Bitcoin Forum

I see something strange on Premier League Everton vs Burnley look exciting https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K6q2WQdGe50

anyone know where the sounds of supporter? when you look inside, there is an empty attribute, nothing the audience. I guess they use sounds on background (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tlU2qo5cYHw), CMIIW.

You mean the background Cheer?

 What we do see on television or YouTube is an edited video. Ofcourse the sound comes from prerecorded sounds from the people who might be now dead. It's not the audience. They are super less because of the pandemic. So they generally either play the prerecorded sounds or either they add them while the video might be going online etc. Either way its not a big matter of concern.

taken from google
Just like this and at the same.tike it's not just sports matches that use such things , most of the times there are cooking shows, there are funny stand up comedians etc.. all of them use such things.

It would be a funny thing to have a silent show. I would like it who knows how it will go though. There will be one or two scattered whistles, audiences are rarely in tune.

I believe they are only using artificial crowd noise to create the similar atmosphere wherein stadiums are full to the brim with people for those who are watching from their houses. It's really boring to watch these sporting events without crowd cheers and noises, There are also virtual audiences (https://www.theverge.com/2020/7/25/21336017/fox-sports-baseball-virtual-fans-epic-unreal-engine-empty-stadiums-mlb) that are being utilized by sports broadcasters in order to mimic a stadium filled with people just to get that atmosphere going for sports fans. We live in crazy times, so it's better to use these artificial sounds and virtual audiences rather than let people attend sporting events personally.

I've never imagine someone would asking this question right on that YouTube videos. That would be funny.

It's all about entertaining the multimedia contents to make it more attractive. If they let the video without the helps of that supporters sounds, it will be a boring video with only the wind or the ball kicked sound, and the players screaming. They even cover the empty seats with interesting design and pictures.

it was only the artificial voices of them which broadcasting the match...
you try to pay attention, each site that holds live broadcasts must have different cheers and some do not make artificial sounds at all. *btw, this topic is more suitable to be discussed in 'off topic' IMO

Thank you for the article https://www.theverge.com/2020/7/25/21336017/fox-sports-baseball-virtual-fans-epic-unreal-engine-empty-stadiums-mlb
I didn't know this process of virtual audience, it's very realistic on the pictures and the videos. I don't know why any stadium don't try to use projectors to project those virtual audience images directly in the stadium, it would be more realistic, and players on the field would feel an almost real audience supporting them.

For the global spectator it will sound the same as in normal matches without covid. it does not bother me to much that we do not see audience in the stadium.
In the beginning we did not hear any audio, yes that was a big difference then you hear really any noise.

That's how the games or tournaments now, to be able to still uplift the surrounding and still gain the vibes of having a audience especially if it will be televised, the event organjzers will put some background, designs, and music. It's quite boring to watch without sounds of cheering especially when it comes in gambling or sports tournament. Maybe it's the 1st time again OP got to watch events due to Pandemic.

Its just artificial sounds that had been generated to make it more to be into those situations where crowd is really watching off a certain game.They had put up that kind of set-up

to make it feel that there's a crowd vibe which i dont see for it to be a bad idea and that do somehow patches up the lack of presence on actual thing.

I dont know on why you do able to ask out for a very obvious thing or simply just using up that common sense of yours.

These sounds are just the addition to the video. To give an excitement and visual involvement to the people watching the game these sounds were added. On some games audience were allowed and this can be seen on games that are being played with any audience on the ground. Earlier this was into discussion during the previous IPL season, because the matches were played with ZERO audience. At times these sounds seems to be unenjoyable, because we can feel it is an addition.

It is very obvious that without noise that place will look boring, that why artificial noise is be created to keep the place a little bit lively. So the noise is be created artificially.

I agree on the mans words said on this video that if you do see a game which doesn't have crowd noise would really be like just a practice game.

All things explained here about that NFL's Fake crowd noise system. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jaO7sxNg2BI
Some might really look for it to be non appealing but this one do really done its job well.

They are pre-recorded.

Having no audience and there's a sound of the crowd then that's the technical side which belongs to the audio team. And it's applicable not only during this pandemic but also in other events that it needs to be played.

We're still in the pandemic and that wouldn't really bother me as well.

I bet for Everton, so I watch this live game 2 days ago, sound is the same as the youtube video.

