|
Title: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: Foxpup on February 10, 2018, 12:39:26 PM There's currently far too much focus being placed on the new merit system and not enough on its opposite: the old reliable report system. It was expected that meriting good posts would reduce the need to report bad posts; however, this does not appear to have happened yet:
Quote You have reported 5398 posts with 100% accuracy It's time to see how the other grizzled reporters are doing. Post your stats! Theymos, compile the Top 50 list! I want to see numbers, people! ;D Previous Top 50 list: All time: Code: +--------------------+-------+-----+-----------+----------+ Last 120 days: Code: +---------------------+------+-----+-----------+----------+ Thanks a lot to all active reporters! Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: Jet Cash on February 10, 2018, 12:48:05 PM I'm just a baby at this. My old school reports used to say " Could try harder", maybe this is still true. :)
Quote You have reported 7 posts with 100% accuracy http://bigsig.com/s/jet-sig.png Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: DooMAD on February 10, 2018, 01:03:56 PM I never realised people were using it that much, I should probably pay more attention to Meta. This is quite the eye-opener for me. Looks like I've only done 13 in the four-and-a-bit years I've been here. 100% accuracy, but that seems decidedly less impressive when 13 is such a tiny fraction of the times other people have reported bad posts. I'll make an effort to report more often going forward.
Kudos to all those being more rigorous than I am. Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: LeGaulois on February 10, 2018, 03:35:29 PM 576 posts with 99% accuracy
Hard to reach the 100%, sorry Mods if sometimes I waste your time :D Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: isaevaen on February 10, 2018, 04:21:30 PM I am surprised to see this really. Never thought that so many members are using report button for posts.
Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: LoyceV on February 10, 2018, 06:28:00 PM I never realised people were using it that much, I should probably pay more attention to Meta. This is quite the eye-opener for me. Theymos' last reported stats served as my eye-opener. I already had hundreds of reports.It's time to see how the other grizzled reporters are doing. Post your stats! I'm not sure how useful it is to fill a thread with stats, but here's mine* anyway:Code: You have reported 1961 posts with 98% accuracy * Please don't report me :D Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: MadZ on February 10, 2018, 06:37:51 PM 155 with 97% accuracy, y'all are putting me to shame.
Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: Welsh on February 10, 2018, 06:50:36 PM Code: 20202 posts with 100% accuracy Although, it isn't 100% accurate, rather it's rounded up. It would be nice if something could be implemented to show this sort of stat permanently to the public as it seems there's enough interest in it to justify it. Also I asked Lutpin recently if he ever won the race to 20k with Shorena but, he hadn't reached it yet. Seems Shorena wasn't active for a few months too, but he may have reached it. Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: jointherevolution on February 10, 2018, 09:00:21 PM This is really a thing? There's a competition about who reports the most abuse posts?
Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: Vod on February 10, 2018, 09:24:08 PM This is really a thing? There's a competition about who reports the most abuse posts? A friendly competition, yes. It's a good thing as the mods can't be everywhere at once. :) Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: LeGaulois on February 10, 2018, 10:28:06 PM This is really a thing? There's a competition about who reports the most abuse posts? A friendly competition, yes. It's a good thing as the mods can't be everywhere at once. :) I don't see it as a "friendly competition" I see it as a punishment for wasting my time :P. Most of my reports are about threads in a wrong section or users copy-pasting. I hate wasting my time reading posts that I have already read on another website, or reading spam topics on a pump and dump telegram channel. The only board I don't report is my local board, it's not moderated at all, the guy doesn't care much (he post once per month or less, last time was to say oh I see the merits system :D :D) He only waits the members to report and as no one report, no one moderate (members got tired to report for nothing and seeing the guy is inactive) To give you an exemple, you go to the dev section and you find a topic about how to find a bounty campaign LOL. Bitcoin section is mixed with altcoin, members introduction and so on... We can't always put the spoon in the mouth if he doesn't make an effort Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: Welsh on February 10, 2018, 10:43:13 PM The only board I don't report is my local board, it's not moderated at all, the guy doesn't care much (he post once per month or less, last time was to say oh I see the merits system :D :D) He only waits the members to report and as no one report, no one moderate (members got tired to report for nothing and seeing the guy is inactive) To give you an exemple, you go to the dev section and you find a topic about how to find a bounty campaign LOL. Bitcoin section is mixed with altcoin, members introduction and so on... We can't always put the spoon in the mouth if he doesn't make an effort Should either speak to him about it, or contact theymos. If there's enough spam to justify moderation then you'll need an active moderator to deal with it. I'm sure theymos will check whether the mods 1. active 2. if the thread needs either another mod, or replace the current one. 576 posts with 99% accuracy Hard to reach the 100%, sorry Mods if sometimes I waste your time :D With a report accuracy at 99% you certainly aren't wasting anyones time. Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: otrkid70 on February 10, 2018, 10:51:42 PM The only board I don't report is my local board, it's not moderated at all, the guy doesn't care much (he post once per month or less, last time was to say oh I see the merits system :D :D) He only waits the members to report and as no one report, no one moderate (members got tired to report for nothing and seeing the guy is inactive) To give you an exemple, you go to the dev section and you find a topic about how to find a bounty campaign LOL. Bitcoin section is mixed with altcoin, members introduction and so on... We can't always put the spoon in the mouth if he doesn't make an effort Should either speak to him about it, or contact theymos. If there's enough spam to justify moderation then you'll need an active moderator to deal with it. I'm sure theymos will check whether the mods 1. active 2. if the thread needs either another mod, or replace the current one. 576 posts with 99% accuracy Hard to reach the 100%, sorry Mods if sometimes I waste your time :D With a report accuracy at 99% you certainly aren't wasting anyones time. Accuracy? Try reporting threads in Politics and Society.(One of my Favorite Areas of the forum) Your Accuracy will drop to shit......watch as the threads remain even though they are shit and have nothing to do with the topic. I have reported so many only to be ignored and watch my accuracy drop. That Area has become off topic and i don't visit it anymore. So sad. Piss poor Moderating in that section that's for sure. Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: TheBeardedBaby on February 10, 2018, 10:59:21 PM I'm fairly new to the community
Code: You have reported 28 posts with 100% accuracy Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: Welsh on February 10, 2018, 11:00:55 PM Accuracy? Try reporting threads in Politics and Society.(One of my Favorite Areas of the forum) Your Accuracy will drop to shit......watch as the threads remain even though they are shit and have nothing to do with the topic. I have reported so many only to be ignored and watch my accuracy drop. That Area has become off topic and i don't visit it anymore. So sad. Piss poor Moderating in that section that's for sure. I don't spend any time in the politics and society board anymore. Most of the things which need to be discussed have already been discussed throughly and any major events that need to be discussed I will read at other sites. Spam is spam at the end of the day and should be easily identifiable most of the time. Taking a look at someones post history and including a note in the report field can sometimes help if they are posting the same thing over and over. Although, I agree some sections are easy than others for example, most of my reports these days are from the altcoin section and it's very easy to keep your percentage up when there's hundreds of posts which consist of the same spam. Though, it's still painful to sort through and report them all. What's your accuracy? Anything over 60% is considered good AFAIK. I'm fairly new to the community Good job!Code: You have reported 28 posts with 100% accuracy Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: otrkid70 on February 10, 2018, 11:05:47 PM Accuracy? Try reporting threads in Politics and Society.(One of my Favorite Areas of the forum) Your Accuracy will drop to shit......watch as the threads remain even though they are shit and have nothing to do with the topic. I have reported so many only to be ignored and watch my accuracy drop. That Area has become off topic and i don't visit it anymore. So sad. Piss poor Moderating in that section that's for sure. I don't spend any time in the politics and society board anymore. Most of the things which need to be discussed have already been discussed throughly and any major events that need to be discussed I will read at other sites. Spam is spam at the end of the day and should be easily identifiable most of the time. Taking a look at someones post history and including a note in the report field can sometimes help if they are posting the same thing over and over. Although, I agree some sections are easy than others for example, most of my reports these days are from the altcoin section and it's very easy to keep your percentage up when there's hundreds of posts which consist of the same spam. Though, it's still painful to sort through and report them all. I'm fairly new to the community Good job!Code: You have reported 28 posts with 100% accuracy I disagree. Politics and Society are ever changing Day to Day so should that Sub Forum. You Can never cover it all. The world is too vast and too much going on to cover it all or discuss it all. I enjoyed the Debates and discussions there about the World Happenings From people in the specific area. Such a great area it was. Sad to see it has gone to shit.....Now i have to visit Reuters.com to get my world info ....And it's not from the people of said countries :-\ Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: Welsh on February 10, 2018, 11:08:22 PM In theory. But, these discussions don't happen anymore. The board doesn't have a dedicated moderator, so maybe theymos would be willing to add one to clear up the mess. We all know that the politics and society has been a mess for awhile. Hilariousandco has mentioned it a few times in the past.
Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: otrkid70 on February 10, 2018, 11:11:11 PM In theory. But, these discussions don't happen anymore. The board doesn't have a dedicated moderator, so maybe theymos would be willing to add one to clear up the mess. We all know that the politics and society has been a mess for awhile. Hilariousandco has mentioned it a few times in the past. That would be Nice! I find myself limited to just Meta board these days. The rest of the forum is just not even worth clicking on anymore. Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: Welsh on February 11, 2018, 12:41:06 AM In relation to reports, @theymos could we get some statistics on how many reports are made a day, and how many of them are bad/good reports? It would be interesting to know how many reports the staff are having to deal with on a day to day basis.
Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: r1s2g3 on February 11, 2018, 03:37:22 AM Sorry for my ignorance, How can I find this. (because I reported few, but I do not know outcome. If it is part of user stats then I get message like user stats are disabled for this user) Last time instead of reporting the posts, I actually reported the user in PM to moderator. I got below in reply. Cleaned up his threads, thanks for the heads up. Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: The Sceptical Chymist on February 11, 2018, 03:53:58 AM I, too, would like to see an updated reporting report. Before the merit system was introduced, I think I was spending more time searching for shitposts than actually posting here. And as you can imagine, the garbage posts were not hard to find. They were (and still are to some extent) everywhere. My report count is now something like 3000 with an accuracy of 98%, I think.
Hilariousandco handled a lot of the spammers I reported, and I am grateful for that. It's nice when you suddenly see someone get busted back down to brand new because a mod deleted all of their shitposts. I've been reporting a lot fewer posts now that we have the merit system--and I feel much less stress these days, too. *Whew* Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: suchmoon on February 11, 2018, 04:51:07 AM What I would really like to see is some feedback on which of my reports were good, bad, or ignored. As it stands now, I report egregious (in my opinion) serial posters and wall-quoters and off-topic spammers and a week later the posts are still there. Sometimes I'm not even sure if I reported them since there is no way to check so I might be reporting the same ones again.
Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: jademacoy on February 11, 2018, 05:46:11 AM Yeah this all we need to avoid some members who created two or more accounts just get more project in bounty campaign. These are greedy members who were actually milking the system. It should be reported to the moderator so that we could help promote the healthy environment for the system. Yet, in dealing with these reports we must also consider that some of the members here are not too good in grammar construction. The thoughts must be consider in reporting to a post or somehow their should be any guide on how and when to report post. I hope that I could see some threads regarding on how to report post. Since I am newbie here, I am still have a lot of research to do and I am also interested in the cryptocurrency that one day I might have.
Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: Foxpup on February 11, 2018, 06:24:22 AM Code: 20202 posts with 100% accuracy I've been reporting a lot fewer posts now that we have the merit system--and I feel much less stress these days, too. *Whew* Really? Because that's not been my experience at all. The merit system seems to have made no difference for me whatsoever.Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: greeklogos on February 11, 2018, 06:40:03 AM This is really a thing? There's a competition about who reports the most abuse posts? A friendly competition, yes. It's a good thing as the mods can't be everywhere at once. :) I don't see it as a "friendly competition" I see it as a punishment for wasting my time :P. Most of my reports are about threads in a wrong section or users copy-pasting. I hate wasting my time reading posts that I have already read on another website, or reading spam topics on a pump and dump telegram channel. Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: Welsh on February 11, 2018, 10:08:56 AM Hilariousandco handled a lot of the spammers I reported, and I am grateful for that. It's nice when you suddenly see someone get busted back down to brand new because a mod deleted all of their shitposts. I've been reporting a lot fewer posts now that we have the merit system--and I feel much less stress these days, too. *Whew* I'm still reporting the same amount of reports that I was before it was introduced, but the merit system has been effective in a way. It's made the forum overall a better place to browse as there's more users trying to make good posts, though the altcoin section and a few others are still littered with spam. Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: actmyname on February 11, 2018, 10:17:28 AM "You have reported 329 posts with 91% accuracy".
I feel like I might be off/too strict with my models. I'm also wondering, though, if moderators investigate more deeply into the post (i.e. context) because sometimes I do mention that the statement has already been made earlier in the thread. (typical recycled post garbage). I believe a lot more spam megathreads should be just cut off and deleted. I still see too many. Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: TheQuin on February 11, 2018, 10:54:01 AM "You have reported 265 posts with 100% accuracy"
I seem to be reporting slightly less since the merit system came in. That's just anecdotal though as others have already said the opposite. It would be interesting if there are statistics for how many posts are deleted by moderators as a whole and if there has been any change. Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: Vod on February 11, 2018, 10:58:35 AM Sorry for my ignorance, How can I find this. Click on the "Report to Moderator" link at the bottom right of any post. That will tell you how many posts you have reported, and your accuracy. :) Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: Thirdspace on February 11, 2018, 12:35:52 PM I noticed there is mixed feeling on reporting, some feel more and some feel less after the merit system introduced.
report stats before and after "January 24" might give us some ideas on relations between post behaviours, merits and spam reports Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: InvoKing on February 12, 2018, 06:22:59 PM Post your stats! I am not an active reporter nor will be tho, just reporting bot's topic mainly. Code: You have reported 356 posts with 100% accuracy Theymos, compile the Top 50 list! I want to see numbers, people! ;D BumpTitle: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: pugman on February 12, 2018, 06:38:07 PM Even I'd like to see the stats.
