Bitcoin Forum

Economy => Exchanges => Topic started by: Forgotoldaccount on October 09, 2019, 09:23:38 AM



Title: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: Forgotoldaccount on October 09, 2019, 09:23:38 AM
I would like to update this thread now as I am EXTREMELY lucky they have made a mistake.
I told them I'm consulting a lawyer and to cancel my pending withdrawals as they were insistant on these informations.
Then somehow (even though they told me no transactions will be processed until they receive these) I did an XRP ripple withdrawal and it was processed instantlyl

Big oops for them and a big relief for me


Hello. I have had a couple btc since about 2014 and mainly use bitcoin for gambling and poker activities.
In April this year I had a big win at fortunejack about 30 btc
I deposited 16 btc to bitstamp. Sold 6 and left 10 btc in there
Few days ago went to sell the rest and they've frozen it and thus begins this following conversation by support tickets::

Quote
Thank you for filling out our KYC form. We have received your transaction request.

However, before we can properly process your currently pending transaction request, we ask that you elaborate further on the origin of the cryptocurrency deposited to your account, as well as provide us with information and documentation which can confirm your statements, such as bank deposit slips showing deposits to other exchanges, purchase logs, trading history, withdrawal history, or any other documentation relevant to your crypto origins.

Additionally, we ask that you elaborate further on your answer in our KYC form regarding your intended activities on our platform being related to online gambling activities.

My response I sent screenshots of my win at fortunejack and an email from fortunejack detailing my withdrawal

They then reply this...
Quote
Thank you for your reply. We have received your transaction.

However, before concluding this procedure, we ask that you provide us with some financial documentation, which can confirm how the funds you used to purchase your initial cryptocurrency acquisitions, that you used in your gambling activities, was acquired or accumulated, such as a salary pay slip, tax revenue statement, investment portfolio or similar. We also kindly ask that you elaborate on how your winning are reported as your taxable income and provide us with your most recent tax statement.

We also ask that you provide us with screenshots showing your initial cryptocurrency purchases and provide us with the relevant addresses where your initial cryptocurrency was deposited.

Additionally, we ask that you provide us with an estimated amount that you would be depositing/withdrawing to/from your Bitstamp account per year (in USD and BTC)?

To which I reply:I do not have any of this information, I have had a few bitcoin for many years, and earlier this year I had a big win on fortunejack casino like shown.
You are asking impossible things.

Then they reply this:
Quote
Continuing with this KYC procedure, before we can process your transactions, we kindly ask that you elaborate further on these BTC that you held for several years, and elaborate on their origin by providing us with documentation which can confirm how the crypto was obtained, such as purchase logs, trade logs, purchase confirmation emails or similar. We also kindly ask that you provide us with your initial addresses that you used during your crypto activities as well as provide us with a few screenshots showing the withdrawal of the crypto to Fortune Jack.

If at all possible we also ask that you sign your initial addresses, that you used during your crypto activities, with a message containing this ticket number, where the "address", "signature" and "message" are clearly separated by quotation marks.

We ask you to submit your documents in PDF, JPG, PNG format in a reply to this ticket.

Thank you for your cooperation and we look forward to your reply.

Best Regards,
Jernej T.

I am basically shocked and do not know how to proceed.. They are clearly just wanting to keep my money, asking these impossible things.
Does anyone have any advice


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: Broly46 on October 09, 2019, 09:45:14 AM
They will continue to harrass you and requesting your grand ancestors grand parent of the sibling of the boss of the name and the every valuable information they can harness, when you keep your btc in their hand, it’s not YOURS anymore, be prepare to be asked to do all the demand they want from you, they may even ask for a copy of your nude photo LOL.😂


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: mk4 on October 09, 2019, 10:06:04 AM
That's a lot of information they're demanding lol. Unfortunately, it looks like they're just doing the typical AML procedures to make sure you didn't get your BTC somewhere illegal or whatever. Though it's understandable how annoying this is. Unfortunately it looks like you have no choice but to do some digging on your gambling accounts and on your bitcoin wallets. 10 BTC is no joke.

Unfortunately, another perfect reason to not unnecessarily leave funds on exchanges.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: TheUltraElite on October 09, 2019, 10:11:14 AM
Are those coins really from FJ casino or did you hide the details here about tainted source coins that you had be dealing with and used FJ as a "mixing" mode or a transit wallet to cover up your tracks? Most of the newbies posting such threads, I would not trust without having head both sides of the story. Bitstamp has been here for long time and them asking KYC with such strict details does make me wonder what juicy information they have obtained on the coins.

