Bitcoin Forum

Alternate cryptocurrencies => Mining (Altcoins) => Topic started by: mineshop.eu on July 28, 2020, 01:14:19 PM



Title: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: mineshop.eu on July 28, 2020, 01:14:19 PM
https://mineshop.eu/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/RX-5600XT-600x338.jpg
Sad news for RX 5700 as they have been absolute best mining cards lately for ROI. Most of the brands like MSI and Sapphire , they are now EOL. The XT version is still produced. Still a very good option but slightly more expensive then the non XT version for the same performance.

Just wanted to test out little brother RX 5600XT. After tests seems like a decent mining farm.

Efficiency rating is slightly better for power usage for hash then RX 5700 . But the RX 5700 is bout 0.7 usd cheaper for 1 mh/s. If the electric rate you pay is high then in long-term the days of ROI could be about the same.

Current time of ROI for 12xgpu mining rig is roughly 300 days at current ETH price and mining difficulty.

Performance :

42mh/s
@100w from the wall
OC (910 mem , Core 1100, PL 100)

I have created also google spreadsheet to compare few of the cards efficiency . - https://bit.ly/3jLAzjK (https://bit.ly/3jLAzjK)

Full video review  - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MDuz3L3IX9o (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MDuz3L3IX9o)






Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: Globalminingcorp on July 28, 2020, 06:54:16 PM
Keep up the nice work with your topics! Much appreciated.


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: Marvell2 on July 29, 2020, 08:21:30 PM
i like your chart that shows what model gpu is mining what, you should also talk about the older asics that might fall off too when dag passes 4.5 gig.

do you own and asics?


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: mineshop.eu on July 30, 2020, 11:12:03 AM
Keep up the nice work with your topics! Much appreciated.

Thank  you i will ;)


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: mineshop.eu on July 30, 2020, 11:13:40 AM
i like your chart that shows what model gpu is mining what, you should also talk about the older asics that might fall off too when dag passes 4.5 gig.

do you own and asics?

I have one E3 sitting in corner. Its off dont know if it is working, need to try turn on one day. Turned off cause the hashrate was drooping cause if the dag.


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: Marvell2 on July 30, 2020, 03:47:19 PM
i like your chart that shows what model gpu is mining what, you should also talk about the older asics that might fall off too when dag passes 4.5 gig.

do you own and asics?

I have one E3 sitting in corner. Its off dont know if it is working, need to try turn on one day. Turned off cause the hashrate was drooping cause if the dag.
I heard there was an update to the E3 to make it mine longer back in april or so, did you apply that?


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: Marvell2 on July 30, 2020, 03:48:53 PM
i like your chart that shows what model gpu is mining what, you should also talk about the older asics that might fall off too when dag passes 4.5 gig.

do you own and asics?

I have one E3 sitting in corner. Its off dont know if it is working, need to try turn on one day. Turned off cause the hashrate was drooping cause if the dag.
i also picked up an asrock 5700 really cheap $325 any ideas how to flash this one, seems to crash when i copy both straps from 1500 to end.


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: mineshop.eu on July 30, 2020, 05:28:18 PM
i like your chart that shows what model gpu is mining what, you should also talk about the older asics that might fall off too when dag passes 4.5 gig.

do you own and asics?

I have one E3 sitting in corner. Its off dont know if it is working, need to try turn on one day. Turned off cause the hashrate was drooping cause if the dag.
i also picked up an asrock 5700 really cheap $325 any ideas how to flash this one, seems to crash when i copy both straps from 1500 to end.

What is your OC, might be your cards cannt handle OC? Or its bricked and doesnt start mining at all?


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: mineshop.eu on July 30, 2020, 05:28:55 PM
i like your chart that shows what model gpu is mining what, you should also talk about the older asics that might fall off too when dag passes 4.5 gig.

do you own and asics?

I have one E3 sitting in corner. Its off dont know if it is working, need to try turn on one day. Turned off cause the hashrate was drooping cause if the dag.

