Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Bitcoin Discussion => Topic started by: phungus on July 11, 2011, 01:20:21 PM



Title: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: phungus on July 11, 2011, 01:20:21 PM
Apparently a lot of coins were dumped on MtGox just awhile ago.


http://bitcoinity.org/markets?exchange=mtgox


Is it related to this? https://forum.bitcoin.org/index.php?topic=16457.0


It's just speculation of course, but the timing of it after allinvain's hack, the number of coins involved, and the reckless way they were dropped on MTGox leads one to think... :-)



Title: Re: 20K Selloff on MTGox
Post by: RogerR on July 11, 2011, 01:28:29 PM
The alleged theft happened more than a month ago. I don't see any direct connection here at this time.


Title: Re: 20K Selloff on MTGox
Post by: phungus on July 11, 2011, 01:34:32 PM

No direct connection yet, but it seems unusual for such an amount to be sold at once, instead of in regular intervals. Everyone knows how the bitcoin markets are subject to wide price fluctuations. Someone who's been sitting on 20,000 coins for awhile (read: long time miner or pool op) will be withdrawing steadily, but not in huge numbers.

It reeks of illicit cash grab to me, just like what happened with MTgox a few weeks ago, but maybe this time it's laundered?


5K could have gone out in the wash to make those coins "clean". Who has the analytic skills to follow Allinvain's coins anyway?



Title: Re: 20K Selloff on MTGox
Post by: RogerR on July 11, 2011, 01:50:11 PM
Well, if you intend to sell 20k (btw - according to bitcoincharts it only were around 10k) without slowly driving the price down, there's nothing wrong per se to drop it into the market like that. The alternative would have been to place a 7.5k offer at $14.5 (10k - 2.5k of existing bids above $14.5), but that would have inevitably scared away other investors just as likely - possibly driving prices even below $14.

I think I would have done the same as this guy/gal. Besides - such drop-offs are better for the general market confidence than slow sell-offs. Nothing more annoying than a meandering bear market. At least when you have several 10k bids below to cushion the fall.


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: RogerR on July 11, 2011, 01:56:14 PM
Like this motherf*cker right there. 8.5k BTC at $14.20 with hardly anything the next $1.30.

Smells like bear trap, but surely gonna drop the market like a dead rabbit for a while.


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: proudhon on July 11, 2011, 01:58:33 PM
Like this motherf*cker right there. 8.5k BTC at $14.20 with hardly anything the next $1.30.

Smells like bear trap, but surely gonna drop the market like a dead rabbit for a while.

Wait, you mean no rally?


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: skyhigh on July 11, 2011, 02:07:56 PM
Someone dumped 20k and you come up with a thread saying it was possible hacked bitcoins. Where were you last time price dropped to $11.50  from $15.00 ? Was that another hacker or maybe same one. In the last 30 days since the alleged incident, we had 19 out of 30 days  volumes above 20k and somehow you think, hacker would dump it all today, causing a massive selloff from $15 to $14. Its not like we get this swings almost every single day. I understand this is a public forum and people can post whatever, but use some common sense.

Conclusion .. yes it must have been the hacker selling allinvain coins.


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: qwk on July 11, 2011, 02:12:11 PM
Conclusion .. yes it must have been the hacker selling allinvain coins.

Yeah, and he teamed with that crook from Hong Kong who hacked MtGox!


Title: Re: 20K Selloff on MTGox
Post by: FlyingFlapjack on July 11, 2011, 02:13:07 PM
It reeks of illicit cash grab to me, just like what happened with MTgox a few weeks ago, but maybe this time it's laundered?

Sure maybe, who knows, but I really don't think so.

There are plenty of miners who got in before Bitcoin was at even $5.

Somebody had a large ~10,000 coin 'buy wall' up at ~$15 yesterday.

The point of a 'buy wall' is not to buy 10,000 coins at $15, it's to force people who want to buy coins to pay more than $15 and help drive up the price.

However, it fails if somebody says 'wow, I can sell 10,000 coins for $15, that's $150,000...I can't leave that money on the table, I just have to do it!.' Then the guy with the 10,000 coin 'buy wall' now has bought 10,000 coins for $15 each.

Maybe it was one somebody who was an early adopter and has way more coins still. For that kind of guy, taking the cash when the opportunity presented itself while still having a lot of bitcoins is a great idea. Or maybe a speculator was able to get completely out. Who knows.