You may try to present a story in your way of describing but this is what I suspect has happened.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: yoseph on October 09, 2019, 10:19:15 AM
That's a lot of information they're demanding lol. Unfortunately, it looks like they're just doing the typical AML procedures to make sure you didn't get your BTC somewhere illegal or whatever. Though it's understandable how annoying this is. Unfortunately it looks like you have no choice but to do some digging on your gambling accounts and on your bitcoin wallets. 10 BTC is no joke.

Unfortunately, another perfect reason to not unnecessarily leave funds on exchanges.
They definitely don't want to give back the bitcoins that's why they are asking for things that they definitely know you are unable to provide. How can you ask someone to provide the origin of the bitcoins that they deposited on the website, it's really absurd. Would have been great if the money was just deposited into a normal wallet instead of exchanges some are very sketchy.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: mk4 on October 09, 2019, 10:22:39 AM
That's a lot of information they're demanding lol. Unfortunately, it looks like they're just doing the typical AML procedures to make sure you didn't get your BTC somewhere illegal or whatever. Though it's understandable how annoying this is. Unfortunately it looks like you have no choice but to do some digging on your gambling accounts and on your bitcoin wallets. 10 BTC is no joke.

Unfortunately, another perfect reason to not unnecessarily leave funds on exchanges.
They definitely don't want to give back the bitcoins that's why they are asking for things that they definitely know you are unable to provide. How can you ask someone to provide the origin of the bitcoins that they deposited on the website, it's really absurd.

Though I find OP's situation very unfortunate and while what they're asking is definitely a bit too much for my taste, I really wouldn't make conclusions that fast. Bitstamp is a big and pretty reputable exchange in the cryptocurrency space, and while 10 BTC is a good amount of money, I don't think they would attempt to take funds of people with that low of an amount(in contrast to the size of their userbase and trading volume).


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: o48o on October 09, 2019, 10:37:27 AM
Oh wow! One thing i have seen them speeding things up is tweeting about it. I am pretty sure that people will retweet it for you and it's bad publicity for them so they want to clear things up as fast as possible before it is trending.

But this is one more reminder that there could be price to pay for letting exchanges hold your bitcoin.
Then again, i am pretty sure i am in this exact situation if i try to cash out my btc and deposit them on my bank account. I have no proof on their origins from when they ask about it.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: Forgotoldaccount on October 09, 2019, 10:45:32 AM
Are those coins really from FJ casino or did you hide the details here about tainted source coins that you had be dealing with and used FJ as a "mixing" mode or a transit wallet to cover up your tracks? Most of the newbies posting such threads, I would not trust without having head both sides of the story. Bitstamp has been here for long time and them asking KYC with such strict details does make me wonder what juicy information they have obtained on the coins.

You may try to present a story in your way of describing but this is what I suspect has happened.

Wow this is quite inflammatory. Yes it's legitimate winnings at fortunejack. I deposited something like 0.5 btc and withdrew 36 btc in total. If you work for fortunejack like your avatar suggests you would know which account I am as there was a big fuss about that in that fortunejack themselves did extensive kyc and asked me to send Apostilled identification and other things before finally releasing my winnings...
And now this from bitstamp, it seems every company in the crypto space is at it.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: Kyraishi on October 09, 2019, 10:59:33 AM
They will continue to harrass you and requesting your grand ancestors grand parent of the sibling of the boss of the name and the every valuable information they can harness, when you keep your btc in their hand, it’s not YOURS anymore, be prepare to be asked to do all the demand they want from you, they may even ask for a copy of your nude photo LOL.😂
Sadly, these are the standards that exchanges are forced to adhere to, to even be able to operate, and it does just seem like regular AML practices that the exchange needs to adhere to.

It's around 100,000 or so USD, and any exchange would be pretty tight about that money and they need to know exactly where the funds came before they are able to help you move the funds, unfortunately they'll need a shit ton of your details and it's almost normal practice.

Next time, I recommend you just go p2p transactions and don't touch exchanges at all, so your money can't get frozen.



Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: clonely on October 09, 2019, 11:05:00 AM
They will continue to harrass you and requesting your grand ancestors grand parent of the sibling of the boss of the name and the every valuable information they can harness, when you keep your btc in their hand, it’s not YOURS anymore, be prepare to be asked to do all the demand they want from you, they may even ask for a copy of your nude photo LOL.😂
Sadly, these are the standards that exchanges are forced to adhere to, to even be able to operate, and it does just seem like regular AML practices that the exchange needs to adhere to.

