Bitcoin Forum

if a beggar asks you for money, what will you do?
what if the rules in your country do not allow money to beggars and if you are still willing to give then you will get a fine.
so what would you do ???

i'm having this, try to give me a solution .. thanks

Hello, and in what country do you live - that you can not give money to the poor?
In my country, Ukraine, the poor in most cases - it's lazy, alcohol-consuming personality. Because in my country work can always be found to keep myself and my family.
PS And I do not when I do not give them money, but I can buy food.

First of all, if your country will have such rules as to fine people giving alms to beggars, they should have an effective method make lives better for these people. If not, then i think it's not right to have such rules. And giving money isn't a good idea as well. Better to just give them what they really need. Food, clothing, medicines, if i'm not allowed to give them money, i'd give them those

Instead of using the money to help the homeless you can buy them food and water to help them. I thought of the solution that was using Crypto to help him, but I realised that the homeless could not have smartphones to use, this is impossible.

If they are then that is their own fault. They can work on their own if they have two hands and two legs and almost everything they need for work! There are so many employment options in the country, from swiping, car washing and much more which doesn't need formal education or things like that! If they are willing to work then they can surely and could make a difference in everything.  ;)

Giving money to poor is not good thing as it depresses their will to self-work! So its better that they are left alone and let them think by themselves to work more and feed themselves.

---

For disabled poor its understandable but for healthy peoples its not a choice!

What kind of question is this?as what youve said the government not allowing you to give beggars money,but you can buy them everything that they need instead of giving cash,whybnot buy them foods,and clothing's i think government will agree on that right?simple matter youre just making it hard,next time use youre commonsense regarding this kind of nonsense

It seems that there is no country that do not allow their countryman to help other people in need because its economic growth as far as I know, you and only your countryman can help the progress of you country.
Anyway if that is the case you better give them a food aside from money.

Well, your topic is quite different, as a way of helping beggars instead of giving money you can give in kind like food, clothing, scholarship to there children or anything which you can afford.

In my country, I do not allow to give money to beggar, and I will get fine or will be arrested for giving them money. But we still can donate money to institution,orphanage, or come into their home to give what they need. Because in my country, beggar can have much income, and for them begging its like a job. This "job" couse lazziness and they can't learn that to achive somethings we need doing somethings that not easy.

If a Country's rule not to give money to beggars, then it must be followed. and it's safe to assume that the Government of that Country already got some ideas to prevent the beggars from what they are doing.so I will obey the Rules and will still help beggars by giving them what they need instead of Money.

Is there a country where people can't help each other!! This is really wierd.
You can help him and give hkm some money without being noticed.
Else, try to buy him some food as other members proposed or help him find a job so he can be able to support himself.

You have to give a job to the beggar, if you give it money it will be useless because it will not make his life any better.

If will have to follow the rules and laws, but you can look for loopholes. I am sure that giving food might be allowed in such a case.

I tell him to find a job and work. because I will not give him money, he will not change anything.I think this is the best for him.

Money is not the best way to help others. There are many people who cause poverty for their own reasons. Some are very lazy and have some bad hobbies. There is no need to pity such people. Of course you can give up some food or advise them to work out of humanitarianism.

You can't give money to poor people? It is normal in almost every part in the world to just help people that needs this, it is just a human behavior to do things like that for me.

I think helping others is a good deed. Where the rich help the poor. those who are able to help the poor and this also needs to be applied to our children. I think there is no prohibition to help those who are weak. But if we want to give beggars better not get used to give money because it will make them lazy. Buy them food, drink or something that is their daily needs such as clothes and medicine.

state action may beggars can work to earn their own money, and so that people can live independently without relying on others,

It is more of a question related to our morals. I understand I shouldn't, but sometimes it just feels like giving them some money.

Maybe you could give money to beggars it silently without no one saw you but, if you're caught and fined just pay the fines then you can. Because I believe as we give something to other people with sincere then God will replace him.

There are few people who are in charge of your country - you and all the rest of citizens from there.

Can give it other things, as long as it is not money, for example, to eat, but also can help him.

I wanna go to travel around the world :)

Best solution here. Its is even better to give food to begggar than money wiwh will be used to buy booze.

If your country has a rule of not giving money to he beggars maybe it's better to give them food. It's a better alternative than simply giving them money. In that case you will know that the beggar will eat a real foor instead of money.

If in my country there are laws about virtual currency and how to use them, the government has the intention to remove them from the market; many people think that money will beg.

I will keep trying to do something good for ourselves and for others. like behaving well to someone older than us .

Better to give them useful items and give scholarships. And build their house

I agree with giving them something like food or clothing. That way you know they are using it for something that isn't destructive. At least that's the general idea.

If I have the money. I will spare change. It's good to give back to charity. You should always give back but I would give food unless you know the person is not using iyt for drugs than I would only buy food for him or her

A country where there is a law against giving money to beggars should have a centre for the less privileged then because they will always exist. If that be the case, there is no wisdom in giving money to beggars on the street when that can lead you to trouble. The best is always to donate to those centres whose job is to care for the less privileged.

If there is a government that prohibits giving to a beggar, I think it is very unreasonable. if we can give, then why do not we just give something that a beggar needs, because he asked not to get away. but if in your place the government forbids a person to give money to a beggar, as a people who are obedient to the rules you must abide by the rules. unless you still have a sense of pity to a beggar, you can break it and give money to beggars.

i will buy bitcoin

I will invest bitcoin

I think this is true when investing in Bitcoin in the current situation, and many people believe that will be able to receive proper profits this month.