Yeah heared about update, but didnt try it myself. I hate the ASICs :D


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: Wotan Wipeout on July 31, 2020, 11:21:32 AM
You dont need to copy all straps. It wont work with 2000 Mhz and more anyway.


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: Marvell2 on July 31, 2020, 03:58:20 PM
You dont need to copy all straps. It wont work with 2000 Mhz and more anyway.
it seems the ones with straps coppied are faster by 3mhs at least ar least on the msi ones that the 1550 straps were copied on.  all the 5700 tuning guides say straps and powerplay


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: mineshop.eu on August 01, 2020, 12:09:49 PM
You dont need to copy all straps. It wont work with 2000 Mhz and more anyway.
it seems the ones with straps coppied are faster by 3mhs at least ar least on the msi ones that the 1550 straps were copied on.  all the 5700 tuning guides say straps and powerplay
Yeah straps on 5700 needs to be edited to reach higher performance. Powerplay if you use hiveos can be edited directly in OC now.
You are right about 1550 straps are slower slightly, depends on memory type.


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: Sy on August 03, 2020, 07:01:06 AM
Did you have a chance of using RTX 2080? If yes, then what would you say is better AMD RX 5700 or GeForce RTX 2080? Lately am in the market for an upgrade and I looking for something that doesn't overheat easy.


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: mineshop.eu on August 03, 2020, 10:18:03 AM
Did you have a chance of using RTX 2080? If yes, then what would you say is better AMD RX 5700 or GeForce RTX 2080? Lately am in the market for an upgrade and I looking for something that doesn't overheat easy.

I have not myself. Had couple pre-ordered for tests when they launched, and then there was issue with lot of cards burning, so i canceled.
But Nvidia has always been very expensive for mining , as their cost is lot higher usually then AMD. Nvidia usually does much better on core hard algorithms, but there is very little coins that would have large networks.
AMD has always been better on memory hard algorithms, and there is few coins in top 50 Mcap which has these algos.  

Any of these with great cooling should be ok. Sapphire nitros, pulse for AMD usually have great cooling


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: Metroid on August 03, 2020, 04:38:19 PM
Did you have a chance of using RTX 2080? If yes, then what would you say is better AMD RX 5700 or GeForce RTX 2080? Lately am in the market for an upgrade and I looking for something that doesn't overheat easy.

check reviews about heatsink weight, in general, the more it weights the better will be the cooling when summer hits because what is important is to keep the gpus temperature less than 70 degrees Celsius, on winter it won't matter much but on summer it will, the problem is that most reviewers don't say the heatsink weight, they should, that is important not only from a miner perspective but from an end user/gamer too.


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: Sy on August 05, 2020, 05:54:24 AM
Did you have a chance of using RTX 2080? If yes, then what would you say is better AMD RX 5700 or GeForce RTX 2080? Lately am in the market for an upgrade and I looking for something that doesn't overheat easy.

check reviews about heatsink weight, in general, the more it weights the better will be the cooling when summer hits because what is important is to keep the gpus temperature less than 70 degrees Celsius, on winter it won't matter much but on summer it will, the problem is that most reviewers don't say the heatsink weight, they should, that is important not only from a miner perspective but from an end user/gamer too.

Well that's something new I learned today I had no idea that GPU's heating is dependent on heatsink's weight. What would you say the ideal weight of heatsink should be when considering a new GPU?


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: Marvell2 on August 05, 2020, 08:13:52 AM
Did you have a chance of using RTX 2080? If yes, then what would you say is better AMD RX 5700 or GeForce RTX 2080? Lately am in the market for an upgrade and I looking for something that doesn't overheat easy.

check reviews about heatsink weight, in general, the more it weights the better will be the cooling when summer hits because what is important is to keep the gpus temperature less than 70 degrees Celsius, on winter it won't matter much but on summer it will, the problem is that most reviewers don't say the heatsink weight, they should, that is important not only from a miner perspective but from an end user/gamer too.