I don't know, either way it doesn't seem all that...unexpected, wild, crazy, suspicious or whatever to me.


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: Bitcoin Swami on July 11, 2011, 02:13:20 PM
Apparently a lot of coins were dumped on MtGox just awhile ago.


http://bitcoinity.org/markets?exchange=mtgox


Is it related to this? https://forum.bitcoin.org/index.php?topic=16457.0


It's just speculation of course, but the timing of it after allinvain's hack, the number of coins involved, and the reckless way they were dropped on MTGox leads one to think... :-)



Where do you get 20k from?  


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: Oldminer on July 11, 2011, 02:13:35 PM

Smells like bear trap,

Yea I was thinking the same


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: qikaifu on July 11, 2011, 02:14:32 PM
We just need another crash from 15$ to 9.5$ to wipe out the doubting Thomas.


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: Bitcoin Swami on July 11, 2011, 02:17:11 PM
I'm expecting a big bounceback any time now this seems to happen every day. lol


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: GeniuSxBoY on July 11, 2011, 02:37:05 PM
let me guess... gox is sleeping right now


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: MagicalTux on July 11, 2011, 02:38:42 PM
let me guess... gox is sleeping right now

Not sleeping right now, and not hacked coins.


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: GeniuSxBoY on July 11, 2011, 02:41:25 PM
yay!  ;)


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: skyhigh on July 11, 2011, 02:51:49 PM
MagicalTux, I would like to ask you something. If an early adopter who holds large number of coins, wants to sell approx 50-100k BTC, could he arrange it with you personally, that he/she would fly over to where ever you guys are and sell his/her coins on your exchange while being physically present at your office while the selling is in progress. They would show all the papers needed so everything is legit, passport, ID, whatever papers you need, bank accounts to where you would transfer the money.

Questions I have are..

1. Can they come to the office, hand you hdd with 100k coin on it and sell it on your exchange?

2. If you could then transfer the cash immediately from your exchange account to their bank account?


Thank you




Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: GeniuSxBoY on July 11, 2011, 02:58:16 PM
I hope that person knows he's not getting $14 for his bitcoins anymore and that might as well bring the price down to $13.


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: MagicalTux on July 11, 2011, 02:58:35 PM
MagicalTux, I would like to ask you something. If an early adopter who holds large number of coins, wants to sell approx 50-100k BTC, could he arrange it with you personally, that he/she would fly over to where ever you guys are and sell his/her coins on your exchange while being physically present at your office while the selling is in progress. They would show all the papers needed so everything is legit, passport, ID, whatever papers you need, bank accounts to where you would transfer the money.

Questions I have are..

1. Can they come to the office, hand you hdd with 100k coin on it and sell it on your exchange?

2. If you could then transfer the cash immediately from your exchange account to their bank account?


Thank you

Most of this is possible without problem, just contact me (admin@mtgox.com) for details.


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: RogerR on July 11, 2011, 03:08:27 PM
MagicalTux, I would like to ask you something. If an early adopter who holds large number of coins, wants to sell approx 50-100k BTC, could he arrange it with you personally, that he/she would fly over to where ever you guys are and sell his/her coins on your exchange while being physically present at your office while the selling is in progress. They would show all the papers needed so everything is legit, passport, ID, whatever papers you need, bank accounts to where you would transfer the money.

Questions I have are..

1. Can they come to the office, hand you hdd with 100k coin on it and sell it on your exchange?

2. If you could then transfer the cash immediately from your exchange account to their bank account?


Thank you

I seriously doubt you're planing to dump 50-100k into the market! Smart move though to announce something like that aforehand. Driving down the price for you to buy, buy, buy, eh?


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: GeniuSxBoY on July 11, 2011, 03:09:41 PM
Sadly, he didn't typo once. That means he's serious.


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: Savior on July 11, 2011, 03:12:23 PM
Now the 10k sell wall has shifted to 10k buy wall .. at 14 $ this one too.


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: RogerR on July 11, 2011, 03:14:26 PM
Now the 10k sell wall has shifted to 10k buy wall .. at 14 $ this one too.

Buy, Buy, Buy, Buy, Buy, Buy, Buy, Buy, Buy, Buy, Buy, Buy, Buy, Buy, Buy, Buy, Buy, Buy, Buy, Buy, Buy, Buy, Buy!

 ;D


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: Bitcoin Swami on July 11, 2011, 03:18:54 PM
I'm expecting a big bounceback any time now this seems to happen every day. lol

there's a bounceback.