I guess sound engineering in behind had a good hand at editing video in live.

oh thats creepy as f , playing and there might be dead people watching and cheering in your game inside that stadium but normal at the same time because they arent the one who does this and it will be plain/less lively if no sounds at all  .

this is what i noticed when i check the video  . i tried to adjust the video to make it clearer and replay it many times because the background looks wierd and found out that they dont move but the crowd was still there  but there are a few people on that stage that do real noise but sadly thier sounds wont be heard in the edited stream

The voice is a recording as mentioned by Jossiel, and you can read here that the audience's voice was supplied by EA Sports
sources: https://www.si.com/soccer/2020/06/12/la-liga-premier-league-fake-fan-noise-broadcasts-ea-sports

That was my first instinct too, that it was a ploy to make the game more entertaining since there aren't a lot of audience, I understand this kind of thing for entertainment, we watch a lot of shows with laugh tracks and we don't seem to mind so I guess that there is nothing wrong with this video. I am imagining it already, with no cheering and only commentary, I think that viewership is going to go down.

I wouldn't even notice any of those cheers because most of the time I will just watch the game and whatever happens in the background will just be ignored. But I would assume the players themselves wouldn't be hearing all these cheers and all the celebrations they do when they hit the goal are just them yelling. The background music and cheers are just in the commentator's booth.

If anyone just missed the reply of Strongkored this was the answer from the OPs post. I think it isn't strange considering they will really find some alternative just to make the audience feel it was like before when this pandemic hasn't hit yet. Furthermore, I guess you already find it OP, the answer on your question was on your post, it may not be the right one but I think they use other recorded audios from the crowd.

With the growth of technology, making a fake sound will not difficult, especially there is an expert who knows the trick to make it. They can take the recorded from the previous match which has an audience and combine it with the match, so the audience in their home can see the sound on their television or even in the live match. The officials of those sports will figure out how to make the match can entertain people at their home as we still at the pandemic. It is like we watch a movie or else from Youtube with a sound background at the movie. So I guess that will still give another experience to the audience at their home.

It is kind of odd that you are only noticing this now but after sports began again it was clear that something was needed to be done because the absence of public will have an effect on the matches, we know that a soccer game is supposed to sound in a particular way and if it does not then people will lose interest despite the fact they knew deep down there could not be such sounds since there was no public, so it was decided to add sounds that recreated the experience of the audience and personally I prefer this many times to a silent game.

They need to hype the game for the television audience so the viewership goes up and they can earn money, you don't want to be sitting on your home cheering for your team alone, the sound reinforces the idea that you are not alone in the cheering of your team which is a good psychological trick to make people stay on the program, imagine a sitcom that you are the only one laughing, I guess you could say that it is a little boring.

you're talking about putting the image projectors physically inside the stadium during games, right? it's just my opinion(since I might be wrong) but the projector to make a virtual audience wouldn't make sense to the athletes because of their angles and the movements they would make around the field. it might even become a distraction to them because of the distortion the image would make in different angles if you project it on the audience's seats.

They try their best but the problem at least in the Champions League games I have seen in Tv is that the cheering is linear.The real cheer has moments of joy when your team is playing well and moments of sadness where your team does not perform well.They need to change this to make the game attractive to watch during this pandemic time.

They don't have to change anything, they know how this thing works and only avid fans will be able to tell the difference in the cheering and they know that there is only a few people that have that keen insight so they don't have to spend a lot of time perfecting the fake crowd cheer.

Yeah it's artificial sound added to the game from previous ones. They have been doing it in my country since last year. Honestly, it's alright in my opinion. Seeing an empty stadium without any sounds was really wierd in the begging. We just got so used to people cheering during sport matches. But for the players it's still wierd to play on an empty stadium without anyone cheering if they score a goal.

It's not that difficult nowadays and even a kid can do it, well, it's still fine I think that they do this kind rather than nothing because that will really be too boring. It will be cool to see if they do the same in the basketball live games were people on the bench side has live screen but I think it will really be hassle putting such large screen in a football arena.

Is this the very first time that you watched a Pre recorded Videos? this is like Crating a Movie when the editor put sounds or effects in the scene to make it looks like realistic .
and your video shared is not Live game means that can be easily edit and gives viewers/watchers a good experience even that the game was HELD ON A ZERO FANS global .

Exactly. They can do that easily with the help from many officers in that match.
During this pandemic which makes people need to stay at home, the competitions need to attract their fans back in the fields, and they will do many things to make sure the audience and the fans can enjoy the match.
I think it will be no problem for the audience if the sound is fake because what they want is to watch their favorite team compete with the other team.
They can watch the match from home with their family or friends, so that will almost be the same although they are not watching in the stadium.

