Bitcoin Forum

Alternate cryptocurrencies => Altcoin Discussion => Topic started by: smooth nobody on November 16, 2018, 12:32:20 PM



Title: confused about bitcoin cash
Post by: smooth nobody on November 16, 2018, 12:32:20 PM
i'm just now hearing about bitcoin SV and ABC. really need to understand whats going on. i heard that bitcoin cash is "no more." is BCH being dropped completely? what happens to my BCH? do i have to claim the new coins or does it get converted automatically? do i get both SV and ABC or will only one survive? i still have a bitcoin core wallet that never claimed BCH coins. will i still be able to claim BCH/SV/ABC?


Title: Re: confused about bitcoin cash
Post by: JimmyNg90 on November 16, 2018, 12:54:26 PM
is BCH being dropped completely? what happens to my BCH?

BCH will be valueless.

do i convert it to both SV and ABC?

It seems that process is automatic.

You can read some explanation here: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5069039.0

And you can leave your questions there, maybe members who understand blockchain will give you the answer.


Title: Re: confused about bitcoin cash
Post by: olgamir on November 16, 2018, 01:08:40 PM
I do not like all these divisions of chains and forks of coins.  After hardfork, usually the price of new coins is lower than it was originally.


Title: Re: confused about bitcoin cash
Post by: cytpoway121 on November 16, 2018, 01:10:57 PM
There is no need to confused or whatsoever, Bitcoin cash has forked and it happened automatically, either you keep your coins at an exchange or in your blockchain wallet.
Now just be careful, expect a drop in price or an increase in price.

Whichever happens, always remember the basic principles of crypto currency trading.


Title: Re: confused about bitcoin cash
Post by: kumiskura on November 16, 2018, 01:14:40 PM
is BCH being dropped completely? what happens to my BCH?

BCH will be valueless.

do i convert it to both SV and ABC?

It seems that process is automatic.

You can read some explanation here: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5069039.0

And you can leave your questions there, maybe members who understand blockchain will give you the answer.

Based on the article and news that i heard, there will be no more BCH because after it(fork) and successfully forking it. the chain will split and will create Bitcoin ABC and Bitcoin SV.
for a brief explanation about it, you can read it here ; https://medium.com/@jcliff/bitcoin-cashs-november-2018-fork-804596268771

it will be processed automatically if you are holding it on supported exchange, but if you do not. you need to claim it by using your own private keys.

why they did that ? tension ? misunderstand ? nobody knows excatly what is going on. maybe they want us to see their dominance ?


Title: Re: confused about bitcoin cash
Post by: pixelvault on November 16, 2018, 01:26:14 PM
i'm just now hearing about bitcoin SV and ABC. really need to understand whats going on. i heard that bitcoin cash is "no more." is BCH being dropped completely? what happens to my BCH? do i have to claim the new coins or does it get converted automatically? do i get both SV and ABC or will only one survive? i still have a bitcoin core wallet that never claimed BCH coins. will i still be able to claim BCH/SV/ABC?

this all seems retarded. why is this happening? is this still all about block size or is something else going on?

it will fork to BCH ABC or BCH SV

Your BCH will be either one of those.

And most likely worth shit all for awhile


Title: Re: confused about bitcoin cash
Post by: smooth nobody on November 19, 2018, 08:34:05 AM
been trying to read as much as i can and i still have unanswered questions. what happens to BCH that is held in private wallets? i'm using exodus. what happens with my bitcoin core wallet that was eligible to claim BCH? will i still be able to claim BCH or will i be able to claim ABC/SC instead?


Title: Re: confused about bitcoin cash
Post by: BitcoinReseller on November 19, 2018, 08:39:49 AM
been trying to read as much as i can and i still have unanswered questions. what happens to BCH that is held in private wallets? i'm using exodus. what happens with my bitcoin core wallet that was eligible to claim BCH? will i still be able to claim BCH or will i be able to claim ABC/SC instead?

yes you can claim new SV coins and exchange into bitcoin or into original BCH.

here is step by step :
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5070999.0 (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5070999.0)


Title: Re: confused about bitcoin cash
Post by: fuer44 on November 19, 2018, 08:46:03 AM
but bitcoin cash is doing hardfork with almost all famous exchange sites, surely bitcoin cash will go back up and be ready to compete with bitcoin.


Title: Re: confused about bitcoin cash
Post by: smooth nobody on November 19, 2018, 08:59:04 AM
i appreciate the link on how to claim SV, but that's not what i was asking.

what happens to the BCH in my private wallet? does it stay BCH? does it become ABC? does it become a worthless unsupported currency?

i keep hearing so much conflicting information i'm not sure what is factual. i've heard.....

