Bitcoin Forum

Other => Politics & Society => Topic started by: Bit_Happy on April 12, 2014, 05:10:24 PM



Title: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: Bit_Happy on April 12, 2014, 05:10:24 PM
Who could ever forget Tank Man, that unknown man who stood in front of all those tanks at Tiananmen Square? As epic as that act of defiance was, there are other classic examples that are spun from the same material as Tank Man’s story. The amazing acts of defiance listed below are veritable legends and, as such, deserve their own rightful place in history.

The Man Who Refused To Do The Nazi Salute
http://i0.wp.com/listverse.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/2-nazi-salute.jpg?resize=632%2C408

The Woman Who Brushed Off A Bayonet
http://i0.wp.com/listverse.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/6-gloria2.jpg?resize=632%2C420

more: http://listverse.com/2014/04/02/10-amazing-acts-of-defiance-throughout-history

How are things in your town these days?


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: WEB slicer on April 12, 2014, 08:34:31 PM
https://i.imgur.com/VM2gF1t.jpg
tank man blocking tanks after china declared martial law and killed civilians.

https://i.imgur.com/0cgqBQ0.jpg
burning monk burned himself to death to protest persecution of buddhist monks, he did not move or make a sound.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: Nemo1024 on April 12, 2014, 08:50:36 PM
http://www.maddebagimlisi.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/04/bernie-flowerpower-manset-400x254.jpg
http://visualcultureblog.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/jan-rose-kasmir_marc-riboud-e1370259963284.jpg
Hippies. Choose, America. War and self-destruction, or peace and prosperity. The message of this iconic images needs to be repeated these days.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: Bit_Happy on April 13, 2014, 01:40:44 AM
http://www.maddebagimlisi.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/04/bernie-flowerpower-manset-400x254.jpg
http://visualcultureblog.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/jan-rose-kasmir_marc-riboud-e1370259963284.jpg
Hippies. Choose, America. War and self-destruction, or peace and prosperity. The message of this iconic images needs to be repeated these days.

Peace :)


https://i.imgur.com/VM2gF1t.jpg
tank man blocking tanks after china declared martial law and killed civilians.
...

Is this the same person who was run over?
RIP...


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: WEB slicer on April 13, 2014, 01:46:57 AM
he was not run over. he jumped on the tank pounded on the hatchet had words with the crew and got back in front of the tank. two people from the crowd grabbed him and pulled him in to the crowd. he was never seen or heard from again. people think the government killed him or threw him in jail for life.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: bryant.coleman on April 13, 2014, 03:05:55 AM
Is this the same person who was run over?

He is better known as the Tank Man.

He was a 19-year old student. More details can be found here:

http://articles.latimes.com/1990-06-03/news/mn-819_1_man-tank-pictures


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: LostDutchman on April 14, 2014, 01:47:31 AM
Who could ever forget Tank Man, that unknown man who stood in front of all those tanks at Tiananmen Square? As epic as that act of defiance was, there are other classic examples that are spun from the same material as Tank Man’s story. The amazing acts of defiance listed below are veritable legends and, as such, deserve their own rightful place in history.

The Man Who Refused To Do The Nazi Salute
http://i0.wp.com/listverse.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/2-nazi-salute.jpg?resize=632%2C408

The Woman Who Brushed Off A Bayonet
http://i0.wp.com/listverse.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/6-gloria2.jpg?resize=632%2C420

more: http://listverse.com/2014/04/02/10-amazing-acts-of-defiance-throughout-history

How are things in your town these days?

In my town things went to shit today as some Neo-Nazi shot up a couple of Jewish places and killed some people:

http://www.kctv5.com/story/25235053/shooting-reported-at-overland-park-jewish-community-center

A very bad deal.

My $.02.

:(


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: Bit_Happy on April 14, 2014, 01:51:10 AM
....

In my town things went to shit today as some Neo-Nazi shot up a couple of Jewish places and killed some people:

http://www.kctv5.com/story/25235053/shooting-reported-at-overland-park-jewish-community-center

A very bad deal.

My $.02.

:(

I heard on the radio.
Very sorry you were so close to that.
Someday, the world will hopefully be safer and more peaceful.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: Vod on April 14, 2014, 01:51:53 AM
Someday, the world will hopefully be safer and more peaceful.

I don't think that is in humanity's future.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: LostDutchman on April 14, 2014, 01:54:27 AM
....

