Bitcoin Forum

Other => Meta => Topic started by: vnvizow on April 20, 2014, 12:36:26 PM



Title: Just wondering if we can make quotes unchangeable
Post by: vnvizow on April 20, 2014, 12:36:26 PM
in the title, I've seen people take advantage of this


Title: Re: Just wondering if we can make quotes unchangeable
Post by: Chemistry1988 on April 20, 2014, 03:53:51 PM
I've seen people take advantage of this

Would you mind elaborating it a bit?  :)
I can't think of how people take advantage by changing their quotes...


Title: Re: Just wondering if we can make quotes unchangeable
Post by: DiamondCardz on April 20, 2014, 04:07:25 PM
"I'm going to give away 10 BTC to the first guy to send me 5 BTC, quote this so I can't change this"

Trustworthy member quotes this, and later receives a PM:

"Hey, some guy actually sent me 5 BTC, can you change your quote for 1 BTC so I don't have to pay them?"


Title: Re: Just wondering if we can make quotes unchangeable
Post by: theymos on April 20, 2014, 05:24:01 PM
"I'm going to give away 10 BTC to the first guy to send me 5 BTC, quote this so I can't change this"

Trustworthy member quotes this, and later receives a PM:

"Hey, some guy actually sent me 5 BTC, can you change your quote for 1 BTC so I don't have to pay them?"

All edits are recorded, so I can confirm/deny whether someone did this if I'm asked.


Title: Re: Just wondering if we can make quotes unchangeable
Post by: Vod on April 20, 2014, 05:25:53 PM
"I'm going to give away 10 BTC to the first guy to send me 5 BTC, quote this so I can't change this"

Trustworthy member quotes this, and later receives a PM:

"Hey, some guy actually sent me 5 BTC, can you change your quote for 1 BTC so I don't have to pay them?"

All edits are recorded, so I can confirm/deny whether someone did this if I'm asked.

Awesome.  Maybe the new forum could have a "post history" link that showed the edits.  Make the link available only to hero members.   ;D


Title: Re: Just wondering if we can make quotes unchangeable
Post by: DiamondCardz on April 20, 2014, 05:31:03 PM
"I'm going to give away 10 BTC to the first guy to send me 5 BTC, quote this so I can't change this"

Trustworthy member quotes this, and later receives a PM:

"Hey, some guy actually sent me 5 BTC, can you change your quote for 1 BTC so I don't have to pay them?"

All edits are recorded, so I can confirm/deny whether someone did this if I'm asked.

Interesting, I didn't know you were able to do that. That makes the OP pretty redundant then.


Title: Re: Just wondering if we can make quotes unchangeable
Post by: theymos on April 20, 2014, 05:37:03 PM
Interesting, I didn't know you were able to do that. That makes the OP pretty redundant then.

I think that he actually wants to ban "misquotes". But these are often useful, so I'm not going to disallow them.


Title: Re: Just wondering if we can make quotes unchangeable
Post by: DiamondCardz on April 20, 2014, 05:43:00 PM
Interesting, I didn't know you were able to do that. That makes the OP pretty redundant then.

I think that he actually wants to ban "misquotes". But these are often useful, so I'm not going to disallow them.

Ah, if he is talking about someone purposefully misquoting a post, then they usually will be called out for doing so by the people on the thread anyway. I can see your logic.


Title: Re: Just wondering if we can make quotes unchangeable
Post by: rhino34567 on April 20, 2014, 05:46:51 PM
Interesting, I didn't know you were able to do that. That makes the OP pretty redundant then.

I think that he actually wants to ban "misquotes". But these are often useful, so I'm not going to disallow them.

Ah, if he is talking about someone purposefully misquoting a post, then they usually will be called out for doing so by the people on the thread anyway. I can see your logic.
I get it it is just like with buying accounts: Instead of banning it, we can use it to our own advantage by knowing who does it and being aware of them.


Title: Re: Just wondering if we can make quotes unchangeable
Post by: hilariousandco on April 20, 2014, 09:19:01 PM
in the title, I like turtles

You mean stopping things like that?

But then you wouldn't be able to edit irrelevant bits out of people's posts. Also, clicking the quote takes you back to the original.


Title: Re: Just wondering if we can make quotes unchangeable
Post by: Darkstone2 on April 20, 2014, 09:51:53 PM
Interesting, I didn't know you were able to do that. That makes the OP pretty redundant then.

I think that he actually wants to ban "misquotes". But these are often useful, so I'm not going to disallow them.

Ah, if he is talking about someone purposefully misquoting a post, then they usually will be called out for doing so by the people on the thread anyway. I can see your logic.
I get it it is just like with buying accounts: Instead of banning it, we can use it to our own advantage by knowing who does it and being aware of them.
It would be better to just ban them on sight so nobody bothers to buy accounts anymore. Kill the problem at the source, don't fight the side effects.


Title: Re: Just wondering if we can make quotes unchangeable
Post by: vnvizow on April 21, 2014, 04:34:25 AM
"I'm going to give away 10 BTC to the first guy to send me 5 BTC, quote this so I can't change this"

Trustworthy member quotes this, and later receives a PM:

"Hey, some guy actually sent me 5 BTC, can you change your quote for 1 BTC so I don't have to pay them?"

All edits are recorded, so I can confirm/deny whether someone did this if I'm asked.
Wow, an admin replied to my post :) . Anyways, so are you the only one who can see edits? Or do all admins have the privilege? I think it's better if other people can see the edits as well. Or, make it so that the edits can only delete parts of the quotes and not add in parts, because some people take out irrelevant parts. And on that topic sometimes when people join late for a conversation and see quotes with 'irrelevant' parts missing they may not be seeing what the original message was trying to express. Just my humble opinions  ;D


Title: Re: Just wondering if we can make quotes unchangeable
Post by: vnvizow on April 21, 2014, 04:37:27 AM
in the title, I like turtles

You mean stopping things like that?

But then you wouldn't be able to edit irrelevant bits out of people's posts. Also, clicking the quote takes you back to the original.
Good point but do people even bother? The internet is overrun by lazy people anyways (talking from experience)  ;D


Title: Re: Just wondering if we can make quotes unchangeable
Post by: DeathAndTaxes on April 21, 2014, 04:44:45 AM
Wow, an admin edits a quote, and people not seeing the original opinion


Title: Re: Just wondering if we can make quotes unchangeable
Post by: Lethn on April 21, 2014, 05:15:13 AM
Make a quote yourself, take a screenshot of the thread, or copy and paste the quote somewhere where it can't be changed or messed with.


Title: Re: Just wondering if we can make quotes unchangeable
Post by: vnvizow on April 21, 2014, 06:48:21 AM
Wow, an admin edits a quote, and people not seeing the original opinion
oh well, this is a problem as well