It's around 100,000 or so USD, and any exchange would be pretty tight about that money and they need to know exactly where the funds came before they are able to help you move the funds, unfortunately they'll need a shit ton of your details and it's almost normal practice.

Next time, I recommend you just go p2p transactions and don't touch exchanges at all, so your money can't get frozen.




I understand what you're saying. But then what is the meaning of decentralization? Anyone can somehow own 16 BTCs. I know we're talking about a big amount, but it's inconceivable to ban a person's account for that.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: Wexnident on October 09, 2019, 11:30:34 AM
Hello. I have had a couple btc since about 2014 and mainly use bitcoin for gambling and poker activities.
In April this year I had a big win at fortunejack about 30 btc
I deposited 16 btc to bitstamp. Sold 6 and left 10 btc in there
Few days ago went to sell the rest and they've frozen it and thus begins this following conversation by support tickets::

Quote
Thank you for filling out our KYC form. We have received your transaction request.

However, before we can properly process your currently pending transaction request, we ask that you elaborate further on the origin of the cryptocurrency deposited to your account, as well as provide us with information and documentation which can confirm your statements, such as bank deposit slips showing deposits to other exchanges, purchase logs, trading history, withdrawal history, or any other documentation relevant to your crypto origins.

Additionally, we ask that you elaborate further on your answer in our KYC form regarding your intended activities on our platform being related to online gambling activities.

My response I sent screenshots of my win at fortunejack and an email from fortunejack detailing my withdrawal

They then reply this...
Quote
Thank you for your reply. We have received your transaction.

However, before concluding this procedure, we ask that you provide us with some financial documentation, which can confirm how the funds you used to purchase your initial cryptocurrency acquisitions, that you used in your gambling activities, was acquired or accumulated, such as a salary pay slip, tax revenue statement, investment portfolio or similar. We also kindly ask that you elaborate on how your winning are reported as your taxable income and provide us with your most recent tax statement.

We also ask that you provide us with screenshots showing your initial cryptocurrency purchases and provide us with the relevant addresses where your initial cryptocurrency was deposited.

Additionally, we ask that you provide us with an estimated amount that you would be depositing/withdrawing to/from your Bitstamp account per year (in USD and BTC)?

To which I reply:I do not have any of this information, I have had a few bitcoin for many years, and earlier this year I had a big win on fortunejack casino like shown.
You are asking impossible things.

Then they reply this:
Quote
Continuing with this KYC procedure, before we can process your transactions, we kindly ask that you elaborate further on these BTC that you held for several years, and elaborate on their origin by providing us with documentation which can confirm how the crypto was obtained, such as purchase logs, trade logs, purchase confirmation emails or similar. We also kindly ask that you provide us with your initial addresses that you used during your crypto activities as well as provide us with a few screenshots showing the withdrawal of the crypto to Fortune Jack.

If at all possible we also ask that you sign your initial addresses, that you used during your crypto activities, with a message containing this ticket number, where the "address", "signature" and "message" are clearly separated by quotation marks.

We ask you to submit your documents in PDF, JPG, PNG format in a reply to this ticket.

Thank you for your cooperation and we look forward to your reply.

Best Regards,
Jernej T.

I am basically shocked and do not know how to proceed.. They are clearly just wanting to keep my money, asking these impossible things.
Does anyone have any advice
Follow the procedures and if you see that the same requirements are just being repeated over and over again, then that would be the time to act. Basic standards of investigation especially since the transaction came through the internet. It really is quite hard to verify the information since the data was a few years ago plus the information bitstamp has is also limited with how the crypto is a decentralized system after all.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: Kyraishi on October 09, 2019, 11:32:27 AM
They will continue to harrass you and requesting your grand ancestors grand parent of the sibling of the boss of the name and the every valuable information they can harness, when you keep your btc in their hand, it’s not YOURS anymore, be prepare to be asked to do all the demand they want from you, they may even ask for a copy of your nude photo LOL.😂
Sadly, these are the standards that exchanges are forced to adhere to, to even be able to operate, and it does just seem like regular AML practices that the exchange needs to adhere to.

It's around 100,000 or so USD, and any exchange would be pretty tight about that money and they need to know exactly where the funds came before they are able to help you move the funds, unfortunately they'll need a shit ton of your details and it's almost normal practice.

Next time, I recommend you just go p2p transactions and don't touch exchanges at all, so your money can't get frozen.




