Bitcoin Forum

Economy => Lending => Topic started by: oppahdoggystyle on June 13, 2014, 05:04:44 AM



Title: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: oppahdoggystyle on June 13, 2014, 05:04:44 AM
I am curious if fiat like USD count as collateral on bitcointalk's lending section.


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: Confessions on June 13, 2014, 05:09:03 AM
Yes, and probably is the best collateral


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: hilariousandco on June 13, 2014, 05:36:52 AM
Yeah it would, but as long as it wasn't sent to the lender via a reversible medium like Paypal or something. If you've got the money though why don't you just buy the coins yourself?


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: oppahdoggystyle on June 13, 2014, 05:43:47 AM
Fees and other Bitcoin-acquisition costs are reasons I am considering putting up fiat for a bitcoin loan. Of course, paypal would not be used as collateral. More like bank transfers or other secure fiat transfer methods


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: Parazyd on June 13, 2014, 05:45:18 AM
Just ditch Western Union. They take sky-high fees. 10% I think :D


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: oppahdoggystyle on June 13, 2014, 05:48:21 AM
WU fees = death. I just calculated how much money I spent on fees to obtain BTC in the past and it is embarrassing.


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: Parazyd on June 13, 2014, 05:55:43 AM
WU fees = death. I just calculated how much money I spent on fees to obtain BTC in the past and it is embarrassing.

Yeah... I'd recommend a simple Wire Transfer or a SEPA Transfer if you locate in Europe.


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: oppahdoggystyle on June 13, 2014, 06:08:39 AM
Good idea. Thanks for that. I'll be searching for credible exchanges then. I'm sick of paying 10%+ above market.


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: DubFX on June 13, 2014, 06:23:13 AM
IMHO i wouldn't call it best form of collateral, wire transfers are expensive and take ALOT of time.


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: Parazyd on June 13, 2014, 06:24:51 AM
IMHO i wouldn't call it best form of collateral, wire transfers are expensive and take ALOT of time.

Depends what's expensive for you. It's cheaper than WU and it takes max. 3-4 working days.


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: oppahdoggystyle on June 13, 2014, 06:41:03 AM
3-4 business days... is better than paying WU fees/other payment type fees and paying above market value.


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: Killerloop on June 13, 2014, 08:12:37 AM
WU fees = death. I just calculated how much money I spent on fees to obtain BTC in the past and it is embarrassing.

How much exactly? If you trade on an exchange you will pay wire transfer and trading fee... 0.5%?


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: oppahdoggystyle on June 13, 2014, 08:38:41 AM
Damn... you're right. It might just be better if I put fiat in escrow and borrow. Cost of getting bitcoins is getting way too high for me.


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: Killerloop on June 13, 2014, 08:42:56 AM
Damn... you're right. It might just be better if I put fiat in escrow and borrow. Cost of getting bitcoins is getting way too high for me.

If you deposit USD to a trustable forum escrow I will be happy to lend BTC to you.


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: oppahdoggystyle on June 13, 2014, 08:49:55 AM
I am interested and more than willing to do escrow. But, I am curious if you have someone in mind who is trustworthy enough to escrow. Also, what kind of int rate and terms are you considering. I hope you don't mind making this lending terms/escrow discussion for public to see.


Feel free to propose the escrow terms/loan terms/etc. I am all ears


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: Killerloop on June 13, 2014, 09:18:59 AM
I am interested and more than willing to do escrow. But, I am curious if you have someone in mind who is trustworthy enough to escrow. Also, what kind of int rate and terms are you considering. I hope you don't mind making this lending terms/escrow discussion for public to see.

Feel free to propose the escrow terms/loan terms/etc. I am all ears

These are my conditions: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=632483.0
I have more than 1 BTC now.

For escrow I had a positive experience with Monbux, but I do not know if he accepts USD and if it is feasible for you to send money to him. From my point of view any trustable escrow will do, but you should seek someone in your country as currency conversion may take a sensible toll on your collateral.


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: oppahdoggystyle on June 13, 2014, 09:21:39 AM
I have read your loan terms page. I will put out a thread to see if any trusted member can act as the escrow.



