Bitcoin Forum

Other => Beginners & Help => Topic started by: nguoinhaque on September 06, 2011, 02:18:11 PM



Title: Will governments attack bitcoin?
Post by: nguoinhaque on September 06, 2011, 02:18:11 PM
What's your choice :D? Sorry for my bad english :'(


Title: Re: Will governments attack bitcoin?
Post by: MoonShadow on September 06, 2011, 02:29:40 PM
My choice would be that they already are.


Title: Re: Will governments attack bitcoin?
Post by: Bitcraft on September 06, 2011, 02:55:28 PM
My choice would be that they already are.

+1


Title: Re: Will governments attack bitcoin?
Post by: micgrez on September 06, 2011, 03:31:24 PM
I think they are already in the process:) sorry to say


Title: Re: Will governments attack bitcoin?
Post by: bitconformist on September 06, 2011, 03:54:39 PM
No, because they don't know it exists, aren't agile enough to act against it so quickly, and honestly wouldn't care about it anyway. What is the market cap? $50M USD?

The only thing the US government will do about BTC is use it as a honeypot for catching inept drug users and pedos.


Title: Re: Will governments attack bitcoin?
Post by: klaus on September 06, 2011, 03:56:37 PM
No, because they don't know it exists, aren't agile enough to act against it so quickly, and honestly wouldn't care about it anyway. What is the market cap? $50M USD?
The only thing the US government will do about BTC is use it as a honeypot for catching inept drug users and pedos.

+1


Title: Re: Will governments attack bitcoin?
Post by: Explodicle on September 06, 2011, 04:22:22 PM
They'll attack it because they think it's bad. Government is run by people who think they're doing the right thing but are often mistaken. They honestly want to protect people from dangerous things like Bitcoin, and the control (so they tell themselves) is a means to that end.


Title: Re: Will governments attack bitcoin?
Post by: dyce on September 06, 2011, 05:13:25 PM
it might get hit because of tax evasion i suppose.


Title: Re: Will governments attack bitcoin?
Post by: travistouchdown on September 06, 2011, 09:41:00 PM
if it hasn't happened it will, but who knows what the future holds for something like this. They won't look at it like a revolutionary electronic currency. They'll demonize it, and ward off individuals because its a currency they can't tax. Simple.


Title: Re: Will governments attack bitcoin?
Post by: FreeMonies on September 07, 2011, 04:01:59 AM
It seems obvious to me that they already have been. the government doesn't want a true anonymous currency to be in the hands of civilians. Its common sense!

JM


Title: Re: Will governments attack bitcoin?
Post by: bitconformist on September 07, 2011, 04:29:25 PM
It seems obvious to me that they already have been. the government doesn't want a true anonymous currency to be in the hands of civilians. Its common sense!

JM
Which government? Which department? Name one agency with the resources, purview, and agility to actually act on bitcoin so quickly. Those in (massively under-resourced and technologically illiterate) financial enforcement departments are either ignorant of bitcoin or think it's a joke.


Title: Re: Will governments attack bitcoin?
Post by: Gabi on September 07, 2011, 04:50:14 PM
Some senators for example?


Title: Re: Will governments attack bitcoin?
Post by: NAGAjalokia on September 07, 2011, 04:53:56 PM
not gonna vote cause i dont believe in it but. the man doesnt care yet. in fact check out Gavins visit with the cia thread.

i think the cia is actually using it to send money to informants and spies, but we will never know.


Title: Re: Will governments attack bitcoin?
Post by: indian on September 07, 2011, 05:15:31 PM
Nothing has happened to LR , althought bitcoin is different than LR but still it should be safe .


Title: Re: Will governments attack bitcoin?
Post by: bitcoinhead on September 07, 2011, 10:33:28 PM
China is outlawing it for physical transactions.  France is figuring out what to do (is it money or something else?).

I am sure some governments might want to DDOS or somehow otherwise attack it if lots of transactions are happening.  But really these days they are more interested in intercepting encrypted communications (see the Comodo and Diginotar CA hacks where Iran was intercepting encrypted gmail traffic).

I would think that intelligence agencies would be more interested in letting bitcoin run, and in building analytic tools to watch the blocks and try to deduce patterns around who is transacting with whom.  Combine this analysis with IP logs and they may be able to slowly figure out some "people of interest".  For example, if they arrest a criminal who has a wallet, then they know their keys and historical transactions, and this can be traced to see which receivers got their coins.  With enough seized wallets they then start to know some IPs or keys of other bad players.  Maybe this won't lead to finding people, but it could be used as evidence in prosecutions once someone is arrested.

$0.02.

oops, sorry, I mean 0.002 BTC



Title: Re: Will governments attack bitcoin?
Post by: molecular on September 07, 2011, 10:45:03 PM
If they attack bitcoin it'll probably not be out of self-interest, but because people from the banking sector pressure them.


