Bitcoin Forum

Alternate cryptocurrencies => Altcoin Discussion => Topic started by: miner2002 on November 29, 2013, 12:22:28 AM



Title: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: miner2002 on November 29, 2013, 12:22:28 AM
I'm currently mining FTC coins on my gaming rig (Nvidia 770) and I'm getting close to 10 coins per day.  I just ordered the R9 290 so I should be getting about 3 times the performance, or 30 FTC coins a day. 

30 coins x 30 days = 900 coins x $1= $900

At $900/month, that is a massive ROI.  I'll get the cash back for my whole rig in around a month if prices hold. I know I'm not taking into account energy cost, but even still, it should be very profitable. 

If I were to invest in 5 similar rigs, I could be pulling in at least $2,500 / month if not more after energy expense which seems like a no-brainer.

Obviously if the coin prices on FTC drop that math doesn't work.  Other than the risk of price drop, what am I missing? This just seems too obvious and too easy.



Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: An amorous cow-herder on November 29, 2013, 08:28:55 AM
Switched my gaming rig (with an ATI 7950) from LTC to FTC as well. FTC is a bit more profitable currently. Not sure if the prices are gonna hold though, and if they do i would assume the difficulty to rise pretty quickly.
The thing about no-brainers is that many people realise it quickly, which will probably reduce the profit fairly quickly. Or in other words, you might end up with a couple of gaming rigs that are near worthless as miners in a couple of weeks.
You might ROI by then (and end up with a couple of gaming that rigs that have a resale value as well), it may continue to be worthwhile (possibly switching to a different altcoin) or you may have wasted a couple of thousand on gaming rigs. Your choice, your risk.


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: Bipity Bupity on November 29, 2013, 09:12:10 AM
how about adding some hd 7950 instead? they are really cheap and perform very good, 640 - 650 kh/s each for me, with some overclocking i can get two of them at 1.4 MH/s.. right now they make more or less 0.04 btc a day, and i dont pay for energy.. not bad for 2 cards.. im planning to add more hd 7950 of course  8)

i tried mining on feathercoin and other coins pools but it was kinda messy, all the clients, all the logins.. i switched to a middlecoin, that way its more clean, one wallett, no logins..


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: skleven on November 29, 2013, 10:14:18 AM
If you are planning to mine almost fulltime, stay away from the 290 and 290x. The best gpu`s for mining now days is 7950, 7970 or 280x. The first two is easy to get second hand. And put as many gpus in the same rig to cut costst. Both in hardware and power.


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: limbaugh on November 29, 2013, 10:18:12 AM

Obviously if the coin prices on FTC drop that math doesn't work.  Other than the risk of price drop, what am I missing? This just seems too obvious and too easy.



It's an unusually profitable time. Mining is a low profit margin, don't be fooled. Most months you are scraping enough just to pay for power. Honestly I had most of my rigs boxed and ready to sell a few weeks ago. Unboxed them to mine some TAG.


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: Lauda on November 29, 2013, 10:18:56 AM
The crazy increase in prices have made the ROI times very short.
Buying the 290 or 290x is a mistake.


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: miner2002 on November 29, 2013, 02:30:01 PM
The reason I went with the 290 was because I don't want to JUST mine, I want to game as well so that aspect made the 290 more appealing to me.  I had the GTX 770 and by simply switching to the 290 I'm going to get about 3x the performance when I am mining and slightly improved gaming performance.

If I set up another rig solely to mine, I'll go with a different card of course.

Personally I see bitcoin continuing to do well and Alt coins continuing to go up.  With the current ROI of about a month, and the potential to mine other coins, it seems like a risk work taking to me!


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: Lauda on November 29, 2013, 02:32:19 PM
The reason I went with the 290 was because I don't want to JUST mine, I want to game as well so that aspect made the 290 more appealing to me.  I had the GTX 770 and by simply switching to the 290 I'm going to get about 3x the performance when I am mining and slightly improved gaming performance.

If I set up another rig solely to mine, I'll go with a different card of course.

Personally I see bitcoin continuing to do well and Alt coins continuing to go up.  With the current ROI of about a month, and the potential to mine other coins, it seems like a risk work taking to me!
You don't need a 290 for gaming.
A 7950 is enough.


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: miner2002 on November 29, 2013, 02:38:19 PM
The reason I went with the 290 was because I don't want to JUST mine, I want to game as well so that aspect made the 290 more appealing to me.  I had the GTX 770 and by simply switching to the 290 I'm going to get about 3x the performance when I am mining and slightly improved gaming performance.

If I set up another rig solely to mine, I'll go with a different card of course.

Personally I see bitcoin continuing to do well and Alt coins continuing to go up.  With the current ROI of about a month, and the potential to mine other coins, it seems like a risk work taking to me!
You don't need a 290 for gaming.
A 7950 is enough.

Not to go too off topic here, but that's a matter of personal preference.  You don't NEED a 290 to game, but when you're playing BF4 a higher end card like the 290 makes a very noticeable difference.

