Bitcoin Forum

with limited total supply im just got interesting, that's seems cool for me and i will follow it , why is my comment got deleted? ???

im so confused that im starting to learn what is decentralized digital currency and got deleted soon after the try on a centralized Bitcoin Forum.

Hi! Welcome to the forum. Dont be offended, your are not the only one. I’ve read a lot of complains about posts being deleted but dont take it personally. Its not deleted because it is a newbie’s post. Posts are deleted for some reasons and its not always because it is off topic. Sometimes they delete a repeated topic or posts. Or it could also be that the whole thread was deleted because similar topic has been created already before so all the other posts under the thread will also be lost.  Dont be discouraged. Feel at home.

You got interested, that's fine, but if you have nothing to add to the conversation, keep your mouth shut, and your hands away from the keyboard.
I know it may sound offensive, but think of all the people reading the thread that you've just posted in and everyone saying more or less the same thing "it's nice, i like it, keep it up, great project"... It would be so difficult to find any information there, you'd be scrolling through hundreds of posts with no meaning.
Don't get discouraged, we've all started at some point.

well you got to proof that you are not one of these spam accounts and get some activity to get respected more in your opinion and stuff^^ keep calm and post mate haha ~peace

because you posted useless, non-constructive content
your first 5 posts in your local board are in the same nature, luckily they are in foreign language and noone bother reporting them
to start your journey ;) on this forum, it's best to spend some time reading the rules thread
here's the link Unofficial list of (official) Bitcointalk.org rules, guidelines, FAQ (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=703657.0)

It's nothing like "you are not welcome here". We love newbies. It is just  a matter of post quality. We are all here to skill up on bitcoin, discuss the ecosystem and find new insights into things.
 
Always before you post anything ask yourself "Is what I am about to say going to contribute to the conversation?" if not then don't post anything.
If you like someone's post and you don't have an sMerit to send them you can always send them a private message. Let's say someone asks a question and wants to discuss security in payment channels and 200 people reply with "nice question". What would be the point of that? The whole thread will be filled with spam.
So these rules are just here to make it more pleasant for everyone using the forum.

The same goes for creating a topic like "How do I get merit?" or "I need merit" - Most of the forum absolutely hates this kind of spam.

Always ask good questions if you are going to start a new topic. Meaning try google around for 10 minutes at least, if you cant find an answer or don't understand the answer then post away for clarity. There are many seriously intelligent people on this forum who know the inter-workings of bitcoin top to bottom.

It's not because you feel that thing and so you wrote it and thinking it was good to others. No my my friend, newbies like us is always suspected for making a spam message just to increase the activity and be a Jr member to join a campaign, I'm not saying that is your kind but avoid yourself to be like that by making a constructive post and to avoid the mods of deleting your post.
Keep on learning man. Good luck.

Do not be discouraged, make it a valuable lesson, and as an introspection. To start posting, you should first read the rules that are applied in the forum, among other posts with quality sentences so not just saying "thank you", "I agree with you", and such phrases without in the add with other qualified sentences.
Here's a link to some more complete guides before you start posting
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1689727.0

I would'n say that. I am here newbie too, and never felt like being not welcomed. This is a great forum and community, best in the crypto world.

 I feel very welcome here at bitcoin community, I just passed the newbie status, now I'm JR member, some of my post was deleted but it does not bother me, because  I understand the rules and regulation here, and for those newbie who are interested to stay in the community, please follow the etiquette of posting.

It's simply because your reply is useless. It doesn't contribute to the topic whatsoever. If you post useless stuff like that, then you're no different from those new accounts who just spam to get their rank up. Thank god for the new merit system though.

I gave you a merit because I thought you were trying to help the forum with some of your posts ( not neccessarily this one ).

It doesn't look as if you are using Bitcoin yet, if you get the chance, you will learn a lot if you can make a couple of small transactions.

I beg to disagree. I've been in different threads for more than a week now and most of the members in the upper rank are very accommodating (but that is if you really like to learn). It is easy for those who have been here for a long time to notice if you really want to understand or share something helpful or just want to go up in the ranks or gain merits. I remember posting a new topic before that I thought would be helpful (it just contained 'additional' suggestion in response to another thread). My bad. I should have just posted my recommendations on the thread already discussing the topic rather than creating a new one that only contained supplementary information to that thread.