In my town things went to shit today as some Neo-Nazi shot up a couple of Jewish places and killed some people:

http://www.kctv5.com/story/25235053/shooting-reported-at-overland-park-jewish-community-center

A very bad deal.

My $.02.

:(

I heard on the radio.
Very sorry you were so close to that.
Someday, the world will hopefully be safer and more peaceful.

Yeah, thanks, I am about 20 miles from the sites of the violence so no danger to me but the whole thing stinks.

My $.02.

;)


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: LostDutchman on April 14, 2014, 01:55:01 AM
Someday, the world will hopefully be safer and more peaceful.

I don't think that is in humanity's future.

I heard that!

My $.02.

;)


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: Bit_Happy on April 14, 2014, 01:55:10 AM
Someday, the world will hopefully be safer and more peaceful.

I don't think that is in humanity's future.

History sucks, perhaps there is little hope.
No need to tell the children.  :D


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: WEB slicer on April 14, 2014, 02:19:07 AM
I don't think that is in humanity's future.
agreed


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: Nemo1024 on April 16, 2014, 11:14:18 AM
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BlVYjrhCIAErogz.jpg
The whole of South-Eastern Ukraine is now a big act of defiance, with hundreds, if not thousands of "Tank Men" stopping tank columns with only their bodies as a weapon.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: bryant.coleman on April 16, 2014, 03:22:34 PM
This, from Ukraine. 3 elderly women trying to stop army tanks:

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BlWjbs1CYAEpNcR.jpg


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: counter on April 16, 2014, 11:09:46 PM
All these stories are amasing but the one photo and story of the monk on fire is one I'm not very familiar with and it really got my attention.  Thanks for sharing these stories with some of us who may not have been aware of them.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: Nemo1024 on May 14, 2014, 07:34:10 AM
I am compelled to add this here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A05s6GrztbQ

Kherson Governor Yury Odarchenko during a speech on the 9th of May, stated that Hitler tried to liberate Ukraine by invading it. One brave soul from the public comes forward and deprives him of the microphone.

This resonates with the first picture of the thread.


And another:

Ever heard about the Tank man from China?

http://chinadigitaltimes.net/wp-content/uploads/2009/06/89-63_tank_man_-_web.jpg

Well.... here is an image from Mariupol, of a civilian trying to stop a Right Sector-controlled tank. No idea what happened to him afterwards.

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BnMyZuTIMAANb5M.jpg


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: RodeoX on May 14, 2014, 03:28:32 PM
As a side note about "tank man". That image is almost completely unknown in China. That is how clamped down the government is there.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: Trading on May 25, 2014, 03:21:42 AM
Some of those cases, like the tank man and the monk, are indeed remarkable, but others are less "amazing". Big part of its fame are derived from the fact that someone took a picture.
There are historical cases much more dramatic. Think about Giordano Bruno. He was burnt alive for refusing to repent for saying that there were other worlds spinning around stars that were suns like ours in 1600. The major accusations were about theological issues, but he repented about those; but not on this one.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: bryant.coleman on May 25, 2014, 04:43:39 AM
Here is another. Meriam Yahya Ibrahim Ishag sentenced to death by stoning, for refusing to convert to Islam. Her husband is an American citizen, but there has been no help from the United States authorities so far.

http://i1.ytimg.com/vi/k03WzDGjRyA/0.jpg


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: Bit_Happy on May 25, 2014, 06:08:42 AM
Here is another. Meriam Yahya Ibrahim Ishag sentenced to death by stoning, for refusing to convert to Islam. Her husband is an American citizen, but there has been no help from the United States authorities so far.

http://i1.ytimg.com/vi/k03WzDGjRyA/0.jpg

I was curious what country:
"A Sudanese court has sentenced Mariam Yahya Ibrahim Ishag, 27..."
Sudan? Wow, I will be certain to stay away from there.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: bryant.coleman on May 25, 2014, 06:28:55 AM
I was curious what country:
"A Sudanese court has sentenced Mariam Yahya Ibrahim Ishag, 27..."
Sudan? Wow, I will be certain to stay away from there.

Sudan is the shit-hole of the world. The country is currently in the middle of the third civil war, after the first and second claimed millions of civilian lives.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Sudanese_Civil_War
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Sudanese_Civil_War
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sudan_internal_conflict_(2011%E2%80%93present)

And don't forget the Darfur conflict.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_in_Darfur


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: LostDutchman on May 25, 2014, 09:10:58 AM
Here is another. Meriam Yahya Ibrahim Ishag sentenced to death by stoning, for refusing to convert to Islam. Her husband is an American citizen, but there has been no help from the United States authorities so far.

http://i1.ytimg.com/vi/k03WzDGjRyA/0.jpg

OK, I agree that this is a bad situation but just what is it that you think the USA should do?


