Bitcoin Forum

Hello, I have a new account here and have made 1 post reply, and 2 (or so?) posts, both of the posts got like 1 or 2 replies but then they dissapeared, I'm wondering if there is some rule I broke or what I have to do to maintain a post that I make? not sure what the deal is, thanks

Read the forum rules to know why.
Unofficial list of (official) Bitcointalk.org rules, guidelines, FAQ (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=703657.0)

yeah, I don't see any of the rules I broke, I didn't make both posts back to back, the 2nd was a day or 2 after I noticed the first was deleted (they weren't the same post either)

Make a new account with another adress to see if the problem is present with a new account

Based on the "Deletion log (mod log) (https://bitcointalk.org/modlog.php)":

- I didn't find a deleted reply regarding your account (I'm guessing the thread that you replied to, was moved to "Trashcan (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?board=15)" [as a result, all of the posts on that thread will automatically disappear too])
- You didn't receive any notifications, am I right (if so, then the above line is accurate)?

You probably made your posts on a megathread that has outlived its usefulness. The Bitcoin Discussion board is fertile ground for spam posts and useless megathreads that end up deleted. Is that where you made posts you are complaining about?

Might have broken some rules unknowingly.

If you post

1.a copy paste post
2.In a unrelated section
3.Something doesn't agree with Bitcointalk rules.

they will be deleted.

There is no other reason to delete your posts.

1.Don't copy paste anything from anywhere. This may lead to account ban also. If you want to quote something use below tags.



2.Post things in a suitable section. ex:- post about bitcoin in bitcoin discussion not in altcoin discussion.
3.Always folow rules and guidlines.
Unofficial list of (official) Bitcointalk.org rules, guidelines, FAQ (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=703657.0)

Then your posts will be perfectly safe.

Maybe your post is some kind of off topic or just been moved though , if the post are deleted by reason you will receive some messages that you're post or thread are deleted. I think its better to explore the forum first though , and read some rules and regulation don't get lazy on reading it.

You are right. You are having activity score of 7 with three day's posts.  It means 4 day's posts are got deleted.  I advise you :
Go to >My Messages> check messages in Inbox> 
In case some posts have been deleted; you must have got some message from Bitcoin Forum with your message which have been deleted and reason for deleting the post.

Hello I think that scenario is necessary if you post or reply but after a few hours you notice that your post gonna be disappearing. Probably that situation was being deleted or sometimes if your post or reply was read by the global moderator and your post had a personal message it will be remove by the moderator. But that things is ordinary if your post was deleted don't blame our global moderator because they are also do their respective job.

Thank you.

At least one of your posts was nuked because you opened the thread "Mining Profitability vs Just Hodling" in Mining speculation (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?board=81.0).

There are like 100 threads on this subject and frodocooper (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=988740) just nukes them, and thank god he does this.

Correct, there are forum rules in bitcointalk forum. The reason why your post is delete may be.
1-your post violate some of bitcointalk's rules.
2-it may have been moved to another section.
3-your post may be trash that's why they deleted it or it may be a duplicate to another post that may have been posted before you post.

What sort of suggestion is this ? You are asking him to create a new account just for checking why the posts are getting deleted.

Op, I think the possible reason is that the thread you posted in was deleted because of violation of forum rules and thus your reply was also deleted (like all other replies made there).

Considering your account was not banned there's a good chance they may have been redundant posts in threads that have become a hotbed for spam.

Did you receive a PM stating a post/reply if yours was deleted? If not then it was the whole thread being trashed. It happens.

Having posts deleted isn't a major concern either. I've had several deleted, it happens. Before you post just think has this been said a bunch of times in the thread? Am I adding anything of value to the conversation?

Good luck.


Very true.

Edit: Yeah hoodwinked scrolling mobile, this is why I wish threads auto locked after a certain amount of time.

OP was last active 157 days ago. I don't think he will read your answer.  :)