Bitcoin Forum

Etherdelta are struggling with issues from two weeks and aren't reacting at all.

Today Coinmarketcap.com changes EtherDelta with ForkDelta in their Market list tab. This will cost EtherDelta most of the remaining traffic.

What do you think? Is ED dead now or they will recover eventually?

It looks weird to see etherdelta died after the developer of etherdelta collection million dollars from ico. But fork delta is not 100% trustworthy in my opinion. I was prefer to use idex exchange rather thgan fork delta but it looks forkdelta is very similar to the etherdelta. I think etherdelta will be died forever. The only possible thing the developer will try to rebrand etherdelta to the new platform.

etherdelta does is annoying, the buy and sell order is not updated. the withdrawal process is sometimes difficult and must pay several times the gas to process the withdrawal, this is what makes me switch to forkdelta. etherdelta may take time to fix all the problems, but if the developer is serious and still want the exchange live.

As much as I want decentralized exchanges and promoting them I am not really a fan of Etherdelta since before. Too slow and too many issues unsolved. Maybe it is better to close it. I haven't tried yet this ForkDelta but I hope this is way better and is an improved version of EtherDelta.

I am not a fan of Etherdelta, but obviously its  one of the used exchange for erc20 tokens.

What will be the remaining tokens in the stock market? Will we be able to get it back? I have a lot of tokens inside and I do not want to open Forkdelta.
Because i'm afraid of hacking my wallets :(

Etherdelta has so many bad issues with these forkdelta I dont know yet if this is good exchange. Maybe in etherdelta they will recover from slow transactions. Has someone here used forkdelta already? In this exchange is good to use?

Never liked Etherdelta. I was waiting that they will make it work perfect after collecting from ICO that much but looks like they don't have any interest on upgrading site

Maybe we should see it for ourselves if this one is a good one however nobody wants to take risk their coins. But one of my friends had already used it and he said that his transaction went smoothly and I just hope this will continue so etherdelta will rest in peace.

Then this might be useful to you  - how to withdraw your tokens directly from MEW, without opening forkdelta:

https://deeponion.org/community/threads/instructions-on-how-to-withdraw-your-token-on-etherdelta.21307/

Forkdelta are sharing the same contract with etherdelta.

I have recently met Forkdelta, I will observe a time to see if it is reliable and people speak well about it. Before I used Etherdelta at specific moments, for tokens that have just been released to the market or if there was something quite cheaper than in other exchanges. Now that Etherdelta doesn't work, I will try to try IDEX or Forkdelta for these cases, but I'll wait some time.

Absence of EtherDelta we needed another decentralized exchange, I think ForkDelta will fill in the blank.
I didn't try the Idex.market yet, I'll check it too.

Yep. I wish etherdelta died. Actually this is a bad deal. It cost me a lot of money. and everyone. It was no longer listed at CMC. hope it will die forever

I think it will be over in the nearest time. Developers can not do anything to save this coin, so it will be sad end for ethereumdelta

I felt EtherDelta was always the perfect place to buy post-ICO tokens/coins. Last few months especially great, since many tokens were below ICO price at ED. IDEX is more user friendly, but it also attracts way more people, which causes prices to increase faster (I think at least).

Did a few buys through ForkDelta. It is the same as ED in terms of usability.

So I understand correct, what would make ForkDelta a risk? What made EtherDelta a risk? Isn't every transaction a risk, even from reputable exchanges?

I don't know whether it is dead or not but is really good for crypto someone fork it and offer better platform. This is why decentralized exchanges will be the future, it is open source and decentralized but as you can see it is not enough.

Its so sad to think Etherdelta to be dead. I've been trading there for some time and honestly speaking I earned a great deal there. That hacking issues that happened last year shocked me and luckily was not hacked. Still hoping they will get it back to business again. And fix security issues to attract new traders again.

I don't think EtherDelta will just die like that, they are well capitalised because their ICO collect million of USD recently and I think mostof the money is to develop and improve their platform, I will still give them benefit of the doubt. I will not touch ForkDelta until they have significant number of transaction on the exchange

This question also worries me. I have a lot of coins on the balance of the eserdelta. Looks like I need to urgently solve this problem.

they just tweeted regarding their API issues, i think it will take some time to put things back how they used to be. I hope they can resolve things and atleast make their user interface a lot friendly user  :D

Here is a link I did use for withdraw my tokens and ETH from EtherDelta: https://www.reddit.com/r/KinFoundation/comments/7l6lgc/guide_on_removing_tokens_from_etherdelta_during/

if its dead, a lot of user have private key in etherdelta,  is stil save? i hope team etherdelta read this and make some movement..

Is ED really dead? I want to start trade on them too long  ;D
Sorry, guys, FD better? Do not waste my time on ED, isn't it? How did you think?

İ think etherdelta not dead. will be ok soon , delta has a good potential , but fork delta good too. we will se soon who is better :)

the two exchanges are exactly the same. both slowly and the same token. the same safety or uncertainty. both projects are not that good. only for scam token suitable.

I think private keys aren't stored in ED database. If that's the case then it's quite risky. It might get hacked by some 3rd party. Etherdelta was a good decentralised exchange but the new team completely ruined it's past glory by launching some kind of ICO and compromising on security.

Where to go? Forkdelta better? Which volumes and how many order? Are you know? Because on ED last time nothing to see. How to trade on it? Hard, very hard

I think etherdelta will able to solve of their problems eventually it's just that right now they are facing major problems when it comes to their system but, to be short etherdelta will stay alive and won't close .

i will not trade on forkdelta. seems to suspicious to me.

Nobody have private keys there... ED is not saving it. You are using the private key to operate over ED contract.

If you still have tokens in ED, here is a tutorial how to withdraw it:

https://www.reddit.com/r/KinFoundation/comments/7l6lgc/guide_on_removing_tokens_from_etherdelta_during/

it's very sad to hear about it!
but If I had a coins of EtherDelta , how can I transfer it back now? I hope there is some I some way to get coins back?

Maybe you just should read what is written in least the last post before your's...

If etherdelter eventually died what then will happen to the funds of some people in their possession. Despite the fact that i usually find it difficult to trade on etherdelter i still have some amount of money in my etherdelter account.

Oh dear
502 Bad gateway

Well people were warned

Forkdelta is much faster and more convenient than EtherDelta. I'm sure you'll do better than Etherdelta. I think Coinmarketcap has made the right decision

But the only question, Does fork delta is more trustworthy rather than ED? I guess there are so many people are still thinking about that right now. The fact that the forkdelta gains its momentum through make a backup exchange site after etherdelta gets fucked up.




Are you looking for this? https://coinmarketcap.com/exchanges/forkdelta/

i think forkdelta same founder with etherdelta
because interface and all system same with etherdelta, and buy wall and sell order in forkdelta same price and same quantity with etherdelta

Forkdelta now become more popular and etherdelta is letf by their customer.
Etherdelta has so many problem but you have mention the above the big main problem. Its also very slow and need to improve soon before all customer left.

I do not care about ED, too disappointed.
My hope is there is a better exchange of ED. may fork delta be the answer, but there is no clear information. I'm waiting for people to say about Forkdelta.

I had some sell orders in low volume tokens there, is there any way to recover or did I lose them already?