BCH will go away completely
ABC is BCH and will retain the BCH symbol
the winner of ABC vs SV will retain the BCH symbol

what happens with my bitcoin core wallet that was eligible to claim BCH on august 2017? i was told i can claim that BCH at any time. can i still claim that BCH? do i claim ABC/SV instead? can i claim all three BCH ABC SV?


Title: Re: confused about bitcoin cash
Post by: snakey on November 19, 2018, 09:00:22 AM
BCH is on many exchanges with the former coin. Though the value of forked will be determined by people but i still uses original bch only.


Title: Re: confused about bitcoin cash
Post by: batang_bitcoin on November 19, 2018, 09:13:33 AM
Yes that's right, BCH = Bitcoin cash will be totally gone as the fork was the upgrade of it but needless to say, neither of the two (SV/ABC) shall be adopted by most.

Why not follow BCH's thread?

[ANN] Bitcoin Cash - Pro on-chain scaling - Cheaper fees (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=2040221.0)


Title: Re: confused about bitcoin cash
Post by: mr.robot8 on November 19, 2018, 10:24:56 AM
there was a fork on the blockchain of bch after which this has been split into two new coins abc and sv for now it seems that the two new blockchain have trouble meshing and perhaps the miners are undermining at a loss just to keep the chains alive


Title: Re: confused about bitcoin cash
Post by: muslol67 on November 19, 2018, 12:06:15 PM
Forks getting worst all market. People getting confuse about forks. So many fork coins has created. It is not good. There are almost 25 Bitcoin forks. With other project we can see over 100.


Title: Re: confused about bitcoin cash
Post by: Bonwin on November 19, 2018, 03:10:09 PM
The process of acquiring the forks of the fork needs to be well expressed, because some of us still have our BCHBon exchanges. I do noy also know if the forks will be automatically send to wherever the coin BCH is. I also discovered that some exchanges have disabled the trading of BCH.


Title: Re: confused about bitcoin cash
Post by: Usafstar on November 19, 2018, 03:33:22 PM
Bitcoin cash is a good asset if you are confused to it it is just simple as we use our currency in traditional way it is a cash in the digital form and it is faster than any other form of money it can be used for buying things for transferring into other coins it is acceptable world wide and many exchanges are holding a good reserve of it for the trade and it is the ongoing currency of the crypto market i love to use crypto for online trade while many projects are reviewing this for currency.


Title: Re: confused about bitcoin cash
Post by: Louis21 on November 19, 2018, 03:46:51 PM
You have no reason to be confused, Bitcoin Cash has splitted into two and if you have it on an exchange that supports both the two, you will surely receive them. Your old Bitcoin Cash is useless now but you will surely get the new one.


Title: Re: confused about bitcoin cash
Post by: smooth nobody on November 19, 2018, 04:54:27 PM
it seems like alot of you guys are not even reading what i'm posting and are just posting random information that is not directly answering my questions.

adding to the confusion, i contacted exodus. they told me ABC is BCH. it's the same thing. SV is the only new coin. ABC is the same protocol as BCH. they only make it BCH-ABC to distinguish from BCH-SV.

more confusion, different exchanges seem to be handling this according to their own judgement / desires. some are trading both ABC and SV. some haven't made any changes and are still trading BCH.


Title: Re: confused about bitcoin cash
Post by: xPASTELx on November 21, 2018, 05:33:54 PM
i'm just now hearing about bitcoin SV and ABC. really need to understand whats going on. i heard that bitcoin cash is "no more." is BCH being dropped completely? what happens to my BCH? do i have to claim the new coins or does it get converted automatically? do i get both SV and ABC or will only one survive? i still have a bitcoin core wallet that never claimed BCH coins. will i still be able to claim BCH/SV/ABC?

Well that is what happens when someone hardforks a hardforked coin. ABC is the bitcoin cash that you already know and then the SV is the hardforked coin that came out as a result and now with the two coin being out there is a hash war which has been dragging on and the miners are starting to move some of their equipment to start mining the new fork coin


Title: Re: confused about bitcoin cash
Post by: mksundip on November 21, 2018, 05:36:04 PM
actually I'm also confused, I can't find bch abc in coinmarketcap, but can still continue to see bitcoincash, even though hardfork is finished, is bch is bch-abc?


Title: Re: confused about bitcoin cash
Post by: AgentZero23 on November 21, 2018, 05:56:24 PM
i'm just now hearing about bitcoin SV and ABC. really need to understand whats going on. i heard that bitcoin cash is "no more." is BCH being dropped completely? what happens to my BCH? do i have to claim the new coins or does it get converted automatically? do i get both SV and ABC or will only one survive? i still have a bitcoin core wallet that never claimed BCH coins. will i still be able to claim BCH/SV/ABC?
The hard fork issue about BCHSV and BCHABC are really dragging the market down. I think the exchanges should have delist them both as they are confusing. The hash war are really creating a mess in the market and i hope eth would not end up like this in the future.


