Title: [POLL 3/3] Bitcoin: URI refactor? Units (poll reset Apr 21 to clarify options) Post by: Luke-Jr on April 21, 2011, 01:32:14 AM Should Bitcoin: URIs be allowed to contain only decimal bitcoins (BTC), or tolerate the human's choice of BTC or TBC (converted first to hexadecimal)?
Please note that even if hexadecimal is supported, nobody is required to use it. It remains the user's choice which number system they use. Even if you open a URI encoded in hexadecimal, you will see the Decimal/BTC equivalent in your client (unless you configure it for TBC). In other words, a vote for decimal-only is a vote to force humans who want to use tonal to switch to decimal. If you want to request/bill for 10.25 BTC, you (or your shopping cart) would write:
If you want to request/bill for 1.5 mBTC (milli-BTC), you (or your shopping cart) would write:
If you want to request/bill for 10.2 TBC (TonalBitcoin), you (or your shopping cart) would write:
If you want to request/bill for 1 ᵐTBC (mill-TonalBitcoin), you (or your shopping cart) would write:
Title: Re: [POLL 3/3] Bitcoin: URI refactor? Units Post by: theymos on April 21, 2011, 01:38:43 AM This poll is biased and therefore meaningless. ;)
Title: Re: [POLL 3/3] Bitcoin: URI refactor? Units Post by: Luke-Jr on April 21, 2011, 01:41:12 AM This poll is biased and therefore meaningless. ;) Is notTitle: Re: [POLL 3/3] Bitcoin: URI refactor? Units Post by: [Tycho] on April 21, 2011, 02:01:00 AM This poll is biased and therefore meaningless.
Title: Re: [POLL 3/3] Bitcoin: URI refactor? Units Post by: Luke-Jr on April 21, 2011, 02:03:01 AM Objectively, the decimal-only option isn't rational, so the meaning of this poll remains: to show how bigoted the people on this forum are.
Title: Re: [POLL 3/3] Bitcoin: URI refactor? Units Post by: xf2_org on April 21, 2011, 02:03:44 AM This poll is biased and therefore meaningless. +1 ... Title: Re: [POLL 3/3] Bitcoin: URI refactor? Units Post by: theymos on April 21, 2011, 02:07:41 AM You're using emotionally-charged words in the poll. Few people will vote for "forcing" anyone to do anything. Maybe the options should be changed to:
Title: Re: [POLL 3/3] Bitcoin: URI refactor? Units Post by: Luke-Jr on April 21, 2011, 02:10:42 AM You're using emotionally-charged words in the poll. Few people will vote for "forcing" anyone to do anything. Maybe the options should be changed to: 1. URIs are not meant to be read by humans, so people being "familiar" with all possibilities is irrelevant.
2. You assume a glim future where people still use not only decimal, but BTC. This is not even rationally possible: people will either use mBTC, TBC, or Bitcoin will fail outright. 3. You imply supporting hexadecimal is difficult. 4. Dozenal has a rather large userbase too. Title: Re: [POLL 3/3] Bitcoin: URI refactor? Units Post by: theymos on April 21, 2011, 02:15:16 AM URIs are not meant to be read by humans, so people being "familiar" with all possibilities is irrelevant. Why do you even care what is supported, then? Quote 2. You assume a glim future where people still use not only decimal, but BTC. This is not even rationally possible: people will either use mBTC, TBC, or Bitcoin will fail outright. Everyone will at least understand decimal for the next 100 years. Everyone will understand what an original BTC represents for as long as Bitcoin exists. Quote You imply supporting hexadecimal is difficult. It's a waste of time. Title: Re: [POLL 3/3] Bitcoin: URI refactor? Units Post by: Luke-Jr on April 21, 2011, 02:20:14 AM URIs are not meant to be read by humans, so people being "familiar" with all possibilities is irrelevant. Why do you even care what is supported, then?Quote 2. You assume a glim future where people still use not only decimal, but BTC. This is not even rationally possible: people will either use mBTC, TBC, or Bitcoin will fail outright. Everyone will at least understand decimal for the next 100 years. Everyone will understand what an original BTC represents for as long as Bitcoin exists.Quote You imply supporting hexadecimal is difficult. It's a waste of time.Title: Re: [POLL 3/3] Bitcoin: URI refactor? Units (poll reset Apr 21 to clarify options) Post by: DiabloD3 on May 09, 2011, 04:27:40 PM This poll is useless, there is no option for "decimal satoshis only for all API work".
|