Below is the link to thread requesting trusted members to act as escrow.

https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=650709.0


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: oppahdoggystyle on June 13, 2014, 10:52:37 AM
Killerloop,

I contacted DannyHamilton to oversee the escrow process. According to Bitcointalk users, he is trustworthy and legitimate. Let me know if you are okay with me asking DannyHamilton.


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: tertius993 on June 13, 2014, 11:25:48 AM
I am interested and more than willing to do escrow. But, I am curious if you have someone in mind who is trustworthy enough to escrow. Also, what kind of int rate and terms are you considering. I hope you don't mind making this lending terms/escrow discussion for public to see.

Feel free to propose the escrow terms/loan terms/etc. I am all ears

These are my conditions: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=632483.0
I have more than 1 BTC now.

For escrow I had a positive experience with Monbux, but I do not know if he accepts USD and if it is feasible for you to send money to him. From my point of view any trustable escrow will do, but you should seek someone in your country as currency conversion may take a sensible toll on your collateral.

I think the in country bit is important.  At least within the UK person to person transfers are free and more or less instant.  However, the amount of collateral would need to cover any wire costs if it eventually *had* to be sent to the lender.


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: oppahdoggystyle on June 13, 2014, 11:34:12 AM
That is actually a good point. That is why I am hoping an escrow holder has a BofA account so it will be a free transaction.


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: Killerloop on June 13, 2014, 11:56:15 AM
I think the in country bit is important.  At least within the UK person to person transfers are free and more or less instant.  However, the amount of collateral would need to cover any wire costs if it eventually *had* to be sent to the lender.

Or, in the unfortunate case the borrower defaults, the trusted escrow could buy bitcoins with local currency and send it to the lender after appropriate fees are paid.
Are we dealing with cryptocurrency AND sending money overseas? This is enough to be burned at the stake imho  ;D


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: tertius993 on June 13, 2014, 12:03:20 PM
I think the in country bit is important.  At least within the UK person to person transfers are free and more or less instant.  However, the amount of collateral would need to cover any wire costs if it eventually *had* to be sent to the lender.

Or, in the unfortunate case the borrower defaults, the trusted escrow could buy bitcoins with local currency and send it to the lender after appropriate fees are paid.
Are we dealing with cryptocurrency AND sending money overseas? This is enough to be burned at the stake imho  ;D

Hmm, good point, thus introducing one (or two?) exchange rate variables ...

It can certainly work but it needs to be structured carefully, and agreed exactly what the loan is for (BTC or fiat)?


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: Killerloop on June 13, 2014, 12:08:10 PM
Hmm, good point, thus introducing one (or two?) exchange rate variables ...

It can certainly work but it needs to be structured carefully, and agreed exactly what the loan is for (BTC or fiat)?

BTC loan backed by fiat using BTC/USD ratio of a certain exchange. All altcoin backed loans should work like this too


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: oppahdoggystyle on June 13, 2014, 12:10:58 PM
UPDATE:

Killerloop and I have come to an agreement for the loan structure. I think it would be best for the lender, Killerloop, to announce to the public the terms of the loan structure.

Also, we are awaiting for responses from people who may act as escrow. If you know anyone who can act as an escrow, and is trustworthy and has a BofA account, please let me know.


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: tertius993 on June 13, 2014, 12:23:39 PM
Hmm, good point, thus introducing one (or two?) exchange rate variables ...

It can certainly work but it needs to be structured carefully, and agreed exactly what the loan is for (BTC or fiat)?

BTC loan backed by fiat using BTC/USD ratio of a certain exchange. All altcoin backed loans should work like this too

I agree but the exchange rate moves of course.  I guess if the borrower defaults they won't be getting their collateral back anyway; just thinking through scenarios in my head really.

Just a further thought if the intention is that the escrow holder buys BTC to compensate the lender, ensure they have sufficient for their fees and any exchange/similar fees; plus the headroom for exchange rate changes.


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: oppahdoggystyle on June 13, 2014, 12:25:03 PM
Because Killerloop requires a 5% edge, I believe there is compensation for any fees related. Please see terms of agreement.


