Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Bitcoin Discussion => Topic started by: bitcola on October 01, 2011, 09:16:05 PM



Title: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: bitcola on October 01, 2011, 09:16:05 PM
Serious cannabis growers will steal electricity rather than pay for it.

So I'm wondering if criminal gangs have started to do this and mine bitcoins yet? I imagine that bitcoins require a larger initial capital outlay but what about the yield per square foot as it seems that apart from this capital outlay the only other limiting factor is space or maybe heat or noise.

I'm just curious as to why we haven't heard of criminal gangs moving in yet. I guess they don't need to be close to market so maybe they are already operating but in developing countries?


Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: johnj on October 01, 2011, 09:23:00 PM
I would imagine the maintainence required for a mining farm is far more than for a cannibis farm.  Sure, growing eats up power with lamps, but its on/off (usually on an auto timer), with replacing a bulb here and there - hardly any 'intensive' upkeep. Plus most of your investments can't 'break' (soil, pots, seeds). In addition, growers don't need to worry as much about ventilation, especially in regards to cooling. Plus the yield of space/energy in growing is much more lucrative than mining.

I'd imagine if you have access to the funding, space, ventilation, and energy to do something illegal, I don't think 'mining bitcoins' is very high on the list.

edit: less->more


Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: bitcola on October 01, 2011, 09:55:54 PM
I dunno. I've never had a grow room but I've read a lot about it. You do have to monitor a lot of things and ventilation you got to take care of, primarily because otherwise the stink will be detected.

With mining rigs, the advantage is that you don't have to return to tend to it or "harvest", you can manage it all remotely. Build in some redundancy and you hardly ever have to return to swap anything out.

A well tended grow needs people coming back to change various things, otherwise the crop would taste nasty, nutrients etc. As far as I know nobody has automated this process yet.


Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: Swishercutter on October 01, 2011, 10:07:38 PM
I would imagine the maintainence required for a mining farm is far more than for a cannibis farm.  Sure, growing eats up power with lamps, but its on/off (usually on an auto timer), with replacing a bulb here and there - hardly any 'intensive' upkeep. Plus most of your investments can't 'break' (soil, pots, seeds). In addition, growers don't need to worry as much about ventilation, especially in regards to cooling. Plus the yield of space/energy in growing is much more lucrative than mining.

I'd imagine if you have access to the funding, space, ventilation, and energy to do something illegal, I don't think 'mining bitcoins' is very high on the list.

edit: less->more

Wrong...I have known people who run grows...if you are not there doing work every day things come out like crap.  I have not had to even look at my mining rigs in weeks...I know they are working by the heat.

There is massive intensive upkeep in grows...like pruning, insects, mold, fertilizer levels, not to mention pumps, bulbs, fans, charcoal filters, etc.

I would not get into either one expecting no work.



Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: elggawf on October 01, 2011, 10:14:43 PM
People steal electricity to grow pot? Seems to me like that's a really easy way to get caught.


Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: Swishercutter on October 01, 2011, 10:22:58 PM
People steal electricity to grow pot? Seems to me like that's a really easy way to get caught.

Those are the only ones I ever read about getting busted due to power use.  Everyone thinks you will get caught for power usage...from what I have seen the power company is more than happy to take your money as long as you are paying on time and in full.  I always read in the news about these major grows >15kw that are stealing power.  The power company knows how much gos into a neighborhood and how much is metered at the houses...if those numbers don't match up they think its a short in the line somewhere and send out a crew...they find you illegal power tap and report it to the police.

I guess it depends on where in the world you live also....some areas have specific regulations on reporting abnormal power usage to the local authorities.


Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: elggawf on October 01, 2011, 10:36:27 PM
Well I have heard about abnormally high power usage in a house leading to a tip off to the cops, but it just doesn't seem like stealing juice is going to help solve that.

Besides why steal power to mine bitcoins with a few really expensive graphics cards when you can just write malware and steal power + equipment for a fraction of the effort and almost none of the risk?


Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: Swishercutter on October 01, 2011, 10:41:14 PM
Well I have heard about abnormally high power usage in a house leading to a tip off to the cops, but it just doesn't seem like stealing juice is going to help solve that.

