange regulations related PAN will be similar. As you are not taking cash deposits you no need PAN at all. Second legit question if you asking people to deposit bitcoins or INR that would be reasonable to ask what kind of organization behinde of this exchange. It is some one personal savings account, it proprietorship or partnership, it is private limited company. certain level of public scrutiny and transparency is requited before anyone will deposit anything. We have done quite research regarding exchange of BTC/INR in legal perspective, invested lots of time. Its in the best interest of all our clients in order to protect them and our organization we are required to have PAN. Thank you. I assume that pinwheels question is geared more towards: 1. Who are you guys? 2. Are you scamming? Genuine Question. Although answer may not be. 3. Most of the WHOIS details looks like a fly-by-night op. 4. SVE does not have internet presence, that makes Pinwheel a bit anxious. Rest assured that we all want an exchange to succeed. Hoping that you are genuine and will be able to run this business with transparency. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: axorb on May 20, 2013, 04:03:38 AM I like the minimalist design of the site. If you guys are able to pull this of , this is seriously going to be a game changer. I will be monitoring the progress. Good Luck :)
Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Dashing on May 20, 2013, 08:49:11 AM Quote Outgoing(Withdrawing funds) 0.99% or 99₹ whichever is higher Might want to think about that, what If I want to withdraw say Rs, 200 ? I'll end up losing Rs. 99 (as you say "Whichever is higher") wicked sick one week exchange next week a coin. If that;s referring to BitOcean, Let me make things clear, A week after I opened BitOcean, I did consult a lawyer about it, while he did not have much knowledge about bitcoin, he did explain a few cases and situations which we could encounter on the way and NONE of the situations/cases he mentioned were good, all ended up in either the owners getting arrested on running a Exchange Racket and the funds being seized or a HUGE HUGE fine and the license to run a exchange is NOT cheap either. I NEVER took a single deposit from ANYONE, not even 0.0000001 Bitcoin. I closed it for the better of Bitcoin in India, if BitOcean exchange were to get say seized or bank accounts frozen, it would SERIOUSLY dent the image of Bitcoin in India and that would be pretty bad. I coded it from scratch after weeks of coding and could have just kept it going, but I didn't just for the better of Bitcoin in India, like I mentioned above. Heck, At least I listened to the suggestions that were given in the forums and made needed changes, even if they involved coding a WHOLE new module in a day. And again, I don't know why you're being so angry against me, As I was not trying to be arrogant or rude and I was just asking why the fee was so high and maybe the question I asked about the fee could trigger an idea in their minds to make a way for cheaper withdrawals. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: drdanishkhan on May 20, 2013, 02:57:30 PM C'mon guys relax..
Dishwara.. dude dont just go on a rampage over every small detail.. people do ask quesyions and it isnt a bad thing.. Dashing.. chillax man.. we are all brothers here.. Cheers guys.. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: dishwara on May 20, 2013, 07:03:46 PM C'mon guys relax.. Dishwara?Dishwara.. dude dont just go on a rampage over every small detail.. people do ask quesyions and it isnt a bad thing.. Dashing.. chillax man.. we are all brothers here.. Cheers guys.. when i asked/said anything in this thread? Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 21, 2013, 01:05:40 AM Who are you guys a little details will help . i really don trust "the fly by night operators. "
and not some crappy word about being a bitcoin believers and for the community crap . your supporting evidence is that, you guys are a registered company with your company details . office phone numbers, office address, list of partners, and your photographs. and do you have permission to run a bitcoin based business with the bank you are operating with ? Straight froward questions and require straight forward answers . Thanks :-) Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 21, 2013, 01:34:09 AM O i forgot to ask you, how are you getting around the RBI guidelines of withdrawing INR from you e-wallets .
Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: drdanishkhan on May 21, 2013, 01:39:55 AM Sooo sorry dishwara.. i meant pinwheel.. apologies.
Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 21, 2013, 11:08:00 AM Now ive got more questions. guess after looking through your site and details there is a larger Question mark.
You are located in a town no bigger than 10 football fields big in the middle of nowhere. you contact numbers not there . owners name not there. atleast we could see the people before doing business with. you still have not been able to answer how you are working around the RBI guidelines of withdrawing money from the e wallets . awaiting your answer eagerly . Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 21, 2013, 12:25:24 PM you still have not been able to answer how you are working around the RBI guidelines of withdrawing money from the e wallets . This may not be a problem if it is confirmed to be unregulated. Dunno who is the person who confirms that though. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: wisard on May 21, 2013, 12:40:50 PM What are your security measures?
What percentage of funds are kept in cold storage? Do you intend to provide 2-factor authentication? Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: wisard on May 21, 2013, 12:43:18 PM Why are you hesitant in revealing the names behind the entity?
Your terms and conditions say legally this is done by an entity formed in 10 years back. Why not form a new company? What else is this existing company involved in? Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: wisard on May 21, 2013, 01:12:27 PM What are your security measures? What percentage of funds are kept in cold storage? Do you intend to provide 2-factor authentication? Keeping % of funds in cold storage is not the only solution, ofcourse its a good security measure, when something drastic happens it will minimize the damages, only the funds in the wallet is lost. In one of the recent event, one of the exchange followed the cold storage method still they had to shutdown the exchange. Of course your funds are important to us and we have designed\developed system that in mind and which are hosted in secure servers. We are not intending to provide 2-factor authentication currently, all the communication happens on secure socket layer. You always have 4 attempts to login, if you fail you have to reset the password over your email. Which is simple and still effective. So do you keep funds in cold storage? Cold storages help against theft. Not against regulation that can get an exchange shut down. Also, 2 factor authentication is an absolute requirement as it keeps your money safe even if your laptop is stolen or a spyware gets installed on your computer. Bitfloor and btc-e hacks have shown us that this is the bare security requirement for a bitcoin exchange: cold storages and 2-factor authentication. You can't take a lean startup approach to a venture where money is involved as a product. You can't fix bugs as they occur. You have to provide more security than your usual social media or blogging based startup. If you don't intend to provide these security measures yet, you should re-think and change your intention. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 21, 2013, 02:18:51 PM So basically we have no way to verify if, you are who you say you are. ther is nothing that can link you, no phone number, no proper address. dont even know if you are real.