I understand what you're saying. But then what is the meaning of decentralization? Anyone can somehow own 16 BTCs. I know we're talking about a big amount, but it's inconceivable to ban a person's account for that.
I think what you don't realize here, is that a lot of services that operate in the crypto industry are actually completely against our way of thinking, especially with decentralization, and most companies just want profits.

Most exchanges like bitstamp are not decentralized at all, and when you give them your funds, the funds are no longer yours and they are able to just pull bullshit like this, freezing accounts, etc. Unfortunately, exchanges need to do this, due to the KYC and AML policies they are required to follow.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: Forgotoldaccount on October 09, 2019, 12:35:10 PM
I would like to update this thread now as I am EXTREMELY lucky they have made a mistake.
I told them I'm consulting a lawyer and to cancel my pending withdrawals as they were insistant on these informations.
Then somehow (even though they told me no transactions will be processed until they receive these) I did an XRP ripple withdrawal and it was processed instantlyl

Big oops for them and a big relief for me


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: mk4 on October 09, 2019, 12:49:31 PM
I would like to update this thread now as I am EXTREMELY lucky they have made a mistake.
I told them I'm consulting a lawyer and to cancel my pending withdrawals as they were insistant on these informations.
Then somehow (even though they told me no transactions will be processed until they receive these) I did an XRP ripple withdrawal and it was processed instantlyl

Big oops for them and a big relief for me

So you pretty much just sold the BTC for some XRP and you were able to withdraw them? If that's all it took then that's one hell of a amateur loophole on their side lol.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: Forgotoldaccount on October 09, 2019, 12:50:41 PM
I would like to update this thread now as I am EXTREMELY lucky they have made a mistake.
I told them I'm consulting a lawyer and to cancel my pending withdrawals as they were insistant on these informations.
Then somehow (even though they told me no transactions will be processed until they receive these) I did an XRP ripple withdrawal and it was processed instantlyl

Big oops for them and a big relief for me

So you pretty much just sold the BTC for some XRP and you were able to withdraw them? If that's all it took then that's one hell of a amateur loophole on their side lol.

Yes. Now watch xrp depreciate overnight massively 🙄🤣


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: Kyraishi on October 09, 2019, 12:55:41 PM
I would like to update this thread now as I am EXTREMELY lucky they have made a mistake.
I told them I'm consulting a lawyer and to cancel my pending withdrawals as they were insistant on these informations.
Then somehow (even though they told me no transactions will be processed until they receive these) I did an XRP ripple withdrawal and it was processed instantlyl

Big oops for them and a big relief for me
That's crazy mate. I never would have expected anything like that to happen.

I'm assuming it's likely a problem with their support staff, and when they canceled the other transactions, they only put a block on BTC transactions, not in other currencies, and then you where quick enough and you didn't get flagged for withdrawing a large amount of ripple (which is weird, but lucky actually).

Good job mate, this time if you want to cash out try local bitcoins or localETH, don't use a centralized exchange.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: mk4 on October 09, 2019, 01:21:26 PM


So you pretty much just sold the BTC for some XRP and you were able to withdraw them? If that's all it took then that's one hell of a amateur loophole on their side lol.

Yes. Now watch xrp depreciate overnight massively 🙄🤣

What the hell. Have they responded to your reply concerning lawyers and stuff? I'm just curious.

With that said, you dodged a huge bullet there. Well done. I don't think I would think of trying to dodge them in that in that way if I was in your situation.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: Forgotoldaccount on October 09, 2019, 01:27:22 PM
Thanks yes. They did reply this after I asked they cancel the frozen withdrawal::
Thank you for your reply. As per your request, your pending withdrawals have been cancelled.

Please note that, in order to properly process your future transactions, we are going to have to require you to provide us with the previously requested information and documentation.

We look forward to your reply.


Anyway, let this thread serve as a warning to anyone using exchanges that unless you have a complete evidence trail of where your coins are from you are liable to lose them


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: dothebeats on October 09, 2019, 01:29:56 PM
This is a common occurrence from huge exchanges complying to AML regulations set in place. Heck, even in small sum withdrawals, if you exceeded the exchange's low limits, you'd be asked on where did your funds came from, and you'd be put in this tedious task of asking your bank for statements some few months (or even years) ago and the exchange will decide whether you have the capacity (or the 'weight') to trade those sums. Good thing that they do not really see how things work on their end and you managed to get past this annoying verification through XRP. I didn't know XRP has some uses after all!


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: Kyraishi on October 09, 2019, 01:37:24 PM
Thanks yes. They did reply this after I asked they cancel the frozen withdrawal::
Thank you for your reply. As per your request, your pending withdrawals have been cancelled.