I think all the exchange can be a scam when the lack of funds not just etherdelta. Moreover, the crypto market condition is uncertain. But that's just a possibility

so far i use etherdelta and there is no problem when i use it.
I have never tried forkdelta and I do not yet know how it works.
do etherdelta and forkdhelta have in common?

I also have never used forkdhelta, but in view of the web interface it is exactly the same as etherdelta, in my opinion forkdhelta equals etherdelta

I am having the problem while canceling the orders and I think it'll be dead soon. Unfortunately there are some tokens I am interested only available in ED otherwise I'll never use this slowest exchange ever I used.

Actually never like etherdelta, and I think it will be dead, new team can't save it.

Is it confirmed that Etherdelta is dead? I sent some ETH over to test it today and it let me deposit. I tried to do a little arbitrage, but all the orders were taken and just not updated. Etherdelta let me pull my ETH back out. I won't be back.

I hope that etherdelta will soon recover, and remain credible. I also believe that all the teams at the company are doing their best, and professionally. may etherdelta be back soon. good luck

Feeling scared when leaving money on small exchanges. dead at any time

Maybe this is true, because these days I can not use etherdelta, and hopefully forkdelta will be better than him.
I really hope for a good exchange

Yes it is, ED even gets delisted form the coinmarketcap. That means if etherdelta doesn't operate anymore, or it was definitely dead exchange right now. But you are still able to withdraw your amount. Just try to do a little effort try to visit interesting discussion on the reddit. Some people are still able to withdraw their money from ED smartcontract.

If it's true, we will see a massacre on shittoken market. Another Christmas sale is coming... but there'll be nowhere to buy

im not a fan of etherdelta but i admit i gain some by trading in the site i have lots of erc20 tokens, i hope they can solve their present issues

Ok ok, but anyone already use forkdelta ? Good return ?

as far as i've used etherdelta, there had no anything problem.
but the interface is a bit odd.
i use etherdelta if there is no other market

From ForkDelta Twitter:

We have been alerted to a HARMFUL extension in the Chrome Store that claims to help you set gas price quickly. This extension transmits your account details (including private key, if set) to a third party.

Stay safe. Do not install extensions from unknown authors.

I hope it will be back. Very strange and would be scam action after devolopers ran an ICO to collect millions dollar and now everything going very bad.
For alternate Idex exchange is the good one as decentralized explatform now.

Yesterday I tried to trade on the forkdelta. I am satisfied with the process. Work has become more convenient and faster. So I'll agree, Etherdelta is dead.

EtherDelta works too bad the last few weeks. I heard that the problems arose because the founders of this exchange did not find a consensus among themselves. It's pity and now I will probably use ForkDelta...

You can still deposit or withdraw without an issue just trading is mostly inaccessible

Trading on EtherDelta is one thing: "strengthening the nervous system."At the moment, I have this exchange does not cause positive pleasant emotions during trading.

Have you used Etherdelta in the past week? I got caught up in seeing prices way better than other exchanges. That should have been a red flag. I could not trade as the orders there were fake orders from the past. Token.store is better but I could not use my Ledger.

Very nice that we have another exchange that is like EtherDelta. I really like the concept behind these exchanges. Everybody can instantly trade their tokens even if it isnt listed official on the exchange!!!

Etherdelta died and this has been confirmed by so many users of etherdelta itself, Some people are still complaining about the useless token called etherdelta token. The developer was running away with all of the money that has been raised through ico. Fork delta becomes an alternative right now with some improvements. Why are you still talking about etherdelta if that has died?

Hello KJMZNine, could you please provide more details, regarding which another exchange are you talking? I would like to have alternative to EtherDelta and will be thankful for the information

that's true because i also experienced the same problem in etherdelta. probably because they want to replace it with a new exchange

I also heard that there are very large commissions for Gas, it's true? Now it's not profitable to sell coins with Airdrops?

Airdrops give only a few amounts of money (around 5-10$). You need to pay at least 2-3$ for transaction fees.
It's not worthy to use decentralize exchanges to dump your tokens.
Just wait for hitbtc etc.

I have never heard of forkdelta until today and am surprised at how identical the two exchanges are and ED has not come to its full functionality for a long time am starting to think ED and FD are one and the same and let us not forget we have idex which is also a good exchange.


this will depend on how popular ForkDelta will turn out.

so with the ETHER DELTA stock exchange, there are really a lot of problems in the recent past, and I also faced certain problems, but everything was solved after a while. It seems to me that ED will not simply die, but will do rebranding and will continue to exist!

I will stop using Etherdelta now. Forkdelta isn't what I'm looking for. Three management team has changed. They ran a bull shit ICO for Etherdelta and now they are enjoying their money. I recommend everyone to use idex exchange which is fast and better then forkdelta.

Forkdelta if everything is as it is now, then it will return the lost positions to the etherdelta. I was not used to the IDEX personally.

Well, Etheredelta are having a hard time to make a good services. Its better for ICO's to look for better exchanges so many investors will come and try not to use etherdelta because its a total mess. Idex exchange are good right now, new coins should be listed here for good.

I'm surprised that it's taking them this long. To be honest, their site has been crappy for ages, and it is long overdue for a complete overhaul. I had the fortune to move most of my holdings from ED before this latest technical incident happened, but I do still have some small holdings that I would like to view in my previous orders section.

ForkDelta is sharing the same problems like Etherdelta on loading. Sometimes I need to wait more than 60 seconds for a single load due twitter. If they don't fix this soon, they will follow Etherdelta to oblivion...

I think forkdelta will not be good in the coming months it is like etherdelta. It is like etherdelta that has more issues with it comes to daily transactions too loading the page and even withdrawals. Much better to use good exchange for a security purposes.

Have you been reading about the latest issue of etherdelta's API? It seems to become the main reason how etherdelta becomes a crap right now. But forkdelta was coming with a little increase in the UI.l It's a better response compared with etherdelta. Or I can think if someone behind forkdelta is the developer of etherdelta itself. It looks pretty odd this person can build forkdelta very similar with etherdelta.

yeah mate you are correct from time to time need to pay the gas for every single transactions and not allowed to make  big transaction for one time, hoping if the system switch into the frok delta the fees are moderate not like etherdelta one always asking fees. unlike in the other online exchange can i transac one time in the is lower tha to etehrdelta.

i tried forkdelta and it's seems better than the old etherdelta, it's faster and less buggy. sadly the old etherdelta seems is going to die. if it solves the problem of the high gas fees it will be the definitive exchange

Ethetherdelta is never user friendly . But We were able to find the Gems there at a low price. Decentralized Exchanges are a great concept. IDEX and Forkdelta looks strong atm. They can go bigger in 2018

There is a place to buy for a long-term investment, if not have time to buy at ICO. Prior to entering the normal exchanges, you can often buy them at the price of ICO and sometimes even slightly lower.

etherdelta is back online, from their official twitter:

The EtherDelta platform is back online and trading has resumed. Thank you for your patience. More updates coming soon.


 

What the hell is ForkDelta? I knew they were going to have a crowdsale but I didn't think that was going to produce a fork. In any case I traded on Etherdelta last week, so summize to say it isn't dead just yet.