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: bryant.coleman on May 25, 2014, 11:45:53 AM
OK, I agree that this is a bad situation but just what is it that you think the USA should do?

For the start, Obama could open up his mouth and condemn the death sentence imposed on the unfortunate woman. We can think about sanctions and embargoes later, if the Sudanese ignore the warnings.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: RodeoX on May 27, 2014, 08:25:22 PM
OK, I agree that this is a bad situation but just what is it that you think the USA should do?

For the start, Obama could open up his mouth and condemn the death sentence imposed on the unfortunate woman. We can think about sanctions and embargoes later, if the Sudanese ignore the warnings.
I don't know what we can do about this. It is not our country or our laws. It makes me sick, but we in the west only recently stopped killing people for religious beliefs. Besides, who are we to talk about what God wants? Maybe this is what God wants, maybe God hates all Christians?


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: LostDutchman on May 28, 2014, 02:41:13 AM
Here is another. Meriam Yahya Ibrahim Ishag sentenced to death by stoning, for refusing to convert to Islam. Her husband is an American citizen, but there has been no help from the United States authorities so far.

http://i1.ytimg.com/vi/k03WzDGjRyA/0.jpg

I was curious what country:
"A Sudanese court has sentenced Mariam Yahya Ibrahim Ishag, 27..."
Sudan? Wow, I will be certain to stay away from there.

I mean, like, who would want to go there anyway?


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: zolace on May 28, 2014, 03:48:48 AM
OK, I agree that this is a bad situation but just what is it that you think the USA should do?

For the start, Obama could open up his mouth and condemn the death sentence imposed on the unfortunate woman. We can think about sanctions and embargoes later, if the Sudanese ignore the warnings.
I kinda agree on this, Im sure there is so much Obama can handle the problem is the whole government not one person is fighting for this mans right, nor any other country.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: Bit_Happy on May 28, 2014, 04:13:10 AM
Here is another. Meriam Yahya Ibrahim Ishag sentenced to death by stoning, for refusing to convert to Islam. Her husband is an American citizen, but there has been no help from the United States authorities so far.

....

I was curious what country:
"A Sudanese court has sentenced Mariam Yahya Ibrahim Ishag, 27..."
Sudan? Wow, I will be certain to stay away from there.

I mean, like, who would want to go there anyway?

People urgently needing to leave Egypt or Chad would have a motivation to try Sudan.
Is it a place you would like?
Variety is the spice of life, but too much spice can cause digestive issues.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: LostDutchman on May 28, 2014, 04:33:05 AM
Here is another. Meriam Yahya Ibrahim Ishag sentenced to death by stoning, for refusing to convert to Islam. Her husband is an American citizen, but there has been no help from the United States authorities so far.

....

I was curious what country:
"A Sudanese court has sentenced Mariam Yahya Ibrahim Ishag, 27..."
Sudan? Wow, I will be certain to stay away from there.

I mean, like, who would want to go there anyway?

People urgently needing to leave Egypt or Chad would have a motivation to try Sudan.
Is it a place you would like?
Variety is the spice of life, but too much spice can cause digestive issues.

No shit!

Thank you for your insightful post!


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: bryant.coleman on May 28, 2014, 12:34:13 PM
People urgently needing to leave Egypt or Chad would have a motivation to try Sudan.
Is it a place you would like?
Variety is the spice of life, but too much spice can cause digestive issues.

Makes sense. But in this case Mariam Yahia Ibrahim Ishag was a Sudanese citizen, although she is of partial-Ethiopian origin. Her mother was also a Sudanese citizen, a descendant of immigrants from Ethiopia.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: KonstantinosM on May 28, 2014, 02:46:14 PM
The Greek States VS the Persian Empire in thermopylae

20,000 men against 300,000.... And they won.

The Greeks lost 4k men the Persians lost 20k.

2nd failed invasion in a row by Persia.


What makes this an act of defiance is that Leonidas started marching with only 300 hoplites and then others joined him to form the army of 14-20k that defeated the Persians.


