Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Electrum => Topic started by: samuel-sd on July 15, 2018, 04:53:23 AM



Title: Questions to the developers of the android version
Post by: samuel-sd on July 15, 2018, 04:53:23 AM
1. I would like to protect my watch-only wallet with a pin or a password. (this option is greyed out) Now anybody who runs the app can see the amount of money in my wallet, I think it is private information which could have been protected from unauthorized viewing. The linux version has this protection why the android one doesn't?

2. I can restore a BIP39 seed mnemonic on the linux version, why I cannot do the same on the android one?


Title: Re: Questions to the developers of the android version
Post by: bob123 on July 15, 2018, 02:35:05 PM
1. I would like to protect my watch-only wallet with a pin or a password. (this option is greyed out) Now anybody who runs the app can see the amount of money in my wallet, I think it is private information which could have been protected from unauthorized viewing. The linux version has this protection why the android one doesn't?

Unfortunately i can't answer your question regarding the reason for a passlock not being chooseable.
But you can use apps which do restrict the access to applications with a pincode / password. There are quite a few available (named safe/vault/..).
Android does have an own app-safe from version 6+ which can be used to restrict access to applications.

Note that (on a rooted phone) your information can alway be seen by other applications when you are using/unlocking your wallet.



2. I can restore a BIP39 seed mnemonic on the linux version, why I cannot do the same on the android one?

Electrum does not support BIP39 in the first place. An additional option to use BIP39 is only given in the desktop version.
But there are other mobile wallets available (especially for android) which do support BIP39 (e.g. MyCelium, Coinomi, Samourai, ..).


Title: Re: Questions to the developers of the android version
Post by: samuel-sd on July 15, 2018, 04:10:23 PM
But you can use apps which do restrict the access to applications with a pincode / password. There are quite a few available (named safe/vault/..).
Android does have an own app-safe from version 6+ which can be used to restrict access to applications.

Note that (on a rooted phone) your information can alway be seen by other applications when you are using/unlocking your wallet.
I think that any banking like software is supposed to have some kind of embedded password or pincode protection. What's the point to push ordinary users to look for an extra layer of protection?


2. I can restore a BIP39 seed mnemonic on the linux version, why I cannot do the same on the android one?

Quote
Electrum does not support BIP39 in the first place. An additional option to use BIP39 is only given in the desktop version.
Why is that? Aren't the developers interested in making the mobile version is as functional as the desktop one?


Title: Re: Questions to the developers of the android version
Post by: Abdussamad on July 15, 2018, 04:44:13 PM
You could put in a feature request on github.