I confirm! The order book and spisokksdelok are updated normally! Which exchanger will win now?)

ForkDelta looks same. And for me FD work faster. But for both - so poor interface and possibilities  ;D How to trade on those exchanges?

Everything is almost "dead", this crash took everyone huge gains and made everyone depressive, even if people are still up from initial investment.

Etherdelta works on a unique platform compared to the other trading platforms available. Recently Etherdelta has encountered some issues and finding difficulty in sought out of issues. Most tokens get listed to it, which is also an added benefit using etherdelta.

Any can be listed on ED by smartcontract. With new team I hope that exchange will change in best side. But not sure. If we will see BTC growth nothing will change

That is interesting to see a replica forkdelta came up in no time when etherdelta was having some issues, looks like the old guys that were behind etherdelta came up with this new decentralized exchange, is it true?

Etherdelta is currently experiencing a number of issues, so I switched to the Idex decentralized trading platform. Idex is also a commercial site similar to Etheredelta but has more improvements in terms of interface, speed, and security. Idex is currently receiving support from many investors.

Possible but there are no strong evidence or proofs that the person behind that forkdelta are old guys came from ED itself. Two sites or exchangers are almost identical and now ED becomes operational once again I doubt the traffic came from ED comes to half since Forkdelta is there then users would really divide and it would already matter on how people do trust into these exchanges. Competition is back once again.

Well really etherdelta is no longer an option that I think is feasible to exchange currencies, transactions are slow and the problems on the page gives very bad image and mistrust and with other pages that are appearing with many improvements, leaves ED far behind

is the own etherdelta site is same with forkdelta?
For me it's not a problem,anyway that old site is need to fix since a long time

I noticed that my ED holdings on Blockfolio were active again. It's good to have them back, and my current holdings are undergoing a bit of a rally back to (hopefully) their former glory.

I've been noticed a change for the worse with etherdelta ever since its DNS was hacked. A conspiracy theory could be that the original owner sold it and the new management is really bad. In any case, out with the old and in with the new.

Kudos to forkdelta. I just tried it now and damn. It was almost 1000x times faster.

After reading  all those comments on twitter I don’t think ED will ever recover anymore.  They are just barely keeping the site alive at this point until everyone forgets they banked over 10million on a their ICO. Maybe we did get screwed after all. Great example of how NOT to run an exchange service.

The king is dead, long live the king! @ForkDelta

It is a big risks trading in etherdelta always having a problem. I read a lot of bad feedback on this exchange more on deposits and withdrawals. And Ive heared lately they are on back to operate I hope all are working fine. With forkdelta I tried trading this exchange all went smooth transactions.

Im a big fan before of Etherdelta exchange before because of being decentralized, but now that there are too many issues unresolve and the website seems very slow to respond. Its very risky to deposit now your coins in ED and trade so its a good thing that there is a rising Forkdelta now. Long live!

Whatever the name, this stock market does not give me confidence and will never give me confidence. Even when I saw this design I became uncomfortable. I do not think I will ever use this stock market again when there is a stock exchange like idex ;)

I can't stand the interface of either. It's horrible.

Etherdelta was never usable. It had a terrible user interface. It would take any smart person atleast few hours to even understand how it works and that too if he is able to understand in the end. All the options for trading were made too complex with no guides in place.

Does the forkdelta promise a fundamental change about the weakness of etherdelta. If it only shows the same service, what fork delta is made for?
just wasting time to deliver duplicated things. that sounds bad

Absolutely I agree..Aside from the fact that their functions are the same, I can see the token I sent to etherdelta in forkdelta..A copy of exactly the same thing..Mission, speed, use, everything is the same.

Actually for what two exchangers with the same system.?
many are asking the security of storing assets in ED, whether to move immediately to the fork?

ED is dead, at least for me because i haven't used it since i knew forkdelta about two months ago. Etherdelta is already hard to use when the eth network is congested and their ui lags a lot so i search for an alternative and found forkdelta which is the better version of etherdelta. I thought they will change for good when they run their ico but it's been a month i think and there's no change at all.

Forkdelta works fine. And I'm happy to trade now on this dex. It does not matter for me where exactly to trade. It is much more important to be able to successfully trade and make profit)). I hope we'll see a lot of new DEXes this year.

I just tried forkdelta and it is almost same user interface but the loading is faster then ether delta. What i kno ed have rise fund and why they did not fix their exchanger with the money they collected ? Fork delta better and faster then etherdelta. So we have 2 good exchanger now. Idex.market and forkdelta

Good thing I removed all of my tokens there. I thought I lost my Telcoin and Car Vertical there. Good thing I managed to move it to my Meta Mask after buying them.  ;D

Etherdelta can not be used. it makes us all crazy. I am moving on idex market motlo more efficient and I have also bought idex membership tokens

I really do not like Etherdelta for a start. Every time I make a transaction there it always ask me to pay gas which is expensive now specially if one is not really aware of the gas prices and just transacts and transacts not knowing that you have already paid so much.

I hate this exchange. but honestly. This exchange is where the start of the erc20 token. Very good for the erc token

I once read about exchange forkdelta, from the news that forkdelta is a substitute of etherdelta. Some of my friends in the forum say can login in forkdelta using privatekey old account from etherdelta.

Etherdelta has announced if the trade was resumed again and you must see the latest tweet from the etherdelta developer. But honestly i was still prefer to use forkdelta rather than etherdelta. It looks like fork looks smoothly compared with etherdelta itself. Idex looks an improvement from both of ethereum decentralized exchange site. It has the same system order just like centralized excahnge site.

The problem I have found with forkdelta is very low volume. I tried to sell but it timed out so no sale and lost 0.002 ether for nothing. Will avoid until volume picks up.

I heard that EtherDelta is back online and the people can start again. I see some volume again at EtherDelta and I am happy about it because I am trading on EtherDelta since the first days!!!

it's all due to errors of the delta ether and indeed many problems I encountered here like buy and sell orders are not updated. The withdrawal process is sometimes difficult and must pay several times the gas for the withdrawal process. maybe etherdelta will not come back before solving the problem

ForkDelta uses EtherDelta's contract, they just "forked" the UI and backend, and have been updating it. As always, you can interact directly with the contract if you are having difficulties with EtherDelta's UI.

Actually, they are just doing such a long maintenance break to enhance their services and do some additional to their system. As I've visited their site, they are now currently in operation starting last March 1. I think not only ed doing these, but  it happen also to other exchanger also.

Etherdelta went to hell and now we just move over to this one.
I'm having a hard time trusting forkdelta.

Etherdelta seems dead to me ,  for now forkdelta works good . But there are still a lot of improvements to be made so we can have better dex's in the future. I can't wait for these developments.

I heard the CEO of etherdelta now is different, and maybe that is the reason why Etherdelta is now dead. It is the first exchange that I used but now it's gone.  :'(

I haven't try forkdelta yet but I think they are both similar because new Tokens are being listed on it first. A lot of new projects listed their tokens on forkdelta just like on etherdelta before.