Anyhow,my reports have been so bad,I hardly report at all. :/ Here it is: Code: You have reported 26 posts with 95% accuracy Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: LTU_btc on February 12, 2018, 11:51:03 PM Shameful stats:
Code: You have reported 46 posts with 98% accuracy Now I got more motivation to report posts more active. It's impressive to see report stats posted here. It's great to see many members who cares much about bitcointalk and spending lot of hours to make this forum to a better place. Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: The Sceptical Chymist on February 13, 2018, 12:12:54 AM I noticed there is mixed feeling on reporting, some feel more and some feel less after the merit system introduced. Yah, I definitely report fewer posts now that we have the merit system, but I'm not reporting zero. report stats before and after "January 24" might give us some ideas on relations between post behaviours, merits and spam reports I'm of the mind that shitposters are eventually going to get the message that it's near impossible to rank up without buying merit points, and that they'll give up. That might take some time, and I'm not even 100% confident that's what will happen, but I'll be patiently watching. I was furiously reporting posts prior to the merit system being introduced, as I was just so frustrated at how many there were. After that I started tagging the shitposters. Now that it takes so much work to rank up, I've kind of developed a sense of serenity that only comes with the knowledge that the shitposter issue will resolve itself naturally. I'm hoping that's what's going to happen. And although I'm still seeing idiotic pajeet shitposts, I'm definitely seeing a lot of users making longer, more coherent posts that obviously took more effort than is normally put into posting here. That's a joy to see. Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: Welsh on February 13, 2018, 12:19:51 AM That's wishful thinking The Pharmacist. Shitposters will continue shitposting it's what they are best at, but the system does prevent them from progressing and if theymos implements a system to only show merited posts on a topic it might mean those who only want a see the most constructive and relevant points can without shifting through rubbish replies.
It might just be me, but I find reporting posts and contributing that way to be quite therapeutic. Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: wwzsocki on May 24, 2019, 03:51:10 PM I have already made 2500+ reports with 100% accuracy and I am not on the list. https://i.imgur.com/ZHO8xNB.png After I have written this post I found that quoted post from Theymos is dated 2017 so everything is correct. I started to report spam and abuse during the bull market when the amounts of spam on the forum were overwhelming and that was after 2017. Sorry for the misunderstanding. Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: DireWolfM14 on May 24, 2019, 03:58:16 PM I think these stats are outdated... Well, this thread is over 15 months old, and the OP hasn't been updated. So yeah, it's safe to assume the data is outdated. Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: Bitlover10 on May 24, 2019, 03:59:50 PM This is my report status :-
Quote You have reported 127 posts with 100% accuracy (125 good, 0 bad, 2 unhandled). Do not worry about your accuracy too much; one accurate report is worth many inaccurate reports. Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: Last of the V8s on May 24, 2019, 04:00:48 PM https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5058163.0
they're using this thread to showcase their stats Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: The Cryptovator on May 24, 2019, 04:32:01 PM Here is my little efforts,
https://i.imgur.com/8pyMsMt.png Wondering when admin will implement "Reporter Badge" ??? Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: LoyceV on May 24, 2019, 04:36:33 PM Wondering when admin will implement "Reporter Badge" ??? I don't expect it any time soon anymore:I'll probably add it next week sometime. Sorry for the wait, when I went to implement this it ended up being quite a bit more of a can of worms than I originally thought Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: LFC_Bitcoin on May 24, 2019, 04:40:00 PM Code: You have reported 1116 posts with 99% accuracy (1089 good, 13 bad, 14 unhandled). Do not worry about your accuracy too much; one accurate report is worth many inaccurate reports. I don’t report that much but the above are my stats. Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: Lafu on May 24, 2019, 04:42:16 PM And i will post mine too just for the Statistics :D
Code: Bitcoin Forum > Your reports Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: lobcmt2 on May 24, 2019, 11:56:18 PM More statistics on this, in turn might cause more analytical topics on this one in Meta board, which already burried by Ban Appeals and analytical updates :D
I don't think we need more stats on this (Report to moderator), if Report badges will be lively applied. If we can keep it simple, statistics can be displayed simply through reporter badges, we should stick to the approach. The ideas onSeeking reporter badge images (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=4742257.0), raised in June of 2018, by theymos caught lots of attention, interest, suggestions (suggested reporter badge collection) from forum community, but by now there is no confirmation from theymos that it has been on top of his to-do list and will be implemented soon. Title: Re: It's time for more "report to moderator" stats! Post by: bitart on May 29, 2019, 08:34:15 PM Here is my little efforts, Nice stats :)https://i.imgur.com/8pyMsMt.png Wondering when admin will implement "Reporter Badge" ??? Don't worry about the Reporter Badge, it's on the TODO list of Theymos :) So it will just appear sometime somewhere in your profile or under your avatar :) |
