Bitcoin Forum

Other => Off-topic => Topic started by: coinorium on August 20, 2020, 01:29:45 PM



Title: Coin or Token?
Post by: coinorium on August 20, 2020, 01:29:45 PM
Hello guys, we are developing a project only for university students.
Our project involves students in Turkey and all over the world.
In this case, we plan to invest in the development of the project and reach a more robust structure, and we plan to take this with an ICO Project.
But whether we should make our ICO Project by creating a new coin or with ERC-20 derivative Token systems, we were unsure about this issue and we wanted to learn your ideas.
We would be very happy if you give your opinion.

Thanks to everyone in advance.


Title: Re: Coin or Token?
Post by: Ucy on August 20, 2020, 03:44:35 PM
I guess token will be better if you are not planning to build something too advanced and independent. That will even help the school/schools take advantage of the features and ecosystem of the Blockchain you are building on.
I think coin (or blockchain?) is better for large Network that enables difference networks/communities to be built on top of it


Title: Re: Coin or Token?
Post by: semobo on August 20, 2020, 04:02:54 PM
When you don't even know which blockchain to choose for your project then how you are going to develop the project as you promised.I will say creating your own blockchain is better than erc 20 token because it has very low chance of getting survival.


Title: Re: Coin or Token?
Post by: coinorium on August 20, 2020, 05:50:21 PM
I guess token will be better if you are not planning to build something too advanced and independent. That will even help the school/schools take advantage of the features and ecosystem of the Blockchain you are building on.
I think coin (or blockchain?) is better for large Network that enables difference networks/communities to be built on top of it


Thank you for your consideration.


Title: Re: Coin or Token?
Post by: coinorium on August 20, 2020, 06:14:58 PM
When you don't even know which blockchain to choose for your project then how you are going to develop the project as you promised.I will say creating your own blockchain is better than erc 20 token because it has very low chance of getting survival.


Our project has already been greatly improved. However, we thought about collecting investments in order to accelerate the development and we had some disagreements with our teammates on behalf of the blockchain to be chosen. That's why we wanted to learn the opinions of forum users.
We thank you.


Title: Re: Coin or Token?
Post by: odolvlobo on August 20, 2020, 08:09:43 PM
The advantage of a token is that you don't need a mining infrastructure. Supporting a mining infrastructure can be a huge burden for developers, and it potentially can be a serious distraction for the project. Creating your own block chain also introduces security risks that you wouldn't have as a token.


Title: Re: Coin or Token?
Post by: articlecity on August 20, 2020, 10:00:06 PM
As far as i can get from your intro about the project, Token model will be ok for you unless you want to create your own infrastructure, blockchain network and all the coding.


Title: Re: Coin or Token?
Post by: GeorgeJohn on August 21, 2020, 01:22:34 AM
When you don't even know which blockchain to choose for your project then how you are going to develop the project as you promised.I will say creating your own blockchain is better than erc 20 token because it has very low chance of getting survival.

While is that creating just like block chain is better than a token?
Want to understand, can you throw more lite of this, because I think am misunderstanding something serious.


Title: Re: Coin or Token?
Post by: semobo on August 21, 2020, 05:15:03 AM
When you don't even know which blockchain to choose for your project then how you are going to develop the project as you promised.I will say creating your own blockchain is better than erc 20 token because it has very low chance of getting survival.

While is that creating just like block chain is better than a token?
Want to understand, can you throw more lite of this, because I think am misunderstanding something serious.
Independent blockchain projects are called as coins where as projects created on other blockchain like ethereum,tron,waves,etc will be terms as tokens and now tokens can be created pretty easily and to create independent blockchain will take efforts and then only you can develop the projects further more and can bring it into a successful path.


Title: Re: Coin or Token?
Post by: boyptc on August 21, 2020, 05:23:45 AM
It would be a token.

ERC-20 tokens have been tested and proven to be as good as the tokens that we have in the market. If there are things you are unsure of, better you should someone who's knowledgeable in what you do.

A blockchain consultant will help you guys a lot.


Title: Re: Coin or Token?
Post by: Salauddin1994 on August 21, 2020, 02:25:13 PM
In the case of blockchain technology, it is better to do ICO projects but tokens are more powerful. How you complete your work will depend on the project you decide to work with. To know the ideas you will get the right idea by analyzing the different sites of the forum and you will be able to gain knowledge. The projects are improving a lot and are more reliable for ERC-20 blockchain tokens.


Title: Re: Coin or Token?
Post by: bitterguy28 on November 28, 2020, 10:57:05 AM
When you don't even know which blockchain to choose for your project then how you are going to develop the project as you promised.I will say creating your own blockchain is better than erc 20 token because it has very low chance of getting survival.


Our project has already been greatly improved. However, we thought about collecting investments in order to accelerate the development and we had some disagreements with our teammates on behalf of the blockchain to be chosen. That's why we wanted to learn the opinions of forum users.
We thank you.
So how is it going now after 3 months of Asking here?does the Whole team come to single and strong decision?or again another Disagreement?

If you will Not stick in same stand then the project will not going far but surely will collapse so either some of you will adjust and join others or be separated and make your own ICO each group .


Title: Re: Coin or Token?
Post by: jrrsparkles on November 28, 2020, 05:21:08 PM
Token or coin, I guess the result is going to be the same which is most likely not going to attract the investors because the use case is not actually practical.Students or the education institute may not care much about the payment and not going to make it as transparent as well.


Title: Re: Coin or Token?
Post by: devil2man on November 29, 2020, 04:06:43 PM
the best thing would be to create a new blockchain and an altcoin from scratch, if you really need to create a token on another blockchain make a utility token, the service tokens could be taxed or require additional duties and kyc for any users


Title: Re: Coin or Token?
Post by: LiceNseHit on October 22, 2021, 07:30:46 PM
Hello guys, we are developing a project only for university students.
Our project involves students in Turkey and all over the world.
In this case, we plan to invest in the development of the project and reach a more robust structure, and we plan to take this with an ICO Project.
But whether we should make our ICO Project by creating a new coin or with ERC-20 derivative Token systems, we were unsure about this issue and we wanted to learn your ideas.
We would be very happy if you give your opinion.

Thanks to everyone in advance.


If it something simple it will be cool idea.