If no one had joined him he would have picked a battle nearly 1 vs 1000

That would only make sense if he had invented the AK-47 2200 years in advance and each solider had 34 magazines of ammo and were really, really, really good shots.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: Trading on May 28, 2014, 05:17:56 PM
The Greeks were only about 7000, maybe 7700, from several cities, so the act of defiance was even greater. But they didn't win, many of them were massacred after 3 days of heroic struggle, fighting to the last men (not only the 300 Spartans).

Things didn't end there. Xerxes and the Persian army managed to burn Athens and only after the naval battle of Salamis were defeated. Well, actually, after that, Athens was again conquered by the Persians under Mardonius. Only with the battle of Plataea (479 BC) they were expelled from Greece.

Yes, I like military and political history.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: cbeast on May 28, 2014, 05:24:12 PM
Life is short. Do what you can. Hope for the best.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: bryant.coleman on May 28, 2014, 07:03:00 PM
Things didn't end there. Xerxes and the Persian army managed to burn Athens and only after the naval battle of Salamis were defeated. Well, actually, after that, Athens was again conquered by the Persians under Mardonius. Only with the battle of Plataea (479 BC) they were expelled from Greece.

The Battle of Plataea is considered as the final major battle during the Persian invasion of Greece. It forms a part of the Persian invasion. So we can say that the Greeks actually defeated the Persians and repelled the invasion. Battle of Plataea was very devastating for the Persians... they lost more than 250,000 men.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: Bit_Happy on May 28, 2014, 07:07:56 PM
Things didn't end there. Xerxes and the Persian army managed to burn Athens and only after the naval battle of Salamis were defeated. Well, actually, after that, Athens was again conquered by the Persians under Mardonius. Only with the battle of Plataea (479 BC) they were expelled from Greece.

The Battle of Plataea is considered as the final major battle during the Persian invasion of Greece. It forms a part of the Persian invasion. So we can say that the Greeks actually defeated the Persians and repelled the invasion. Battle of Plataea was very devastating for the Persians... they lost more than 250,000 men.

That is exciting but horrific. Will mankind ever learn how to avoid brutal wars?


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: LostDutchman on May 28, 2014, 07:16:42 PM
Things didn't end there. Xerxes and the Persian army managed to burn Athens and only after the naval battle of Salamis were defeated. Well, actually, after that, Athens was again conquered by the Persians under Mardonius. Only with the battle of Plataea (479 BC) they were expelled from Greece.

The Battle of Plataea is considered as the final major battle during the Persian invasion of Greece. It forms a part of the Persian invasion. So we can say that the Greeks actually defeated the Persians and repelled the invasion. Battle of Plataea was very devastating for the Persians... they lost more than 250,000 men.

That is exciting but horrific. Will mankind ever learn how to avoid brutal wars?

I doubt it.

Humankind is an agressive, territorial and highly combative species.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: bryant.coleman on May 28, 2014, 07:20:12 PM
That is exciting but horrific. Will mankind ever learn how to avoid brutal wars?

Well.. the Persians invaded the Greeks and the Greeks fought back to expel the invaders. How can we blame the Greeks for defending their homeland? As long as there are loonies who want to invade the weaker nations, we will witness similar wars.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: Trading on May 28, 2014, 07:28:59 PM
The problem is that the Greeks didn't stop there and, commanded by the Macedonians (I'm not going to enter the fight on the issue of the autonomy of ancient Macedonia from Greece), did to the Persian what they did to them: in 334, invaded them, burnt their capital and conquered their Empire.



Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: Bit_Happy on May 28, 2014, 07:30:33 PM
That is exciting but horrific. Will mankind ever learn how to avoid brutal wars?

Well.. the Persians invaded the Greeks and the Greeks fought back to expel the invaders. How can we blame the Greeks for defending their homeland? As long as there are loonies who want to invade the weaker nations, we will witness similar wars.

History is amazing but also very dark since it often tells us what to expect in the future.



That is exciting but horrific. Will mankind ever learn how to avoid brutal wars?

I doubt it.

Humankind is an agressive, territorial and highly combative species.

Well, if enough people learn to change & teach their children, then there might be some hope.
We need HOPE and CHANGE.....Oops.......Those once useful words are now tainted.
Bitcoin: = Change you can actually believe in.

Hey, maybe someday BTC will be viewed as a "great act of defiance"....?
On the brink of economic collapse, we have taken a stand against the evil paper money system.





Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: acs267 on May 28, 2014, 07:38:47 PM
As a side note about "tank man". That image is almost completely unknown in China. That is how clamped down the government is there.