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: Killerloop on June 13, 2014, 12:30:55 PM
I agree but the exchange rate moves of course.  I guess if the borrower defaults they won't be getting their collateral back anyway; just thinking through scenarios in my head really.

Just a further thought if the intention is that the escrow holder buys BTC to compensate the lender, ensure they have sufficient for their fees and any exchange/similar fees; plus the headroom for exchange rate changes.

My "0% risk model" works exactly like that: I required a 5% edge to allow breathing room for the volatility.
I actually requested 10% but oppahdoggystyle was already comfortable with 5%  :)

I will not wait for his eventual default at all, once the provided collateral (USD) is barely enough to purchase the expected amount BTC + escrow fees I'll seize the collateral and the loan will end.
I'm sure we will not come to this.  :)


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: tertius993 on June 13, 2014, 12:43:02 PM
I agree but the exchange rate moves of course.  I guess if the borrower defaults they won't be getting their collateral back anyway; just thinking through scenarios in my head really.

Just a further thought if the intention is that the escrow holder buys BTC to compensate the lender, ensure they have sufficient for their fees and any exchange/similar fees; plus the headroom for exchange rate changes.

My "0% risk model" works exactly like that: I required a 5% edge to allow breathing room for the volatility.
I actually requested 10% but oppahdoggystyle was already comfortable with 5%  :)

I will not wait for his eventual default at all, once the provided collateral (USD) is barely enough to purchase the expected amount BTC + escrow fees I'll seize the collateral and the loan will end.
I'm sure we will not come to this.  :)

That sounds sensible.

I too am sure it won't come to that either, this has certainly been amongst the more grown-up conversations in this section ... ;)


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: oppahdoggystyle on June 13, 2014, 12:45:37 PM
I agree but the exchange rate moves of course.  I guess if the borrower defaults they won't be getting their collateral back anyway; just thinking through scenarios in my head really.

Just a further thought if the intention is that the escrow holder buys BTC to compensate the lender, ensure they have sufficient for their fees and any exchange/similar fees; plus the headroom for exchange rate changes.

My "0% risk model" works exactly like that: I required a 5% edge to allow breathing room for the volatility.
I actually requested 10% but oppahdoggystyle was already comfortable with 5%  :)

I will not wait for his eventual default at all, once the provided collateral (USD) is barely enough to purchase the expected amount BTC + escrow fees I'll seize the collateral and the loan will end.
I'm sure we will not come to this.  :)

That sounds sensible.

I too am sure it won't come to that either, this has certainly been amongst the more grown-up conversations in this section ... ;)


Well, it is a loan so I think grown-up conversation is a basic requirement.


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: bitpop on June 13, 2014, 10:21:14 PM
Sorry I can't hold usd



Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: monbux on June 14, 2014, 01:24:55 AM
If you would like me to act as an escrow - I can try to see what I can do.  What are your methods of sending the USD?
I believe Danny probably would accept USD as well.


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: haploid23 on June 14, 2014, 06:20:09 AM
I can escrow if you want me to. I'm in the US and have a BofA account. I've provided a few large loans and ran group buys before.

No hard feelings if you don't want me to  ;)


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: gondel on June 14, 2014, 10:11:57 AM
I am curious if fiat like USD count as collateral on bitcointalk's lending section.
Hello,
I think it can be accepted, but not sure if you need to provide the amount of the loan plus 10% or it is negotiable.. Cna someone explain  exactly how it is done? I can provide small loan if you provide a stable alt crypto as collateral :)
BR
Gondel


Title: Re: Does fiat currency count as collateral.
Post by: haploid23 on June 14, 2014, 10:33:32 AM
I am curious if fiat like USD count as collateral on bitcointalk's lending section.
Hello,
I think it can be accepted, but not sure if you need to provide the amount of the loan plus 10% or it is negotiable.. Cna someone explain  exactly how it is done? I can provide small loan if you provide a stable alt crypto as collateral :)
BR
Gondel

You didn't bother reading the thread, why bother replying?