Bitcoin Forum

Economy => Service Discussion => Topic started by: James222 on February 20, 2014, 11:55:23 PM



Title: What if I buy a bitcoin from MTGOX?
Post by: James222 on February 20, 2014, 11:55:23 PM
Hi everyone. I haven't got any bitcoins in my wallet and I think that this is a good opportunity to get some. As all of you guys know, mtgox has had some so called "problems" and that resulted in the price of bitcoins to go down. The average price of bitcoin is at 160$. I was wondering: if I buy some bitcoins off them, will I be able to get them automatically or I will be just another person who has lost his bitcoins?


Title: Re: What if I buy a bitcoin from MTGOX?
Post by: Holliday on February 20, 2014, 11:58:15 PM
Hi everyone. I haven't got any bitcoins in my wallet and I think that this is a good opportunity to get some. As all of you guys know, mtgox has had some so called "problems" and that resulted in the price of bitcoins to go down. The average price of bitcoin is at 160$. I was wondering: if I buy some bitcoins off them, will I be able to get them automatically or I will be just another person who has lost his bitcoins?

No, you won't get them automatically. They have frozen Bitcoin withdraws.

The gamble is whether or not they will ever allow, or are capable of allowing, Bitcoin withdraws again in the future.

If you want to gamble, go to a casino. If you want to buy a bitcoin, avoid Gox.

I apologize in advance if you heed this free advice and miss out on ridiculously cheap bitcoins should Gox reinstate Bitcoin withdraws again in the future.


Title: Re: What if I buy a bitcoin from MTGOX?
Post by: bitlancr on February 20, 2014, 11:59:43 PM
$160 isn't the price of a Bitcoin - it's the price of a promise from MtGox to pay you one. Many people doubt that MtGox will keep their promises, that's why the price is so discounted.


Title: Re: What if I buy a bitcoin from MTGOX?
Post by: James222 on February 21, 2014, 12:00:04 AM
Hi everyone. I haven't got any bitcoins in my wallet and I think that this is a good opportunity to get some. As all of you guys know, mtgox has had some so called "problems" and that resulted in the price of bitcoins to go down. The average price of bitcoin is at 160$. I was wondering: if I buy some bitcoins off them, will I be able to get them automatically or I will be just another person who has lost his bitcoins?

No, you won't get them automatically. They have frozen Bitcoin withdraws.

The gamble is whether or not they will ever allow, or are capable of allowing, Bitcoin withdraws again in the future.

If you want to gamble, go to a casino. If you want to buy a bitcoin, avoid Gox.

I apologize in advance if you heed this free advice and miss out on ridiculously cheap bitcoins if Gox reinstates Bitcoin withdraws again in the future.

I understand. If I ever hear that everything is fixed, I might jump on the occasion tho. Guess I will keep playing Poker Stars!


Title: Re: What if I buy a bitcoin from MTGOX?
Post by: induktor on February 21, 2014, 12:01:06 AM
if you do, you are gonna get fucked!
be careful.
nobody gives anything for free
use your head, and be honest with yourself and you will know.


Title: Re: What if I buy a bitcoin from MTGOX?
Post by: lumierre on February 21, 2014, 12:01:55 AM
Don't ever buy goxcoins. They moved their offices because THEY KNOW it will get ugly.


Title: Re: What if I buy a bitcoin from MTGOX?
Post by: Beliathon on February 21, 2014, 12:03:23 AM
$160 isn't the price of a Bitcoin - it's the price of a promise from MtGox to pay you one. Many people doubt that MtGox will keep their promises, that's why the price is so discounted.
This. You CAN'T buy a bitcoin from mt. gox. They're not selling btc, they're selling lies.


Title: Re: What if I buy a bitcoin from MTGOX?
Post by: Holliday on February 21, 2014, 12:04:08 AM
Hi everyone. I haven't got any bitcoins in my wallet and I think that this is a good opportunity to get some. As all of you guys know, mtgox has had some so called "problems" and that resulted in the price of bitcoins to go down. The average price of bitcoin is at 160$. I was wondering: if I buy some bitcoins off them, will I be able to get them automatically or I will be just another person who has lost his bitcoins?

No, you won't get them automatically. They have frozen Bitcoin withdraws.

The gamble is whether or not they will ever allow, or are capable of allowing, Bitcoin withdraws again in the future.

If you want to gamble, go to a casino. If you want to buy a bitcoin, avoid Gox.

I apologize in advance if you heed this free advice and miss out on ridiculously cheap bitcoins if Gox reinstates Bitcoin withdraws again in the future.