Think about it as 'changing history'. Forty-five years from now, It'll be completely unknown. And it's basically that, right now, with China's censorship. They're not exactly clamped down, they're 'controlling' their people.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: cbeast on May 28, 2014, 10:52:35 PM
Most of 'murikan history is whitewashed. Fifty years from now some kids will buy a book that mentions "Bit-Coin was a poorly managed economics experiment filled with observational bias."


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: kuroman on May 28, 2014, 11:24:03 PM
Here is another. Meriam Yahya Ibrahim Ishag sentenced to death by stoning, for refusing to convert to Islam. Her husband is an American citizen, but there has been no help from the United States authorities so far.

http://i1.ytimg.com/vi/k03WzDGjRyA/0.jpg

I don't know all the circumstances about this, but in Shariaa (7th century Islamic law) Stoning is the capital punishment for cheating under marriage and it goes for both the man and woman that were found guilty ( I think to validate this there is need for 4 witness minimum that saw them during the sexual act if the couple (penetration)) also If I remember correctly from what I read even in the Shariaa forcing people to Islam is not allowed. So to resume if these the woman is found guilty and being judged for the supposed crime you are mentioning these guys are criminals even according to their laws and she needs to be released immediately, but I sadly the amount of lies we get to see from our western media makes warry even if sometimes they are telling the truth, I really can't help but feel that something wasn't mentioned here 


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: Trading on May 29, 2014, 01:06:20 AM
The Jews have a history of resistance against the Romans with pretty defiant situations.

Think about Masada (73 CE). Josephus wrote a vivid description, saying that, after a stubborn resistance, the defenders, about 1000, decided to kill them selves in order to avoid being captured alive.
Archaeological findings didn't confirm this numbers, but found structures used by the Romans to breach the walls.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: LostDutchman on May 29, 2014, 02:15:29 AM
The Jews have a history of resistance against the Romans with pretty defiant situations.

Think about Masada (73 CE). Josephus wrote a vivid description, saying that, after a stubborn resistance, the defenders, about 1000, decided to kill them selves in order to avoid being captured alive.
Archaeological findings didn't confirm this numbers, but found structures used by the Romans to breach the walls.


Much of the whole suicide theory has been debunked.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: DVFree on May 29, 2014, 02:31:41 AM
Things didn't end there. Xerxes and the Persian army managed to burn Athens and only after the naval battle of Salamis were defeated. Well, actually, after that, Athens was again conquered by the Persians under Mardonius. Only with the battle of Plataea (479 BC) they were expelled from Greece.

The Battle of Plataea is considered as the final major battle during the Persian invasion of Greece. It forms a part of the Persian invasion. So we can say that the Greeks actually defeated the Persians and repelled the invasion. Battle of Plataea was very devastating for the Persians... they lost more than 250,000 men.

That is exciting but horrific. Will mankind ever learn how to avoid brutal wars?

I doubt it.

Humankind is an agressive, territorial and highly combative species.

I can see why you'd say that, however this has proven not to be so. Have a look at the Trap by Adam Curtis, it will very well explain how disturbed notions amplified Hobbes's philosophy in order to create that missconception.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: Trading on May 29, 2014, 02:42:37 AM
The Jews have a history of resistance against the Romans with pretty defiant situations.

Think about Masada (73 CE). Josephus wrote a vivid description, saying that, after a stubborn resistance, the defenders, about 1000, decided to kill them selves in order to avoid being captured alive.
Archaeological findings didn't confirm this numbers, but found structures used by the Romans to breach the walls.


Much of the whole suicide theory has been debunked.

Josephus was part, and therefore was a direct witness, of a suicidal pact after the fall of Jotapata (Yodfat) (67 CE), where several defenders killed each other. Josephus was the last one, breached the pact, and surrender to the Romans, as he confessed on his book The Wars of the Jews. So, these kind of pacts were common. Maybe the numbers involved were false, but the all history?


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: LostDutchman on May 29, 2014, 02:43:57 AM
The Jews have a history of resistance against the Romans with pretty defiant situations.

Think about Masada (73 CE). Josephus wrote a vivid description, saying that, after a stubborn resistance, the defenders, about 1000, decided to kill them selves in order to avoid being captured alive.
Archaeological findings didn't confirm this numbers, but found structures used by the Romans to breach the walls.


Much of the whole suicide theory has been debunked.