Please note that, in order to properly process your future transactions, we are going to have to require you to provide us with the previously requested information and documentation.

We look forward to your reply.


Anyway, let this thread serve as a warning to anyone using exchanges that unless you have a complete evidence trail of where your coins are from you are liable to lose them
That's crazy, they didn't even mention the issues with the lawyers and they look like they are surprised - they probably think it's a normal threat for people to make.

You didn't give them any of your documents, right? There's a chance that even though you escaped with your own funds they might have to come after you due to AML rules and it you gave them enough to chase after you you might be in for a long battle.

This is a common occurrence from huge exchanges complying to AML regulations set in place. Heck, even in small sum withdrawals, if you exceeded the exchange's low limits, you'd be asked on where did your funds came from, and you'd be put in this tedious task of asking your bank for statements some few months (or even years) ago and the exchange will decide whether you have the capacity (or the 'weight') to trade those sums. Good thing that they do not really see how things work on their end and you managed to get past this annoying verification through XRP. I didn't know XRP has some uses after all!
I haven't seen it a lot with low amounts, exchanges don't usually have time to hold amounts like 0.2 BTC, but they will definetly fuck around with your 10 BTC withdrawal.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: fenixosup on October 09, 2019, 01:39:02 PM
Not your keys, not your money, unfortunatly. Terrible situation


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: deadsilent on October 09, 2019, 01:45:02 PM
Definitely this is just a typical AML/KYC procedure. If you are withdrawing huge amount of funds. Make sure you're a verified. I'm from the Philippines and some of exchange here are implementing AML/KYC procedure. The amount you are able to withdraw depends on your verification level. In your case, you're withdrawing huge amount of BTC. So you're verification level must be higher. They will ask you some documents like how and where you get that amount of BTC. That's pretty normal.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: qiwoman2 on October 09, 2019, 02:04:15 PM
I am so sorry for all the problems you went through but I am likewise relieved that you were able to finally get your money back. I want to also congratulate you on the big wins and that what you won is truly lifechanging money indeed. I think for many of us even owning one Bitcoin would be a boost to our savings and moral, let alone, 30. This is an inspirational journey for you which despite all the challenges, has ended well and also gives many of us hope along the way. I hope to God you get another 30 BTC in the next bull run, good luck to you and your endeavors.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: Dabs on October 09, 2019, 02:34:10 PM
Some people use DOGE to transfer coins between exchanges, although I think Bitstamp doesn't have that trading pair. So where did you move the XRP to and did you trade it back for BTC or another coin?


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: rdbase on October 09, 2019, 02:38:02 PM
Heard from other users bittrex have been sending out emails similar to this one requesting transactions to prove where the crypto originated from.
But that was inregards to being able to withdraw alt coins as well. Not to withholding bitcoin especially a substantial amount such as this. :-[


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: Forgotoldaccount on October 09, 2019, 02:38:53 PM
Some people use DOGE to transfer coins between exchanges, although I think Bitstamp doesn't have that trading pair. So where did you move the XRP to and did you trade it back for BTC or another coin?
Sorry don't understand. I simply withdraw xrp to my toast wallet...  And holding it now in xrp


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: bryant.coleman on October 09, 2019, 02:51:11 PM
This is very disturbing. Why do they need to know the origin of the cryptocurrency holdings, and that too from many years back? For example, I have several transactions which are linked to the now defunct exchanges such as Wex.nz, Cryptopia and BTC-e. How I am supposed to get the transaction details for the withdrawals I made from these exchanges?

I can provide them with the KYC details such as passport copy or national ID card. But signed message.etc can be very difficult, as I no longer have access to some of the wallets that I had used earlier. Anyway, many thanks for posting this thread. I would be careful enough to not deposit any of my BTC in this exchange. I think I would have to depend on peer to peer platforms now to trade my coins.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: buwaytress on October 09, 2019, 02:58:17 PM
Good update, glad you got it all out and, yeah, I know it doesn't need repeating, but for the sake of anyone at all still contemplating this:

Never store your assets on an exchange. Period.