Each of us once walked through that "newbie door" for the first time. So behave yourself, follow the rules and you'll always be welcomed here  ;)

I believe everyone is welcome here what makes someone unwelcome is through his/her own manners on this forum it is also unwelcome here the off topic and the spam messages. So it's ok, don't be upset, we will have more understanding about this forum as we continue to learn while we are here.

if you have a question, first take the time to search, maybe the answer is already there. if you want to say something, think about whether it will be useful.

I don't think so, i don't feel it that way well sorry if you felt it that way, you can easily give comments in every topic you choose just learned to understand and obey their rules and regulation then you won't have any problem.

I translated your words and here's my result.
Some members here they don't know how to respect other members or newbie but you can report them via the report button if you know it's offensive post like trolling you can report them.
You can also check if what are the rules of this forum by checking this https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=703657.0

And if you found the post of this man is listed from the list of their forum rules you can report them.

And hope to read them well because even me, my post can be deleted if I'm not following the forum rules or guidelines.

i'm understand with your problem, why newbie or some new member such as not being accepted by more senior members because some newbie like you just spamming post and thread....

they will appreciate you if you contribute in this forum to make a better...
i've learn from my experience.. that creating a thread or post like what you create is useless and meaningless and that's one of the reasons why other members like to stay away from you..

so I suggest you to try not to create a thread like this anymore ( and i was trying too), with make a quality post i hope you can be accepted by other member... and with a lot of reading other thread i hope you can get more knowledge about this forum and what's in this forum...

I also have a start difficult time like you. With amount of little knowledge, I was very hard to post something which useful. So, step by step, I have tried my best to research and read more information to my post which have many contents to share with everybody. Stop lamenting and start trying right now

Welcome man, I just need to justify on your title there. Of course newbies are welcome here. I’ve been a newbie myself and I’ve felt a lot welcome here after posting such fruitful posts. My piece of advise to feel the same way as I did, post and comment fruitful things about the topic. Do not just react and compliment, add insights and idea and benefits. Do not treat the comment as a chat box, treat your comment as another post. Alright? Good luck out there bud.  :)

btw does anyone had their account ban for being a newbie out of sudden without warning?

Its just normal even i got that message when im i was newbie, deleted post are sometimes post that are not constructive  and considered as a spam. Level up the way you post make it constructive to avoid deletion of it.

Newbies are the new currency in this forum, without newbies who's gonna read the threads?  The higher rank members certainly don't read them because they're busy posting to make money.

Try to make your post more constractive. They will not delete your post if it is good post. As you are waiting for your rank to go up. Improve your knowledge about cryptocurreny.

Everyone is welcome on this thread, its just that trying to avoid spamming, so always try to make good post that will be helpful to others or you should be doing twitter facebook bounty and be giving report so that your activity / post can be upgraded...

Is it true that newbie not accepted here? so what posts that was deleted? I hope my this post will not be deleted as I am newbie also here

you are totally wrong to say that newbie is not accepted in this forum ...

all members here accept newbie, but there are things that make why some newbie is not liked by more senior member ... it's because:

1. never read sticky tread that contains term & condition about this forum

2. just do shitpost (post is meaningless and just spamming to raise rank only)

3. begging for merit

4. copy paste post others without permission

5. traded accounts or merit

6. because you never read another thread or never read another thread, finally most new members often create the same thread of the question (when you can read another thread to find answer from the question what that is in your mind)

so far, this is what I know why the more senior members do not like new members or seem to be away from it, so if we (new members) want to be appreciated and accepted by more senior members then contribute to make this forum better by avoiding things the things I've mentioned above ...

so do more reading and create a higher quality post/thread to make this forum better and appreciated by other members

Yes, they often do.  I try to write a lot of posts but for some reason some are removed , lower the activity and number of posts are((it is very difficult to develop my account.

This is a common forum, everything here has the same purpose. Newbie, Junior Member, Member, Full Member it just rank.
What distinguishes is experience, that's what bitcointalk is for. So we all here should be discussions about future cryptocurrency problems. sharing information and latest ico projects. Thanks.

Well, we all know that this forum is useful for everyone so that doesn't mean that everyone should post reply on every post. If you liked the post then the best way is to offer merits to the poster and if you don't have merits with you then it's completely fine, just read and understand that member is willing to say.

