Bitcoin Forum

Alternate cryptocurrencies => Altcoin Discussion => Topic started by: harlemmarketmaker on April 08, 2018, 11:27:03 PM



Title: Unlimited claiming of BTCP from BTC. What is happening here???
Post by: harlemmarketmaker on April 08, 2018, 11:27:03 PM
I can't tell what is going on but I've been able to "claim" BTCP over 100 times from the SAME Bitcoin that I have. I was just messing around with wallets but I have 2100 BTCP now. It doesn't seem right, I haven't tried moving them to an exchange (as if there are any right now) but I can transfer them between wallets. I would chalk it up to a wallet bug but how can I possible move them between wallets? Has anyone else experienced this?



Title: Re: Unlimited claiming of BTCP from BTC. What is happening here???
Post by: faiz1998 on April 08, 2018, 11:29:49 PM
What is btcp sir? It is not specific


Title: Re: Unlimited claiming of BTCP from BTC. What is happening here???
Post by: harlemmarketmaker on April 08, 2018, 11:37:02 PM
What is btcp sir? It is not specific

Sorry, BTCP is Bitcoin Private. It was a bitcoin fork that happened it February. It was a huge mess, but this is ridiculous.


Title: Re: Unlimited claiming of BTCP from BTC. What is happening here???
Post by: Tankdestroyer on April 08, 2018, 11:53:06 PM
I can't tell what is going on but I've been able to "claim" BTCP over 100 times from the SAME Bitcoin that I have. I was just messing around with wallets but I have 2100 BTCP now. It doesn't seem right, I haven't tried moving them to an exchange (as if there are any right now) but I can transfer them between wallets. I would chalk it up to a wallet bug but how can I possible move them between wallets? Has anyone else experienced this?


I haven't really tried messing around with their wallets as I only claimed once, but most probably that is a bug on the fork's side not on the wallet. If you can transfer them between wallets, most probably BTCP developer is unaware of the issue ATM. It should be fixed soon but I wonder if you will lose those 2100 BTCP or not? Even if you don't many users would not claim BTCP so I think it is probably the reason why it is possible ATM(what you experienced).


Title: Re: Unlimited claiming of BTCP from BTC. What is happening here???
Post by: harlemmarketmaker on April 09, 2018, 12:15:34 AM
I wonder if I should move them to an exchange and try to cash them in....What a terrible time to want to do that though.


Title: Re: Unlimited claiming of BTCP from BTC. What is happening here???
Post by: forumsehat on April 09, 2018, 01:20:46 AM
I have never experienced as you experienced, you better try it on and move through other markets, to smooth.


Title: Re: Unlimited claiming of BTCP from BTC. What is happening here???
Post by: j62 on April 10, 2018, 06:29:50 AM
Lol are you kidding me right now... @hilariousandco

I will ask again, as this is on topic. PROOF or it didn't happen. Where are the steps to reproduce or at least screenshots?


Title: Re: Unlimited claiming of BTCP from BTC. What is happening here???
Post by: BTCPrivate on April 10, 2018, 11:43:05 AM
I can't tell what is going on but I've been able to "claim" BTCP over 100 times from the SAME Bitcoin that I have. I was just messing around with wallets but I have 2100 BTCP now. It doesn't seem right, I haven't tried moving them to an exchange (as if there are any right now) but I can transfer them between wallets. I would chalk it up to a wallet bug but how can I possible move them between wallets? Has anyone else experienced this?



We are unable to replicate this issue using the desktop wallet and/or the electrum wallet. If you are actually experiencing this issue, please report it via our GitHub repo: https://github.com/BTCPrivate/BitcoinPrivate/issues

Thank you,
The BTCP Contribution Team


Title: Re: Unlimited claiming of BTCP from BTC. What is happening here???
Post by: keycellko on April 10, 2018, 11:57:17 AM
How did you claim it? Which wallet did you use? There are only 3 wallets that can be used to transfer bitcoin private: Coinomi, Electrum BTCP and BTCP Full Node Wallet. I saw an article giving out the steps on how to claim the forked coin. You might wanna check on it here https://www.buybitcoinworldwide.com/claim-sell-bitcoin-private/


Title: Re: Unlimited claiming of BTCP from BTC. What is happening here???
Post by: commlinx on April 11, 2018, 12:15:41 PM
If you are experiencing unlimited claim of btcp,  then it should be the fault of the.wallet provider,  maybe there is an error in the code with is to duplicate the coin and add the equivalent  of the newly forked coin into the database,  am very sure that sooner or later,  it should be corrected before they can enable transfer of that new forked coin in which you have received from your existing bitcoin.


Title: Re: Unlimited claiming of BTCP from BTC. What is happening here???
Post by: rezurect on April 11, 2018, 12:19:27 PM
Looks like almost nobody is supporting this fork anyway, sell it all before its too late.