If you love the way you can control all your money. If you want to sleep at night and never worry your funds can be seized, frozen or take over, you must be the only one with access to it. No exceptions.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: ivakar on October 09, 2019, 03:01:21 PM
I guess the point was just to steal your btc
cause for the question - how did you obtain your first BTC, you may say that you've mined it.
And what documents for confirmation would they ask in that case?!!!
Pool transaction, or what?
that is really looks like some people inside exchange decided to do some shady business  >:(


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: kryptqnick on October 09, 2019, 04:56:09 PM
I would like to update this thread now as I am EXTREMELY lucky they have made a mistake.
I told them I'm consulting a lawyer and to cancel my pending withdrawals as they were insistant on these informations.
Then somehow (even though they told me no transactions will be processed until they receive these) I did an XRP ripple withdrawal and it was processed instantlyl

Congratulations! It's great that it worked out for you. You should celebrate that you got such a big amount of money back, even though it was not the likely outcome of this situation. Bitstamp is a company with a good reputation, so I don't think they were trying to scam you. However, their KYC requirements are very serious (though the amount of money you were trying to withdraw was a very big one as well). In fact, if you just google 'Bitstamp KYC' you'll see that people have been complaining about crazy KYC questions since 2017. Next time make you're clear about KYC policies before you deposit any money on an exchange.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: Mpamaegbu on October 09, 2019, 05:43:37 PM
Thanks yes. They did reply this after I asked they cancel the frozen withdrawal::
Thank you for your reply. As per your request, your pending withdrawals have been cancelled.

Please note that, in order to properly process your future transactions, we are going to have to require you to provide us with the previously requested information and documentation.

We look forward to your reply.


Anyway, let this thread serve as a warning to anyone using exchanges that unless you have a complete evidence trail of where your coins are from you are liable to lose them
You were lucky to have escaped by the tail. It was obvious they didn't want to release your cash. Such scammy attitude is what makes people scream blue murder when anyone wants to leave tokens/coins on an exchange. That mark of generalization on what fraudulent activities exchanges go into is what causes distrust in traders. You made your withdrawal through Ripple and it scaled through. That means they had a surveillance on your 10Bitcoin.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: boltz on October 09, 2019, 05:52:06 PM
First time I hear a story like yours from Bitstamp as there are my favorite crypto exchange and never had any problems with them. Anyway before your problem was solved I'm sure that you had a rough day as 10 btcs are a big amount if money no matter what but asking for a signed address is too much , what if you didn't hold any ? They should have any methods in longer for you to prove that you're the owner besides ID and all that KYC.

Anyway I'm glad that your problem was solved and they admit they did wrong but there is a still big WHY this happened on Bitstamp ...next time keep your coins into your personal wallets.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: malevolent on October 09, 2019, 10:45:20 PM
Bitstamp has been here for long time and them asking KYC with such strict details does make me wonder what juicy information they have obtained on the coins.

You may try to present a story in your way of describing but this is what I suspect has happened.

No, this is normal for bitstamp, they have been asking similar questions for >5 years now. Other exchanges are catching up with their intrusiveness. It's better to take your time to find a trustworthy person to make an exchange in-person.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: gentlemand on October 09, 2019, 10:52:10 PM
That's a lot of information they're demanding lol. Unfortunately, it looks like they're just doing the typical AML procedures to make sure you didn't get your BTC somewhere illegal or whatever.

No bleedin' WAY is that typical. I've run plenty of stuff through Kraken and not once have they ever asked for anything other than the initial ID and proof of address and that was about four years ago now. I've never heard of Coinbase asking for any extra intrusive info. They either let you play or tell you to sod off. There's no hostage taking.

Bitstamp seem to specialise in asking for stuff that I've never, ever heard any 'real' financial institution asking for. Why the fuck would you give that to a bunch of anonymous Slovenes?

OP was not clever using open gambling funds. Most exchanges would've given him the boot for that. Good on him for getting one over on them.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: malevolent on October 10, 2019, 01:24:44 AM
No bleedin' WAY is that typical. I've run plenty of stuff through Kraken and not once have they ever asked for anything other than the initial ID and proof of address and that was about four years ago now. I've never heard of Coinbase asking for any extra intrusive info. They either let you play or tell you to sod off. There's no hostage taking.

Bitstamp seem to specialise in asking for stuff that I've never, ever heard any 'real' financial institution asking for. Why the fuck would you give that to a bunch of anonymous Slovenes?

OP was not clever using open gambling funds. Most exchanges would've given him the boot for that. Good on him for getting one over on them.

In this case it doesn't matter that he used gambling funds, Coinbase will close your account for that due to some silly US anti-gambling laws/regulations, Bitstamp is unaffected by that, as you can see they never said anything about it, nor are they closing his account, but they are strict about knowing the source/trail of all of your money/coins at their exchange, stricter in fact than any legacy financial institution.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: mk4 on October 10, 2019, 04:08:07 AM
That's a lot of information they're demanding lol. Unfortunately, it looks like they're just doing the typical AML procedures to make sure you didn't get your BTC somewhere illegal or whatever.