You are supposed to post/quote his text if you have anything valuable to add in the same or if you have any different opinion that would make the change.

Generally speaking I have found most on this forum to be helpful and accommodating. I have had a post previously deleted but you move on. Don't let it bother you and try to post constructively.

Look at it from another angle.

The forum is being bombarded with people that are creating newbie accounts to spam or advertise illegal content. They have to make this forum a nice place for legitimate and genuine Bitcoin enthusiasts. So, how do they discourage that kind of posting? - They restrict newbies more than other higher ranking users.

You go through this learning and educational newbie phase, to improve your posting quality and to show that you are also here for the right reasons. <Not spamming / shilling / bot posting etc.>

Once you bumped into some <no go areas> and your posts have been moderated, you will know what is accepted and what not.

We have all gone through this initiation or Hazing phase and we survived. Now we know what is accepted and what is not. Just read and follow the rules and you will be fine.  ;)

That is part of the job of the moderators here to see to it that the post of all the members in this forum is on topic and useful. Take it as a challenge and don't quit, somehow you will learn to post and you will thank the mods in the future because of what they have done to you.

Everyone of us begins from being a newbie so i think, thinking of being a newbie as not welcome is not right to say. Me,myself from being a newbie through patience im a member now. You need to make good quality post. And post only on threads that you are allow to post. Once you follow all the rules you will feel very welcome.

You know when I first started here,I got the same vibe. But now if I look at my journey from them to now, I realized just because of these restrictions I learnt a lot. Like before posting,I know I have to have research about that topic resulting me to gain more and more knowledge.And that it happens really quickly. Now if you ask me,I am thankful to all these restrictions for all the knowledge I gained is because of it and you will also feel the same mate!

It's simple that your comment on that thread was an unhelpful one line response and ought to be deleted

You wouldn't go far in here being an unhelpful one liner!!

That's right you should not be discouraged even though posts are being deleted because there are some of it are having lacks, gramatically error or the content information which you have replied don't have a good quality.

There is no prejudice for newbies. And in general, your rank doesn`t matter. Your behavior - that`s what important. It`s always worth remembering that this forum was created by the efforts of a huge number of people who invested their strength in the development of the bitcointalk site and continue to do so to this day. Many newbies come here and start breaking the rules. Such actions offend those members who struggle every day for the well-being of this forum. And they fight not only for themselves, but also for those newcomers who came here to study and share their knowledge.

When I was a beginner, at first I only read topics on cryptocurrencies in order to understand the subject matter. It`s better for newbies to communicate in local branches (to gradually overcome the language barrier), in Beginners & Help and Politics & Society boards. As in any other new business, you must go through a period of adaptation and the "rite of initiation" (write a really useful post, which will be appreciated by other members). But everything has its time. Don`t rush to suffer graphomania. Write only what you are sure of, and express only the point of view that you can argue. Remember that respect is one of the fundamental bitcointalk principles. Respect the rules and other participants, so you won`t have problems, and I`m sure you`ll feel the same attitude from other members of the forum.

It is true sir that so many people complains about this problems. But they don't know some thing that if users replied on any topic and topics get deleted for low quality or similar topic reasons and that's why whole thread has been deleted with all replys. Also if they make very low quality post or off topic unuseful post then their post will get deleted if any moderator saw that.

Exactly sir I also didn't feel that. Cause this forum is for every ranked peoples and members of this forum is very friendly with each others. Also they help each others on every situation.

Usually, the reason for the posts removal is precisely the unqualified author and irrelevant comment on his part (this may be due to the fact that the information published by the author is fake, non-argumentative, or has already been expressed many times in this topic). The size (length) of a post doesn`t play a special role (exceptions are posts like "hello", "me too", "support", "+1"). A constructive and interesting idea can be expressed with a couple of phrases, so your posts were hardly deleted due to the fact that they were too short (on the contrary, too long posts from newbies suspicions). The main reason was their irrelevance, as you correctly noted. Try to write the information are sure about and which will be useful to other participants.

All of us encountered this thing but it doesn't mean that you are not welcome as a newbie. We were all a newbie before so we knew the feeling. Let's just stick on the rules and make your post precisely.