Title: Re: confused about bitcoin cash
Post by: yudayaurelia on November 21, 2018, 06:03:33 PM
Bitcoin is electronic money made in 2009 by Satoshi Nakamoto. The enactment of Bitcoin in this virtual world might make some people think it is similar to electronic money.
Bitcoin and electronic money or e-money are certainly not the same. To understand the characteristics of both, here are some differences.

Access
Developing in cyberspace, Bitcoin certainly needs an internet network to be accessible. Bitcoin is increasingly being used for transactions for internet users and now some businesses are starting to accept payments with Bitcoin.
E-money in terms of access does not need an internet network. This electronic money can be used to transact through telecommunications equipment to the form of a card.

Production
Bitcoin is produced through encryption of data and certain algorithms. With a peer-to-peer topology system and a lack of a single administration, the value cannot be manipulated by the authorities or the government, and does not cause inflation if the production of Bitcoin increases.
Unlike virtual money, e-money is issued digitally by financial institutions and guaranteed by authority.

Publisher
Bitcoin is published by a community called 'miner'. Whereas e-money publishers are official banks and financial institutions.

Regulator
Bitcoin is not regulated by any institution, unlike e-money regulated by the central bank.

Owner Data
All Bitcoin transactions are stored publicly and permanently on the network, which allows everyone to see balances and transactions from any Bitcoin address. However, the identity of a Bitcoin user cannot be known until the information is revealed when making a purchase or under certain other conditions.
Whereas in e-money, the ownership data system complies with the applicable financial institution standards.

Value
The Bitcoin value system is determined by the level of trust, supply and demand. Meanwhile, the e-money value system applies like conventional money, only in electronic form


Title: Re: confused about bitcoin cash
Post by: smooth nobody on November 21, 2018, 07:57:04 PM
Bitcoin is electronic money made in 2009 by Satoshi Nakamoto. The enactment of Bitcoin in this virtual world might make some people think it is similar to electronic money.
Bitcoin and electronic money or e-money are certainly not the same. To understand the characteristics of both, here are some differences.

Access
Developing in cyberspace, Bitcoin certainly needs an internet network to be accessible. Bitcoin is increasingly being used for transactions for internet users and now some businesses are starting to accept payments with Bitcoin.
E-money in terms of access does not need an internet network. This electronic money can be used to transact through telecommunications equipment to the form of a card.

Production
Bitcoin is produced through encryption of data and certain algorithms. With a peer-to-peer topology system and a lack of a single administration, the value cannot be manipulated by the authorities or the government, and does not cause inflation if the production of Bitcoin increases.
Unlike virtual money, e-money is issued digitally by financial institutions and guaranteed by authority.

Publisher
Bitcoin is published by a community called 'miner'. Whereas e-money publishers are official banks and financial institutions.

Regulator
Bitcoin is not regulated by any institution, unlike e-money regulated by the central bank.

Owner Data
All Bitcoin transactions are stored publicly and permanently on the network, which allows everyone to see balances and transactions from any Bitcoin address. However, the identity of a Bitcoin user cannot be known until the information is revealed when making a purchase or under certain other conditions.
Whereas in e-money, the ownership data system complies with the applicable financial institution standards.

Value
The Bitcoin value system is determined by the level of trust, supply and demand. Meanwhile, the e-money value system applies like conventional money, only in electronic form
this is another garbage post about random information nobody asked for.


Title: Re: confused about bitcoin cash
Post by: smooth nobody on November 21, 2018, 08:03:23 PM
actually I'm also confused, I can't find bch abc in coinmarketcap, but can still continue to see bitcoincash, even though hardfork is finished, is bch is bch-abc?
exodus told me they consider BCH and BCH-ABC to be the same thing and they plan to keep using the symbol BCH. i also read an article that some exchange is doing the same thing cause they don't consider SV to be viable. the problem is people in this thread have said BCH is going away and will be worthless so it's clear people don't know WTF is going on. when you have some exchanges and wallets listing BCH and others BCH-ABC is only adds to the confusion. there is no order or agreement on how to proceed. people are doing different things. it's pure chaos.


Title: Re: confused about bitcoin cash
Post by: zulzedd on November 21, 2018, 08:09:22 PM
actually I'm also confused, I can't find bch abc in coinmarketcap, but can still continue to see bitcoincash, even though hardfork is finished, is bch is bch-abc?
exodus told me they consider BCH and BCH-ABC to be the same thing and they plan to keep using the symbol BCH. i also read an article that some exchange is doing the same thing cause they don't consider SV to be viable. the problem is people in this thread have said BCH is going away and will be worthless so it's clear people don't know WTF is going on. when you have some exchanges and wallets listing BCH and others BCH-ABC is only adds to the confusion. there is no order or agreement on how to proceed. people are doing different things. it's pure chaos.
So should we hodl?)