No bleedin' WAY is that typical. I've run plenty of stuff through Kraken and not once have they ever asked for anything other than the initial ID and proof of address and that was about four years ago now. I've never heard of Coinbase asking for any extra intrusive info. They either let you play or tell you to sod off. There's no hostage taking.

Bitstamp seem to specialise in asking for stuff that I've never, ever heard any 'real' financial institution asking for. Why the fuck would you give that to a bunch of anonymous Slovenes?

OP was not clever using open gambling funds. Most exchanges would've given him the boot for that. Good on him for getting one over on them.


I'd say it's typical, but I'd agree that it's just blown way out of proportion concerning the data they're asking for. While other exchanges might not be doing these sort of stuff, the hostage taking of funds is really not that rare based on my experience(not personally, based on what I've been reading throughout the years on various bitcoin communities). My guess, they're probably just trying to give out a bit of fear due to OP getting the funds from gambling. I mean, they immediately gave in when OP mentioned lawyers and stuff lol; so I don't think they probably intentionally made the data collecting mandatory.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: TheUltraElite on October 10, 2019, 06:59:10 AM
No, this is normal for bitstamp, they have been asking similar questions for >5 years now. Other exchanges are catching up with their intrusiveness. It's better to take your time to find a trustworthy person to make an exchange in-person.
I would be extremely uncomfortable with having to deal with a person face to face but its better with a P2P exchange like LBC.

I always feel it to be better if governments would allow trading in crypto and that country people use an exchange where they can verify themselves to buy and sell. As for the OP this is not important but I see your point here. The more the governments try to supress crypto the more AML/KYC problems will arise because of non-compliance from public.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: marky89 on October 10, 2019, 07:50:29 AM
Bitstamp has been here for long time and them asking KYC with such strict details does make me wonder what juicy information they have obtained on the coins.

Where have you been? Bitstamp is notorious for freezing accounts and requiring DNA-level KYC. The complaints about them are rampant. It's at the top of my list of exchanges to avoid.

Read through some of these threads:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5172859.0
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1928777.0
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1818079.0
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=2214456.0
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5064228.0


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: Quidat on October 10, 2019, 11:51:07 AM
That's a lot of information they're demanding lol. Unfortunately, it looks like they're just doing the typical AML procedures to make sure you didn't get your BTC somewhere illegal or whatever.

No bleedin' WAY is that typical. I've run plenty of stuff through Kraken and not once have they ever asked for anything other than the initial ID and proof of address and that was about four years ago now. I've never heard of Coinbase asking for any extra intrusive info. They either let you play or tell you to sod off. There's no hostage taking.

Bitstamp seem to specialise in asking for stuff that I've never, ever heard any 'real' financial institution asking for. Why the fuck would you give that to a bunch of anonymous Slovenes?

OP was not clever using open gambling funds. Most exchanges would've given him the boot for that. Good on him for getting one over on them.


I'd say it's typical, but I'd agree that it's just blown way out of proportion concerning the data they're asking for. While other exchanges might not be doing these sort of stuff, the hostage taking of funds is really not that rare based on my experience(not personally, based on what I've been reading throughout the years on various bitcoin communities). My guess, they're probably just trying to give out a bit of fear due to OP getting the funds from gambling. I mean, they immediately gave in when OP mentioned lawyers and stuff lol; so I don't think they probably intentionally made the data collecting mandatory.
So in short those kind of requirements are just a test if the user would decide to forget those funds that he have? No surprising on any service on this market where
selective scamming or hold-up of funds into some number of users.If they do easily admit and processed out the withdrawals after mentioning some legal aspect then
you cant really avoid not to be suspicious with their modus.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: mk4 on October 10, 2019, 03:18:18 PM

So in short those kind of requirements are just a test if the user would decide to forget those funds that he have? No surprising on any service on this market where
selective scamming or hold-up of funds into some number of users.If they do easily admit and processed out the withdrawals after mentioning some legal aspect then
you cant really avoid not to be suspicious with their modus.

Nah. It's more of fear mongering in the hopes of probably OP stop depositing funds from gambling sites(because most exchanges doesn't like this). If Bitstamp would be to attempt to start such a modus, for a business as big as their size, I'm pretty sure they wouldn't be attempting to grab 10 BTC. If they would attempt to do so, it would definitely be a lot bigger than 10 BTC.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: Quidat on October 10, 2019, 04:27:36 PM

So in short those kind of requirements are just a test if the user would decide to forget those funds that he have? No surprising on any service on this market where
selective scamming or hold-up of funds into some number of users.If they do easily admit and processed out the withdrawals after mentioning some legal aspect then
you cant really avoid not to be suspicious with their modus.

