Bitcoin Forum

Source: https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/industry/banking/finance/banking/top-banks-suspend-accounts-of-major-bitcoin-exchanges-in-india/articleshow/62576882.cms


If this is true, Indian exchanges will soon turn into Mt. Gox. Get your funds out, while u still can.

yes its true news, people who not paid full tax to the government of india , they are taking strict action now. Because they transfer heavy amount daily



http://www.moneycontrol.com/news/business/cryptocurrency/top-banks-including-sbi-axis-icici-suspend-some-acs-of-major-bitcoin-exchanges-in-india-report-2487505.html


The total revenue of top ten exchanges in India could well be worth Rs 40,000 crore and they operate at margins greater than 20 percent, the ET reported citing sources.

This is the reason behind this. Why they charge 20% extra from normal rates?
another reason they operate multiple accounts to transfer the funds

The tax department also recently sent tax notices to tens of thousands of people dealing in cryptocurrency after a nationwide survey showed more than USD 3.5 billion (RS 2,234 crore) worth of transactions have been conducted over a 17-month period.

Its normal if you dont pay tax they will take some action. Same thing happens in south korea

Banks suspending accounts of private limited companies appear to be serious issue. May I expect Benson, Sathvik & Mahin to comment on this regarding their respective companies?

Yes that surely will help a little.

Few banks have started to take action and this is not a good sign as far as cypto market is concerned in the country. Even if you see govt stand is now getting more clearer than before. All this steps is curbing the use of btc and finally after the report it will be clear that it might not be allowed in the country and close down all the exchanges by giving them notices for the closure.

im just corious what if all people in the world encourage to use bitcoin..what will be the effect?

suspending or banning anything without any protest by people is a bad thing .

if traders have no issue and everyone pay their tax then why such actions ??

indian govt should regulate it , but must not ban it .

bitcoin is not a organisation running by any person , it is decentralized network .

many people in india do scam with others but i can see they roam happily in foreign .

but someone do trading in crypto , they have issue with that ..

please update the name of the exchanges !! whose bank accounts are stopped !! let not spread the FUD !!! YOU know this newspaper are at best to do it !! lets confirm about onground facts that did seriously exchange like zebpay !! stopped the payout !!

Indian bank accounts suspended created news all over world and market is reacting to this as well india is major contributor for bitcoin

Hey seriously, I haven't received any news about my bank account suspension.

Well, haven't heard any such news but it might be true since many exchanges and wallets are having withdrawal and deposit issues nowadays.

Benson and ZebPay Representative should comment here and clear the worries but i do not think these 2 exchange effected anyway as their service same as it was before . Just got Paid from Zebpay on time as usual .

really it is a very bad news. i didn't hear any news about it. only SBI, AXIS,HDFC, ICICI, YES Bank's only suspended the bitcoin exchanges what about other banks. i can operate through other bank's there is any issue. any one can able to clarify my doubt please.

Bank accounts being shut down for Indian exchanges is very bad for Bitcoin in general. This can result in:

1) Fear among Indian investors that there money might get trapped when the bank accounts are locked. As a result they will take out the money even in loss.

2) New Indian investors will not invest in Bitcoins due to same fear. Demand for Bitcoins will decrease and thus prices will drop. Loss for current investors worldwide.

Much ado about nothing

It's just formality sake

To prove that everything is going OK

This might be due to the pressure put by Indian government. It may be due to following reasons:

1) Government tried to prevent tax evasion by sending notices to Bitcoin investors. But a lot of people might be using KYC of other people like their servants.

2) It is hard to shut down the exchanges til proper laws are made regarding this. At such, suspending their bank accounts is only way to stop these exchanges.

Well, i was able to transfer the money from Zebpay to my ICICI bank easily on 23rd Jan. There was no issue at all.
Even if the banks stop it, people can still do it for cash. India is a developed market now for Crypto.

What will happen to their employees? One of my friend working in one of them.

If you use the KYC documents of your servants, it is a case of downright fraud. There is a paper trail and if your servant gets a IT notice, you know where the trail will lead to. There are strict laws against Benami transactions.

If the government decides to shut down exchanges, they can do so easily through a notification. They would not want to be hasty in passing laws, especially in a complex area like cryptocurrencies, but they still have the ability to shut down exchanges.

A few years back, raids from the ED resulted in exchanges being shut down.
https://www.theverge.com/2013/12/27/5248942/indian-feds-raid-bitcoin-exchange-as-other-traders-suspend-service
http://www.thehindu.com/business/Industry/bitcoin-exchanges-shut-shop-in-india/article5504407.ece

This bit of news is significant and as many have stated before me, I would expect Benson and representatives of other exchanges to comment on it. There is nothing on the Coinsecure blog as well...

Latest update on this news: https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/industry/banking/finance/banking/bank-crackdown-takes-a-toll-on-bitcoin-trading/articleshow/63324854.cms

I was also able to transfer the money from zebpay to SBI bank on 26th Feb without any issue.

Suspending bank accounts is not the solution..

Did banks forgot that bitcoin can be bought with cash in a nearby ATM ?

There is no Bitcoin ATM in India.

I think that you are living in USA or Japan country that is why you are commenting about bitcoin ATM, when all of them know that their is no debit card for Indian users and their is no Bitcoin ATM.

But still i have seen lot of my friends accounts are got blocked from their respective bank and when asked they just gave reason of cryptocurrency trading but some friends who have doing trading and even showing transaction in IT so they just showed all details and their accounts got cleared and they are now able to trade. So this should be problem with illegal money users who are trading to evade tax.

India hold Neutral Status in cryptocurrency but govt consider it as commodity and asset  class investment where we need to pay capital gains but banks considering as threat is very surprising instead of taking it as growth and technology adoption they are giving warning for newbies

Even till today there has been no problem in transferring money from any exchange site to any Indian Bank and i am sure in future also it will not be a problem.

All the more reason why we need decentralized exchanges!