Besides why steal power to mine bitcoins with a few really expensive graphics cards when you can just write malware and steal power + equipment for a fraction of the effort and almost none of the risk?

To most it's easier to steal power...the majority have no programming knowledge.


Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: zer0 on October 01, 2011, 10:57:31 PM
People steal electricity to grow pot? Seems to me like that's a really easy way to get caught.

They hire blackmarket techs that used to work for the power company to set it up.
http://www.cannabisculture.com/articles/3268.html

Because US housing is so cheap right now, there are plenty of Canadian weed growers buying up houses to convert solely into farms and it's easier to pirate electricity in states not known for growing with outdated power infrastructure. Guess you could make a mining house too but I imagine the payoff isn't near as great


Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: worldinacoin on October 02, 2011, 01:09:18 AM
If we are seeing such criminal activities, I think it will show that Bitcoin is starting to go widespread in the society, not a bad sign.


Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: d.james on October 02, 2011, 04:51:56 AM
stealing bitcoins directly is easier


Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: bitcola on October 02, 2011, 05:58:35 AM
Very good points, especially from wisdomtool.

I think we will see it happen. Not just anyone can write and launch the code for a botnet. These things tend to be done in the developing world where they are less easily caught by Western authorities.

Your typical criminal gang in the West may not want to risk getting tracked like that. They prefer to stay further under the radar. Furthermore, they may lack the contacts if they don't have the programming expertise.

Your average Joe has no idea how to set up a mining rig but it's a damn site easier learning curve to do it than to program a botnet.

And given the potential profits from it, perhaps it won't be long before we see it happen.


Can any growers give an idea of the yield from a grow on a space basis? Doesn't each plant give a few ounces or something? And how much could that be sold for if you wanted to get rid of your crop quickly and not sell it in small amounts?


Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: Manko on October 02, 2011, 06:05:35 AM
If we are seeing such criminal activities, I think it will show that Bitcoin is starting to go widespread in the society, not a bad sign.

Yep, at least someone is using them :)

I wonder what the tax people's stance is on cryptocurrency ? Keeping your money in BTC and on exchanges, could be a good way to avoid taxes.


Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: bitcola on October 02, 2011, 08:28:36 AM
If we are seeing such criminal activities, I think it will show that Bitcoin is starting to go widespread in the society, not a bad sign.

Yep, at least someone is using them :)

I wonder what the tax people's stance is on cryptocurrency ? Keeping your money in BTC and on exchanges, could be a good way to avoid taxes.

Absolutely, it seems it has the same tax "advantages" of cash.


Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: Swishercutter on October 02, 2011, 11:04:08 AM
Very good points, especially from wisdomtool.

I think we will see it happen. Not just anyone can write and launch the code for a botnet. These things tend to be done in the developing world where they are less easily caught by Western authorities.

Your typical criminal gang in the West may not want to risk getting tracked like that. They prefer to stay further under the radar. Furthermore, they may lack the contacts if they don't have the programming expertise.

Your average Joe has no idea how to set up a mining rig but it's a damn site easier learning curve to do it than to program a botnet.

And given the potential profits from it, perhaps it won't be long before we see it happen.


Can any growers give an idea of the yield from a grow on a space basis? Doesn't each plant give a few ounces or something? And how much could that be sold for if you wanted to get rid of your crop quickly and not sell it in small amounts?

Has to do with a lot of things...plant number, who is growing it...but I have heard it's mostly dependent on number of lights.  Most indoor people I have heard say 1lb/1000w light is doing good.  There are so many variables though...type of setup, care, fertilizer...the list continues.  One power outage at the right time throws off your light cycle and can ruin a whole crop.  Insect control is a major issue also.  Smell, humidity, heat...sounds like a total nightmare to me.

Then you have to sell it too...not worth my time.  I know many people who have tried for years and nobody is rich (or even well off) yet.


Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: bitcola on October 02, 2011, 11:54:38 AM
And the other thing I forgot about, of course you may be stealing electricity but otherwise you are not doing anything illegal. No threat of multi-year jail sentences for growing drugs to supply others.