Nah. It's more of fear mongering in the hopes of probably OP stop depositing funds from gambling sites(because most exchanges doesn't like this). If Bitstamp would be to attempt to start such a modus, for a business as big as their size, I'm pretty sure they wouldn't be attempting to grab 10 BTC. If they would attempt to do so, it would definitely be a lot bigger than 10 BTC.
Yeah i got your point which is definitely right and well said, big business like this one will not really risk up to ruin their
reputation for mere amounts of BTC. Dont know why there are still people who arent that careful on sending out their funds
came from gambling sites where most service specially exchangers do have this typical terms or prohibition.
Lesson learned for those who arent fan on reading sites terms until they realize that they already violate when they already
experiencing some withdrawal issues.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: bryant.coleman on October 12, 2019, 01:32:34 AM
Bitstamp has been here for long time and them asking KYC with such strict details does make me wonder what juicy information they have obtained on the coins.

You may try to present a story in your way of describing but this is what I suspect has happened.

No, this is normal for bitstamp, they have been asking similar questions for >5 years now. Other exchanges are catching up with their intrusiveness. It's better to take your time to find a trustworthy person to make an exchange in-person.

No one can be 100% trustworthy. I have seen vendors in Localbitcoins selling their old accounts to scammers and the latter using them to con unsuspecting users. EVen I had a few bad experiences with LBC, and my coins were returned only after I contacted the LBC admins. If you are talking about face-to-face transactions, then they are not only risky, but unsafe as well.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: malevolent on October 12, 2019, 02:32:48 AM
No one can be 100% trustworthy. I have seen vendors in Localbitcoins selling their old accounts to scammers and the latter using them to con unsuspecting users. EVen I had a few bad experiences with LBC, and my coins were returned only after I contacted the LBC admins. If you are talking about face-to-face transactions, then they are not only risky, but unsafe as well.

Yes, in-person = face-to-face. Never had a problem, know your surroundings, learn how to spot fakes, and if you live somewhere where violent crime is a concern be armed or bring an armed friend. I'd be more wary of receiving a bank transfer from a hijacked bank account and having my money frozen after releasing bitcoins to the fraudster.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: magneto on October 12, 2019, 12:22:13 PM
This is insane. I knew that Bitstamp was always overboard with their KYC requests to the point that it's probably even required by law for them to do some of the things that they ask for, but never knew that they would peer into such private details of every single transaction that you make just so that you can withdraw what is rightfully yours.

What right do they have to ask for tax statements, your income, where you got funds from, and what you are going to use funds on? And what relevance does that even have in terms of them upholding a very simple KYC procedure?

Why do they care that this was your gambling winnings? They are not the prosecutors nor the police, they have no proof of any wrongdoing on your side.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: BitHodler on October 12, 2019, 01:36:10 PM
No one can be 100% trustworthy. I have seen vendors in Localbitcoins selling their old accounts to scammers and the latter using them to con unsuspecting users.
Bingo! I see that happen even here on non crypto marketplace sites. The first sign of trust (people think like that) is to avoid new accounts and only deal with older accounts---resulting in scammer offering big money for these older accounts.

People with older accounts who don't often list anything for sale will likely not reject an offer of a few hundred bucks for their account, especially since they can simply create a new one.

It provides scammers easy access to old accounts. By the time people no longer connect trustworthiness to old accounts, scammers will find other routes to gain people's trust and scam them. They are always a step ahead.


Title: Re: BITSTAMP frozen my 10 btc and asking years worth of signed address transactions
Post by: figmentofmyass on October 12, 2019, 06:52:10 PM
Why do they care that this was your gambling winnings? They are not the prosecutors nor the police, they have no proof of any wrongdoing on your side.

i'm not sure on the specifics in other countries, but the USA has strict federal laws prohibiting interstate gambling activity. to avoid liability, banks and payment processors avoid transmitting money on behalf of sportsbooks and gambling sites. this naturally extends to exchanges, which is why coinbase and gemini have policies against usage for gambling in their user agreements. in fact, bitstamp does include something about "illegal gambling operations" in its terms. if the OP were from the USA or a country with similar laws, i wouldn't be surprised to see account termination over it.

and that's what would happen on coinbase or gemini---they would just close his account and send him his funds. leave it to bitstamp to put the OP through hell and possibly steal his coins because he can't prove the source of every satoshi.