I think that's true. That etherdelta has been defeated by forkdelta. Can be seen from the state of exchange altcoimnya there. In etherdelta increasingly rare enthusiasts or people who buy altcoin, although there is even with a price far from the original price. For forkdelta marketnya start stable and progress. The transaction process is faster in forkdelta. So it's no wonder many people prefer forkdelta compared to etherdelta. They even say that etherdelta will die soon. That is all and thank you

Etherdelta was the first place many people used. It is the place for many people. But it was everyone who could not be trusted after the negative things like hacking.
It is now completely over and we will work with forkdelta or idex :)

I think ED will never be the same again. At least I really like Forkdelta. I like its interface and loading time of this or that window, unlike ED

really was for me the first exchange and at first I liked the work of this exchange like the interface and the principle of work. but over time I started working on other exchanges and realized that ETN is the worst exchange I've worked on!

it opened again.
coinmarket ddidnt listed it. but soon they will.

etherdelta is the one of the best of decentralized exchanges

maybe etherdelta is dead because I also see forkdelta as a substitute that isn't much different with etherdelta
i think forkdelta developed by the same developer with etherdelta but I have not tried to transact there

never know for sure but at least etherdelta now has a successor that is forkdelta where everyone starts to like the exchange, and I think ED and FD have similarities so it does not matter

Forkdelta is now slow as fuck... Again....

First Etherdelta now Forkdelta.

OCC Original Crypto Coin just started on Forkdelta and its the only exchange get them before they go to other exchanges!

forkdelta use same contract address of etherdelta , so no loss to etherdelta .
ED interface is buggy always and site not in trends but still with help of forkdelta they earn all the commission .

etherdelta was listed on coinmarketcap from many months but after issue in api in february they delisted it .
instead of etherdelta they used api of forkdelta and listed forkdelta .

now again both sites are shown in CMC .

my advice on etherdelta, I do not know for sure whether etherdelta is now dead or dead trafficnya just because the visitor is empty, etherdelta should provide more details, what and how the condition of etherdelta latest situation, and directly from the party responsible for etherdelta.
so we have clarity, hopefully useful and spirit

maybe the ED side made a security system update by turning it into a forkdelta, and I think it worked pretty well. because when I use this Forkdelta the transaction process becomes lighter and faster, and I am now satisfied with this market

I used to loved EtherDelta before for it is a decentralized coins exchange the the transactions runs smoothly. I have been there for almost 5 months trading coin. What i don't really like with the etherdelta that the responce of their interface was very slow and that's the reason why i switch to forkdelta, and i am beginning to love forkdelta now since some of their team was from etherdelta too, etherdelta will soon be laid to rest and i don't think if their ED coin could survive that long.

Since ED has a replacement of Forkdelta then lets just use FD then . It has the same features just have different interface in ED ( little difference ). 

i always visit etherdelta to find coins or token their in the list imfact  i use etherdelta to sell my altcoins i do not believe to the people making an issue without verified before making thread actually etherdelta dev's continue to upgrade to gives convenience of the user satisfactions.  

But fork was a little bit better rather than ED on its performance, When it comes to execute the order and Fork will become more responsive compared with ED. Fork has a better improvement on the responsively of the platform compared with ED and this has stated by so many person. And you can try to make a comparison between both of exchange sites.

Actually forkdelta is more used these days but thorough observing on these two exchange etherdelta and forkdelta they were the same. They were the same why? Because it so happen etherdelta and forkdelta always had an issue on too slow to process during deposits and withdrawals. Hope they will update their server.

that's true because i also experienced the same problem in etherdelta. probably because they want to replace it with a new exchange

ForkDelta looks same. And for me FD work faster. But for both - so poor interface and possibilities  How to trade on those exchanges?

I often traded on ED, but now I do not trade there. it's buggy, and I'm sick of it. as for another exchange, I do not trade it yet. maybe later I'll start, but now I'll bypass it.

I think most of the etherdelta users are now using forkdelta though. In my opinion forkdelta is better than etherdelta, also from the twitter we can see that forkdelta admins are more active than etherdelta, also I love the logo more lol. But either forkdelta or etherdelta, both are not a really good exchange in my opinion. I prefer IDEX to be honest, but IDEX right now sucks also, the minimum amount for withdrawal and selling is really annoying in my perspective (i used to sell my leftovers there).

Both exchanges work. But it seems to me that ForkDelta works a little faster than EtherDelta. But this is a minor difference. I use both.

So true. It's working much faster than ED for me, as well. But, I still use the ED for placing orders sometimes. Since platforms use the same smart contract, this is still possible.

Never tried EtherDelta thanks to all the complaints I started seeing, and definitely not going to try ForkDelta as I suspect this will go the same route as ED. People need to realize that the ETH network simply cannot handle the stress of trading, when it is already struggling with all those collectible crypto games. Psst, time to move on to Waves platform guys. Quick and fixed fee so you all don't need to worry about gas price.

But why do you still insist on using these exchanges? Idex is the best decentralized exchange. Fast and efficient

Etherdelta exchange is still alive but seem like nobody wanna this worst exchange anymore cause they don't want their ETH wallet hacked ;D. If it were before, I think people would keep using ETD because it's the only decentralized exchange but for now I think they won't cause we have ForkDelta now :)

Surely they have the same API. But still, etherdelta was pretty good to trade half year ago, and now it's absolutely unreal, how do people trade there, or they are using the bots..

Yes, probably only bots looking for a price difference in comparison to other exchanges or for some inexperienced users to place an order with unrealistic price. I've seen many times that such orders get executed within a few seconds. ;)

I used Etherdelta before for several weeks last year and I would say it is very slow, you are forced to increase gas to make transactions work, interface like it came from an 90's site, and also the way to pull up new coins is abysmal at least. I took out all my coins there and back to my wallet for safekeeping.

Ether Delta most reputed ether based erc20 exchange is struggling now we are going to see forkdelta is on rise and coinbase too coming up with erc20 tokens in their wallet which is good sign for all of us

I agreed with what you said cause idex seems to be the best ethereum token exchange site and for the fork delta who know maybe the people that own the hacked etherdelta are the same owner of the forkdelta cause there template look the same.

I can not understand why forkdelta has the same problems as ethrdelta. This site is not well loaded by any of the browsers, and it works fine only when using a VPN

I hope Etherdelta’s not dead yet but if it is then I also hope the coins listed on Etherdelta are also found on Forkdelta or hopefully they will be listed there soon.

Well, forkdelta and etherdelta are own by the same person if you ask me and I wonder why still rate the forkdelta over etherdelta while it follow the foot step of the hacked ether delta.

I think both of them have died and will not be using them again, I hear there are many problems there and many of my friends have lost their assets when import private key there. so pathetic.

I was never a friend of etherdelta so i don´t use forkdelta such "exchanges" are no good for the whole crypto scene.

Yes they are both the same and we can easily tell it because their sites names are verry simillar to each other. And i dont think etherdelta is dead because id still access it and i still traded my tokens thru it on the past days . I dont also tried to use forkdelta but if there were problems in etherdelta , i may then try to use forkdelta as an alternative so that i can still trade my coins .  



I suggest youd better try etherdelta because this exchange is also good when it comes to trading or buying alts and tokens due to the fact that it is decentralize which means all transactions are automatic without human supervision for a better and faster processing.

Ed is also known to be the first trading platform that accepts ico coins to be listed on their exchange as when compared to other.