I am really quite shocked to not hear of any criminals doing this.


Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: payb.tc on October 02, 2011, 12:45:49 PM
I am really quite shocked to not hear of any criminals doing this.

why would they advertise?


Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: dancupid on October 02, 2011, 01:48:57 PM
It's easy to do this in China - my wife found a guy in Shanghai who she payed the equivalent of $50 to modify the electricity meter and halved our electricity bills (personally I thought it wasn't worth the risk, but everyone seems to do it). There was recently a crackdown on this, so she called the electricity company to say there was a problem with the meter, 2 'repair men' turned up in BMWs to repair it - we took them out for a nice meal and nothing more was said of the matter.


Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: bitcola on October 02, 2011, 03:32:14 PM
I am really quite shocked to not hear of any criminals doing this.

why would they advertise?

It's not about advertising, it's about what filters through to local and eventually national news.


Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: hashman on October 02, 2011, 05:30:32 PM
Very good points, especially from wisdomtool.

I think we will see it happen. Not just anyone can write and launch the code for a botnet. These things tend to be done in the developing world where they are less easily caught by Western authorities.

Your typical criminal gang in the West may not want to risk getting tracked like that. They prefer to stay further under the radar. Furthermore, they may lack the contacts if they don't have the programming expertise.

Your average Joe has no idea how to set up a mining rig but it's a damn site easier learning curve to do it than to program a botnet.

And given the potential profits from it, perhaps it won't be long before we see it happen.


Can any growers give an idea of the yield from a grow on a space basis? Doesn't each plant give a few ounces or something? And how much could that be sold for if you wanted to get rid of your crop quickly and not sell it in small amounts?

Has to do with a lot of things...plant number, who is growing it...but I have heard it's mostly dependent on number of lights.  Most indoor people I have heard say 1lb/1000w light is doing good.  There are so many variables though...type of setup, care, fertilizer...the list continues.  One power outage at the right time throws off your light cycle and can ruin a whole crop.  Insect control is a major issue also.  Smell, humidity, heat...sounds like a total nightmare to me.

Then you have to sell it too...not worth my time.  I know many people who have tried for years and nobody is rich (or even well off) yet.

Seriously?  Then you don't know many people.  Its the #1 cash crop in all 50 states. 


Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: hashman on October 02, 2011, 05:37:10 PM
I am really quite shocked to not hear of any criminals doing this.

why would they advertise?


One example:

http://www.securelist.com/en/blog/208193084




Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: phishken on October 02, 2011, 05:53:06 PM
First off only stupid pot growers steal electricity.

Secondly, growing pot is far far more work than running a bitcoin farm.

You have to start seeds, or maintain mothers.  You have to clone - prepare plants for flower.  This alone with roots and good growth can take 3 weeks to a month.   Plants need watered constantly.  Even a very automated hydroponic system needs water and nutrients topped off every other day.  There is always work to be done.  I'd say a 4000w system to keep running no with interuptions between crops you are looking at 2 hours a day of work.  Then once the harvest comes in, I'd say at least very minumum 24 hours of trimming work.  A week of drying then more work preparing for sale.   Not to mention the complete cleaning of the grow space between crops, more hours of work.

Heat from a garden is way more than a mining rig will ever think of being.  Then you have to dispose of the heat.  Try dealing with 4000w in the middle of summer   :o

A professional gardener will make so much more with cannabis than with a bitcoin farm.   A professional grower will be doing 1.5lbs per 1000w and most pros will have 3000-4000w minimum.   So 4-6lbs every 60 days.  Retail in my area for high end dank $400/oz x 64oz (4lbs) = $25,000 every 60 days on the low end.

Gardening is a labor of love and for a professional it is a very lucrative endeavor.   I'd still be at it if it wasn't for a few douchebags with badges.


Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: bitcola on October 02, 2011, 06:01:19 PM
First off only stupid pot growers steal electricity.

That is not true.

Many serious, large-scale growers steal electricity.

Whether it's a Vietnamese criminal gang operating out of a house in the UK or one of the best Dutch growers using a cavity inside a highway bridge lined with electricity cables, both will steal their electricity. Both are highly profitable. Neither is stupid.