You have every right to your opinion though :)


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: Lauda on November 29, 2013, 06:03:10 PM
Not to go too off topic here, but that's a matter of personal preference.  You don't NEED a 290 to game, but when you're playing BF4 a higher end card like the 290 makes a very noticeable difference.

You have every right to your opinion though :)
No, it makes almost no difference. It is overkill. You should consider quitting gaming and just focus on mining, just a suggestion.


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: An amorous cow-herder on November 29, 2013, 11:31:18 PM
Not to go too off topic here, but that's a matter of personal preference.  You don't NEED a 290 to game, but when you're playing BF4 a higher end card like the 290 makes a very noticeable difference.

You have every right to your opinion though :)
No, it makes almost no difference. It is overkill.
You dont even know what kind of setup the OP has. Some people have dual or even quad monitor setups, you know.

You should consider quitting gaming and just focus on mining, just a suggestion.
Geez, some people have hobbies, you know. And a couple of lucky few gamers even make more a lot more money gaming than you could with mining.


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: Lauda on November 29, 2013, 11:45:58 PM
You should consider quitting gaming and just focus on mining, just a suggestion.
Geez, some people have hobbies, you know. And a couple of lucky few gamers even make more a lot more money gaming than you could with mining.
That's like saying: a couple of lucky few tennis players even make more than you could with mining.
Nice comparison. It's most likely an addiction, not a hobby.


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: 9971ea1a on November 29, 2013, 11:52:09 PM
I'm currently mining FTC coins on my gaming rig (Nvidia 770) and I'm getting close to 10 coins per day. 
Which pool are you using?


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: miner2002 on November 30, 2013, 12:20:37 AM
I'm using coinotron.  Pretty easy to set up.

Does anyone else have recommendations for a different pool? I didn't put a ton of researching into the pool I selected so I'm sure there's better options. 


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: An amorous cow-herder on November 30, 2013, 04:19:25 AM
Geez, some people have hobbies, you know. And a couple of lucky few gamers even make more a lot more money gaming than you could with mining.
That's like saying: a couple of lucky few tennis players even make more than you could with mining.
Nice comparison. It's most likely an addiction, not a hobby.
You might as well say mining is an addition then as well. At the prices some of the devices are going (USB block eruptors anyone?) a lot of people are likely wasting money instead of making it.


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: An amorous cow-herder on November 30, 2013, 04:26:14 AM
I'm using coinotron.  Pretty easy to set up.

Does anyone else have recommendations for a different pool? I didn't put a ton of researching into the pool I selected so I'm sure there's better options. 
Also using coinotron. And difficulty went up quite a bit during last retarget. If the next one has a similiar jump i might go back to LTC ...


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: miner2002 on November 30, 2013, 04:33:52 AM
Yes, I have noticed difficulty going up as well.  To be expected!

Even still, with money flowing into Alt coins I think mining will continue to be profitable even for GPU mining without a custom rig. Who knows, but looking at the current numbers I think I'll be able to at least break even. You can look at threads from early november talking about GPU mining being dead and not worth it, but with the rise in alt coin pricing I don't think that's the case anymore.

I think if you believe alt coins will have a place in the market going forward (which I do) then mining is worth the gamble. 


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: Lauda on November 30, 2013, 07:23:47 AM
You might as well say mining is an addition then as well. At the prices some of the devices are going (USB block eruptors anyone?) a lot of people are likely wasting money instead of making it.
At the current prices, even USB eruptors ROI/make money. Correct me if I'm wrong.


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: An amorous cow-herder on November 30, 2013, 09:43:19 AM
You might as well say mining is an addition then as well. At the prices some of the devices are going (USB block eruptors anyone?) a lot of people are likely wasting money instead of making it.
At the current prices, even USB eruptors ROI/make money. Correct me if I'm wrong.
Assuming a fairly low difficulty increase of 80%/month a block eruptor would make like $17 if it started mining today. Best prices on ebay are around $50. Well, assuming BTC hits like 3.5k it will break even. In which case it would have been better just buying bitcoins ...


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: Lauda on November 30, 2013, 12:28:42 PM
Assuming a fairly low difficulty increase of 80%/month a block eruptor would make like $17 if it started mining today. Best prices on ebay are around $50. Well, assuming BTC hits like 3.5k it will break even. In which case it would have been better just buying bitcoins ...
You could have bulk purchased a while ago for less than that. Also if you use that logic (which is beyond any common sense), buying bitcoin is always better than buying mining equipment.


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: PenAndPaper on November 30, 2013, 12:46:26 PM
I don't think that you are missing something it's just that prices of alt coins are through the roof.
For all i know people will start buying gpu's again  :P


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: An amorous cow-herder on November 30, 2013, 01:13:44 PM
You could have bulk purchased a while ago for less than that. Also if you use that logic (which is beyond any common sense), buying bitcoin is always better than buying mining equipment.
Sure at certain points in time it would have made sense or makes sense.
But whats wrong with my logic there? I look at the price of mining equipment in BTC (or whatever altcoin i want to mine), then i try to estimate how many coins i will get from mining. If i would get fewer coins back then i spent on the mining equipment its a bad idea. Simple as that. Otherwise you spent coins to "enjoy the luxury of mining".


