Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Bitcoin Discussion => Topic started by: User705 on October 10, 2013, 03:13:47 AM



Title: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: User705 on October 10, 2013, 03:13:47 AM
So FBI "seized" BTC from SR.  And by "seized" they had to get their own address and then do a correct signed transaction to send btc to that address.  Oh and DPR supposedly has 600k more coins.  They are fully visible but can't be seized.  It must feel odd not to be able to just take.  It's likely FUD but still I wonder how long till governments just say fuck it and simply outlaw bitcoins. 


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: Phinnaeus Gage on October 10, 2013, 04:02:17 AM
So FBI "seized" BTC from SR.  And by "seized" they had to get their own address and then do a correct signed transaction to send btc to that address.  Oh and DPR supposedly has 600k more coins.  They are fully visible but can't be seized.  It must feel odd not to be able to just take.  It's likely FUD but still I wonder how long till governments just say fuck it and simply outlaw bitcoins. 

Good news! Bitcon won't be outlaw prior to DPR's trial.


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: User705 on October 10, 2013, 04:19:51 AM
Nice at least a few more years then.


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: Phinnaeus Gage on October 10, 2013, 04:28:45 AM
Nice at least a few more years then.

Are we forgetting about Mt Gox's account that is also locked up by the USG? The more they lock up and would eventually want in their coffer, the longer Bitcoin will stay online.


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: TheButterZone on October 10, 2013, 04:40:44 AM
Is 1F1tAaz5x1HUXrCNLbtMDqcw6o5GNn4xqX really an address the FBI generated securely and randomly themselves? Or did they just put an unencrypted private key of the Silk Road tumbler onto blockchain.info wallet, a private key that could be stored elsewhere and spent right out from other them?


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: Wipeout2097 on October 10, 2013, 06:20:21 AM
How come the FBI can't get the cash??  ::)

http://static02.mediaite.com/geekosystem/uploads/2012/07/security.png


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: crazynoggin on October 10, 2013, 06:28:25 AM

According to GTA 5, government institutions torture people to get information to get money so this must be true.


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: ixne on October 10, 2013, 11:06:55 AM
A great article by Wired on how the FBI might deal (or not deal) with their seized bitcoins:

http://www.wired.com/wiredenterprise/2013/10/silk-road-bust/

Very interesting problem for them: bitcoin has already been legally declared a form of currency, but they have no government-sanctioned method of dealing with bitcoin currency.  I'm guessing it either gets sold at auction or they tear up the private key.


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: Birdy on October 10, 2013, 01:39:21 PM
Oh and DPR supposedly has 600k more coins.  They are fully visible but can't be seized.
This is news to me. They are fully visible? Any source of that information?
Afaik the amount in his private pockets isn't known, only estimated (and most likely way less than 600k).


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: dserrano5 on October 10, 2013, 02:04:07 PM
This is news to me. They are fully visible? Any source of that information?

Yes, page 15 mentions 614,305 BTC in commissions.


Afaik the amount in his private pockets isn't known, only estimated (and most likely way less than 600k).

Of course it's less, DPR had some expenses to cover after all, and some of those were paid when BTC was worth much less than today.


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: cbhelp on October 10, 2013, 02:09:15 PM
A great article by Wired on how the FBI might deal (or not deal) with their seized bitcoins:

http://www.wired.com/wiredenterprise/2013/10/silk-road-bust/

Very interesting problem for them: bitcoin has already been legally declared a form of currency, but they have no government-sanctioned method of dealing with bitcoin currency.  I'm guessing it either gets sold at auction or they tear up the private key.

The governement loves money, 0% chance they tear up the private key


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: joesmoe2012 on October 10, 2013, 02:15:11 PM
This is news to me. They are fully visible? Any source of that information?

Yes, page 15 mentions 614,305 BTC in commissions.


Afaik the amount in his private pockets isn't known, only estimated (and most likely way less than 600k).

Of course it's less, DPR had some expenses to cover after all, and some of those were paid when BTC was worth much less than today.
They don't see that all in one account though, but rather they calculate it based upon sales recovered from the SQL DB.


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: shuttleclock on October 10, 2013, 04:02:58 PM
So I heard that 600K more Bitcoin doesn't belong to DPR, but it belongs to TSR members..


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: providers36 on October 10, 2013, 04:29:18 PM
Looking fwd to see how this will play out :) there are few scenarious how fby can destabilize btc...


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: FanEagle on October 10, 2013, 04:45:23 PM
I really wanna see what's going to happen.


