|
Title: What happens if I send LTC to a segwit address BTC that starts with 3? Post by: Forsyth Jones on June 12, 2019, 03:12:01 AM Imagine that someone was withdrawing LTC in exchange and mistakenly copied a bitcoin address segwit-p2sh (starts with 3), has there any way to recover those funds? some way to convert the bitcoin private key to Litecoin (or any other currency that is compatible with P2SH addresses)
OBS: Relax, guys, nobody lost funds, this is just a question that arose in my head like many others, respond without haste Title: Re: What happens if I send LTC to a segwit address BTC that starts with 3? Post by: pooya87 on June 12, 2019, 03:56:28 AM as far as i know both bitcoin and litecoin use the same method to get the output script for a P2SH which also includes the witness nested in script hash types. so the only thing you would need to do is to import the same key in the other coin's wallet and select the same address type to be derived from its (compressed) public key.
Title: Re: What happens if I send LTC to a segwit address BTC that starts with 3? Post by: Khaos77 on June 12, 2019, 05:06:08 AM as far as i know both bitcoin and litecoin use the same method to get the output script for a P2SH which also includes the witness nested in script hash types. so the only thing you would need to do is to import the same key in the other coin's wallet and select the same address type to be derived from its (compressed) public key. Not thinking that would work. I think the generated private keys would be different. How would the private key be the exact same, between the BTC & LTC network for the public address? Title: Re: What happens if I send LTC to a segwit address BTC that starts with 3? Post by: pooya87 on June 12, 2019, 05:24:18 AM How would the private key be the exact same, between the BTC & LTC network for the public address? private key is just a number so that is no the place you should look. what you should look into is the type of the curve and then the script types they create. since LTC is the exact copy of bitcoin, it also uses the same curve so the same number (private key) corresponds to the same public key. and since both use the same hash functions, they both come up with the same hash. and since they also use the same script structure (OP_HASH160 <20 byte> OP_EQUAL) then the scripts are also the same. the only thing different would be address format which is the base58 encoding (first byte) which doesn't matter at all. Title: Re: What happens if I send LTC to a segwit address BTC that starts with 3? Post by: Khaos77 on June 12, 2019, 06:33:12 AM How would the private key be the exact same, between the BTC & LTC network for the public address? private key is just a number so that is no the place you should look. what you should look into is the type of the curve and then the script types they create. since LTC is the exact copy of bitcoin, it also uses the same curve so the same number (private key) corresponds to the same public key. and since both use the same hash functions, they both come up with the same hash. and since they also use the same script structure (OP_HASH160 <20 byte> OP_EQUAL) then the scripts are also the same. the only thing different would be address format which is the base58 encoding (first byte) which doesn't matter at all. Looks like you are right, it can be done. :) found the following. https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/byk9qc/help_needed_stupid_me_sent_litcoin_from_trezor_to/eqk63ut/ Quote Here is how to do it: Take a Bitcoin private key in WIF (wallet import format). Convert it to hexadecimal format. Add "b0" in front of it and "01" at the end of it. Calculate a double SHA256 hash of the resulting string as a hex (use https://www.fileformat.info/tool/hash.htm and use the field Binary hash / Hex bytes). Add first 8 symbols from the result of step 4 to the resulting string of step 3. Convert the resulting hex string to WIF using https://incoherency.co.uk/base58/ The result is a Litecoin private key in WIF (wallet import format). Example: Bitcoin private key (WIF): KzNDQwKngvExhYzGhsMhHjeacwB9L1Asgo293Kf8TPMutvfr89wv Converting to hex format: 