I think it's something that was already coming, because since the emergence of IDEX there is no way to compare the functionality and efficiency of one platform and another. In fact just take a look at the tab "markets" in coinmarketcap to see that in the matter of tokens erc20, IDEX is monopolizing the market, while EtherDelta has simply stopped appearing.

Etherdelta had management problems early in the year,  and I think that has been resolved.  Another problem that plague Etherdelta was the lagging and very slow trading platform that Etherdelta was running and it really wore so many people out.  I think Etherdelta is better now!

I believe etherdealta will recover eventually. There are just going through some difficult times, like every other organization. They'll bounce back.

I think right now Forkdelta is more stable when it come down to token trades

Honestly speaking I have always preferred using the forkdelta exchange compared to the etherdelta exchange. I wish them well. I hope they will improve their services and become a better idea exchange than they used to be.

Etherdelta has a good purpose which is to list all those shitcoin tokens that other exchanges won't list. Better versions like forkdelta and idex are better to trade on, but ideally they should try to get on the bancor network which gives the token more value

in my opinion etherdelta remains the best but does not rule out the possibility of being left by the trader. this is due to the large number of deductions taken for one transaction, while now many markets have a minimum deduction for each transaction.

etherdelta and forkdelta are the same,
we can trade in etherdelta or in forkdelta, but we have to be careful,

Yes both platform are owned by the same owner but etherdelta is the only one and the original when it comes to decentralized exchange that accepts all kinds of tokens and altcoins . forkdelta on the otherhand is only a copy paste or a clone but i notice that most people are starting to migrate on this platform .

In my case i only trust etherdelta because this is the only exchange that i learn how to trade my coins that i get from a bounty and airdrops .

I do not think it will die. It is a very interesting trading platform and it usually buys and sells tokens at very cheap prices. It is a must-have for bounty hunters and professional ICO investors.

Like obviously, forkdelta is a fork of etherdelta which is just new in the market and it's actually doing fine. Since I use forkdelta, I stopped using ED since I didn't like its new interface in mobile browsing so I'm getting a hard time. Also I use ethernext, seems a legit one as I successfully traded without having problems, considering it's just a new one.

Really? So how you guys can explain our previous transaction? In which perfectly executed.

this has happened since there was a case with exchange etherdelta, which is the breakdown of a number of ethereum and a large number of tokens

I sent to the address of the smart contract 42.5 DGPT. I don’t have them on my account, they are on the address of the exchange smart contract.
where are my funds? support does not respond at all.

Etherdelta had an issue with SEC before that's why exchange is acting strange before.. but until now i haven't use it again since the time my 2 tokens was hack on their excahnge

Forkdelta and etherdelta just same connection, if you transferred token in the same contract address you can see in etherdelta or forkdelta, its just same decentralized exchange, the different is etherdelta have old coin list thats you cant find in forkdelta but when you input the smart contract the result is same, i am enjoy used forkdelta and etherdelta..

I've been using forkdelta for some time and I'm obviously glad. But I haven't been able to access FD for the last week. I cannot contact Metamask.

I'm using Chrome. It works when I try it with Firefox, but it's a problem with Chrome. Why could it be? Anybody have an idea?

may be you should update your browser, chrome or firefox its work for me

I used both, but much more etherdelta on past, but if both give the same address when deposit means maybe forkdelta was made for more security i think, but i didn't hear any complain about etherdelta.

I can not reach Etherdelta without VPN in my country, its download time was too long, so for me it died with ForkDelta appearance.

in which country are you in? for me etherdelta or forkdelta are just as easily accessible
maybe your internet needs to be upgraded so you don't need to use VPN again to access Etherdelta  :P

EtherDelta died the day the former founder sold the project to new owner, this is what I was saying, can anyone compare ED and IDEX now interms of volume, this sows how people behind a project is the most important thing not a sound idea, there is no way ED should lose its first mover advantage but they do and many project can do, do not get emotionally attached to any project out there

Etherdelta had problem from Day 1, the exchange was too difficult for newbies to understand. Some later part of time it grew popular and newbies were forced to use it but when they launched their Own ICO, it was disaster they literally sold their exchange.

https://www.reddit.com/r/EtherDelta/comments/7n628d/warning_etherdelta_ico/

Until now I still use Etherdelta to sell coins that I think are worthless, Sometimes when the coins that we have do not have prices on Etherdelta are surprisingly priced even though they are very cheap.

is etherdelta is same as forkdelta? i thought etherdelta and forkdelta is from the same site lol. well today i learned that it's not the same. in my opinion forkdelta is far better than etherdelta, the UI is also good and it's not slow compared with etherdelta. etherdelta is so slow to load the site too.

I think Forkdelta is an upgrade of EtherDelta so the EtherDelta will soon be removed from the market because it no longer provides a good user experience. If it does not resolve the issues that arise at present, it is sure that in the future it will be replaced by EtherDelta and it will completely remove. Those are my reviews of outdated EtherDelta.

It seems like the developers from Etherelta are no longer interested in developing the platform that they have, there have been many sad events from Etherdelta.
now maybe the developers only rely on the rest of the trust of small traders or bounty hunters who throw bounty tokens at very low prices in etheredelta.

The case of hacking that happened was a problem from Etherdelta and I saw the volume in the exchange also decreased. and Forkdelta as a substitute indeed in terms of appearance almost the same but has a distinguishing thing so that it can shift the existence of etherdelta. well, it is not impossible that the exchange will disappear later if no one is interested again

Etherdelta is not dead as assume by most of us but the trading volume have greatly reduced unlike the forkdelta which is a direct clone of ED and also uses its resources, forkdeltal trading volume have increased because it look more of a modern day exchange while ED is the old fashion but not dead.

That issue with hacks really bring this exchange to reduced users and go with forkdelta, assuming that the exchange lost most of the traders trust but they still working and you can still check coins inside and still manage to do the trades, still working and still manage to survive even competitions already been race against each others.

I think ED users are also now switching to FD and idex. because most of the tokens that have not been registered in the exchange have been officially released in some of these exchanges. and I think it's quite helpful if you want to buy coins at a cheaper price than the price of ico.

Since the forkdelter has hardfork with etherdelta, things has been very difficult for etherdelta and forkdelter has become the most favorite decentralized ethereum market.  The volume of trade has drastically reducing and of a truth since 2017 I have not used etherdelta for trading and most of the tokens that I have sold was done in forkdelter.  However,  the current happening may not lead to the death of etherdelta and it is still too early to judge what is going to happen since etherdelta has survived this long.

Etherdelta is surely a scam project. I don't know what happened to their crowdfunding but they surely collected funds and never develop the platform as promised. About Forkdelta, I think it's a good DEX as well with IDEX, it's just that Forkdelta is a newer form of ED and IDEX is great in terms of live support, volume and coins listed. IDEX has a better development but that doesn't mean forkdelta is a scam one, it's DEX.

The word scam is a serious word in this community don't say it unless you have a concrete evidence, if ED ran an ICO their coin will also be listed and known to us all. I log into my ED day before yesterday after a long time and withdrew some that I had forgotten there and I received it instantly.
ED may not be active but it not a scam or dead.