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: PenAndPaper on November 30, 2013, 01:25:09 PM
Assuming a fairly low difficulty increase of 80%/month a block eruptor would make like $17 if it started mining today. Best prices on ebay are around $50. Well, assuming BTC hits like 3.5k it will break even. In which case it would have been better just buying bitcoins ...
You could have bulk purchased a while ago for less than that. Also if you use that logic (which is beyond any common sense), buying bitcoin is always better than buying mining equipment.

Obviously almost in all cases it's better to buy bitcoins directly than mining equipment. People buy miners because they can't do basic maths. Are you among them? :P


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: miner2002 on November 30, 2013, 04:18:27 PM
Assuming a fairly low difficulty increase of 80%/month a block eruptor would make like $17 if it started mining today. Best prices on ebay are around $50. Well, assuming BTC hits like 3.5k it will break even. In which case it would have been better just buying bitcoins ...
You could have bulk purchased a while ago for less than that. Also if you use that logic (which is beyond any common sense), buying bitcoin is always better than buying mining equipment.

Obviously almost in all cases it's better to buy bitcoins directly than mining equipment. People buy miners because they can't do basic maths. Are you among them? :P

With bitcoins, I agree with you. However, if Alt coin prices stays high, there's a good chance you can make an ROI or break even and then mine speculatively from there.  With the jump in alt coin pricing over the last 30 days, I think we're in a different environment than before and the rules have changed.

I'll bump this thread up in 30 days and let you guys know how my investment did. :)


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: x0rcist on November 30, 2013, 04:22:10 PM
Assuming a fairly low difficulty increase of 80%/month a block eruptor would make like $17 if it started mining today. Best prices on ebay are around $50. Well, assuming BTC hits like 3.5k it will break even. In which case it would have been better just buying bitcoins ...
You could have bulk purchased a while ago for less than that. Also if you use that logic (which is beyond any common sense), buying bitcoin is always better than buying mining equipment.

Obviously almost in all cases it's better to buy bitcoins directly than mining equipment. People buy miners because they can't do basic maths. Are you among them? :P

With bitcoins, I agree with you. However, if Alt coin prices stays high, there's a good chance you can make an ROI or break even and then mine speculatively from there.  With the jump in alt coin pricing over the last 30 days, I think we're in a different environment than before and the rules have changed.

I'll bump this thread up in 30 days and let you guys know how my investment did. :)

profitability is over 1000% more then a week ago, its crazy (on a hd7950 you can earn 30$ p/day atm).......... it looks almost like manipulated market  ;)


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: An amorous cow-herder on November 30, 2013, 05:59:52 PM
profitability is over 1000% more then a week ago, its crazy (on a hd7950 you can earn 30$ p/day atm).......... it looks almost like manipulated market  ;)
Yeah, the prices on some of the alts are more than weird currently. My best guess is that in the wake of the bitcoin rise quite a few investors are buying alt coins "just in case". Might as well get going while the going is good ;)
No idea how long this will last, but i aint complaining.


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: PenAndPaper on November 30, 2013, 06:16:33 PM
With the jump in alt coin pricing over the last 30 days, I think we're in a different environment than before and the rules have changed.
I agree that the rules have changes and i think they changed 've in many levels not only on mining.
For all i know people are looking for the next coin that is going to get pumped. Seems it's ppc turn now.

profitability is over 1000% more then a week ago, its crazy (on a hd7950 you can earn 30$ p/day atm).......... it looks almost like manipulated market  ;)

What coin do you mine and you get a return of 30$/day with your 7950?


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: Lauda on November 30, 2013, 07:07:30 PM
Obviously almost in all cases it's better to buy bitcoins directly than mining equipment. People buy miners because they can't do basic maths. Are you among them? :P
Really? Basically you're saying that miners made a bad choice for investing in mining.
Your logic is beyond me. I've been mining for 2 months with rig C, kept all the coins it has generated. I've done the math and buying bitcoin back then (with the amount of money that I spend for the rig), would have earned me much less. While bitcoin is on the road for a tenfold increase, some coins have had much more than that.
*points at MEC, initial blocks of 500*  :D
Can't do basic math, pf.


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: wheatrich on November 30, 2013, 08:18:54 PM
nice apples to oranges math

OP--you're missing the fact that difficulty is about to spike like hell.  Welcome to the arms race again.

Yes, it's better to buy but in some places *cough US cough* it's MUCH easier to buy mining equip than it is the coins.

In the case of GPU's you also have a hedge against a massive price drop.


Title: Re: Alt coin mining profitability - What am I missing?
Post by: miner2002 on November 30, 2013, 11:10:38 PM
nice apples to oranges math

OP--you're missing the fact that difficulty is about to spike like hell.  Welcome to the arms race again.

Yes, it's better to buy but in some places *cough US cough* it's MUCH easier to buy mining equip than it is the coins.

In the case of GPU's you also have a hedge against a massive price drop.

I'm with you.  I just got into this so I'm sure I don't know how bad the spike will be, but I would expect it to be much more difficult quickly as people see the potential.  Worth the gamble in my opinion :)