Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Bitcoin Discussion => Topic started by: Eri on July 10, 2011, 11:59:00 AM



Title: Running bitcoin through TOR
Post by: Eri on July 10, 2011, 11:59:00 AM
Has anyone ever ran bitcoin through the TOR network? any thoughts or concerns?


Title: Re: Running bitcoin through TOR
Post by: timsmith on July 10, 2011, 12:12:46 PM
You can. I'm not sure it achieves a great deal. TOR is about trying to hide the fact that two points A and B are communicating. It makes it difficult to say that A definitely talked to B, or that B was talked to by A.

Bitcoin is a P2P protocol, and all you are transferring is block chain data. I'm not sure having an open connection to the TOR network looks any less 'suspicious' than participating in the Bitcoin P2P. It just means that instead of saying you are definitely looking at Bitcoin, you now have the possibility that you are looking at Bitcoin, or Silk Road, or warez, or kiddie porn, or all manner of other things that people use TOR for.

Assuming you definitely want to, I've tried it and it can be done. You just run TOR, and put the SOCKS proxy information into the Bitcoin client. There are several guides if you Google it.

But again, I don't think it achieves a great deal. You don't really 'log in' to the Bitcoin P2P network, you just participate in it. So unless you are planning on doing some dodgy purchases (at which point you probably need to remember that although the block chain is anonymous, it's also transparent, so any agency with an ounce of statistical hardware can just 'map' your transactions through the chain from your initial deposits to your eventual purchase), I don't think that you'll really gain anything from it. It will also waste the valuable resources of TOR on transferring the multi-megabyte block chain around.

My advice, don't bother.


Title: Re: Running bitcoin through TOR
Post by: titeuf_87 on July 10, 2011, 12:36:48 PM
The wiki has a page about tor (https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Tor).


Title: Re: Running bitcoin through TOR
Post by: Eri on July 10, 2011, 12:47:09 PM
what made me ask and probably should have mentioned this before, is that its possible and likely that china will block bitcoin if possible, so anyone would be able to run bitcoin over tor to hide the fact they are using it. but not sure it would be worth using/risking using it since it wouldn't work for person to person transactions if using bitcoins is illegal there at some point in the future. though I'm still interested in general opinions regarding it since i really haven't seen anyone mention TOR.