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: Mitchell on October 10, 2013, 04:50:20 PM
So I heard that 600K more Bitcoin doesn't belong to DPR, but it belongs to TSR members..
Other way around.


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: User705 on October 10, 2013, 06:48:40 PM
Oh and DPR supposedly has 600k more coins.  They are fully visible but can't be seized.
This is news to me. They are fully visible? Any source of that information?
Afaik the amount in his private pockets isn't known, only estimated (and most likely way less than 600k).
I see.  I was under the impression that had his wallet files.  Wouldn't that mean they have the public addresses or no?


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: marcus_of_augustus on October 10, 2013, 07:19:22 PM
Nice at least a few more years then.

Are we forgetting about Mt Gox's account that is also locked up by the USG? The more they lock up and would eventually want in their coffer, the longer Bitcoin will stay online.

The Gox seizures were a US dollar Wells Fargo account ($2.1 million) and more recently a Dwolla account ($2.9 million), totalling $5 million, held by a subsidary called Mutum Sigillum LLC. Of course, "seizing" fiat digital bank accounts is a misnomer because the funds do not have an objective existence, e.g. like a private key, but are merely database entries that everyone believes have value so they do, until someone sets a flag against the database entry that signifies "seized".


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: Luckybit on October 11, 2013, 02:30:26 PM
Nice at least a few more years then.

Are we forgetting about Mt Gox's account that is also locked up by the USG? The more they lock up and would eventually want in their coffer, the longer Bitcoin will stay online.

The Gox seizures were a US dollar Wells Fargo account ($2.1 million) and more recently a Dwolla account ($2.9 million), totalling $5 million, held by a subsidary called Mutum Sigillum LLC. Of course, "seizing" fiat digital bank accounts is a misnomer because the funds do not have an objective existence, e.g. like a private key, but are merely database entries that everyone believes have value so they do, until someone sets a flag against the database entry that signifies "seized".


Just like tainted coins.


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: MicroGuy on October 11, 2013, 08:48:27 PM
I wonder what will happen to the coins (aka balances) belonging to people that were using the site for legal purchases?  ???


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: Epinnoia on October 11, 2013, 10:00:13 PM
A great article by Wired on how the FBI might deal (or not deal) with their seized bitcoins:

http://www.wired.com/wiredenterprise/2013/10/silk-road-bust/

Very interesting problem for them: bitcoin has already been legally declared a form of currency, but they have no government-sanctioned method of dealing with bitcoin currency.  I'm guessing it either gets sold at auction or they tear up the private key.

Quote
An FBI spokesperson quoted by Forbes explained that the amount of Bitcoins already seized was held from Silk Road user accounts, and that the agency has not yet been able to get to Ulbricht’s own encrypted Bitcoin wallet.

“That’s like another $80 million worth,” the spokesperson was quoted as saying.

The agency also appeared to be unsure what to do with the digital money trove once the Silk Road court case is closed.

“This is kind of new to us. We will probably just liquidate them,” the FBI spokesperson said.

http://rt.com/usa/fbi-silk-road-protest-785/


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: geniusboy91 on October 11, 2013, 10:16:50 PM
I wonder what will happen to the coins (aka balances) belonging to people that were using the site for legal purchases?  ???
I wouldn't expect anyone to ever see a (bit)cent. Legal users will just be lumped in with everyone else.


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: Interjekcion on October 11, 2013, 10:24:26 PM
If the Feds connected that wallet to DPR, can't they just get a court order for the key to his wallet?


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: QuantumQrack on October 12, 2013, 08:37:11 AM
He can plead the 5th, to avoid self-incrimination easily.


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: User705 on October 12, 2013, 08:39:06 AM
If the Feds connected that wallet to DPR, can't they just get a court order for the key to his wallet?
This is a joke right?


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: kcirazy on October 12, 2013, 10:28:46 AM
If the Feds connected that wallet to DPR, can't they just get a court order for the key to his wallet?
This is a joke right?

There is probably a legal difference between

  • a password to an ecrypted wallet file on your PC
  • a private key to an address in the blockchain.


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: dserrano5 on October 12, 2013, 12:09:05 PM
He can plead the 5th, to avoid self-incrimination easily.

Or give a passphrase/privkey that unlocks only a chunk of the profits big enough for him to be able to plausibly claim that it's the whole stash.


Title: Re: FBI has to follow bitcoin rules! How long will that last?
Post by: FanEagle on October 12, 2013, 01:37:21 PM
I don't know, but it seems it's going to be very complex to solve it.
Will he ever release the "secret" to unlock his wallet?