Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Mining speculation => Topic started by: jenga on November 27, 2013, 11:35:55 AM



Title: Bitcoin difficulty is slowing down?
Post by: jenga on November 27, 2013, 11:35:55 AM
For some reason, according to this chart, the bitcoin network hashrate is having major fluctuations and it appears as it is losing its exponential growth:
http://bitcoin.sipa.be/speed-lin.png (http://bitcoin.sipa.be/speed-lin.png)
Why is that? Some big pool is having issues lately?


Title: Re: Bitcoin difficulty is slowing down?
Post by: DeathAndTaxes on November 27, 2013, 11:40:50 AM
For some reason, according to this chart, the bitcoin network hashrate is having major fluctuations and it appears as it is losing its exponential growth:
http://bitcoin.sipa.be/speed-lin.png (http://bitcoin.sipa.be/speed-lin.png)
Why is that? Some big pool is having issues lately?

KNC stopped shipping?  Don't worry they will be shipping 2.5 PH/s+ pretty soon again.


Also you do understand that exponential growth forever is impossible right?  Within a couple years Bitcoin mining would use more energy than used by the human race for all other purposes combined.  Law of large numbers takes over.   When network is 1 PH/s for the network to double in a month requires 1 PH/s more hash power today it would require >5 PH/s so even if for example ASIC companies shipped out constant volume the growth as a % would decline.  For the growth % to remain constant they would need to manufacture and ship an exponential volume.  Thousands of units per month this year,  millions of units per month next year, billions of units per month the year after that, trillions of units per month the year after that, quadrillions of units per month the year after that ...




Title: Re: Bitcoin difficulty is slowing down?
Post by: jenga on November 27, 2013, 12:05:26 PM
KNC stopped shipping?  Don't worry they will be shipping 2.5 PH/s+ pretty soon again.

Acknowledged.

Also you do understand that exponential growth forever is impossible right?  Within a couple years Bitcoin mining would use more energy than used by the human race for all other purposes combined.  Law of large numbers takes over.   When network is 1 PH/s for the network to double in a month requires 1 PH/s more hash power today it would require >5 PH/s so even if for example ASIC companies shipped out constant volume the growth as a % would decline.  For the growth % to remain constant they would need to manufacture and ship an exponential volume.  Thousands of units per month this year,  millions of units per month next year, billions of units per month the year after that, trillions of units per month the year after that, quadrillions of units per month the year after that ...

That's true of course. But one shall also consider the efficiency of new ASIC chips making the exponential growth last longer. If even asic companies sell at a constant rate, but their chips become faster and more efficient the effect is the same with lower energy consumption. As older mining rigs get replaced by new less power hungry miners the total network energy consumption may even decrease (very unlikely but hey, we are in the "speculation" subsection :P).
My point is that the hashrate will continue going up exponentially for an unexpectedly long amount of time.


Title: Re: Bitcoin difficulty is slowing down?
Post by: DeathAndTaxes on November 27, 2013, 12:15:06 PM
On the efficiency aspect it is nothing compared to the prior difficulty increases.

A GPU is something like 300 J/GH.  The "worst" ASIC is ~8 J/GH so you are talking almost a 40,000% improvement.   Various different smaller process node designs dropped from the 8 J/GH to 5 J/GH to ~0.8 J/GH (Bitfury - reference clock)).

On paper we have the rest of the 28nm players showing ~0.8 J/GH and KNC estimating ~0.7 J/GH.   Seeing a trend.  Overnight we went from 300 J/GH to 8 J/GH and then over the next six months saw that fall by a factor of 10 to ~0.8 J/GH.   That "might" go down to a staggering 0.7 J/GH by next Spring.

Quote
My point is that the hashrate will continue going up exponentially for an unexpectedly long amount of time.

Who is going to buy all that hashrate increases. $3 per GH works out to $3M per PH.   So to double the network again in a month would "only" require $15M in sales.  Ok no problem there.  To double it again would require another $30M in sales the following month, $60M the next month, $120M the monh after that, a quarter billion the month after that ...

Will difficulty keep going up?  Oh HELL YEAH!  Is it possible from either a cashflow or energy standpoint to double continually every month for years?  No.



Title: Re: Bitcoin difficulty is slowing down?
Post by: CobaltBlueD on November 27, 2013, 04:35:04 PM
On the efficiency aspect it is nothing compared to the prior difficulty increases.

A GPU is something like 300 J/GH.  The "worst" ASIC is ~8 J/GH so you are talking almost a 40,000% improvement.   Various different smaller process node designs dropped from the 8 J/GH to 5 J/GH to ~0.8 J/GH (Bitfury - reference clock)).

On paper we have the rest of the 28nm players showing ~0.8 J/GH and KNC estimating ~0.7 J/GH.   Seeing a trend.  Overnight we went from 300 J/GH to 8 J/GH and then over the next six months saw that fall by a factor of 10 to ~0.8 J/GH.   That "might" go down to a staggering 0.7 J/GH by next Spring.

Quote
My point is that the hashrate will continue going up exponentially for an unexpectedly long amount of time.

Who is going to buy all that hashrate increases. $3 per GH works out to $3M per PH.   So to double the network again in a month would "only" require $15M in sales.  Ok no problem there.  To double it again would require another $30M in sales the following month, $60M the next month, $120M the monh after that, a quarter billion the month after that ...

Will difficulty keep going up?  Oh HELL YEAH!  Is it possible from either a cashflow or energy standpoint to double continually every month for years?  No.