Josephus was part, and therefore was a direct witness, of a suicidal pact after the fall of Jotapata (Yodfat) (67 CE), where several defenders killed each other. Josephus was the last one, breached the pact, and surrender to the Romans, as he confessed on his book The Wars of the Jews. So, these kind of pacts were common. Maybe the numbers envolved were false, but the all history?

Most of it.

Do your homework.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: Trading on May 29, 2014, 02:46:07 AM
I did. And I quoted my source. The burden of proof is in your side.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: wachtwoord on May 29, 2014, 02:58:49 AM
That is exciting but horrific. Will mankind ever learn how to avoid brutal wars?

Well.. the Persians invaded the Greeks and the Greeks fought back to expel the invaders. How can we blame the Greeks for defending their homeland? As long as there are loonies who want to invade the weaker nations, we will witness similar wars.

As long as we have nations ....


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: LostDutchman on May 29, 2014, 03:16:59 AM
I did. And I quoted my source. The burden of proof is in your side.

http://www.bibliotecapleyades.net/biblianazar/esp_biblianazar_56.htm

http://www.haaretz.com/archaeology/.premium-1.563888

http://wanderinghebrew.com/2010/07/18/israels-masada-scholars-untease-the-myth-from-the-history/

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/religion/portrait/masada.html

Get back to me.

I can get more bu you need to do some work on your own.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: Trading on May 29, 2014, 05:38:07 AM
Thanks for the links.
But I told you, I done my work reading on Masada, including the doubts on Josephus.
I was expecting some new facts, but your links basically give speculation. And none of them negates the mass suicide. We basically don't know what happened.

Yes, the story was changed for political reasons. Some crazy assassins, mostly of fellow Jews, were converted on heroes. But they also resisted the Romans, we don't know how much, and many refused to be taken alive.

It's well known that the archaeologists only found 28 skeletons. But since it's clear that 28 persons, including women and children, couldn't resist the Romans, many bodies are missing. The remains don't refute Josephus, even if some parts of his story, including the speeches, are controversial. But since he was writing on the time of the facts, when many Romans that were there were alive, he couldn't lie much.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: zolace on May 29, 2014, 07:38:04 AM
The Salt march and getting beating by soldiers with Ghandi that was also defiant in my book.  There is movie on it by the way.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: bryant.coleman on May 29, 2014, 09:23:26 AM
The Salt march and getting beating by soldiers with Ghandi that was also defiant in my book.  There is movie on it by the way.

There is a lot of criticism about Ghandi in India. No one should forget the fact that his so called non-cooperation and non-violence campaign only succeed due to the parallel violent uprising led by people such as Subhash Chandra Bose.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: murraypaul on May 29, 2014, 09:38:28 AM
But since he was writing on the time of the facts, when many Romans that were there were alive, he couldn't lie much.

If you stop and think about that, it is obviously wrong.
Both sides in a war lie to make their own part look better.
Look at what is happening in the Ukraine now. The Ukranian version and the Russian version can't both be right, can they? So at least one side is lying, and that is with all the modern communication methods we have available now.
Then, Josephus could have said anything he wanted to his own people, chances are the Romans would never have heard about it, and if they had contradicted him, he would have just said that they were lying.

Quote
I was expecting some new facts, but your links basically give speculation. And none of them negates the mass suicide. We basically don't know what happened.

Yes, the story was changed for political reasons. Some crazy assassins, mostly of fellow Jews, were converted on heroes. But they also resisted the Romans, we don't know how much, and many refused to be taken alive.

It's well known that the archaeologists only found 28 skeletons. But since it's clear that 28 persons, including women and children, couldn't resist the Romans, many bodies are missing.

If only 28 bodies were found, a reasonably conclusion is that either there weren't any more than that to start with, or that there were, but most of them got away.
You are starting from an assumption that there were a thousand people resisting in the first place. That isn't a known fact.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: LostDutchman on May 29, 2014, 09:48:08 AM
But since he was writing on the time of the facts, when many Romans that were there were alive, he couldn't lie much.

If you stop and think about that, it is obviously wrong.
Both sides in a war lie to make their own part look better.
Look at what is happening in the Ukraine now. The Ukranian version and the Russian version can't both be right, can they? So at least one side is lying, and that is with all the modern communication methods we have available now.
Then, Josephus could have said anything he wanted to his own people, chances are the Romans would never have heard about it, and if they had contradicted him, he would have just said that they were lying.

Quote
I was expecting some new facts, but your links basically give speculation. And none of them negates the mass suicide. We basically don't know what happened.