That is funny if someone asks something about that about the videos. Those crowd noises are surely an edited video, maybe they just add those voices so the game would look like an intense game and for entertainment as well. An original video would look so boring if they don't even add some extra effects and edits to it. It's just fun reading a thread like this lol.

Just imagine a game without any noise, that would be a boring game and will look like a not intense battle. This pandemic gives big changes to the game settings, so they need to do some effort on making the sports alive to satisfy the fans.

Management will really be making out those kind of changes which does simply shows that they are really adapting into the current situation we are in.

This doesn't only solve out players problems about crowd noise but also into the viewers itself because it is really on different vibe when you don't hear out some crowd noise
on just watching.

With having this then its really a good addition to compensate the user experience that had been a while is on absence.

yes, exactly! players just doing their job without any noise from the background. thats really boring! they need to spice up the game, otherwise, viewers will not see this as interesting to watch. that strategy is like an old news though.
anyway, it seems that we are slowly seeing live audience again very soon. though contained, at least have some people inside the arena. it will take time before we will see the same enthusiasm from the crowd. but we will get there...

It wouldnt be surprising that they have used artificial sound. Due to Covid 19 situation and strict rules that prevents to attend in some sports area with crowded people, they pre recorded audience noise and play it while the game is happening. This isn't something new. Rather, it just added some spice and presentation to the sports as well. An impact is there if we hear some cheering sounds.

We all know that there’s no live audience or very limited to none at all, so in order for the league to become more fun, for sure they’ve decided to put an artificial sounds where people can think that there’s actually an audience. Those league are trying their best to make this season through, its not fake its just happen that this is the best they can do under this circumstances, not a big deal at all.

This explains all.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jaO7sxNg2BI
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aUrHaGvU1Mk

Good solution if players and audience are bored on having no-crowd noise games.

No, I watched it Live either, sounds the same as a youtube video.

we have to watch another game next week, maybe specific games of Everton or Burnley. I just curious maybe they pay to attract large audiences on tv shows, we all know both teams standing on the middle board where not much audience to watch without that sound.

Yes, it is. I am sure the officials will think about how they can serve entertainment to their audience, and they will do anything to get good ratings. Perhaps, they can use the other recorded match and edit to have sounds, the people in the field or stadium, and give another experience to the audience. People in their home will try to watch the match together, which can feel like at the stadium for them.

I remember Myself like this Last year , when the sports finally allowed to conduct games again but no allowed Fans to enter the premises.

I keep asking myself about the crowd shouting and cheering.

Until an hour that i realized it was edited as not Live game is what i'm watching  ;D

It would suck watching a sport event without even a sound of a cheer even if it is artificial. This had been the new normal sonce the pandemic started, it is difficult to conduct social distancing especially if it's a major sport even. That is why they have virtual audience and most are recorded or broadcasted live.

That will be different to hear the crowd noise from home than in the stadium, but we as an audience can not do anything except trying to enjoy the match.
Maybe that is the solution that we can get right now in this pandemic, but I am sure that when the pandemic is ended, we can go back to the stadium to feel the real experience as before.
We do not have to complain if the noise comes from the recorded of the previous match because I think the staff involved in that match is creative and want to give the best thing to their audience or fans.

For players they will might feel that they are in practice if there's no sound came out whenever they score or whatever activity they do on the court and it's really suck to watch the game without sound since I feel sleepy watching it on the long run that's why it's good thing to have a virtual cheer up and good addition that they have recorded sound since even if there's less audience in the court the player can still feel the intensity of the game by hearing the noise.

i been there in a footbal practice and we are allowed to watch .
 practice game are like a real tournament game because of the large audience and cheer ups but that can be a memory of the past because that happened before pandemic but now practice or not the number of audience wont change and they are less .
 watching the game in t.v is the same that you muted your t.v using your remote control and theres no need to wonder why you become dizzy watching the game .

No offense but this topic hasn't to do with gambling.

The sounds behind those matches can easily be searched on our preferred search engine bar. It's a pre-recorded video.

When some sports commence after months of being temporarily suspended, there are lots of topics about using those fake sounds to somehow give those players the same environment prior to the pandemic. Don't know though if it's effective but that was several months ago. Today, players are now fully used to playing in the new normal sports environment so they don't bother if they are cheered with artificial sounds.

You're right about that word, the sound engineering.

They're the ones who's assigned in the music or any sound effects that will be added to a show, a gig or event like this. The addition of it for them to make the rendition and show appealing to the viewers.