Title: Re: Will governments attack bitcoin?
Post by: travistouchdown on September 07, 2011, 11:14:51 PM
not gonna vote cause i dont believe in it but. the man doesnt care yet. in fact check out Gavins visit with the cia thread.

i think the cia is actually using it to send money to informants and spies, but we will never know.

Hahaha that is so ridiculous that it has to be true! 


Title: Re: Will governments attack bitcoin?
Post by: heatherk on September 08, 2011, 01:41:51 AM
Bitcoin will definitely stay under the radar until it is too late for any action to be taken. If any attempts after that are made to make accessing it illegal it will be too difficult to control the use. Oddly enough, I think users that try too hard to attach their identity to their wallet will wind up being the ones made an example of.


Title: Re: Will governments attack bitcoin?
Post by: deherbs on September 08, 2011, 07:37:37 AM
possibly if it gains a certain level of "popularity"


Title: Re: Will governments attack bitcoin?
Post by: BitcoinRedLight on September 08, 2011, 12:42:43 PM
It is likely a matter of time, if they are not already engaged.


Title: Re: Will governments attack bitcoin?
Post by: caston on September 08, 2011, 12:49:56 PM
Its use is so wide spread already that it would be impossible for them to stamp out but government may use it to help them pay off their debts.


Title: Re: Will governments attack bitcoin?
Post by: Explodicle on September 08, 2011, 01:08:47 PM
Its use is so wide spread already that it would be impossible for them to stamp out but government may use it to help them pay off their debts.

lol how hilarious would it be if the USA government and most citizens amassed huge debts in USD, then Bitcoin "wins" and the USD crashes, and they effortlessly pay off their now-meaningless debt. Ha HA shoulda lent in GOLD, bitches! Thanks for all the consumer goods!


Title: Re: Will governments attack bitcoin?
Post by: MoonShadow on September 08, 2011, 02:06:32 PM
Its use is so wide spread already that it would be impossible for them to stamp out but government may use it to help them pay off their debts.

lol how hilarious would it be if the USA government and most citizens amassed huge debts in USD, then Bitcoin "wins" and the USD crashes, and they effortlessly pay off their now-meaningless debt. Ha HA shoulda lent in GOLD, bitches! Thanks for all the consumer goods!

Yeah, real funny.  Right up until the point that, at best, all the factories in China that make our consumer products are nationalized and retooled for products never intended to come to the US.  What then, once your Iphone breaks?  And that is assuming that they don't decide to invade to take whatever they can find in payment.  Wars have started for much less.  And there is no case in history wherein the national monetary system collapsing did not result in civil unrest or a civil war, or fascism.  Be very careful what you wish for, young man.  You might just get it.


Title: Re: Will governments attack bitcoin?
Post by: Explodicle on September 08, 2011, 07:22:54 PM
Its use is so wide spread already that it would be impossible for them to stamp out but government may use it to help them pay off their debts.

lol how hilarious would it be if the USA government and most citizens amassed huge debts in USD, then Bitcoin "wins" and the USD crashes, and they effortlessly pay off their now-meaningless debt. Ha HA shoulda lent in GOLD, bitches! Thanks for all the consumer goods!

Yeah, real funny.  Right up until the point that, at best, all the factories in China that make our consumer products are nationalized and retooled for products never intended to come to the US.  What then, once your Iphone breaks?  And that is assuming that they don't decide to invade to take whatever they can find in payment.  Wars have started for much less.  And there is no case in history wherein the national monetary system collapsing did not result in civil unrest or a civil war, or fascism.  Be very careful what you wish for, young man.  You might just get it.

Sorry, I didn't mean to offend with my crude gallows humor. I agree with your analysis, but this wouldn't happen overnight - surely the powers that be would work something out in the meantime.


Title: Re: Will governments attack bitcoin?
Post by: MoonShadow on September 08, 2011, 08:05:09 PM
Its use is so wide spread already that it would be impossible for them to stamp out but government may use it to help them pay off their debts.

lol how hilarious would it be if the USA government and most citizens amassed huge debts in USD, then Bitcoin "wins" and the USD crashes, and they effortlessly pay off their now-meaningless debt. Ha HA shoulda lent in GOLD, bitches! Thanks for all the consumer goods!

Yeah, real funny.  Right up until the point that, at best, all the factories in China that make our consumer products are nationalized and retooled for products never intended to come to the US.  What then, once your Iphone breaks?  And that is assuming that they don't decide to invade to take whatever they can find in payment.  Wars have started for much less.  And there is no case in history wherein the national monetary system collapsing did not result in civil unrest or a civil war, or fascism.  Be very careful what you wish for, young man.  You might just get it.

Sorry, I didn't mean to offend with my crude gallows humor. I agree with your analysis, but this wouldn't happen overnight - surely the powers that be would work something out in the meantime.

Don't count on that.  Those powers are the same that continue to deny the problem exists.