Yes, the story was changed for political reasons. Some crazy assassins, mostly of fellow Jews, were converted on heroes. But they also resisted the Romans, we don't know how much, and many refused to be taken alive.

It's well known that the archaeologists only found 28 skeletons. But since it's clear that 28 persons, including women and children, couldn't resist the Romans, many bodies are missing.

If only 28 bodies were found, a reasonably conclusion is that either there weren't any more than that to start with, or that there were, but most of them got away.
You are starting from an assumption that there were a thousand people resisting in the first place. That isn't a known fact.

Now don't try to confuse things by brining in FACTS!

;)


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: umair127 on May 29, 2014, 01:38:12 PM
https://i.imgur.com/VM2gF1t.jpg
tank man blocking tanks after china declared martial law and killed civilians.

https://i.imgur.com/0cgqBQ0.jpg
burning monk burned himself to death to protest persecution of buddhist monks, he did not move or make a sound.

The worse is part is that there are other people like me and you just watching when they couldve stopped this shit, god............we suck!


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: cbeast on May 29, 2014, 02:16:20 PM
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/b/b0/Mohamed_Bouazizi.jpghttp://alwaysproventrue.files.wordpress.com/2012/08/mohamed-bouazizi-sets-himself-on-fire-immolates.jpg


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: bryant.coleman on May 29, 2014, 06:44:47 PM

That is Mohamed Bouazizi of Tunisia, the street vendor who set himself on fire. The incident triggered the Arab Spring. Feels bad for him... he was just 26 years old when he died.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: Trading on May 29, 2014, 11:13:48 PM
But since he was writing on the time of the facts, when many Romans that were there were alive, he couldn't lie much.

If you stop and think about that, it is obviously wrong.
Both sides in a war lie to make their own part look better.
Look at what is happening in the Ukraine now. The Ukranian version and the Russian version can't both be right, can they? So at least one side is lying, and that is with all the modern communication methods we have available now.
Then, Josephus could have said anything he wanted to his own people, chances are the Romans would never have heard about it, and if they had contradicted him, he would have just said that they were lying.

Quote
I was expecting some new facts, but your links basically give speculation. And none of them negates the mass suicide. We basically don't know what happened.

Yes, the story was changed for political reasons. Some crazy assassins, mostly of fellow Jews, were converted on heroes. But they also resisted the Romans, we don't know how much, and many refused to be taken alive.

It's well known that the archaeologists only found 28 skeletons. But since it's clear that 28 persons, including women and children, couldn't resist the Romans, many bodies are missing.

If only 28 bodies were found, a reasonably conclusion is that either there weren't any more than that to start with, or that there were, but most of them got away.
You are starting from an assumption that there were a thousand people resisting in the first place. That isn't a known fact.

Josephus, was a Jew, but defected for the Romans after being captured.
He wrote his book in Italy, not in Palestine, and in Latin for the Romans to read.
 
The truth is the first casualty in war, but there are limits about how much someone can invent.

The massive ramp he writes about is still there. Would the Romans built that to conquer a place defended by 28 individuals, some of them women and children...



Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: KonstantinosM on May 30, 2014, 02:20:06 AM
Chelsea Manning

I'm immature but I always thought of this about her sex change.

Bradley Manning: What you're doing isn't right, I just leaked all your dirty little secrets!
Gov: We'll slap you so hard you'll change your name.
Bradley Manning: I'll take it because I have balls you spineless bureaucrats!
Chelsea Elizabeth Manning: ...

P.S.: I'm all for people identifying with whatever gender they do. Her contribution to our society is of the utmost importance shedding light where there previously was none sparking possible change in our corrupt government. Few people in her position are brave and selfless enough to do likewise.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: Bit_Happy on May 30, 2014, 02:51:12 AM

That is Mohamed Bouazizi of Tunisia, the street vendor who set himself on fire. The incident triggered the Arab Spring. Feels bad for him... he was just 26 years old when he died.

I don't watch the news every day and had not heard about Mohamed Bouazizi: "Defiant" is one way to describe what he did, at least it looks like no one else was hurt. If anyone want to know more, here is a brief part of a documentary:
Mohammed Bouazizi. A tunisian martyr.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jHw_auqod6Y

Edit: He had been working to support his family since he was only 10 years old, and here at bitcointalk.org we have "spoiled" people who freak out when the BTC price goes down. We should pause to remember how lucky we are.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: LostDutchman on May 30, 2014, 03:11:29 AM

That is Mohamed Bouazizi of Tunisia, the street vendor who set himself on fire. The incident triggered the Arab Spring. Feels bad for him... he was just 26 years old when he died.