That's why they are very important part of it, they're like the silent workers that we don't usually appreciate as we watch events.

Why not, the organizers will try to make an impact of the game from both players and audiences as realistic as possible, that is why want to create an environment, this is why we hear those sounds and see the bench with images of people, this will motivate players and audiences, they don't want to have an impression that they are doing practice or an exhibition game, they want to capture the old spirit of the game, that is why they employ this.

However, it is no problem asking that question, mate. It is normal if someone is curious about the crowd sounds of supporters while the regulation didn't allow the supporters to go Stadium. Regarding it is a fake or artificial supporter sounds, maybe @blue Snow really doesn't know about it yet. Most people only know the artificial supporter sounds on PES (football game), it's a game. But for real matches, he may never imagine if it is using fake/artificial supporter sounds as well. So, don't be so surprised!  ;)

Hi,
Undoubtedly, it is something strange, in fact, some of the past events, some celebrities were seen on those virtual screens that they place on the stages.

Now the environment (sounds) is something very old really, on TV when broadcasts lose audio they using recorded broadcasts so as not to leave the transmission without background audio, and in current radio radio stations are used a lot for a matter of copyrights, They use mock environments to create the atmosphere of the match being broadcast.

On the other hand, I have a relative who narrates commercial football on the radio and it is really very good, when he does it the audio comes from the radio and the visual from TV, it is very crazy but it's worth it ... crazy times have always been , more and more crazy people are being added.

G.B.

If that's a video upload from youtube, they could manipulate the sounds or background. Maybe it's good to watch the live game instead of replayed game played over online, because there could be editing softwares that can do that now.
Even with online live streaming they're using more effects to make the live game more exciting for the viewers.
Much better to watch lively on the physical game.

Part of the new normal when Premier League returns. A subject that has been discussed before by their fans during its early phase.

Only viewers can hear it to enhance their viewing experience. Although some fans don't like the idea. :P

Why is crowd noise used in Premier League matches? (https://www.goal.com/en-us/news/premier-league-crowd-noise-why-how-to-turn-it-on-off-can-players-/1fn9xscokj38t10ssltv3ve7tg)
Football's canned atmosphere: how crowd noise is added to empty Premier League grounds (https://www.techradar.com/news/footballs-canned-atmosphere-how-crowd-noise-is-added-to-empty-premier-league-grounds)
Premier League Returns With Fake Crowd Noise And Fans Aren't Sure About It (https://www.sportbible.com/football/football-news-reactions-premier-league-returns-with-fake-crowd-noise-20200617)

Anyways, in NBA (basketball), fake audience sounds are heard by the players and some don't like it. Some of them like to hear instead of the real cheer from the few audiences inside (which are now allowed at some teams) compare to those over 10,000 fans cheering loudly in virtual.

Pretty sure I like the crowd-noise when watching Live match, I don't touch the button off. If player noise only, I feel like watching the training games. I will be feeling sad if lost the bet either, If you felt the same as me, you will also don't felt anything when you lose the match, you will enjoy it.

Some bettor enjoys watching the games while betting.

I have watched few games without the background noise of the crowd, it is very weird as you are accustomed to those loud noises. You will hear few voices, those are the players talking to each other and of course the commentary. You will lose interest at some point if the game is not engaging. Whereas those artificial crowd noises sometimes do irritate if not done properly by the broadcaster. This is the new normal in this pandemic situation you cannot do anything until things go back to what it used to be before the pandemic.

Very annoying if the people behind those sounds are not good enough to bring the sounds in the  right timing, there are  players
who doesn't like this kind of setup as they know that everything is just artficial.

Some find this sound as intereferance, while to some, it's fair enough than nothing. People have different approach with this new normal
scenes from each sporting events.

You can add pre-recorded audios on your videos or sometimes if you are pro you can record you own audio with different pitch and then add it with Ctrl+D on different timestamps  with Time shift tool on your videos which will duplicate the sound effects and sound like crowd cheering.There are some tools available for adding different noises and echoes to videos and its handy to use them.Its not a big deal at all.But if you are recording manually you need to keep in mind sound track matching to the video being played which means time to which sounds have been cloned.

The background sounds were used during IPL (cricket) last year and to be frank it was really irritating as they play that on a loop even if nothing interesting is going on, i have not seen the match but in Football there is no delay in action and i do not think it will be that irritating if they are not panning the empty stadium while they play the background sound.