I understand. If I ever hear that everything is fixed, I might jump on the occasion tho. Guess I will keep playing Poker Stars!

If "everything is fixed", you won't be able to purchase the ridiculously cheap bitcoin IOUs anymore because they will be actually functioning IOUs instead of possibly-functioning-in-the-future IOUs. In fact, as far as I know, Gox still hasn't fixed their extensive problems with fiat withdraws, so it is likely that if they do reinstate Bitcoin withdraws, Gox bitcoin IOUs will again be more expensive than other exchange's bitcoin IOUs.

Savvy?


Title: Re: What if I buy a bitcoin from MTGOX?
Post by: casinocoin on February 21, 2014, 12:05:54 AM
Hi everyone. I haven't got any bitcoins in my wallet and I think that this is a good opportunity to get some. As all of you guys know, mtgox has had some so called "problems" and that resulted in the price of bitcoins to go down. The average price of bitcoin is at 160$. I was wondering: if I buy some bitcoins off them, will I be able to get them automatically or I will be just another person who has lost his bitcoins?

No, you won't get them automatically. They have frozen Bitcoin withdraws.

The gamble is whether or not they will ever allow, or are capable of allowing, Bitcoin withdraws again in the future.

If you want to gamble, go to a casino. If you want to buy a bitcoin, avoid Gox.

I apologize in advance if you heed this free advice and miss out on ridiculously cheap bitcoins if Gox reinstates Bitcoin withdraws again in the future.

I understand. If I ever hear that everything is fixed, I might jump on the occasion tho. Guess I will keep playing Poker Stars!

Gambling is Gambling, Gox is either going to die or well die.. They have screwed them selves time and time again.
You can always pick up some Bitcoins as the price is quite cheap IMO
https://www.bitstamp.net/
btc-e.com

Cheers,


Title: Re: What if I buy a bitcoin from MTGOX?
Post by: minerpart on February 21, 2014, 12:06:47 AM
They moved their offices because THEY KNOW it will get ugly.

True, they wouldn't go to the no-doubt significant effort of moving all their infrastructure unless they knew they couldn't sort this problem out. They have 2 decent guys demonstrating on the door - is that a reason to abandon your lease (that you still need to pay) and basically go into hiding? No.

Does anyone know where the old offices are that they have supposedly moved to? Has he moved back in with his parents?



Title: Re: What if I buy a bitcoin from MTGOX?
Post by: Doublelucky on February 21, 2014, 01:18:05 AM

Anyone know if abd where I can buy mtgox bitcoins outside of mtgox? - obv taking the risk that I will never see them, but the price is too tempting
I think I read somewhere that this is an option? Or did I misread?


Title: Re: What if I buy a bitcoin from MTGOX?
Post by: gamersglory on February 21, 2014, 01:21:13 AM
Why do I have a feeling that Gox is going to do it's own spinoff of BTC. Goxcoin? and make it closed source


Title: Re: What if I buy a bitcoin from MTGOX?
Post by: thresher on February 21, 2014, 01:49:48 AM
I was honestly going to buy several coins form gox.  I know I fucking hate myself, but i'll take the gamble if it means I'll get compensation to offset the decrease in price per coin. The problem is they have that ten day shit for wire transfer so at that point I would have either missed the boat or been screwed anyways. 
Instead I used btc to buy some gox btc on bitcoinbuilder.  Probably got scammed there for all I know.
Best case scenario, gox gets the coins, gives me them, bitcoin goes back up, profit.
Middle scenario, Gox doesn't give coins, bitcoin goes back up after their demise, ill still be ok.
Worst case scenario, gox doesn't give coins, price continues to plummet, I lost anyways.
At least I aided a poor victim of gox by purchasing their coins.   
I just wouldn't risk everything (as in your entire coin budget) on it.


Title: Re: What if I buy a bitcoin from MTGOX?
Post by: ZooKeeper74 on February 21, 2014, 06:15:11 AM
Japan banks stopped dealing with Gox last Fall. When a bank refuses money, that should be your hint.


Title: Re: What if I buy a bitcoin from MTGOX?
Post by: staffnsnake on February 21, 2014, 06:54:41 AM
I took a punt with BTC2.2. If I lose that then at current prices it's less than a day's work in fiat. If it goes up massively and I can't withdraw, then I'm screwed. If I can withdraw - at all, but better if it goes up - then I win. Just like an options contract but without the security of a contract. A gamble, but there it is.