Well that's something new I learned today I had no idea that GPU's heating is dependent on heatsink's weight. What would you say the ideal weight of heatsink should be when considering a new GPU?
its apples to oranges, ive had some gpus 470x red dragon with a fat ole heatsink but comes with one fan and the run hot and die in droves , others have dual fans an a slim heatsink works fine and they are cool.  i think i do agree  bigger is better but its just on measurable.  Does the card have vrm cooling? or just the gpu , my expreinece msi tends to have the best fans


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: _javi_ on August 05, 2020, 05:11:05 PM


I have created also google spreadsheet to compare few of the cards efficiency . - https://bit.ly/3jLAzjK (https://bit.ly/3jLAzjK)




You have some strange values for the Nvidia Geforce 1070 on KAWPOW algo.. I get 15mh/s @140w, far better than what you have in there.


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: safar1980 on August 06, 2020, 10:51:15 AM
Which of these video cards is better to buy?

SAPPHIRE AMD Radeon RX 5600XT  11296-05-20G PULSE RX 5600XT BE 6G OC
MSI AMD Radeon RX 5600XT  RX 5600 XT MECH
SAPPHIRE AMD Radeon RX 5600XT  11296-01-20G PULSE RX 5600XT 6G OC
POWERCOLOR AMD Radeon RX 5600XT  AXRX 5600XT 6GBD6-3DHR/OC


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: jgonzi on August 06, 2020, 11:27:27 AM
Which of these video cards is better to buy?

SAPPHIRE AMD Radeon RX 5600XT  11296-05-20G PULSE RX 5600XT BE 6G OC
MSI AMD Radeon RX 5600XT  RX 5600 XT MECH
SAPPHIRE AMD Radeon RX 5600XT  11296-01-20G PULSE RX 5600XT 6G OC
POWERCOLOR AMD Radeon RX 5600XT  AXRX 5600XT 6GBD6-3DHR/OC

1. SAPPHIRE AMD Radeon RX 5600XT  11296-01-20G PULSE RX 5600XT 6G OC
2. SAPPHIRE AMD Radeon RX 5600XT  11296-05-20G PULSE RX 5600XT BE 6G OC
3. MSI AMD Radeon RX 5600XT  RX 5600 XT MECH - POWERCOLOR AMD Radeon RX 5600XT  AXRX 5600XT 6GBD6-3DHR/OC



Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: safar1980 on August 06, 2020, 11:40:43 AM
Does vBIOS of 14Gbps memory speed  UPDATE give an increase in hashrate in mining?
Should I flash video cards or does it not affect mining?


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: valjean on August 07, 2020, 09:21:43 AM
Hello All,

Agree with jgonzi  for the cards ranking, Sapphire is the best brand (easy replacable fan, very high quality build and impressive cooling, with NITRO+>Pulse>Pulse BE

If someone can give us information about flashing the bios I would be interrested. I saw a couple of video about rx 5700 biosmod but until now noone of rx 5600 biosmod

Regards
Jean


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: jgonzi on August 07, 2020, 10:14:17 AM
Hello All,

Agree with jgonzi  for the cards ranking, Sapphire is the best brand (easy replacable fan, very high quality build and impressive cooling, with NITRO+>Pulse>Pulse BE

If someone can give us information about flashing the bios I would be interrested. I saw a couple of video about rx 5700 biosmod but until now noone of rx 5600 biosmod

Regards
Jean

Bios RX 5600 is the same… copy STRAPS...


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: Marvell2 on August 08, 2020, 06:24:03 AM
Hello All,

Agree with jgonzi  for the cards ranking, Sapphire is the best brand (easy replacable fan, very high quality build and impressive cooling, with NITRO+>Pulse>Pulse BE

If someone can give us information about flashing the bios I would be interrested. I saw a couple of video about rx 5700 biosmod but until now noone of rx 5600 biosmod

Regards
Jean
saphire has a crap 2 year waranty i shy away from those , msi for amd and asus for nvidia


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: mineshop.eu on August 10, 2020, 01:43:35 PM
Hello All,

Agree with jgonzi  for the cards ranking, Sapphire is the best brand (easy replacable fan, very high quality build and impressive cooling, with NITRO+>Pulse>Pulse BE

If someone can give us information about flashing the bios I would be interrested. I saw a couple of video about rx 5700 biosmod but until now noone of rx 5600 biosmod

Regards
Jean

Bios RX 5600 is the same… copy STRAPS...