5de30ea8c8a415f7b8a0286a033c9ff9e94415326c405cf0ce611df1067ecec6 Add "b0" in front of it and "01" at the end of it: b05de30ea8c8a415f7b8a0286a033c9ff9e94415326c405cf0ce611df1067ecec601 First round of hash: 254609e251aeb830ce0e8c37f75b76a15795d550c410b8bdda32394c1d9a7e6d Second round of hash: 103087d15075dd2464c0b49dabce677e36d68179fbb871cd1f846be451946e37 "b05de30ea8c8a415f7b8a0286a033c9ff9e94415326c405cf0ce611df1067ecec601" + "103087d1" = b05de30ea8c8a415f7b8a0286a033c9ff9e94415326c405cf0ce611df1067ecec601103087d1 Converting to WIF: T6CUrgcy6JDZUPd9FWJZW6BxZnpTQ6BmVzvPu8Hg2MY5QpCvzyjN Result: we converted Bitcoin private key "KzNDQwKngvExhYzGhsMhHjeacwB9L1Asgo293Kf8TPMutvfr89wv" to Litecoin private key "T6CUrgcy6JDZUPd9FWJZW6BxZnpTQ6BmVzvPu8Hg2MY5QpCvzyjN". Proof that it works: Bitcoin private key: KzNDQwKngvExhYzGhsMhHjeacwB9L1Asgo293Kf8TPMutvfr89wv Litecoin private key: T6CUrgcy6JDZUPd9FWJZW6BxZnpTQ6BmVzvPu8Hg2MY5QpCvzyjN Use https://www.bitaddress.org (go to "Wallet Details" and enter the Bitcoin private key). Use https://liteaddress.org (go to "Wallet Details" and enter the Litecoin private key). You will see that for both Bitcoin and Litecoin the hex format private keys (and the uncompressed public keys) are identical. This means that these keys will "unlock" an identical SegWit address on both networks. Title: Re: What happens if I send LTC to a segwit address BTC that starts with 3? Post by: Forsyth Jones on June 13, 2019, 12:43:30 AM @Khaos77 thank you I did the tests following the article quoted and it worked! Now I'd like to know which wallet I still see UTXO non-spent from an address litecoin P2SH started with 3? Litecoin Core?
Title: Re: What happens if I send LTC to a segwit address BTC that starts with 3? Post by: HCP on June 13, 2019, 07:25:51 AM You should be able to use Litecoin Core or Electrum-LTC (https://electrum-ltc.org/) to import the private key
Electrum-LTC also has the advantage of not requiring that you sync the entire blockchain. Title: Re: What happens if I send LTC to a segwit address BTC that starts with 3? Post by: Forsyth Jones on June 13, 2019, 04:56:30 PM You should be able to use Litecoin Core or Electrum-LTC (https://electrum-ltc.org/) to import the private key but how to import the private key with the prefix "3"?Electrum-LTC also has the advantage of not requiring that you sync the entire blockchain. in "info" I have only these instructions: Code: WIF keys are typed in Electrum, based on script type. Title: Re: What happens if I send LTC to a segwit address BTC that starts with 3? Post by: pereira4 on June 18, 2019, 01:10:31 AM You should be able to use Litecoin Core or Electrum-LTC (https://electrum-ltc.org/) to import the private key but how to import the private key with the prefix "3"?Electrum-LTC also has the advantage of not requiring that you sync the entire blockchain. in "info" I have only these instructions: Code: WIF keys are typed in Electrum, based on script type. Im more familiar with Core but the way Electrum works, it basically forces you to create a brand new wallet in order to import keys. So backup your current wallet, and simply follow the GUI... click on "Import Bitcoin addresses or private keys" and enter the addresses during the wizard: https://bitcoinelectrum.com/files/2017/06/electrum-import-privkey-1-1.png Title: Re: What happens if I send LTC to a segwit address BTC that starts with 3? Post by: HCP on June 19, 2019, 09:33:58 PM but how to import the private key with the prefix "3"? I assume you mean 'import the private key for the address that has "3" prefix'... the private key itself should most likely start with a "T"in "info" I have only these instructions: Code: WIF keys are typed in Electrum, based on script type. Theoretically... the SegWit private key that you generated, should be able to be imported as "p2wpkh-p2sh"... it will create an address that starts with "M", but it should be the "same" as the address that starts with a "3"... You can check this by using the Litecoin P2SH address converter here: https://litecoin-project.github.io/p2sh-convert/ Litecoin switched to using "M" prefix to try and prevent people from accidentally sending Litecoin to Bitcoin addresses ;) |