Secondly you have no two factor auth, so i can safely amuse that your site is venerable to sql injection tooo, if you are not able to even impliment a simple two factor auth on your sites. . come to think of it, it's quite odd that some of the business that sell bitcoin came under a ddos attack before you guys announced your self. coincidence may be may be not . You guys seems to be highly reluctance to give out your identy to make every one feel secure. that raises a big red flag. as far as i know you could be my neighbor next door, your information is not sufficient . Let me tell you some thing, in a country filled with scam artist, for you to do business you will have to assure your customers that you can be trusted ., right now there is no trust . As for now i would put a RED FLAG on i-co.in , Sree Vinayaka Enterprises or iCoin . P.s - Bitcoin is an open community if you want this community to trust you stay in a open manner. dont try to hide or obscure details and twist things around. By the way in an earlier post i think you said you were a partnership , now it is a enterprise with a "CEO" Who is the chairman? but then again that is only in a "Company" , some thing is real fishy. I'm not convinced Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 21, 2013, 02:46:15 PM Arjun ( icoinv) you are now making your self look really ignorant, about the bitcoin community , and frankly what you just said suggest that we in the Indian bitcoin community should settle for a bellow standard security. I really wonder what you know about the bitcoin community as a whole.
I really dislike people who see bitcoin as a quick money making scheme. i wonder if that is the same with you . looks like you patched up a website in a hurry with verry little security and used a firm, or some enditity to start up this business (wonder if that enterprise is like a family owned old business you are using as cover). and you have made sure to hide all of your details . so , no can identify you. if you cannot meet the basic security needs and identity disclosure , you are better off working in what ever company you are working as a programmer. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 21, 2013, 02:51:51 PM CEO is just a designation .. looks like you also don have any experience in business. or running a company. let me educate you ,
In a partnership firm the partners are the designation.the profit sharing ration in the business. in a company established by the companies act of 1957, a company is an entity , with shareholders who elect a chairperson who appoints a CEO. (my memory is a bit vague but this is about right.) Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 21, 2013, 03:02:04 PM are you a partner , managing director , or a CEO..
If you have partners how many , what are their background and their entire details. But i guess it useless trying to save a drowning ship. Awh well best of luck on your other endeavours. hard to lie you way out of this one chum. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 21, 2013, 03:14:50 PM Thank you for your honesty. in not able to win my trust.
From my side it a Red Flag for you organisation i-co.in or Sree Vinayaka Enterprises[S.V.E] what ever you call it. I dont know what the others would want to say about this . So guys a little feedback on this would be appreciated Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 21, 2013, 03:19:41 PM Icoinv does have a point here. He does not need to prove his identity or the firms as long as he conducts honest business.
While I would still advice everyone to tread cautiously, I have seen looser knit businesses than these making a good trust based product by the end of their stint. Its an open market. I won't be registering yet as there is a need for PAN card and I do not need INR, hence I can't proceed as per the sites rules. If anyone feels that trust is lacking, then please do not register/ trade. But let us avoid accusations. This is a new business and as the Bitcoin India community, we have a duty to help everyone grow. Hope that made sense. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 21, 2013, 03:22:52 PM Agreed Benson Samuel there is no accusations here just a red flag of caution.
be careful. people. icoinv build your trust. hope you do business in a fare manner. Edit :- Forgot to mention , most of the questions i asked was not answered. so before signing up and transferring your funds think twice. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 21, 2013, 03:56:36 PM Edit :- Forgot to mention , most of the questions i asked was not answered. so before signing up and transferring your funds think twice. And for the rest of you toddlers out there, make sure you drink your milk. :p Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 21, 2013, 04:19:43 PM Edit :- Forgot to mention , most of the questions i asked was not answered. so before signing up and transferring your funds think twice. And for the rest of you toddlers out there, make sure you drink your milk. :p was that for me . :-) Awwww that so sweet. Benson stop pulling my chain . arnt you out of cigs yet.. :P Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: ninjarobots on May 21, 2013, 04:52:18 PM icoinv
Arjun Kumar +91.9902695939 ??? Tech Name: Sujathamma K A ::) Tech Email:icoinv@gmail.com Name Server:GNS19.HOSTGATOR.IN Hostgator? hmm.... Sundeep +919902695939 Karnataka Telecom Circle, Airtel India :o ~ Unleash the Great Ninja Power. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: wisard on May 21, 2013, 06:04:03 PM Many banks dont have 2 factor authentication, one cannot assume the security features about a system. Oh come on - why would you even compare bitcoins with fiat currency? Bank transactions are reversible. Bitcoins are not. A bank is insured. Your exchange is not. You cannot make things right like a bank can if theft occurs. You need to provide security that BSE provides - if you want to compare yourself, compare yourself with an exchange. Match their security standards. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: wisard on May 21, 2013, 06:14:02 PM Icoinv does have a point here. He does not need to prove his identity or the firms as long as he conducts honest business. While I would still advice everyone to tread cautiously, I have seen looser knit businesses than these making a good trust based product by the end of their stint. Its an open market. I won't be registering yet as there is a need for PAN card and I do not need INR, hence I can't proceed as per the sites rules. If anyone feels that trust is lacking, then please do not register/ trade. But let us avoid accusations. This is a new business and as the Bitcoin India community, we have a duty to help everyone grow. Hope that made sense. No. No. No. Just because Bitcoins is not too popular in India does not mean we shouldn't question people who try to build businesses around the bitcoin ecosystem. Bitcoins - because of its value - attract attacks. You actually have to expect attacks if you start a bitcoin related business. That is why you should absolutely challenge an exchange on their security procedures. Its not about my trust in whether the company will run away with my bitcoins. Its about my trust whether the company is even capable to protect my bitcoins from attacks. If you don't question them, they won't improve, and it will lead to a few people losing their bitcoins before the community learns a lesson. We don't need to learn these lessons first hand - when we have seen what has happened to other exchanges already. We don't have a duty to help any business grow, we have a duty to make sure that only the right business can grow. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 21, 2013, 06:27:02 PM Icoinv does have a point here. He does not need to prove his identity or the firms as long as he conducts honest business. While I would still advice everyone to tread cautiously, I have seen looser knit businesses than these making a good trust based product by the end of their stint. Its an open market. I won't be registering yet as there is a need for PAN card and I do not need INR, hence I can't proceed as per the sites rules. If anyone feels that trust is lacking, then please do not register/ trade. But let us avoid accusations. This is a new business and as the Bitcoin India community, we have a duty to help everyone grow. Hope that made sense. No. No. No. Just because Bitcoins is not too popular in India does not mean we shouldn't question people who try to build businesses around the bitcoin ecosystem. Bitcoins - because of its value - attract attacks. You actually have to expect attacks if you start a bitcoin related business. That is why you should absolutely challenge an exchange on their security procedures. Its not about my trust in whether the company will run away with my bitcoins. Its about my trust whether the company is even capable to protect my bitcoins from attacks. If you don't question them, they won't improve, and it will lead to a few people losing their bitcoins before the community learns a lesson. We don't need to learn these lessons first hand - when we have seen what has happened to other exchanges already. We don't have a duty to help any business grow, we have a duty to make sure that only the right business can grow. I am not asking anyone to stop questioning them. Was pointing more towards mild accusations. Rest assured, they will be questioned way way more when the general public gets involved. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 22, 2013, 01:26:42 AM Hey hey hey Benson , if you are pointing at "mild accusations" at me. dont worry. my accusation will start when people start signing up with them and their money and bitcoins start to disappear. a firm created in secret no verifiable information, dont really know who this person is. trust is hard to gain but like i said before . when people dont answer questions asked that becomes suspicious. may be you are ok when people dont fully answer questions . but not me.