No argument the rate of increase is unsustainable.  Of course, $/GHs and J/GH will decrease. I haven't run the numbers but going back to CPU/GPU days it's pretty obvious that constant investment will still result in significant increase in difficulty. Mining ROI is painful.


Title: Re: Bitcoin difficulty is slowing down?
Post by: Syke on November 28, 2013, 01:07:36 AM
This is the calm before the storm. Enjoy it while you can.


Title: Re: Bitcoin difficulty is slowing down?
Post by: Sharky444 on November 28, 2013, 01:17:44 AM
This is the calm before the storm. Enjoy it while you can.

+1

Next year large corporation will go into Bitcoin mining. Home users will loose the possibility to mine.


Title: Re: Bitcoin difficulty is slowing down?
Post by: TheJuice on November 28, 2013, 05:40:39 AM
We will see ~40% increase per month until May of the next year. Beyond that I see 2 options - complete plateau or BTC goes up enough in price/we go mainstream that a 'real' company (intel, etc) starts making mining equipment for the masses.

Things are finally looking up for miners.


Title: Re: Bitcoin difficulty is slowing down?
Post by: redmetal on November 28, 2013, 05:50:04 AM
We will see ~40% increase per month until May of the next year. Beyond that I see 2 options - complete plateau or BTC goes up enough in price/we go mainstream that a 'real' company (intel, etc) starts making mining equipment for the masses.

Things are finally looking up for miners.

I tend to agree with this, 40% for a little while seems fesable, Cointerra, Hashfast, VMC, and KNC for their second round will continue this boost,
Look at the lastest GPU's 11nm is where we are at, I don't see any company speeding the 10's of millions required to tape this out, not now anyway, maybe when bitcoin is mainstream, but why would a company like intel want to share in this small time show? ASIC companies are only selling millions worth or hardware, intel would need to be purswaded by 100's of millions before pumping an investment that large into something this small.


Title: Re: Bitcoin difficulty is slowing down?
Post by: DeathAndTaxes on November 28, 2013, 05:52:04 AM
Look at the lastest GPU's 11nm is where we are at

Are you from 5 to 7 years in the future or are these GPU from imaginary land? :)

Top of the line GPUs are 28nm today.


Title: Re: Bitcoin difficulty is slowing down?
Post by: Bitcoinorama on November 28, 2013, 08:24:28 AM
Oh no, so you mean all the FUD the Genesis block spreads is just to redirect traffic to their website as part of some marketing scam??

Who'd have thought? ::)


Title: Re: Bitcoin difficulty is slowing down?
Post by: redmetal on November 28, 2013, 08:52:50 AM
Look at the lastest GPU's 11nm is where we are at

Are you from 5 to 7 years in the future or are these GPU from imaginary land? :)

Top of the line GPUs are 28nm today.
Apologies DRAM is at 11nm gpus are almost at 20nm


Title: Re: Bitcoin difficulty is slowing down?
Post by: AMuppInTime on December 09, 2013, 11:05:23 PM
ASICminer plans a chip with <.2J/GH for January 20 Tapeout... Specs expected before tapeout. They are one of the big HW manufacturers and decided to skip their gen2 to focus of gen3... And have the experience too.
(discl - holder). friedcat (CEO) assumes the network difficulty will be 1000PH in June...


Title: Re: Bitcoin difficulty is slowing down?
Post by: sgbett on December 09, 2013, 11:54:10 PM
For some reason, according to this chart, the bitcoin network hashrate is having major fluctuations and it appears as it is losing its exponential growth:
http://bitcoin.sipa.be/speed-lin.png (http://bitcoin.sipa.be/speed-lin.png)
Why is that? Some big pool is having issues lately?

KNC stopped shipping?  Don't worry they will be shipping 2.5 PH/s+ pretty soon again.


BFL also cleared their backlog...

I'm enjoying the breather, I might get 3 BTC from my single instead of 2 :)


Title: Re: Bitcoin difficulty is slowing down?
Post by: Motya on December 10, 2013, 12:04:28 AM
For some reason, according to this chart, the bitcoin network hashrate is having major fluctuations and it appears as it is losing its exponential growth:
http://bitcoin.sipa.be/speed-lin.png (http://bitcoin.sipa.be/speed-lin.png)
Why is that? Some big pool is having issues lately?

At the very end of that graph, aren't the estimate lines speeding up with a vengeance?


Title: Re: Bitcoin difficulty is slowing down?
Post by: DrG on December 10, 2013, 05:22:05 AM
KNC batch 2 delivered on time


Title: Re: Bitcoin difficulty is slowing down?
Post by: Syke on December 10, 2013, 05:42:42 AM
I'm enjoying the breather, I might get 3 BTC from my single instead of 2 :)

A 30% difficulty adjustment increase is a breather?


Title: Re: Bitcoin difficulty is slowing down?
Post by: jenga on December 10, 2013, 08:16:49 AM
For some reason, according to this chart, the bitcoin network hashrate is having major fluctuations and it appears as it is losing its exponential growth:
http://bitcoin.sipa.be/speed-lin.png (http://bitcoin.sipa.be/speed-lin.png)
Why is that? Some big pool is having issues lately?

At the very end of that graph, aren't the estimate lines speeding up with a vengeance?

Not when I started the thread...


Title: Re: Bitcoin difficulty is slowing down?
Post by: sgbett on December 11, 2013, 01:31:04 AM
I'm enjoying the breather, I might get 3 BTC from my single instead of 2 :)

A 30% difficulty adjustment increase is a breather?

Me and my big mouth eh ;)