We can't deny that the game with no sound is so boring thats why eventhough I heard virtual sound still I lsike to hear them since it brings intensity when a player do a crucial shots and slam dunks. I also trier that turning off the sounds but I never last long since I fall asleep a couple of watching so virtual sounds is so important since it can boost moral to the players as well to the fans. Lets hope that all of this incident happening in the world will end so that we can really feel the real action inside the court.

The crowd noise may be considered as old but let's be honest that the crowd cheer was more pleasant to ear than listening to the recorded cheering where you do know and see that the studio or stadium have no audience, yeah the crowd noise that we have heard on a TV, or in a live game competition was all recorded. I do miss those old times where the life of people doesn't limited to certain period, where no one controls and no threat on health.

People who always come to the stadium to watch a live match will miss that noise and the euphoria of the games. But now, they can not do that because of this pandemic. But they can watch the live match from their home, and I think they will not bother with the recorded noise as they want to watch their favourite sports. If they can not go to the stadium, they do not feel sad because that moment will come again to them. The bettor itself can still place their bets in their favourite sports and team or the player.

We are all wishing for the situation to go back into the normal state because we arent really supposed to live on having this kind of restriction of things due to health protocols.
We dont have any options though but to obey those commands because this is for our sake.As long the cure isnt really available yet then we would really be living to be like this.
I do miss badly the crowd noise because it is just really giving out different essence when you do hear out real-time cheers and boos inside a stadium or venue when
seeing games like this.For now this is something patching up temporarily which it isnt really a bad idea at all.

To manage the ongoing situation and give a complete match experience sound is being added to the background. People need to be more responsible, only then it is possible to overcome. Last March the spread started to progress vigorously, later due to awareness and the usage of social distancing, usage of mask and hand sanitizer drastically made a reduction in the spread. Now once again the spread is increasing even after the vaccine is available. So, it is the mistake of people. We need to change first, automatically the rest will happen good.

Of course, we expect this pandemic can be over soon. It is not only about seeing a football match live in the stadium but we also need to be free to do all activities as before. The pandemic even makes many football players must be rest for a long time because of affected by Covid-19 and many football clubs may be in a financial crisis because they have a limited way to gain money right now.

Having a few live audiences are now being practiced at some game matches. Not that much but at least there's progress and good development.

Covid-19 will be a forever disease by now. It will be like the common flu so our body, with the help of a healthy lifestyle and a vaccine in an emergency, will be used on handling this virus soon.

Back to the pre-recorded audience sound, depends on what sports it is, it's for viewers' purposes only. Sometimes, those are not played in a live match wherein players should hear it.

What the OP might've thought is a cursed video or something of the sorts can be easily answered by editing. The live footage is empty and plain, so the editors opted to add in sound effects like cheers and claps to add a little more life to the otherwise sad match. Though if you come to think of it, the people used to create this sound effect are now probably dead so it's a bit morbid if you'd come to think of it.

That might really the case and its not really something new because even in other shows or events they do some sort of editing to make it more entertaining. Plus with the current situation we are in, its quite understandable. Well its not a big deal for me because what matter is the event itself, the fake crowd doesnt bother me to watch the game.

What the audience wants is a show that can entertain them while they are still at home. If the event can give something different, I think the audience can accept it and the importance they can enjoy the show although that is fake. It is not wrong to give the fake sound that pretends it's coming from the stadium to give an effect to the audience so that they can feel real.

This is not a big deal to the real supporters of a specific league, we all want them to see on court again and entertain us if you think using fake sounds is not good, then you'd better to stop watching that's the best you can do for sure. Many sports are playing on a bubble system, we have to understand their situation as well and continue to support them. I'll keep watching my favorite sports and seriously, I miss them and I want to see them in the court playing live soon.

It's just a recorded voice or cheers from the audience mate.. wherein the time that gathering still okay especially in such events.. Btw in my opinion its good to have that kind of sound effects on this kind of circumstances because it will become a boring game.. Just imagine what will be your reaction while watching through television without cheering and noise from the crowd during the game?  :D

That's right, I've read about a suggestion ^{"before the league run again after break COVID"} to give a fan shouting voice for football matches. In addition to eliminating bored in watching football, for players it may also have its own emotional effect when playing. Especially for those who miss the chants of their supporters that they have never heard starting from march 2020.

Thanks for all posts, I had found the answer to my curious sounds.

because of a pandemic, the audience is forbidden to come to the stadium where makes it boring to watching live on tv. In my opinion, Football without audience sounds is not exciting even if you won in a bet.

I should lock this thread.