Question being avoided and twisted are signs of anterior motives. There are alot of underlying problems to this, that has not been cleared out. the fact being that a exchange holding a client money basically turns an entity into a bank, meaning that all withdrawals have a interest amount attached to it. (RBI norms). if they are going as a Trading firm then the SEBI is involved. which has more rules than a banking regulation. there are too many rules to counter money laundering in india. many are pointed to stop withdraws of cash, and transfer of cash outside india. A exchange in india still holds INR in its account for a client after the sale of bitcoins . making it a deposit felicity . then comes the problem of withdrawing money from the account or the ewallet, and that is prohibited . this is the only thing that needs to be worked around. once this problem is solved then an exchange can operate within india without government interference, atleast for some time. If these problems have not been solved by an exchange opening in india, then the risk of this, being a temp operation is high. The main problem, security of the site is not ensured and the people starting this has a more or less a carefree attitude towards security , showing verry little care about the clients money that are going to be entrusted in them. So Benson if you call this an mild accusation then you are mistaken, ckz this is an observation. the accusation will come later on. ;D Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 22, 2013, 03:07:06 AM Good initiative, i will suggest you to start a new post with a bounty, and a legal disclaimer absolving the testers of legal action.
Its a good step you have taken +1 Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 22, 2013, 03:47:01 AM As far as bounty goes, as i said there is a wallet with my own BTC inside it. Legal action?? I can assure anyone NOT for time being. Lets continue the thread. Hum.. guess no one is gona be willing to help you out on this. (-1) for lack of effort. if you think someone is gona come over to this thread and announce that they will do a pen test for your website without you giving any type of legal disclaimer. you are sadly mistaken. you efforts to entrap people would not really work . Why do you always respond to thing making it more suspicious and harder to trust you . your comments "I can assure anyone NOT for time being. " makes you look highly untrustworthy. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 22, 2013, 04:49:15 AM icoinv, do you have any registered users/ deposits on the site as yet?
If yes, would they be able to recommend your work? This may work better towards building your reputation. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 22, 2013, 04:57:49 AM OK show me a thread of that kind regarding legal disclaimer etc etc, i will just follow those rules. so basically you want me to hand hold you through this process ??? icoinv, do you have any registered users/ deposits on the site as yet? If yes, would they be able to recommend your work? This may work better towards building your reputation. Hum.... interesting... wonder what this may pan out. lets watch and see. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: ninjarobots on May 22, 2013, 01:42:56 PM icoinv, do you have any registered users/ deposits on the site as yet? We have registered user, deposit transactions haven't taken place yet. I will try asking the person for feedback anyway.If yes, would they be able to recommend your work? This may work better towards building your reputation. Now this is interesting... Do you accept cash deposits w/o PAN?? If yes then myself or someone here might deposit. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 24, 2013, 02:04:55 AM icoinv, do you have any registered users/ deposits on the site as yet? We have registered user, deposit transactions haven't taken place yet. I will try asking the person for feedback anyway.If yes, would they be able to recommend your work? This may work better towards building your reputation. Now this is interesting... Do you accept cash deposits w/o PAN?? If yes then myself or someone here might deposit. This question was asked earlier too, i understand the eagerness regarding using the platform, let me clarify that with a small story about jumping ships. There is a mega fiat-ship and there is small btc-boat, people from the fiat-ship needs to get on btc-boat with a ROPE(which is exchanges\local bitcoins etc). Problem comes here, many would have objections with the transition. Too many people at once on rope would attract the owner of the mega-ship and would stop others from the transition. I am sure everyone understand the situation here about the reality. And its a small small world where everyone knows everyone. Unfortunately its a slow process of transition, we will work towards to improve it. Hence PAN. It does seem like you have not yet straightened out your legal bits. If you have PAN numbers and customer data and if your legal is not rock solid, all your customers WILL suffer. The forums here are a boiling pot of entrepreneurs, technologists and legal researchers. It also happens to be the place where 99% of Bitcoin related businesses can expect any kind of traction. Please do not expect an easy entry into this space, especially due to evasive answers and text book customer service responses. The reason for me to outline this is due to several PM's from India forum members raising doubts about your business. Everyone wants a Mt Gox for India, but no one in the current ecosystem will move away from trust based providers as yet. You may get few registrations and maybe even few deposits if you are very lucky. But I can see that the exchange may not take off for months, until there is a critical mass that trusts your operation. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 24, 2013, 02:50:46 AM Thank you Benson for clearing that up, you have elegance in your words.
Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 24, 2013, 03:01:22 AM We don't have a duty to help any business grow, we have a duty to make sure that only the right business can grow. Point taken. After 3 pages of this banter, I agree that we should work in that direction. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 24, 2013, 06:02:32 AM Quote This question was asked earlier too, i understand the eagerness regarding using the platform, let me clarify that with a small story about jumping ships. There is a mega fiat-ship and there is small btc-boat, people from the fiat-ship needs to get on btc-boat with a ROPE(which is exchanges\local bitcoins etc). Problem comes here, many would have objections with the transition. Too many people at once on rope would attract the owner of the mega-ship and would stop others from the transition. I am sure everyone understand the situation here about the reality. And its a small small world where everyone knows everyone. This is where you made a big blunder. If you guys really had the legal backing, govt approval, etc, the owner of the mega-ship mentioned in the above post will not matter at all. You are doing something under the radar which is absolutely fine as something unregulated does not risk anything much. Maybe laws, disclaimers and few inquiries at the most will be the risk to bear. Now, even though you are aware that your business model is not 100% sound, you are still asking for customer identification data and you even claim to have legal counsel to run an Exchange. To me, this is very very very fishy. If you had the legal bits in place, then it makes sense. Unfortunately, we know that is not the case, so consider altering your business model to reflect that. As of now, most in the community already understand legal implications of exchanging BTC and until the RBI or a similar authority mentions something concrete about 'Bitcoin', it will remain unregulated. But we all understand the madness involved with INR conversions. There is nothing new in what you have done. I was hoping that there was. Quote We have done reasonable work on legal issues. Couple of months we made a communication regarding Bitcoins with appropriate legal channels to the top officials, directors of Govt organization. Initially they replied with not much information(looked like basically they were dodging). We didnt stop there, we appealed the response with higher officials, they answered saying the questions are "HYPOTHETICAL"!! Any appeal from here is wastage of time. Officials are looking away from reality. Please outline your accordance with SEBI, FEMA, Prepaid regulations and FERA. I understand you cannot, because none of these regulators are willing to issue any public statement until there is sufficient time spent understanding Bitcoin. Please do not consider this criticism, it is honest advice to help you get this kicked off in the right fashion. This is a trust and reputations market that you have entered into. None of that dodgy keynesian stuff for us. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 24, 2013, 08:55:22 AM I NEVER claimed that business had full approval from govt. We have done reasonable We have discussed with CA's, and few legal councellors and taken advice. We had filed petitions on officials related to FEMA\FERA and Payment\settlement dept(which regulates e-wallets etc), with appropriate legal channels as i mentioned before. As i said the appeals are dismissed by higher officials. And they are considering it as hypothetical as of now. And there are few other petitions filed on other appropriate govt agencies at this point of time. Point is if something is not regulated, it cannot be deduced clearly as legal or illegal. And we clearly are not doing business without the notices to appropriate govt agencies in advance. The legal quest does not end here, as it is known it takes lots of time and effort. Understanding is govt needs a cut through taxes of any business. Also, i dont want to divulge too much details of our organization strategy on legal approach because it worries me that a competition would follow the same strategy. I guess, most of the rules made after lobbying. Without some organization need for regulation and asking them for it, if we expect them to make public announcement, the wait would be forever. Do you now understand why most of us are skeptical about this? If I deposit 100 BTC into your exchange and if the funds then get frozen, no one will answer for my losses. Now I understand that people may deposit INR as well, but that is not as big a problem as BTC deposits. INR depositors can always go to the courts. Bitcoiners cannot. If you do want a clean start, talk to people like buysellbitcoin, his business model is the closest that I have seen to a clean implement with full working knowledge of the law in India. Keep space open for miners to deposit BTC without a PAN card. Upto 20K INR withdrawals do not need to be reported to the RBI, or is it up to 50K. Without BTC deposits, INR is useless in an exchange. Keep the PAN card as an optional requirement. But make it a mandate to provide that information before withdrawing INR. This will allow for a lot more flexibility and realism in your operation. There is no lack of technology providers in India. Building a robust exchange system is easy peasy. Getting the trust of users, most importantly engaging in deposits is where the key problems in Bitcoin lie. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: buysellbitcoin on May 24, 2013, 10:21:02 AM I NEVER claimed that business had full approval from govt. We have done reasonable We have discussed with CA's, and few legal councellors and taken advice. We had filed petitions on officials related to FEMA\FERA and Payment\settlement dept(which regulates e-wallets etc), with appropriate legal channels as i mentioned before. As i said the appeals are dismissed by higher officials. And they are considering it as hypothetical as of now. And there are few other petitions filed on other appropriate govt agencies at this point of time. Point is if something is not regulated, it cannot be deduced clearly as legal or illegal. And we clearly are not doing business without the notices to appropriate govt agencies in advance. The legal quest does not end here, as it is known it takes lots of time and effort. Understanding is govt needs a cut through taxes of any business. Also, i dont want to divulge too much details of our organization strategy on legal approach because it worries me that a competition would follow the same strategy. I guess, most of the rules made after lobbying. Without some organization need for regulation and asking them for it, if we expect them to make public announcement, the wait would be forever. Now I understand that people may deposit INR as well, but that is not as big a problem as BTC deposits. INR depositors can always go to the courts. Bitcoiners cannot. Bitcoiners cannot go to court, since Bitcoin operates across jursidictions. Best part of Bitcoin is its free operation, not so best part is cannot go to courts(i guess this may happen in future they people indeed may approach courts over bitcoin). We can operate without PAN, and ask PAN while withdrawal. There is are inherent problems with that and need input feedback\solution for this in this community: 1) A person deposits >50K and does not operate his account(this may go not reported, since no identity). 2) A person hacks another bank account and transfers money to the exchange account, buys bitcoins and withdraws bitcoins. This is a huge issue. 3) Person deposits >50K without learning there needs to be PAN and while withdrawing, if we demand PAN while withdrawal of INR he might feel cheated. Many of international payment solution does similar to this. I am sure the above issues attract a competent authority to investigate into matter than trading in BTC. Ok now we are talking on correct points. 