I agree with this. I also logged in recently and withdrew some coins, I didn't have much on there, only 0.5 ETH, but it was still there and there was no problem withdrawing. EtherDelta may not be a great experience and may not have good volumes, but I don't think it's a scam.

Since the appearance of Forkdelta I am sure that there have been many people who left Etherdelta for some reason for convenience and that made Etherdelta rarely used and then almost died.

Not one of these decentralized exchanges does not suit. Endless hang and unpleasant interface. Is it not possible to do something better? Enjoy IDEX and it suits me.

It is possible to do something better, but for the moment there is no perfect decentralised exchange. This is the sort of thing that is a barrier to mainstream adoption. If it is only the more technically adept members of the population that are able to even buy crypto in the first place,  let alone use centralised and then decentralised exchanges, then crypto will not fulfill its potential.
But I think we are moving in the right direction. I've only been in crypto for a couple of years, and user experience is slowly but steadily improving. I do think we will get there eventually.

I have the same experience.
In addition, IDEX pays its tokens every quarter. It was a pleasant surprise for me.
EtherDelta has always been awkward to use. No regrets if it dies.

I haven't used Etherdelta for a long time, for dex trade i am prefer to use IDEX its more easy and fast for make transaction.

Its already dead some of traders who use that exchange are using now forkdelta, but I think it's not really recommended to use I feel that using that kind of exchange is not really secured. Much better to use exchange that have strong security that no one can steal your coins.

Indeed, both of them have lost the trust of many investors. especially at this time many cases that happened like theft made the second volume of the exchange also decreased. only shit tokens are there because the listings are free

Idex is just an trading market that had issue about the volume. I still prefer Etherdelta back in the old days and now forkdelta because you can actually sell right now via p2p trading technique and also it is more safe to trade in there for me.

Indeed etherdelta mostly holds a lot of altcoins, so that every transaction is rather slow, it must be fast to start reducing altcoins that rarely transact or move some to the forkdelta. because I think between etherdelta and forkdelta is the same. but I rarely use etherdelta now, so I do not know whether it is still going well, but if I see etherdelta it is still there and there are improvements.

somehow, as much as possible I will not sell my assets there. indeed, some of the assets of most bounties that have no value are there. if it's not too important I will avoid etherdelta, forkdelta, and idex. if there are other better exchanges with greater volume or better trust, why should you choose them.

I have not used EtherDelta for a long time, because it takes a long time to load. But I do not know what the differences between EtherDelta, ForkDelta, IDEX and other decentralized exchanges are in terms of security. In any case, I prefer not to take risks and do not give my private key to these exchanges, I trade only using spare wallets.

etherdelta is an exchange that was popular in its era for airdrop hunter, unfortunately they always put projects illegally in exchange for them. many projects are listed on Ethereal without being known by the dev project so this causes the price of the project token to fall and can be purchased cheaply from ICO and presale prices. this may be one of the failures of the ICO project but also etherdelta has changed with the new one, namely forkdelta and still with the same problem, they are not permitting or cooperating with the project so the tokens can be traded before the project releases an official exchange.

I haven't used Etherdelta since Forkdelta came along. Now, I'm not interested in tokens, so Forkdelta not in use. I advise you to pay attention only to the coins with the original blockchain, interesting technology, new features. That is, promising projects should be necessary for users. But tokens have always been just unnecessary fun or tools for scammers who collected millions of dollars and ran away. Therefore, all these ether/forkdelta and other exchanges for tokens are dinosaurs from the past and will soon become extinct. Although this is my subjective opinion, and maybe I'm wrong.

from a very long time ago i started using forkdelta over etherdelta it's more flexible and reliable than etherdelta in the user experience at least in my opinion good luck for all :)

I traded on etherdelta the other day. Too lagging. I can't post my sell orders. And there seems to be no active trade there now. So sad because it used to be a great exchange.

I can understand what you mean somehow after we saw all these useless tokens that were created during the ICO-hype. But this would also mean that Ethereum will become obsolete. Do you really think that? I think tokenization is just starting. Just look what potential security tokens might have (even though these probably won't be tradeable on Etherdelta/Forkdelta).

isn't the forkdelta a substitute for etherdelta (same user interface, only different domains)?

yes, I thought it was a clone of ED. FD looks lighter I think, because I last accessed ED it felt very heavy. they must develop and update the system so that it is in accordance with the market's wishes.

They are both using the same smart contract, so you could technically say that Forkdelta is a clone of Etherdelta. Forkdelta was meant to be an improvement over Etherdelta that, for example, processes orders much faster and uses a reworked API.

Same here, etheredelta is really sucks and always loading and so slow to load. I prefer IDEX for DEX exchange but forkdelta is better than etherdelta. I heard Binance released their DEX exchange, so let's see if it will be a good one or not, if it's really good then all dex exchanges user will move to binance.

I meant that utility tokens were not so necessary. Basically their role was to be a speculation tool or a tool for ICO scams. Security tokens are something else. They are somewhat similar to shares. At least they have real value. But on forkdelta, 90% of tokens are junk. And by the way, the functioning of this exchange loads the ethereum network with these useless transactions of unnecessary tokens.

At this time Forkdelta I see the volume is greater than etherdelta because it is possible that the trust of etherdelta has been lost due to many problems
and also the theft of assets in the exchange

I get what you mean. There are dozens of utility tokens with no real purpose around but for me that doesn't mean that utility tokens are useless per se. And I also think we need exchanges like Ether- or Forkdelta where people can safely trade tokens without the tokens having to go through a long (and expensive) listing proccess on other exchanges.

both exchanges are very risky to use as trade. I think nowadays EtherDelta and ForkDelta have greatly reduced users.
I don't see any new developments for progress and make traders comfortable and trusting.
I prefer to hold alt alt rather than having to trade in both exchanges

Of course, coins today are best kept for quite a long time, until the cryptocurrency market recovers again and shows good results.  But nevertheless, if traders use not only rating trading platforms, but also such exchangers as EtherDelta, I would like to talk about the reliability or danger of such a resource.  It is better to know more about this situation information.

If we talk specifically about ether Delta, then the users of cryptocurrency used this exchanger only to drain the coins, which only entered the cryptocurrency market.  It seems to me that its relevance has decreased slightly, since the cryptocurrency market is in poor condition.

Of course, the market will always affect cargo platforms.  But for some reason today, the binance trading market is showing fairly good results, besides their Tolkien price rises and attracts more and more investment, why can't forkdelta use this situation, they also have very popular resources?

I agree with your opinion that it is indeed better and stable to use forkdelta compared to etherdelta. all of this because etherdelta had already appeared earlier and there were already many tokens being marketed there, even tokens that might have no more transactions made etheredelta a bit too long for each transaction. but actually between the two is the same method of transaction because it is forkdelta made to reduce tokens to etherdelta.

Apart from forkdelta, another great market for ERC20 tokens is IDEX. It is more user-friendly than forkdelta and has rarely any issues with transactions.

But on IDEX you can only trade 'listed' tokens, right? Or is it possible to trade a token where you only know the contract address and the token symbol, like at Etherdelta/Forkdelt? Because that's exactly the reason why I like Forkdelta that much. Sometimes you can make a real bargain when some bounty hunters wanna dump their tokens before the first exchange listing.

