Bitcoin Forum

deleted

Very nice compilation!
Would is be possible to add the current price on each one ? I believe all these exchanges have APIs
It would be great to be able to calculate say, if I have USD 1000 I can get X bitcoins if I use exchange Z, considering all fees...

I think you may want to adjust regarding usability of BTC China. My friend in Australia seems to be able to open account and trade there.

Also I know there is Korbit exchange in South Korea, but almost impossible to open an account if you are not there.

 Very nice comparison! Good work!

Good one OP! Always wanted to see the list of all BTC exchanges.
Now put the link of that in your sig  :)

I find the list very helpfull, I discovered few small exchanges I was not aware of, so I will check these

bitstamp is the best. ;D ;D

Very nice, thank you

Nice work.

Only suggestion i have, the table have to much information for a good overview.
I would prefer a more compact table, with the possibility to expand for more info.

I think it's great as it is (it has all the information that needs to be compared), but he can always create individual pages for each website to provide a more detailed description of each exchange.

nice, that's helps folks :D

I kinda like the usability-rating, however it would be nice to have a some kind of explanation to your rating system.
E.g. is +++ the highest score?
Is there a negative score? ---
(negative scores would also be nice to have in red-color).

Yes, and "Pros" / "Cons" of each exchange would be nice :)

Thanks for the list! It's really helpful to see the different characteristics of the exchanges side-by-side, even if we are familiar with some of them. Thanks!

Thank you for all your hard work on this.  I've been looking for something like what you have here for a few weeks now.  Peace.   ;D

Thanks, I was searching for something like this.

Why don't you use your referral link for the exchanges that offer it? You could be making money. :)

I think the referral link is perfectly ok to implement, as long as you state it somewhere on the page.

Alternative:
Make a btc adr. for donations.
Personally is think it is embarrassing when people "beg" for santoshi's, but when you do a piece of work for free that contribute and help everybody then is donation appropiate.
I support "pay what you like to use it" concepts (and yes I do donate if I like the service and it value into my business).
 

Pretty neat. Good job.
A suggestion for a feature: make it sortable.

agree. good job. thanks!

Great job!
As some others stated out, maybe it would be nice to have some sort of criteria or explanation, how you rated the usability?

Also I think it would be worth adding the information, that newly registered members on btc-e can't withdraw any funds within the first 3 days!
You can't find that information anywhere on their page, except when you try to withdraw and are not longer registered than 72 hours.

I believe they also have that policy if you change your password.

I like it, good summary on one page. One thing I don't get is usability. For me you cannot put BTC-e at the same level as Camp BX. The level of liquidity is just not comparable

I liked version 1 better, even though I was requesting simplicity.   :-X

Edit: Its actually a pretty nice feature that you can add/remove columns :)

Thank for the that it very helpfull

If we could sort each column it would be awesome :)

I agree, some liquidity comparsion would be useable

Your site is missing that BTC-e also trades novacoins (NVC).

Please do not omit Cryptsy, the buggy heaven of altcoins.

Thanks, helpful table. Last time I withdraw from mtgox via wire there were $20~ fee from their bank though.

Thanks for the informative thread!

Yes, it has lots of altcoins available. I too would like to see it added :)

So cool, thank you. :-*

thank you

Good chart but what are the + ratings coming from?

I think the subjective evaluation is ok.
Just add a star and explain somewhere how the rating is defined.

or add a superscript "?" and when you roll over with mouse, then is the rating explained.
 

Really a nice comparison,
I suggest you to add a voting system.
Good job !

very useful site.

Why don't you use your referral link for the exchanges that offer it? You could be making money

Very nice work, thanks to OP!

What is the best exchange that dosent require id scans or any privacy breaking stuff?

EUR, less than 1 BTC :(
I checked out Kraken and it was a pain in the ass to get verified with higher tier, I gave up, also volume is really low
What about bitcoin.de??

Have you check localbitcoins? You could find some people in your city buying/selling bitcoin there, and make some p2p trades. :)