1) A person deposits >50K and does not operate his account(this may go not reported, since no identity). You must have daily and monthly or overall limit say 20k. If transaction or overall goes above that you need copy of PAN and verification mandatory for the same. If he is not operating his account, you should just carry forward his balance. Its not your issue and as long as money is not withdrawl to some else account, there is nothing to worry about it. Remember if someone deposits some money in your account, its not your money, its still his money as long as its there. Make sure your transaction account is different bank account and it does not involve your daily other business transactions. This account must be used only for exchange transactions that is only deposit and withdrawl. You can have a periodic evaluation period where you transfer profit to your other account from where exchange pays its operation costs. 2) A person hacks another bank account and transfers money to the exchange account, buys bitcoins and withdraws bitcoins. This is a huge issue. Support only NEFT. NEFT requires user to add payee and mostly have two factor + cooling period enabled. So if transfer is coming from NEFT in 99.99% cases you can prove them user has transferred funds himself. Still want to ensure that user is the actual person to transfer money, for transaction above some value say 20k, ask him to send you notorized affidavit stating that they are going to use X account for transaction to your account. Ask them to provide a physical copy of bank statement obtained from bank branch. 3) Person deposits >50K without learning there needs to be PAN and while withdrawing, if we demand PAN while withdrawal of INR he might feel cheated. Many of international payment solution does similar to this. Thats their problem. Make deposit order based. Allow them to book order in your system. Make it very very noticeable in instructions. Dont allow them to even book order if they do not meet your verification requirement. And on top of all, PLEASE use 100% cold storage. Anything in hot wallet will be stolen, write this on your spects. Everyone in India wants an exchange. We want it badly because that will allow us to find actual INR price and will save us lot of costs. Cheers Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 24, 2013, 10:22:40 AM Quote Bitcoiners cannot go to court, since Bitcoin operates across jursidictions. Best part of Bitcoin is its free operation, not so best part is cannot go to courts(i guess this may happen in future they people indeed may approach courts over bitcoin). Or, new decentralized courts will be setup to identify non-jurisdictional crime. This is in the purview of a Libertarians aspect of Private law. Quote We can operate without PAN, and ask PAN while withdrawal. Thank you. This will help you move forward for sure. Quote There is are inherent problems with that and need input feedback\solution for this in this community: And everyone will help answer to our best ability. Quote 1) A person deposits >50K and does not operate his account(this may go not reported, since no identity). If INR is deposited over specified limit, then PAN must be provided. This is a simple argument that needs to be coded into your deposit rules function. If BTC is deposited, nothing matters on the deposit as there is no regulation 'yet' (24th May 2013). Accounts can even be anonymous until the person wishes to 'Withdraw in INR'. But allowing anon accounts is a strategy decision and I will not advise on that. Your withdrawal rules need to use the same identifier from your database as PAN received. If the PAN has been received then Withdrawal/ Deposit of specified amounts may continue. If no PAN card is received, then no withdrawals in INR will be permitted. So that way, you have no deposits in INR over specified limits and you will not have any Withdrawals from peeps who do not have the required KYC/ AML. This is a model where you play entirely in unregulated space. Assuming that your legal strategy was to circulate money and free accounts within the 7 day deposit rule period, then that is not possible. You 'NEED' a quasi banking licence in order to accept INR deposits. I would advice you to look toward forming your own co-operative society bank for this. Co-operative banks have recently been granted further freedoms from the RBI and they look very promising for community/ local space banking and investments. luckyindia (from our forum) had proposed this model to me some time ago, but the regulations did not look as good as they do now. Please do message him to understand more. He has been a lifetime entrepreneur and loves to help. 2) A person hacks another bank account and transfers money to the exchange account, buys bitcoins and withdraws bitcoins. This is a huge issue. Thats what you hire Fraud and Risk people to deal with. Of course, you need to partner with few banks as well for this. This is a problem that even Flipkart face, so you need to seek guidance in Fraud and Risk. 3) Person deposits >50K without learning there needs to be PAN and while withdrawing, if we demand PAN while withdrawal of INR he might feel cheated. Many of international payment solution does similar to this. If you read point 1, then you will see that a single condition in your code can prevent this. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: buysellbitcoin on May 24, 2013, 10:23:58 AM Ok one more suggestion :
Try to open a testnet.... Let people register, Give them initial fake balance like 50k INR, and 100 fake BTC.. Let them trade.. Let them use system and know how it works. Let them withdraw fiat balance, let them withdraw fake BTC balance and see how it works... It will also serve as great testing ground for you. it will also serve as awesome trial for your trading engine. let people hack it in your testnet and you will know exactly what is the issue before it hurts you. it will also allow people to understand you, your system and it will build trust for your system at least. You will also be able to test your support channel efficiency and you will realize that its easy to setup a phone support for at least paying customer. If this idea gets viral and its hit, you owe us Pizaa delivered to our places :) Once again : Please do not put anything in hot wallet, it will get stolen...Two factor is more important than anything else. Spend all money you can to make sure your DNS is with provider whom you can trust, make sure your mail server is secure like (?) and has SPF records, I am sure you have dedicated server ( No VPS, dedicated is must with no hosting company management account ) and truecrypt installed there, you have offline backups in encrypted drives and internal messaging in your company is all PGP based, and above all you have death switch which will allow next competent official in your team access to cold wallet. Cheers Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 24, 2013, 10:59:58 AM Cant reserve more ;D I accept BTC at 1DZ24R5X4yvmvdAzj7TMnFqWBfv6KPDef5 for the above mentioned advice :p Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: drdanishkhan on May 24, 2013, 12:01:59 PM Finally some humour.. it was gettin intense.. :P
Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: buysellbitcoin on May 24, 2013, 12:05:21 PM Finally some humour.. it was gettin intense.. :P nah.. all Benson wants is BTC.. No fun intended :) Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 24, 2013, 12:06:23 PM Finally some humour.. it was gettin intense.. :P nah.. all Benson wants is BTC.. No fun intended :) OMFG.. That was supposed to be our secret! Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: drdanishkhan on May 24, 2013, 12:17:01 PM LOL..