Yeah he is right it does not work, straps bricks the cards. Think this is because tools not supported with RX 5600


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: mineshop.eu on August 10, 2020, 01:45:34 PM
Which of these video cards is better to buy?

SAPPHIRE AMD Radeon RX 5600XT  11296-05-20G PULSE RX 5600XT BE 6G OC
MSI AMD Radeon RX 5600XT  RX 5600 XT MECH
SAPPHIRE AMD Radeon RX 5600XT  11296-01-20G PULSE RX 5600XT 6G OC
POWERCOLOR AMD Radeon RX 5600XT  AXRX 5600XT 6GBD6-3DHR/OC
I have had tested both Sapphire pulse and MSI mech , and hash-rates for MSI mech much better then Sapphire pulse unfortunetly ;(
Sapphire cards always has better built quality


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: jgonzi on August 11, 2020, 10:35:21 AM
Which of these video cards is better to buy?

SAPPHIRE AMD Radeon RX 5600XT  11296-05-20G PULSE RX 5600XT BE 6G OC
MSI AMD Radeon RX 5600XT  RX 5600 XT MECH
SAPPHIRE AMD Radeon RX 5600XT  11296-01-20G PULSE RX 5600XT 6G OC
POWERCOLOR AMD Radeon RX 5600XT  AXRX 5600XT 6GBD6-3DHR/OC
I have had tested both Sapphire pulse and MSI mech , and hash-rates for MSI mech much better then Sapphire pulse unfortunetly ;(
Sapphire cards always has better built quality

With mod bios or normal bios?


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: Piskeante on August 13, 2020, 11:40:18 AM
i got an XFX 5700 red dragon for 300$ (consider i live in Spain and here everything is much more expensive than in the US) almost brand new. I bios flashed it with the XT version of this card. At this very moment is doing 58mh/s at 140W at the wall.


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: jgonzi on August 14, 2020, 09:15:22 AM
i got an XFX 5700 red dragon for 300$ (consider i live in Spain and here everything is much more expensive than in the US) almost brand new. I bios flashed it with the XT version of this card. At this very moment is doing 58mh/s at 140W at the wall.

In terms of efficency… you can low the Mhs but reduce the Watts in Wall... You can try 52-54Mhs with 90W... That is 1,73W x Mhs… If you look diese extra 4-6Mhs are nearly 9W x Mhs… But if you have a free plug… PUSH 58Mhs  :P


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: mineshop.eu on August 14, 2020, 11:39:29 AM
Which of these video cards is better to buy?

SAPPHIRE AMD Radeon RX 5600XT  11296-05-20G PULSE RX 5600XT BE 6G OC
MSI AMD Radeon RX 5600XT  RX 5600 XT MECH
SAPPHIRE AMD Radeon RX 5600XT  11296-01-20G PULSE RX 5600XT 6G OC
POWERCOLOR AMD Radeon RX 5600XT  AXRX 5600XT 6GBD6-3DHR/OC
I have had tested both Sapphire pulse and MSI mech , and hash-rates for MSI mech much better then Sapphire pulse unfortunetly ;(
Sapphire cards always has better built quality

With mod bios or normal bios?
Bios mod with current tools dont work, bricks the cards RX 5600XT


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: sbcandrew on October 11, 2020, 12:21:31 AM
Unlock bios Powercolor RX5600XT for samsung memory

https://bitby.ru/bios-rx5600xt-mod-en.php


Title: Re: RX 5700 EOL | testing RX 5600XT mining performance
Post by: mineshop.eu on October 23, 2020, 09:41:45 AM
Unlock bios Powercolor RX5600XT for samsung memory

https://bitby.ru/bios-rx5600xt-mod-en.php
Yeah you can get MSI unlocked bios here also. https://youtu.be/tvmutIkbNIs (https://youtu.be/tvmutIkbNIs)
But what i have noticed you can flash this even on different brand and it will be working.