A professional gardener will make so much more with cannabis than with a bitcoin farm.   A professional grower will be doing 1.5lbs per 1000w and most pros will have 3000-4000w minimum.   So 4-6lbs every 60 days.  Retail in my area for high end dank $400/oz x 64oz (4lbs) = $25,000 every 60 days on the low end.

Gardening is a labor of love and for a professional it is a very lucrative endeavor.   I'd still be at it if it wasn't for a few douchebags with badges.


Thanks for this insight. Now we need a comparison on a per unit space basis to compare like for like. By the way, retail is not really a good figure to use seeing as serious growers would get rid of it for less to dealers, instead of dealing it themselves. Is that factored into your price (I'm unfamiliar with weed prices wherever you live).


Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: Big Time Coin on October 02, 2011, 11:07:56 PM
Mining is more heat and more power than growing.  4000W is nothing.  you are looking at about 1 watt per megash, cooling included, total of 10-15 kw for 15 gigahash, which is about the most you can get out of a residential service if you still want to live in the house. 

It is a lot less labor, and it is legal.  Stealing power would not make any sense because that is crossing the line into breaking the law.  If a miner wanted to break the law, there are far more profitable things he could do as a criminal than mine bitcoins.  Aside from getting caught, you could kill yourself by electrocution trying to steal power.  Boy, wouldn't that make you feel stupid.  Oh wait, you wouldn't feel anything.  Instantaneous complete nervous system overload and shutdown.


Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: abracadabra on October 03, 2011, 02:23:38 AM
.... any modern power company they can tell down to the transformer how much power is being used.

Uhm, link?  I searched and found nothing that would substantiate this claim.


Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: Rarity on October 03, 2011, 02:45:25 AM
The power companies should just mine themselves with any excess capacity.  In areas where the government runs the grid that might even be a nice way to fund social welfare programs with what otherwise would have just been wasted power.


Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: Swishercutter on October 03, 2011, 03:37:37 AM
Very good points, especially from wisdomtool.

I think we will see it happen. Not just anyone can write and launch the code for a botnet. These things tend to be done in the developing world where they are less easily caught by Western authorities.

Your typical criminal gang in the West may not want to risk getting tracked like that. They prefer to stay further under the radar. Furthermore, they may lack the contacts if they don't have the programming expertise.

Your average Joe has no idea how to set up a mining rig but it's a damn site easier learning curve to do it than to program a botnet.

And given the potential profits from it, perhaps it won't be long before we see it happen.


Can any growers give an idea of the yield from a grow on a space basis? Doesn't each plant give a few ounces or something? And how much could that be sold for if you wanted to get rid of your crop quickly and not sell it in small amounts?

Has to do with a lot of things...plant number, who is growing it...but I have heard it's mostly dependent on number of lights.  Most indoor people I have heard say 1lb/1000w light is doing good.  There are so many variables though...type of setup, care, fertilizer...the list continues.  One power outage at the right time throws off your light cycle and can ruin a whole crop.  Insect control is a major issue also.  Smell, humidity, heat...sounds like a total nightmare to me.

Then you have to sell it too...not worth my time.  I know many people who have tried for years and nobody is rich (or even well off) yet.

Seriously?  Then you don't know many people.  Its the #1 cash crop in all 50 states. 

#1 cash crop says  nothing to me...I don't know any rich farmers of any kind personally.


Title: Re: Are criminals stealing electricity to mine bitcoins yet?
Post by: phishken on October 04, 2011, 12:01:25 AM
First off only stupid pot growers steal electricity.

That is not true.

Many serious, large-scale growers steal electricity.

Whether it's a Vietnamese criminal gang operating out of a house in the UK or one of the best Dutch growers using a cavity inside a highway bridge lined with electricity cables, both will steal their electricity. Both are highly profitable. Neither is stupid.




Yes pros do steal power but I still think it is a risk that is not needed.


Someone should contact all the online cannabis seed companies and let them know about bitcoin.  An anonymous payment service has been needed for a long time.