Humour plus a friday mini rally.. ;D Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 24, 2013, 12:36:25 PM LOL.. Humour plus a friday mini rally.. ;D 129 and then bust to 109 :p Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 24, 2013, 12:50:45 PM I guess, most of the rules made after lobbying. Without some organization need for regulation and asking them for it, if we expect them to make public announcement, the wait would be forever. Call me on Monday!. I will let ya know 7000 ways that you guys can improve your business model. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 24, 2013, 12:59:52 PM Finally some humour.. it was gettin intense.. :P nah.. all Benson wants is BTC.. No fun intended :) If you were able to speculate on my accumulated BTC wealth, I would be impressed/ Shocked! Hardly 0.05% of my BTC is in Hard wallets :p, so that would mean that you either sold me BTC to find my ID, which is not the case or you know my cold wallet pub key, which is not the case as well. As I have never sold BTC 'ever' from my income wallets, I can be assured, that no one knows what I own. I do not need any more money. That sorted itself few years ago. I want a movement. I want a change. I want real true freedom and peace! I want free market that my children will prosper in; And I do mean better than others! I am also willing to fight for it like a true Anon! With code, discipline and true passion. And no, I cannot be traced :p. I may not be a text book lawyer, but I will sure put those bitches to shame ;0 Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: drdanishkhan on May 24, 2013, 04:29:04 PM Finally some humour.. it was gettin intense.. :P nah.. all Benson wants is BTC.. No fun intended :) If you were able to speculate on my accumulated BTC wealth, I would be impressed/ Shocked! Hardly 0.05% of my BTC is in Hard wallets :p, so that would mean that you either sold me BTC to find my ID, which is not the case or you know my cold wallet pub key, which is not the case as well. As I have never sold BTC 'ever' from my income wallets, I can be assured, that no one knows what I own. I do not need any more money. That sorted itself few years ago. I want a movement. I want a change. I want real true freedom and peace! I want free market that my children will prosper in; And I do mean better than others! I am also willing to fight for it like a true Anon! With code, discipline and true passion. And no, I cannot be traced :p. I may not be a text book lawyer, but I will sure put those bitches to shame ;0 sorta like a future hitman.. no traces.. whatsoever.. i like.. teach me o master benson ;D Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 25, 2013, 12:48:38 AM Ok one more suggestion : Try to open a testnet.... Let people register, Give them initial fake balance like 50k INR, and 100 fake BTC.. Let them trade.. Let them use system and know how it works. Let them withdraw fiat balance, let them withdraw fake BTC balance and see how it works... It will also serve as great testing ground for you. it will also serve as awesome trial for your trading engine. let people hack it in your testnet and you will know exactly what is the issue before it hurts you. it will also allow people to understand you, your system and it will build trust for your system at least. You will also be able to test your support channel efficiency and you will realize that its easy to setup a phone support for at least paying customer. If this idea gets viral and its hit, you owe us Pizaa delivered to our places :) Once again : Please do not put anything in hot wallet, it will get stolen...Two factor is more important than anything else. Spend all money you can to make sure your DNS is with provider whom you can trust, make sure your mail server is secure like (?) and has SPF records, I am sure you have dedicated server ( No VPS, dedicated is must with no hosting company management account ) and truecrypt installed there, you have offline backups in encrypted drives and internal messaging in your company is all PGP based, and above all you have death switch which will allow next competent official in your team access to cold wallet. Cheers +10 for sharing your competitive advantage! Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 25, 2013, 02:56:02 AM Hey ! icoinv
can i see the UI for your site. i really love to see how it is and how you have configured the trading platform for sellers and buyers. after which i will regester on your site and make a deposit. would 20,000/- deposit be fine in the beginning. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 25, 2013, 03:11:29 AM Hey ! icoinv can i see the UI for your site. i really love to see how it is and how you have configured the trading platform for sellers and buyers. after which i will regester on your site and make a deposit. would 20,000/- deposit be fine in the beginning. Deflection, Answer my Questions first! Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 25, 2013, 03:49:51 AM Hey ! icoinv can i see the UI for your site. i really love to see how it is and how you have configured the trading platform for sellers and buyers. after which i will regester on your site and make a deposit. would 20,000/- deposit be fine in the beginning. Deflection, Answer my Questions first! What question, your questions are irrelevant . Me first. I want to be the first to signup for this service and will then monopolize the entire market. open offer to iconiv. 10% of all profits to you if you show me the UI and if i like it is signup and become the dominant player in you exchange monopolizing every one . I will become rich and will buy a house with ten buffaloo, five horses, two cows and a rice field. i will be self sustained and will cut off from this world and live in a isolation. My dream. :-) oops i forgot and also a want a nice honey pot gift for icoinv website business they love it. they have one already. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 25, 2013, 04:30:52 AM Hey ! icoinv can i see the UI for your site. i really love to see how it is and how you have configured the trading platform for sellers and buyers. after which i will regester on your site and make a deposit. would 20,000/- deposit be fine in the beginning. Deflection, Answer my Questions first! What question, your questions are irrelevant . Me first. I want to be the first to signup for this service and will then monopolize the entire market. open offer to iconiv. 10% of all profits to you if you show me the UI and if i like it is signup and become the dominant player in you exchange monopolizing every one . I will become rich and will buy a house with ten buffaloo, five horses, two cows and a rice field. i will be self sustained and will cut off from this world and live in a isolation. My dream. :-) oops i forgot and also a want a nice honey pot gift for icoinv website business they love it. they have one already. no chappals for PW??? Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 25, 2013, 06:06:14 AM We are working hard in order to incorporate your suggestions\feedback into the site. Main focus is on more security features. I understand that some are keen in order to look into the platform. In order to have a sneak peek into the platform will be opening, we will soon open to login to the testnet. As suggested by buysellbitcoin. Once again thanks for suggestions. Looking forward to work with you in future. Hey how about just a screen shot. that would be fun. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 25, 2013, 11:35:01 AM Platform sneek peak: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SYxRjWz_R3Q&hd=1 Why does every thing inside you site look so fake. its like nothing works properly. a few tables nothing showing any sale and purchase, no graphs on the number of sale taking place no comparison chart. And are you for real, a freaking table, in a website.that is what you are using . My money is in, that this is just another Scam. and yes i am accusing you of a scam. Looks like some thing a fly by operator would be using to lure unsuspecting victims. Reasons for Scam Accusation :- 1. Website registered in a town in the middle of nowhere. 2. company registered under looks like a proprietorship, owned by some one else. 3. The person who says he is, is not identified. 4. There is no clear understanding of who the partners are in this venture. 5. Site registered under some one else name 6. The owner refuses to identify him self, and not provide any identification of him or his partners, but expects the customers to provide identifying documents in the start of the signup (Intel gathering) 7. As the owners refused to identify him self , there fore for customers to use this site is highly dangerous and potentially points in the direction of a scam. 8. People who made this site made it like a 5 year old kid making a website for the first time. 9. There is no visible indications in their video that this site can actually work as a exchange. 10.The site seems to be faulty and not in operation at the time of writing this. The site in the registration field behaves like a Intel gathering system rather than a customer signup form. registration does not go through but the file gets uploaded. (fishy) 11.The biggest problem is that there deposit address does not have a auto generate option, which means they never coded a wallet in the site.(biggest give off on the video that made me suspect that this is a scam) 12. site vulnerable to customers, (no verifiable ssl cert) 13. Site does not have password recovery options. 14. Site also does not provide any 2 factor auth Looks like some guy got a cheap web hosting and did not bother to even make it look convincing enough, then saying this is a minimalist design. Reporting to Mod for immediate action against the site before some one looses their money and bitcoins. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 25, 2013, 11:56:43 AM Easy man, i said wait till i provide with testnet platform to have a look. Clean up your act. put you sit down under maintenance. discuss with your so call partners. to have your details and information open for public scrutiny, get a working portal up and running , and then announce the release. the beta tests, you can do with the members here. till then i have placed the tag, up to the other mods to decide what to do .But you wanted a screen shot. Testnet will be provided, then I will take more feedback. you dont have the luxury to stay anonymous, when people will entrust you to keep their money while trading. and let security to laps. I want to trust you guys but it is getting harder every time. sorry . But the Scam Tag stays for now. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 25, 2013, 01:21:07 PM Reporting to Mod for immediate action against the site before some one looses their money and bitcoins. theymos guidelines are not to remove or do anything to possible scams. Scam accusations can be published under https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?board=83.0 and the community will arbitrate. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 25, 2013, 01:48:24 PM Cool would do that asap.