I don't watch the news every day and had not heard about Mohamed Bouazizi: "Defiant" is one way to describe what he did, at least it looks like no one else was hurt. If anyone want to know more, here is a brief part of a documentary:
Mohammed Bouazizi. A tunisian martyr.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jHw_auqod6Y

Edit: He had been working to support his family since he was only 10 years old, and here at bitcointalk.org we have "spoiled" people who freak out when the BTC price goes down. We should pause to remember how lucky we are.


Sorry but I think the guy was a compleat idiot for thinking that setting himself on fire would change a thing.

He would have been much better off CONTRIBUTING instead of going up in flames like a Fourth of July sparkler!


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: Bit_Happy on May 30, 2014, 03:43:39 AM
Sorry but I think the guy was a compleat idiot for thinking that setting himself on fire would change a thing.

He would have been much better off CONTRIBUTING instead of going up in flames like a Fourth of July sparkler!

He was very foolish, and (like I said) it is good he did not kill/harm other people.
"...thinking that setting himself on fire would change a thing."
Apparently, his deadly stunt did change things by motivating others to take action, but that doesn't mean he couldn't have found a better way.
RIP, and let's hope he doesn't inspire more suicide flamers.


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: LostDutchman on May 30, 2014, 03:44:32 AM
Sorry but I think the guy was a compleat idiot for thinking that setting himself on fire would change a thing.

He would have been much better off CONTRIBUTING instead of going up in flames like a Fourth of July sparkler!

He was very foolish, and (like I said) it is good he did not kill/harm other people.
"...thinking that setting himself on fire would change a thing."
Apparently, his stunt did change things by motivating others to take action, but that doesn't mean he couldn't have found a better way.
RIP, and let's hope he doesn't inspire more suicide flamers.

No shit!

We be on the same page and all is good!


Title: Re: 10 Amazing Acts Of Defiance Throughout History
Post by: ShibaWow on May 31, 2014, 03:48:39 PM
there's one missing :)

intro
source ---> http://edition.cnn.com/2011/SPORT/football/01/05/iraq.asia.six.games/
Quote
Dinamo Zagreb versus Red Star Belgrade (1990)
Yugoslavia was already on the brink of imploding by the time Serbia's Red Star Belgrade played Croatia's Dinamo Zagreb at the latter's Maksimir Stadium. Pro- independence parties had already won recent Croatian elections. But the events that unfolded on March 13, 1990 are regarded by many as the opening salvo of the most vicious European war since the Nazis were defeated in 1945.
During the match, future AC Milan and Croatia captain Zvonimir Boban launched a kung-fu kick at a policeman who was attacking a Zagreb fan. Riots broke out between Zagreb's "Bad Blue Boys" ultra group, and Red Star's "Delije" -- led by the brutal war-lord Arkan.
Arkan's Tiger's, the paramilitary group he ruled during the war, recruited heavily from the Delije. Arkan himself was indicted by the United Nations for war crimes, but was assassinated in 2000 before he stood trial. Later, Boban explained what was going through his head.
"Here I was, a public face prepared to risk his life, career and everything that fame could have brought, all because of one ideal cause: the Croatian cause."
For the rest of the soon-to-be-non-existent country, it was a symbolic moment. "It was the most important match in Yugoslav history," explains Dr. Neven Andjelic, author of "Bosnia-Herzegovina: The End of a Legacy."
"It has political implications and is a clear sign of the forthcoming violence and war that this unfinished match provided to the population."
The war went on to rage for five years, with the International Center for Transnational Justice estimating that 140,000 people were killed. Its effects are still evident today, not least outside the Maksimir Stadium, where a statue depicting a group of soldiers stands. On it is the inscription: "To the fans of the club, who started the war with Serbia at this ground on May 13, 1990."

the hit

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NnrLuAzUPMs

the story
after Boban tried to help an injured fan (injured by police) he was pushed aside

the defience

the officers were pro-Yugoslav (90% of military and police were Serbs in Yugoslavia) so the police joined forces with Delije in the Bad Blue Boys vs. Delije conflict
altough Boban was a standard player in the Yugoslavia football squad
Boban couldn't take it and he hit the officer, later he said
Quote
Later, Boban explained what was going through his head.
"Here I was, a public face prepared to risk his life, career and everything that fame could have brought, all because of one ideal cause: the Croatian cause."