I think that this resource has come times more difficult for the previous ones, because there are such exchanges as Tokpie, where a bounty hunter is offered to sell tokens at the stage of steaks.  Nevertheless, a bit of a stir is already created on bitcointalk And a lot of talk about how profitable it is to sell steaks or tokens even after the company’s ico is completed.

I think that each user of a cryptocurrency benefits in one or another exchanger.  The difference between forkdelta and other trading platforms is that no one here requires you to provide any personal data or make registration.

Does OP know that forkdelta is just a fork from etherdelta? Forkdelta network being use is from ether delta so whatever earnings that forkdelta will have the etherdelta will also be earning on the counterpart.

But, I agree one thing to OP that forkdelta now has good number of users and even traders for cryptocurrency.

The main difference between Fork and Ether Deltas,

ForkDelta lists orders placed on EtherDelta,
EtherDelta doesn't list orders placed on ForkDelta.

Meaning on ForkDelta you have access to EDelta and FDelta orders.


Anyway 2020, what heck has happened to the Deltas?
It can't be IDEX their fees are astronomical.

Did some hack or something happen i'm not aware of?
Besides their ICO being a massive plop.  :-X

When I heard the news, I no longer used etherdelta and moved to use forkdelta. But in fact they are the same site and all are not different, it seems like this is indeed a fork from etherdelta. This site is like an illegal exchange because without permission to register tokens that are not supposed to be traded, but this is a bounty hunter advantage if you can't wait to sell the tokens they get

As I know, Etherdelta has indeed been replaced with Forkdelta, I believe that their CEO is the same, just changing the name,
I'm grateful that Forkdelta was born, because Airdrop Hunter or Bounty Hunter really needs this exchange  ;D

The only good thing is that they are DEX, no need to spend a lot of money to get listed on it, but I think both are the same thing to me, McAfee dex do the same thing of both you mentioned and have some good volume for a few coins, so not dead, just different, which is good, more options, more decentralization.

After bear market last 2018 Im no longer using this dex it seems that only shitcoins and scam projects are using this exchange even-thought I still saw some good projects but has 0 or either very low in volume, no liquidity, most traders are looking for a fast and high volumes exchanges some common problems of dex that needs to address are "speed" or transaction fees.

Airdrop hunters and bounty hunters really really need to get a life:P

But okay,,, I had no idea Etherdelta was replaced,,, but I guess all those of us who just use Bitcoin and do not really care about tokens would not really know yeah?

yes, it must be admitted that during the etherdelta period there were many who were helped by its existence, because many altcoins can be exchanged there. with the passage of time due to the large number of altcoins registered there, etherdelta began to experience difficulties and forkdelta appeared to help reduce transactions there. but right now I haven't used either etherdelta or forkdelta for a long time because there are already many alternative.

I had used etherdelta many times before, when they were still in active operations.
I guess there were a lot of crap tokens born owed to etherdelta.  ;D
But anyway, many crypto users are now finding good alternatives when it comes to DEX.
Even Binance has DEX now, so we don't have to worry where to go when you need one.

wait what etherdelta dont work anymore?  omg .  i was expecting that im going to use this exchange because im now going back on airdrop hunting but maybe coin owners will just find other alternatives and i hope they will consider binance dex or if not then forkdelta is okay  .

i have use forkdelta before but not binance dex , i can say that forkdelta is smoother than etherdelta but no doubt that etherdelta help many hunters before  and im one of those.

indeed not many people use this exchange. traders may be more interested in trading on IDEX which has a high trade for tokens with the ethereum blockchain.

guys, I have problems with this resource and I don’t know how to fix this problem at all.  The fact is that I live in Ukraine and a couple of years ago I used EtherDelta for trading without any problems.  But for today I have no access to this resource.  Forkdelta also does not provide any opportunity to use resources for their intended purpose. Not a single web browser opens the entire site. Are there any suggestions that can help me?  I will be very grateful.

After IDEX appeared I used it more often than both because it seemed more comfortable using IDEX. If I'm not mistaken, Etherdelta once had its own token and made a sale, is it still there now or is it dead because there are fewer interested people who use etherdelta.

They are long time dead ever since, they compromised several users before so I don't  think it's good to risk some money there since they will compromised there traders again since seems they are not yet so better stay away on etherdelta and just go with more reliable DEX

There are top tier already release so they are good for enjoying our trades.

we are indeed seeing more and more DEX replacing etherdelta and forkdelta which are no longer crowded. indeed it is true that there are still many who trade on IDEX rather than ED and FD. but maybe a lot of people have started to move on the binance DEX.

Etherdelta is no longer active on their social media, but Etherdelta is decentralized just like Forkdelta, I can still visit Etherdelta but not to trade, because it's very risky, I just check it out, and of course it's better to use forkdelta because it's still safe

ED and Forkdelta does not have a good volume anymore, I think their time is over, the exchange that I can still see having a volume is IDEX, its decentralized as well but in overall, their volume is not really good since we can only trade ETH tokens while most ETH tokens now have a very low demand since ICO is not anymore popular.

Because they already drive out there users that's why we see a less volume on that site and also many DEX has came out now so expect this exchange will die anytime soon so better for those people who still trade at them to get out as soon as possible since that site is not good option to trade their tokens. And expect more to have lower demands since as you said the ICO is dead due to those coming incident happen for those past years.

That's right, with no demand on IEO, these decentralized exchange will not progress.
Also, people will not feel secure using a decentralized exchange as the owner has no responsibility on whatever will happen on the exchange.

like this old news about Etherdelta.

Cryptocurrency exchange EtherDelta gets hacked and replaced by a fake site that steals your money (https://mashable.com/2017/12/21/etherdelta-hacked/)


a lot of traders loses that time and that's the reason why ED loss its popularity.

for now it seems that indeed more people are using forkdelta. but in my opinion etherdelta and forkdelta belong to the same person/partner because both of them have similarities

indeed they are the same, forkdelta is the reincarnation of etherdelta, because etherdelta has many problems in their system, and they make forkdelta to replace etherdelta, trading in forkdelta is still safe and there are no problems

Etherdelta is no longer popular because of the many problems that have occurred to its users, so the decentralization exchange is now less interested and may not be used anymore.

Many cases that occurred against Etherdelta about the hack made the user furious when in the past the first DEX exchange I knew was Etherdelta.

Its a redirect issue which do really leads up users to a fake site and inputting all of their keys and after that incident then no one can easily trust up even if to those so-called decentralized exchanges.

I remember those days where ED was still flying with colors when the market had flooded with so much erc20 token based where it is commonly traded up into these exchanges and after such
days of popularity specially into those projects then expected that the volume is spectacular until all hype had gone and dex'es was dragged on along the way.- Not all but we have
seen significant impact in terms of volume/liquidity.

Etherdelta had a lots of problems in their system like "had to use high gas, couldn't cancle orders, orders were showing after cancellation".  So forkdelta is created to solve those problems instead of etherdelta.there is no chance to come back etherdelta

This crap exchange site must have deatch. I have lost a lot caused by i have not yet received my swpa coin. You can't put anything on this exchange site or use the feature. this exchange site already dead and the only dex that is still operating was FD but there was also another dex that similar as ED and FD like switch.ag

Though this is not the fault of EtherDelta but people blame the site for it, that time this exchange was really popular as it was the first DEX I guess and it grown due to the success of the ICO, I can still remember that I bought cheap bounty rewards in the past in ED that pump during the bull run, and that was EDG iirc.