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: qikaifu on July 11, 2011, 03:23:26 PM
One of the big player just show us his power.
So don't be crazy, everybody! Just calm down! The bitcoin is a long term game. You will be fucked by the big player if you do panic buying.

You can just buy slowly in the future months, if you want to invest into bitcoin.
Do NOT push the price up! if the price is high, just calm down, and wait until it fall back, then buy it at a low price.

Remember, always have some cash ready to buy. Don't buy it at once!


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: GeniuSxBoY on July 11, 2011, 03:39:48 PM
Today would have been a huge rally day since the world economy woke up with grim news.


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: cloon on July 11, 2011, 03:40:08 PM
One of the big player just show us his power.
So don't be crazy, everybody! Just calm down! The bitcoin is a long term game. You will be fucked by the big player if you do panic buying.

You can just buy slowly in the future months, if you want to invest into bitcoin.
Do NOT push the price up! if the price is high, just calm down, and wait until it fall back, then buy it at a low price.

Remember, always have some cash ready to buy. Don't buy it at once!
+1

you got it


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: Bitcoin Swami on July 11, 2011, 03:41:40 PM
Today would have been a huge rally day since the world economy woke up with grim news.

Days not over yet.


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: TraderTimm on July 11, 2011, 03:46:27 PM
Oh good, we haven't heard enough about this alleged theft already. I'm glad that we have the opportunity to drag this well-beaten-down subject out into the sunlight, with a dark cloud of flies swarming the maggot-infested corpse.

Executive summary: No proof, all speculation, pure drama.

Give it a rest.


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: tonto on July 11, 2011, 04:50:37 PM
One of the big player just show us his power.
So don't be crazy, everybody! Just calm down! The bitcoin is a long term game. You will be fucked by the big player if you do panic buying.

You can just buy slowly in the future months, if you want to invest into bitcoin.
Do NOT push the price up! if the price is high, just calm down, and wait until it fall back, then buy it at a low price.

Remember, always have some cash ready to buy. Don't buy it at once!

actually I'd rather people drive the price up to $50+/per btc. :)


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: grndzero on July 11, 2011, 05:10:29 PM
Yeah, and there was a big rally yesterday involving a whole lot of cash.

Cash rally one day ... Bitcoing sell off the next ... Coincidence?



Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: GeniuSxBoY on July 11, 2011, 05:58:58 PM
^well, the big buy was at $15


Wouldn't make sense to sell all the coins he bought at $15 for less than $15.


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: borgfish on July 11, 2011, 07:22:00 PM
well.

just check blockexplorer. difficulty for hashing a block was 1 until some block after 33000. So, 1.650000 coins have been mined with like 3 pcs.
Just Think about it. If BTC would be a success and skyrocket, we have a new bill gates...


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: grndzero on July 12, 2011, 05:12:58 AM
^well, the big buy was at $15


Wouldn't make sense to sell all the coins he bought at $15 for less than $15.

The price went up as high as 15.6.

Buy up a lot of coins at 15 sell at 15.5. Rally flails and price falls back.

Sell a lot of coins to start a downward slide, buy back at a bottom somewhere.

It would make sense, especially since a second rally was attempted at 15.5 and it died on the table.


Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: phungus on July 12, 2011, 02:48:08 PM

Yeah, sorry for making this thread. I see that it wasn't 20K after all.




Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: phungus on July 12, 2011, 02:49:48 PM

But hey, it got you all posting. :-)



Title: Re: 20,000 BTC Selloff on MTGox -- hacked bitcoins?
Post by: Phinnaeus Gage on July 12, 2011, 03:03:07 PM
MagicalTux, I would like to ask you something. If an early adopter who holds large number of coins, wants to sell approx 50-100k BTC, could he arrange it with you personally, that he/she would fly over to where ever you guys are and sell his/her coins on your exchange while being physically present at your office while the selling is in progress. They would show all the papers needed so everything is legit, passport, ID, whatever papers you need, bank accounts to where you would transfer the money.

Questions I have are..

1. Can they come to the office, hand you hdd with 100k coin on it and sell it on your exchange?

2. If you could then transfer the cash immediately from your exchange account to their bank account?


Thank you

Most of this is possible without problem, just contact me (admin@mtgox.com) for details.

In poker, when a bluffed hand is called, everyone gets to see the cards. I'm just saying. Nice call, Gox!