I will give more than a small amount of money that I have in person, but I will not provide much money because no one wants to lose money without receiving anything.

Well if you're asking me i would give the beggar money regardless of the rules in my country cuz you never know their story and how they ended up at that position  ;)

Well I believe there is camera mounted everywhere? So you could still give when no one sees you.

Call the person to your house and give to the person that way no body will know you did.

I doubt if any country will do such a thing where there is hunger in the land. Which country is that so I could verify your claim properly?.

Giving to the beggars secretly or buying them food would a better option.

If that is how the situation looks like then I 'd suggest to help them with food besides money.

I will try to earn a lot of money to have a stable life later. I will marry and give birth to lovely children, obediently.

I would make create a business and try my best at expanding it globally.

help someone is always good and if you found the man really needs money then i think you must help.

i will definitely help him or her.

well if there's legal ramifications, I'll be careful.

in general though, it depends on how they ask. depends on the circumstances surrounding them, and on my financial situation at the time. I don't give out of guilt (I think) and I remain aware of the fact that when I give to them, it makes me feel good too, like I've got 'status' or whatever.

I'll make sure I contribute my quota to the growth of crytocurrency in this county and the world at large as fast as possible.

I will ensure that I love my wife, children, parent and friends .

In my country most of homeless ask you for money to buy alcohol that's why I don't give them any.

if a beggar comes to me for money surely i will give money to him or her, might they need my help and helping other make me happy......

Right now I can do anything to make money. Sometimes life is not what we expected, we are forced to adapt to survive.

right now i'm able to do something to make money. occasionally existence is not what we predicted, we are forced to adapt to continue to exist.

The worst thing about giving money to beggars is that you don't know if they are telling the truth. In many places beggars are actually quite rich. They realize that they can make more money just sitting on the street than at a regular job, so they choose to do that. Some of them will even make up fake illnesses or stories. They may say that they need money to buy bus tickets home. Then you can see them in the same place asking for money for a bus ticket home the next day. They don't actually want to leave. Of course, sometimes people really need help. I usually only give money to people who are providing a service that makes the city better. I like to give money to musicians, for example. If somebody says they need money for food, I sometimes buy them food. I don't like to give them money because they may not actually spend it on food.

What i would do is to give them food or to feed them somewhere. I'll rather take them and give them things that they need specially food. i would definitely not going to give them money because you will jever know what are they going to do with the money.

Totally agreed. Giving them money is actually a bad thing for them!

You have to give a job to the beggar, if you give it money it will be useless because it will not make his life any better.

Do not make things complicated. I don't know any country that prohibits giving alms to street people. If you want to help, then help. If you want to give them money or food, then give them. Do not hesitate to help. That's what God wants us, help each other.

Di negara saya pengemis banyak yg berpura pura susah

I want to invest in a promising ICO and hope it will be profitable in the near future. Although I know there will be many difficulties but I will not give up my intention. Hope I will succeed.

My own opinion is that if you love begars so much and you really wish to help, start a small NGO that provides basic needs such as food, clothing or shelter etc. to the less privileged. This way you avoid breaking the law and still be able to accomplish your objectives. Overtime, you may get support from the government or private companies/individuals.

I do nothing i receive salary from my parents, 2000USD a month.

if the regulations in your country require not to give beggars then you must obey the rules. let the government save beggars.

 I always give money to beggars, But if you are not allowed to give money, then buy food and clothes

I would give if he or she really need the money and pay the fine if I get caught

I might not because there is a reason why the government doesn't allow people to give money to beggars so most of the time I might not give     

Focus on what you don't

How is that possible that You can't give change money to beggars?
What country are You from?

I would assume that the reason you want to give money to the beggar is because you want to them to have money to be able to buy food, well if that is the case I think it would be better if you just give them food. By this I am sure that your government would not take it against you as it shows only that you want to help.

If it is really necessary I might give if the beggar is a child or a women specially

Definitely will donate without hesitation but without getting caught 

If your country has a ban on giving money to beggars, then you don't need to give something to beggars, just report to the government so that they provide solutions for the welfare of the people, for example providing employment, providing business capital, etc.

If in my country govt will not allow it then i will do it and say to other do it if it is illegal...

Depends on the situation and the status of the beggar 

I am willing to give and take the fine if get caught 

I will see what beggars are like, is the beggar body still healthy or helpless, if the beggar is healthy then I will not give him money but I will give him advice. If the beggar is helpless then I will give him money and help him in other matters.

It is a very interesting question - where are you from? I have never heard about rules like these.
But the most people in this topic are right - you could buy some food or clothes for example.

clearly will donate with out hesitation but with out getting caught

In my opinion, it's best not to give them money, but what do they really need - food, clothes, medicines!

 Sure I will give because that is the best thing to do

I will give other gifts in the form of food, clothes, story books, bags etc., besides if I have a job he can do, then I will give him a job

Well i think charity is the optimal answer not to feel bad and have a faith that that money/food/clothes or anything will get to him or her. well if not you will still help others and it's not your fault you have dumbass rulers who restrict kindness

when you have more money there is no harm in giving to the needy because to me it is their fortune through our money