Edit :- is it ok i request this post to be unpinned. dont want any one to be caught in the dragnet. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 25, 2013, 01:51:43 PM Cool would do that asap. Edit :- is it ok i request this post to be unpinned. dont want any one to be caught in the dragnet. That sounds like a fair request until this gets sorted. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: IEA on May 26, 2013, 02:46:47 AM Who are you guys a little details will help . i really don trust "the fly by night operators. " same questionand not some crappy word about being a bitcoin believers and for the community crap . your supporting evidence is that, you guys are a registered company with your company details . office phone numbers, office address, list of partners, and your photographs. and do you have permission to run a bitcoin based business with the bank you are operating with ? Straight froward questions and require straight forward answers . Thanks :-) Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 27, 2013, 03:30:07 AM Any update on the testnet?
Would be awesome if this project kicked off. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 27, 2013, 05:39:46 AM i've been waiting for a proper response from these guys before i posted on the scam section . its been more than 24 hr still no updates or explanation . think its time for me to lay in the accusation now.
Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: buysellbitcoin on May 27, 2013, 05:43:57 AM i've been waiting for a proper response from these guys before i posted on the scam section . its been more than 24 hr still no updates or explanation . think its time for me to lay in the accusation now. Hi Subvolatil, I understand your concerns, but I feel its a bit too early too call them scam. Give them some more time. I know it will take some time for them to release testnet, at least a day or two. Posting a scam accusation at the moment will give them bad publicity without even starting. I believe you should give them some more time before going with scam accusation. But again, its my view and you can disagree with that. Cheers Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 27, 2013, 05:48:03 AM Hi Subvolatil, I understand your concerns, but I feel its a bit too early too call them scam. Give them some more time. I know it will take some time for them to release testnet, at least a day or two. Posting a scam accusation at the moment will give them bad publicity without even starting. I believe you should give them some more time before going with scam accusation. But again, its my view and you can disagree with that. Cheers The website is still up and OP has not responded since 25th. If this is a scam, then it is on the main India thread of the forums and I am getting a bit worried about it. I will add a Mod edit to the OP, but would be good if there was something moving forward to clear this up. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 27, 2013, 05:56:21 AM i've been waiting for a proper response from these guys before i posted on the scam section . its been more than 24 hr still no updates or explanation . think its time for me to lay in the accusation now. Hi Subvolatil, I understand your concerns, but I feel its a bit too early too call them scam. Give them some more time. I know it will take some time for them to release testnet, at least a day or two. Posting a scam accusation at the moment will give them bad publicity without even starting. I believe you should give them some more time before going with scam accusation. But again, its my view and you can disagree with that. Cheers For some strange reason i feel that a testnet is not coming up any time soon. and its not the test net i am concerned about i just want them to start acting in a truthful manner. They keep dodging questions, nothing they say matches the actual reality we see. I know we should give proper chances to indian businesses coming up, and i like to help every type of business related to bitcoin to be successful, my main fear is that a person new to bitcoin comes across this site signup and gets defrauded, then we get bad publicity . its our job to ensure fraud with bitcoin in India does not happen. Our job to clean up the bad rep we have in the world community . I will take your advise and will stop my self and add another 72 hours before i go ahead with the scam accusation. If they are ligit they will resort to a transparent business, if they are not then those who trust them, is in for a ride of their life. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 27, 2013, 06:02:15 AM Quote We are working on the testnet, there is some background work going on. There are few registered users who have registered on the existing site which is online and currently we cannot convert that to testnet, since the service would be disrupted. Just FYI, we have to buy some more servers inorder to host testnet and we are doing that, I will keep you posted. Need new server configuration for testnet etc etc. Will keep you all posted. Superstar! Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: buysellbitcoin on May 27, 2013, 06:03:33 AM Hi Subvolatil, I understand your concerns, but I feel its a bit too early too call them scam. Give them some more time. I know it will take some time for them to release testnet, at least a day or two. Posting a scam accusation at the moment will give them bad publicity without even starting. I believe you should give them some more time before going with scam accusation. But again, its my view and you can disagree with that. Cheers The website is still up and OP has not responded since 25th. If this is a scam, then it is on the main India thread of the forums and I am getting a bit worried about it. I will add a Mod edit to the OP, but would be good if there was something moving forward to clear this up. I agree that there should be more frequent updates and they should convey this on the site too, but come on its Monday morning and we should give them at least a decent amount of time to react. @icoinv, just a humble suggestion, Running exchange requires lot of trust from people. Try to earn that from this community and trust me people here are amazing to help you if you have right intentions and on right track. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: buysellbitcoin on May 27, 2013, 06:05:14 AM Hi Subvolatil, I understand your concerns, but I feel its a bit too early too call them scam. Give them some more time. I know it will take some time for them to release testnet, at least a day or two. Posting a scam accusation at the moment will give them bad publicity without even starting. I believe you should give them some more time before going with scam accusation. But again, its my view and you can disagree with that. Cheers The website is still up and OP has not responded since 25th. If this is a scam, then it is on the main India thread of the forums and I am getting a bit worried about it. I will add a Mod edit to the OP, but would be good if there was something moving forward to clear this up. We are working on the testnet, there is some background work going on. There are few registered users who have registered on the existing site which is online and currently we cannot convert that to testnet, since the service would be disrupted. Just FYI, we have to buy some more servers inorder to host testnet and we are doing that, I will keep you posted. Need new server configuration for testnet etc etc. Will keep you all posted. Great. keep us posted :) Cheers Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: buysellbitcoin on May 27, 2013, 06:07:01 AM We don't have a duty to help any business grow, we have a duty to make sure that only the right business can grow. On a side note, that was amazing line :) Cheers Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 27, 2013, 06:33:21 AM We don't have a duty to help any business grow, we have a duty to make sure that only the right business can grow. On a side note, that was amazing line :) Cheers buysellbitcoin You guys are doing an awesome job, keep up the good work. and in my books you are the right business . Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: nranjan on May 27, 2013, 08:48:30 AM What are your security measures? What percentage of funds are kept in cold storage? Do you intend to provide 2-factor authentication? What is cold storage? I have heard the terms hot wallet elsewhere, what are these two ? Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: buysellbitcoin on May 27, 2013, 08:58:06 AM What are your security measures? What percentage of funds are kept in cold storage? Do you intend to provide 2-factor authentication? What is cold storage? I have heard the terms hot wallet elsewhere, what are these two ? Hot wallet is the one which is hosted on computer with internet connection. Simple like the bitcoin client you have installed on your computer which is connected to internet and you are using it for your daily transactions or your blockchain.info account which is hosted there for you buy blockchain.info so that you can use it any time you want. It is convenient to have such wallet as you can use them for your transactions instantly. Same as rupees in your wallet. You can use them instantly. But this wallet are highly vulnerable to security risks and thefts. Same as your current Indian rupees wallet. So what you will do to resolve this, you will place your most of rupees in some isolated place where it is difficult for any one to find it or steal it. With bitcoins to resolve this issue you can take backup of your wallet.dat ( Your wallet ) in encrypted drive ( optional but highly recommended ), or on paper using some paper wallet generator ( You can use blockchain.info or Armory for this ) and store them in some safe place. Such wallets are known as offline wallets as normally they are stored in manner where they are not connected directly with internet. I hope this helps :) Cheers Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: americandesi on May 28, 2013, 07:28:49 PM THIS IS A TEST SYSTEM! The test system can be accessed from the below URL testnet.i-co.in This system is created for any of its users to take a look about our platform. Anybody can register to testnet.i-co.in Do NOT deposit BTC to your account in TEST system. BTC Withdrawals do NOT work. This system is different from https://i-co.in Exchange. This test system will be available for next few weeks. No real BTC will be traded, as soon as you register\log-in to your account, your account will have BTC's which are NOT real BTC balance and INR which are NOT real INR balance. Please report any issues\comments\feedback to support@i-co.in Throwing a 404 Page not found error.! I don't think the site has been uploaded properly.! Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: nagatlakshmi on May 29, 2013, 12:40:04 AM Good One.
Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 29, 2013, 01:33:48 AM I just edited post with the correct URL. http://testnet.i-co.in/testnet/demo/index.php Your login does not work. !!!! Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: ninjarobots on May 29, 2013, 07:15:15 AM Quote Not Acceptable! An appropriate representation of the requested resource could not be found on this server. This error was generated by Mod_Security. ??? Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 29, 2013, 07:40:40 AM Quote Not Acceptable! An appropriate representation of the requested resource could not be found on this server. This error was generated by Mod_Security. ??? Yeh that is some of the major problems they have on the system. Lag on the site. values changes , the changes are on the wallet value . (Serious) nothing is properly made. nothing is explained in the site. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: ninjarobots on May 30, 2013, 04:02:25 PM All TEST accounts are moved to different testnet and have been reset. https://i.imgur.com/3H5XjCl.jpg More Pics : http://imgur.com/a/EEtpy Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: ninjarobots on May 30, 2013, 05:06:50 PM I was banned? Auto Spam :o
Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: buysellbitcoin on May 30, 2013, 05:10:16 PM Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: ninjarobots on May 31, 2013, 06:35:27 AM I was banned? Auto Spam :o Banned from what? If its from registering and using the platform? No, you are not banned. We dont ban unless contempt of website user agreement. Report any issues to support@i-co.in buysellbitcoin Got banned on forum temp. now its restored. But icoinv does give error msg when signing up from TOR... That is why couldn't register.. figured this out and posted screenshots post registration! +0 for icoinv :-\ Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: buysellbitcoin on May 31, 2013, 06:37:11 AM I was banned? Auto Spam :o Banned from what? If its from registering and using the platform? No, you are not banned. We dont ban unless contempt of website user agreement. Report any issues to support@i-co.in buysellbitcoin Got banned on forum temp. now its restored. But icoinv does give error msg when signing up from TOR... That is why couldn't register.. figured this out and posted screenshots post registration! +0 for icoinv :-\ Actually I will give +1 for that TOR thing. Accessing exchange from TOR should not be allowed. But thats my view again :) Cheers Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: ninjarobots on May 31, 2013, 06:58:05 AM I was banned? Auto Spam :o Banned from what? If its from registering and using the platform? No, you are not banned. We dont ban unless contempt of website user agreement. Report any issues to support@i-co.in buysellbitcoin Got banned on forum temp. now its restored. But icoinv does give error msg when signing up from TOR... That is why couldn't register.. figured this out and posted screenshots post registration! +0 for icoinv :-\ Actually I will give +1 for that TOR thing. Accessing exchange from TOR should not be allowed. But thats my view again :) Cheers Agreed for a functional exchange makes total sense.. same view... :) But for testnet testing smth like icoinv a bit of caution/safety is needed. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 31, 2013, 11:27:36 AM just use a vpn service, Tor is any ways insure when it comes to exit nodes.
but the above posts does make my spidey sense tingle. Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: laserwolf on May 31, 2013, 04:24:08 PM just use a vpn service, Tor is any ways insure when it comes to exit nodes. but the above posts does make my spidey sense tingle. dude your spidey senses have been rattling for a few days now. how did you even detect the tingling? :D Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on May 31, 2013, 07:24:42 PM just use a vpn service, Tor is any ways insure when it comes to exit nodes. but the above posts does make my spidey sense tingle. dude your spidey senses have been rattling for a few days now. how did you even detect the tingling? :D Over sensitive paranoia . Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: Benson Samuel on May 31, 2013, 07:25:22 PM Quote Over sensitive paranoia . Pothead :p Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: subvolatil on June 01, 2013, 03:36:05 AM Quote Over sensitive paranoia . Pothead :p those are crackheads you referring to. We are the peace loving kind. singing near the rivers of Ganges, :P Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: americandesi on June 03, 2013, 04:51:25 AM Quote Over sensitive paranoia . Pothead :p those are crackheads you referring to. We are the peace loving kind. singing near the rivers of Ganges, :P oh really..? lol Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: buysellbitcoin on June 05, 2013, 10:57:58 AM Any updates ?
Title: Re: India's automated Bitcoin exchange Live! Post by: buysellbitcoin on July 19, 2013, 05:43:05 PM Since, the usage of the testnet (demo accounts) is almost NIL on our site from past month and not much new activity, we are sorry to announce that demo accounts would be suspended. In case there is requirement of demo accounts we will restore the demo accounts in the future. Can you publish trade volume etc data, for the exchange if it is not a trade secret. It will help everyone here to understand current Bitcoin market in India. If you can not, I can understand. Cheers |