Title: Re: What if I buy a bitcoin from MTGOX?
Post by: Avirunes on February 21, 2014, 07:49:59 AM

Anyone know if abd where I can buy mtgox bitcoins outside of mtgox? - obv taking the risk that I will never see them, but the price is too tempting
I think I read somewhere that this is an option? Or did I misread?

Bitcoinbuilder.com , need to upload id though and its manual withdrawals


Title: Re: What if I buy a bitcoin from MTGOX?
Post by: innocent93 on February 21, 2014, 07:55:34 AM
I think they will finally recover the bitcoin withdraw , but at the same time they will do some restriction
Whatever MTGOX have lost his position and never able to get it back.


Title: Re: What if I buy a bitcoin from MTGOX?
Post by: davida on February 21, 2014, 11:47:48 AM
We have all thought about it.... But I doubt many people want to put any substantial amounts of money into a company that could literally declare bankruptcy tomorrow and not pay you a damn penny.


Title: Re: What if I buy a bitcoin from MTGOX?
Post by: Blinken on February 21, 2014, 01:04:42 PM
What if you threw one of your shoes into a wood chipper?


Title: Re: What if I buy a bitcoin from MTGOX?
Post by: MinerLT on February 21, 2014, 01:20:11 PM
i bought few bitcoins from gox today ;) still.. i think sooner or later withdrawals will be processed  ;)


Title: Re: What if I buy a bitcoin from MTGOX?
Post by: induktor on February 21, 2014, 02:59:22 PM
I took a punt with BTC2.2. If I lose that then at current prices it's less than a day's work in fiat. If it goes up massively and I can't withdraw, then I'm screwed. If I can withdraw - at all, but better if it goes up - then I win. Just like an options contract but without the security of a contract. A gamble, but there it is.

Less than a day work in FIAT???  man I want your job!!!!, what do you do?, I make 3 BTC a month working as a freelance IT, and a lot of my friends will kill to have my kind of income, where do you live to earn so much money in one day!, I wouldn't make 2 BTC a day even if I grow and sell pot in my basement hehe.


Title: Re: What if I buy a bitcoin from MTGOX?
Post by: bitlancr on February 21, 2014, 04:09:20 PM
2.2 Goxcoin is about $250 - a good income, but not massive...


Title: Re: What if I buy a bitcoin from MTGOX?
Post by: induktor on February 21, 2014, 06:41:52 PM
2.2 Goxcoin is about $250 - a good income, but not massive...
Oh, you are talking about the scamgoxbtc? not the real BTC right?, I thought you where talking about REAL btc , where 2.2 will mean 1188 U$D a day, that's a lot of beer!!!


Title: Re: What if I buy a bitcoin from MTGOX?
Post by: staffnsnake on February 27, 2014, 08:34:19 AM
I took a punt with BTC2.2. If I lose that then at current prices it's less than a day's work in fiat. If it goes up massively and I can't withdraw, then I'm screwed. If I can withdraw - at all, but better if it goes up - then I win. Just like an options contract but without the security of a contract. A gamble, but there it is.

Less than a day work in FIAT???  man I want your job!!!!, what do you do?, I make 3 BTC a month working as a freelance IT, and a lot of my friends will kill to have my kind of income, where do you live to earn so much money in one day!, I wouldn't make 2 BTC a day even if I grow and sell pot in my basement hehe.


It's a good deal less than many of my colleagues. I put people to sleep, usually with endless rants about crypto-currency, but sometimes with (legal) drugs. Then when the surgeon has finished butchering them, I wake them up.

Anyway, when Mt Gox imploded the other day I raced back to bitcoinbuilder and sold my Gox BTC at a third of what I paid for them, so now I have a bit over BTC0.7 to show for my oh-so-clever credit default swap. No such thing as a free lunch and all that. Who knows, maybe they will resume withdrawals, but I don't know where Mark Karpeles is going to find the missing BTC750000 to fund them, even if he has been buying up at low prices on his own exchange.

Lesson learned.


Title: Re: What if I buy a bitcoin from MTGOX?
Post by: staffnsnake on February 27, 2014, 08:44:13 AM
2.2 Goxcoin is about $250 - a good income, but not massive...
Oh, you are talking about the scamgoxbtc? not the real BTC right?, I thought you where talking about REAL btc , where 2.2 will mean 1188 U$D a day, that's a lot of beer!!!


I was. I invested BTC2.2 (real) and "made" over 6.2 Gox BTC which, as can be seen in my post above, I subsequently lost in the crash and then converted to BTC0.7 (real) when I sold the Gox BTC in an effort to stem the haemorrhage.