Volume was my biggest issue with those sites when I used to use them but that has changed. There are too many exchanges that have come out since the inception of said exchanges, and that resulted in them losing business to competitors.

Volume and the prices on ether and fork delta are low, and because of that many don't go there. I sold some tokens there, and that wasn't a good move. I thought I will not be able to sell them and I did that there for some very low price after that token got listed on another exchange at a higher price.

EtherDelta is an exchange of the past and has become a memory for traders. because now there are many trades that far have the qualities of Etherelta. and the project owners entrust their coins to be traded in the new trade rather than EtherDelta

Of course, I will always remember Etherdelta and even if the hack did not happen in the past, Etherdelta will still struggle at the moment.
This exchange should sign off now as it seems like the popularity of DEX is already over.

Etherdelta was and is still a great exchange in my opinion . The fact they are descentralized they are way better than the centralised one . I think they will come back in a short period of time

Etherdelta was good back in the days but shit happens, it's sex so nothing to lose here, things can change in time for sure, I'm even surprised that forkdelta can get to this stage, good volume IMO, anyways Etherdelta is DEX, that's what makes it good

FD is just a birth child of etherdelta born of necessity. After the hack it was necessary to fork. The interface looks pretty the same for me except for a tight security architecture. Its the same for me

At least if this is still alive even no one use this exchange site again. It can't be used to trade crypto right now and the site looks like has already frozen by the developer because it's strictly prohibited the user to do any activity and the majority of ether delta users have been moving to the idex or another ethereum dex

we hope that etherdelta will be like it used to be because etherdelta is famous for the market that provides a variety of newly launched altcoins, but now many etherdelta users are switching to frokdelta and IDEX

When i was newbie, i use Etherdelta for treading. It was good but i found their hosting quality & security, at a low level. Besides it's risky when you have to give them your private key, before start trading.


they developed their Forkdelta exchange, this is because they could replaced it with Etherdelt

Many say if etherdelta has many problems and the transaction forkdelta is faster, in fact I have never used the two exchanges. I only heard from a few of my friends

etherdelta is an exchange where I learn to do my first trade. and if our see developments from this exchange, certainly a very sad thing now. and it could be that if there were no improvements about the etherdelta concept and system it would become a memory for me

But in the end the ED is able to recover and is even available up to now and also, problems or incidents experienced at the beginning will not guarantee the exchange to be destroyed, because with the problems experienced at the beginning it will at least make the exchange stronger over time, because there are at least some big exchanges that were hacked in the past but the proof is they are able to survive and still keep their customers comfortable until now.

Even though it was old news, but it is just on the agenda. Etherdelta is really a popular exchange, which a lot of people like you have made first trade on this platform. But as you said the developments from the exchange are very bad at the moment. Maybe the teams will make something about that for increasing the exchange, on the contrary as you mentioned it can be good history.

The problems at the first stages are more common problems, but what is their excuse for today? There is no single person who will prefer Etherdelta just because this exchange has a good history compared to the new DEX markets. I can't see the logic to survive under these market conditions, so there is a need for re-branding or run away.

all old players are certain to experience trading on etherdelta, because almost all altcoin can be traded there. so we can be sure that etherdelta has a very dense transaction and it is no longer efficient, because almost all altcoin tokens are listed there. so for that they created a forkdelta to be able to hold some tokens so that not all ran only in etherdelta. with the start of forkdelta development, etherdelta by itself begins to disappear from circulation.

If you never tried to use even both of those dexs and how you can say like that? ED is dead and that's why the exchange site and all of the functions that available on etherdelta were not running normally but forkdelta is still active and a lot of people were still trading on FD.

I guess you must try to use at least one time to get your impression with FD.

These exchangers were popular between 2016 and 2017, when it was possible to sell any coins after the completion of the ico company, even before listing on more rated exchanges. First of all, exchangers used these exchangers, and today their relevance has decreased, because in my opinion there are much more decentralized cryptocurrency exchanges with the best functionality. In addition, the future prospects of the new project depends primarily on the credibility of the exchange on which listing is carried out. But ForkDelt’s authority is not very high. only recently, something incomprehensible has been going on with the forkdelta resource, since there is no way to access the resource And at least see what is there and how. to

If Etherdelta died its kinda worries me about storing my private key on Etherdelta.
It is possible that the developer of Etherdelta might gather all our coins in our vulnerable wallet.
So do you think that we should create a new wallet for safety?

i just test the site out and it loads slow but not dead at all  . dunno where they got the false info but maybe they are also experiencing delays and also ed could have been down temporarily last time but thankfully they are back now  .  you shouldnt also have to worry bout your private keys because its a decentralized exchange anyway  not unlike from centralized ones that they can hold all your coins   . no need to panic or create a new wallet  .  if the old wallet works fine then just continue using it

In decentralized exchange once you logout your keys are out and not retain in the exchange, so nothing to worry about, the reason why Ed should not die is the fact that anyone can sell their erc20 token even before that token get listed, that's their uniqueness and why hunters use them alot,
My only problem with them is their slowness, they are not as fast as you would have wanted them, but they still get the job done, Fd and Ed used to be the place to dump tokens immediately without waiting on exchange, now I guess people have move on to better dex, the devs needs to restructure the place to keep it running.

They had problem since 2017. They scammed me (stolen my money there). They said that they got hacked, but I think they just stolen users...
There are a lot of trusted good decentralized exchanges nowdays.

Look Binance Dex, Tomo Dex, ViteX Deex exchange etc...

Are you sure? This is a decentralized exchange which have no control over your funds, you have access to your keys, maybe they got hacked, too bad you lost your funds, they were very popular dex and many people use them, now we have better dex with good ui and smooth performance.

There is no need of trading in any of the two when we have better dex out there. I sold some tokens in 2017 through ether delta but since then I could not remember using them again. I prefer those decentralized new exchanges.

None of them truly decentralized like etherdelta. The problem of etherdelta appeared since the subpoena that already sent by SEC. The latest dex that exists in the market can't be called the dex as if those new dex are truly decentralized exchange site and it's almost impossible for one of them has already hacked.

I know EtherDelta, ForkDelta decentralized exchange. EtherDelta, ForkDelta I never trade because these exchanges are very slow.This exchange has never been on my list of favorite exchanges.I have heard from my friends that these exchanges cause deposit withdrawal problems.I think it is better not to have these exchanges with so many problems.If this problem continues, there will come a time when no one will use these exchange.

Both exchanges are ancient, and very few investors choose to trade at these two decentralized exchanges. If I were to choose, I would choose IDEX because this exchange is much better and is always trusted by everyone. Of course, the liquidity is better, so I won't use the two exchanges you are referring to. Also, you can also consider a new option is Binance Dex because this is the option that people are interested in recently.

Does anybody know why there is no development about Etherdelta respective Forkdelta? It is a great dex but could be developed further. There are so many little things that could be integrated there.