Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Bitcoin Technical Support => Topic started by: BTCkur.com on December 06, 2017, 01:39:02 PM



Title: Priv Key is being used in multiple places/wallet
Post by: BTCkur.com on December 06, 2017, 01:39:02 PM
Is there anyway to know if your private key is being used in multiple wallets/platforms?

For example, if I have your priv key and imported that into my wallet, will you be able to know about it? unless I make a transaction of course.


Title: Re: Priv Key is being used in multiple places/wallet
Post by: AdolfinWolf on December 06, 2017, 01:43:14 PM
Is there anyway to know if your private key is being used in multiple wallets/platforms?

For example, if I have your priv key and imported that into my wallet, will you be able to know about it? unless I make a transaction of course.

No, i believe you won't. Since i could have your private key in an offline wallet aswell, until i sign a message or make a rawtransaction with it, you should/could not know if it is compromised or not.

Some desktop/web wallets might automatically make contact with a node, but that still shouldn't reveal you using private key X, as far as im aware. ( Unless you sign a transaction ofcourse.)


Title: Re: Priv Key is being used in multiple places/wallet
Post by: TryNinja on December 06, 2017, 04:04:41 PM
No. It's literally impossible to know something like that.

If you believe that someone may have access to your private key, create a brand new wallet in a safe environment and move your coins asap.


Title: Re: Priv Key is being used in multiple places/wallet
Post by: PublicCoin on December 07, 2017, 02:15:27 PM
Of course not. If you really my priv key and import that into your own wallet but do nothing else (not spend my coins), there is no way I can know about it.


Title: Re: Priv Key is being used in multiple places/wallet
Post by: malikusama on December 07, 2017, 07:19:09 PM
Is there anyway to know if your private key is being used in multiple wallets/platforms?

For example, if I have your priv key and imported that into my wallet, will you be able to know about it? unless I make a transaction of course.

No, i believe you won't. Since i could have your private key in an offline wallet aswell, until i sign a message or make a rawtransaction with it, you should/could not know if it is compromised or not.

Some desktop/web wallets might automatically make contact with a node, but that still shouldn't reveal you using private key X, as far as im aware. ( Unless you sign a transaction ofcourse.)
Although i never heard about the wallets automatically contacting nodes unless the transactions happens but of course if some wallets are automatically contacting the node that doesn't mean it will be revealed to the owning person.